Kay Meyer
We came for an anniversary and was not disappointed! The ribs were AMAZING! My husband had the fish tacos and was so impressed with them. The banana breeze frozen adult drink is to die for. Prices are good for the quality you receive
Eric
Great place to grab a very strong slushy drink! Classic stop on Duval Street. Stop by and grab a Rum Runner, Banana Chocolate, or one of their numerous flavors. Food is pretty solid and service is awesome!!
Cloe Mohsen
Delicious! Portions were generous and food was fresh. Service was great. Would recommend stopping here for lunch or dinner while in KeyWest. The key lime pie was so good!
Alessandra Distefano
Classic American style restaurant with seating areas and high stool tables. Very friendly and knowledgeable staff. Luke helped us with the menu and suggested the perfect amount of food we needed. We came in right when the storm came and we found a table for four quite easily. The burger, ribs, and tacos were huge and delicious. One of the best restaurants in the area.
Jeff Shore
I've had many meals here. Our sever Natalie was perfect. Mahi tacos, shrimp po boy, and conch fritters. Everything perfect.
LLO Legal Assistant
Generous delicious portions of food and tasty pina coladas. My only dislike was they use high fructose corn syrup ketchup. I meant to order bacon on my burger but forgot so it eould be good if the wait staff were to ask if I wanted bacon like they did the day before when we ate here. Otherwise lovely and highly recommend!
Sabrina Locke
Fogarty’s is an absolute must in KW. The atmosphere of the restaurant is so fun and enjoyable. The menu is not overly complicated like a lot of places are nowadays, the food is fresh and delicious, the drinks are so refreshing (and fun!), the music choices are great, and ALL of the staff is attentive and friendly. As a manager in the Food and Beverage industry, this place hits all my marks. I visit at least twice every trip, and will continue to do so every time I’m in town! I would even dare to say it is my favorite in Key West!
Steve B.
My conch fritter appetizer was amazing! Best on the island, and the remoulade sauce A+ I don't remember our servers name, a redheaded guy. He was 💯 did a great job! Good people are hard to find.
Daddy Hordel
Well I can’t remember all the names of the foods precisely we got but Fogarty’s is easily the best place we have ate at in Key West so far and a few of the drinks we had were just as good, the dirty monkey and the grape ape. The service was great and our blonde waitress was awesome, sorry, forgot your name. We got a fish sandwich, some kind of pecan fish, 3 cheese pasta and blackened fish tacos. I substituted fries for my rice n beans, I’m just not a rice and bean guy. I sampled all 4 dishes and they were all Amazing. My vegetables with my dish were also cooked to perfection. This is definitely a must stop while you’re in Key West. I’m pretty hard to please because I’ve eat country cooking and Cajun food(thanks to my bayou work buddies) all of my life and it’s some of the best food in the world but Fogarty’s definitely met my high expectations.
Peter Commerford
Fogarty's is pretty good and has a great location right on Duval street. The food was great but the drinks were not. The service was slow and almost inattentive. When we asked our server a few details about the food before we placed our order, she said she honestly had no idea. I do admire the honesty, and in the end, the food was great. I ordered the key lime shrimp and my wife ordered the three cheese pasta. Both meals were delicious and visually appealing. For the drinks, my wife order the Pina colada and I the Rum Runner. The rum runner was far too frozen and kept plugging up the straw. I ended up removing the cover and drinking from the top but it tasted like a little kids freeze pop. Way too much sugar and I could not taste any rum. I would still recommend this place as a good place to grab lunch while walking along Duval street.
M C
I’d say the food was just ok for what it cost. We stopped in for lunch. Atmosphere is excellent, but again your in Kew West can’t go wrong anywhere for the atmosphere here. Roosters running around makes it much more entertaining. Service was great and quick. We had a late lunch which put us there around 2:30 and we were seated right away. We’d probably try somewhere else next time in the area.
Gina Rehoseni
Tim our waiter was great, we received fast service, friendly and great attitude.
Food was really good, couldn't have asked for anything better. Great experience.
Kristin Grose
We stopped for Margaritas - my husband had a Banana Split. Very laid back. Friendly staff.
Janet A.
My mom and I had the fish tacos and margaritas. The fish tacos were perfectly cooked and the sauce had a great kick to it. They were not cheap on the liquor for drinks. Would definitely recommend.
Dave Warner
Absolutely great service! Food arrived quickly and was delicious and very ample serving size.
Karolína Machatová
Amazing food and even much more amazing staff! Super friendly and very welcoming. For american customers it could be maybe absolutely normal thing, but for us as a european tourists it was like cuddling our souls. I wish I would remember the name of our waiter, all I know is he was (probably) working also behind the bar and was from Mexico. Shout out to you and Thank you very much again! ♥️
Maribel Cordoba
In the heart of Duval Street. I try to eat here every time I’m in KW. Love the atmosphere and their menu. Fast and fresh food. We have a Fish Sandwich (a whole fish technically) 😊
The pork bowl and a Fogarty’s Burger!! Will visit again next trip!!!
Diane Zeigler
We didn't have food but we did have some great drinks! We sat at the bar for drinks and the bartenders were really nice. They actually seemed to love their job. Katie was super sweet and talkative. The other two were also good but we didn't get their names. They offered samples of the frozen drinks and were right on top of our empty cups. I usually get a mudslide there but we tried other flavors this time and the ruby roo is very refreshing on a hot key west night.
Peter Franc
I had the blackened fish tacos and they were very nice. As something as simple as beans and rice, I couldn't stop eating them; they were very flavorful. The staff was also friendly.
Cesar Phantom
this is an awesome place dadsadadasd ada dadad ada dadad adada dasf afafa fsaf aqfqefwef afsfwef werwtwee twegfsdgfds etwtw wefsdfs fwe wtwt wtw
Raxbay99 Gmail
SCAM...BUYER BEWARE...ordered fish tacos and told the waitress it was chicken to which she insisted was fish. We sent the plate back with a request to advise the cook it was chicken. The manager came to the table with apologies that the "chef" was new. They gave a $2 credit and coupons for free beer with a future order.
Melodi
Efendim ne zamandir tatil munasebetiyle yazamiyorum buyrun floridanin minigi key west te ne yenir lezzetli mi lezzetli deniz urunleri basarili
Eugene Frye-McCormack
The broken light fixture an inch from our seating (picture posted) sparked several times and shocked my 6 year old daughter. The restaurant manager was completely unconcerned (probably wasn't the first time) and offered no discount on food or drink for almost electrocuting my daughter. Otherwise food was pretty average. Standard frozen drinks with so much sugar that the taste was difficult to discern. Almost very unaccommodating to simple requests that were not specifically on the menu.
BlockDaddy21
Really, really good food. We had the cracked pepper Ahi Tuna as a starter - quality fish, seared to a perfect rare and with a chili soy, was absolutely delicious. She had the mixed grill with a lime cilantro sauce that was out-of-this-world and scallops that were perfectly cooked. I had the Cuban pork roast - a dish that tasted like it was cooking for 12 hours. Tender, falling-apart, and with a lime marinade - this has been the highlight of our trip to Key West. Even the black beans were so good, we returned the next day for more. Service was on-point, and the frozen drinks were tasty as well. Highly recommend!
Emilee B
Great service! Even during the holiday rush my group of 10 got in with no wait. The food was absolutely delicious. Our group's favorites were the lettuce wrap and the chopped salad.
Alletun
Yay! Key West Pride 2015! Dinner at Fogarty's was quite a pleasant experience. The service was good even though there was a large crowd.<br/><br/>As an appetizer, I can suggest the Taste of Key West, which has Conch Fritters, Fish Bites, and Fried Shrimp. The tarter and coctail sauces are good. You may have to ask for extra sauce.<br/><br/>For my entree, I was told to try the Blackened Rib Eye. It is a 14 ounce cut of meat coated with Cajun spices, and has mashed potatoes, veggies, and fried onions as sides. If you are a steak person, you will like this one.
Matt Gorham
The crab and corn chowder was some of the best I ever had. That said, Luckie, pick up the pace. Maybe your having a bad day, but try a little harder.
Superfied
Solid pick! Service quick and friendly, food was fresh, key lime pie is among the best she has had. A very easy place to enjoy any type of dinner, for 2 or for a party.
E
Located in the midst of duval street, this establishment was serving up some tasty treats with really friendly service. They have cooling misters which helps when sitting outdoors on those hot days. There is both indoor and outdoor seating with 2 bars. The sandwiches were really good and their fries were spot on. There was live carribean steel drum music which added to the ambiance. Would return again for sure.
Carter
Amazing! Catch of the day was red snapper. Got it blackened, with the house sauce drizzled over, rice and veggies. Everything could not have been more perfect!
Walt
Good was great! We had the catch of the day (mahi) and we had the ribeye. Both were cooked perfect. The customer service was spot on.
Lowkeyfoodie
This place could be good...but it's not. The food is not that great, very mediocre. But the service is pretty good, our server was on top of things. That being said, you can definitely find way better on Duval. Just go for the frozen alcoholic drinks.
Birdiebyrd
Good food... Great service, i went with 2 other friends.. we ordered the shrimp po' boy, the pork ribs and the fogarty burger.. all 3 things were cooked perfect, tasted great and i will def be returning to this place.... <br/><br/>just a great find, and cool place.. a must visit..<br/>also good people watching.. we sat on the actual porch, because it was raining.. but even there, we had a good time and it was just perfect
Rah Cha Chow
Excellent shrimp club sandwich. My friend loved the chopped salad. Fun place to people watch in Key West.
Jimmy Yoder
We both had Chicken Romano and it was delicious, very garlicy. It was a big plate as well, so value was pretty good for $15.
Christy
Wasted meal. My husband got the fish sandwich and it looked great but was undercooked and mushy. When we returned it the manager was very rude, saying there was nothing wrong with it. We had to ask him to take it off our bill. We've never had a manager treat us like that. Just bc the restaurant has a good location they think they don't have to worry about quality or service. Do yourself a favor and don't eat on this end of Duval.
Lacy Pennington
Get the peppered tuna. It will change your life. Seriously.... Do it.<br/><br/>Had a group of 8 have dinner here before we met for a ghost tour. Every person loved their food. Plan on visiting again before leaving KW!
Tulia
Second time here. Fist time about three years ago. The Cobb salad is pretty good and the crusted chicken pasta is great! Will go back the next time I go to key west.
Melonie
Wasn't sure about this place when we first walked in. The food was really great. The chicken over pasta was amazing and you got your moneys worth of food. Key lime pie was amazing and so were their crab cakes. But the staff sucked. Very slow to bring everything from silverware to refill water. The food was great I would go back again..just hoping for a different waitress.
ImReallyPicky
Great atmosphere decebt prices, good location, drinks are ok
Acb244
Good food, fun atmosphere.. This place is a great spot to people watch on Duval. Nice patio, friendly service, huge portions of good food. We had the crab cakes, shrimp po boy, & mahi mahi sandwich- all of which was delicious. Nothing fancy, but a fun place to go.
Carrol Y. Cherry
We had the conch fritters and crab cakes for starters and they were very below average. It tastes like they used the same batter for both. The entrees were better, but nothing to write home about. I was a little disappointed.
Lorenzo Padron
Great place to people watch on Duval. Great drinks at Flying Monkey. Great grilled fish sandwich and shrimp club. Always come here when coming to Key West
Haley
BBQ burger was amazing. Everything else was mediocre.
Lee
We loved the drinks but..... The hostess was a total bitch...we spent 5 days drinking there and on the last day, she ruined the whole experience for us. We will never return<br/>Lost our business
Stephanie Cates Hodges
Had the crab cakes and they were fantastic. Friendly staff and speedy service. Great piña colada daiquiri.
Mary Lane
Best Resturant In the Keys. This is by far a must eat at place in the Keys. I was there 3 days ans ate 2x's a day there. I did try another resturant but it was awful. Back to forgerty's I went. The portions are Huge, you get more than your money's worth. LOVE IT!<br/>Presentation of the food : EXCELLENT, <br/>Service: OUTSTANDING, <br/>Flavor: EXCELLENT<br/>I had the bacon, shrimp sandwich ( everyday for luch) EXCELLENT <br/>The appetizers are almost a full meal<br/>Ribs were so tender they fell off the bone. I could go on but wont. Just make this your must eat place in the Keys.
Jeff Boyles
Good vibe, great food, fast service- did I mention the food!
Hubby_88
HUGE Portions. Be prepared to eat BIG....one of the bet values for the money in Key west. Service was super quick on a very busy night. The Salads were monsterous. Not really a knock your socks of place with menu items but an inexpensive night for 4.
Maggie
We had the lettuce wraps and the pecan crusted Mahi Mahi, both were very delicious. The atmosphere was great and the service was exceptional.
Jon
Fogarty's food. Beautiful-looking what seems to be an historic house.<br/>Food is terrible and overpriced.<br/>Crab cakes were stuffed with mostly filler. No lumb crab meat that is shredded, a common recipe to use less crab meat.<br/>Fish bites were unassuming.<br/>Chose to eat inside to get away from the noise.<br/>We ate on the first floor. Expected something cozy. Wasn't. Just some worn diner-type booths.<br/>Would not go back or recommend.
Jerry
Great find in Key West. If you don't know where your going and have just a short time in Key West, go here! Had the pecan encrusted Mahi and wow! You never know how it's going to go but this place was jam up. Had a sailboat full of scouts with me and they really like this place.
Maggie Watts
Food was excellent. Mahi tacos were big enough to share with 2 or 3 people. Definitly get a frozen drink from the flying monkey. All of them are strong and delicious!
Lindsay
Average average average. Food was totally average, typical American/Waterfront that is overpriced simply because it is in a tourist spot. Conch fritters were fine. My husbands grouper was pretty decent although a bit on the salty side. I got the mahi tacos and my fish was completely overcooked and there was so much melted cheese I left much of it uneaten (although the leftovers were eaten at around 4am after being completely obliterated at Fat Tuesdays). Mahi is so freshly available there it's a shame they couldn't lend a lighter preparation to it and let the fish shine through. Nothing to write home about.
Rose Quintero
Outstanding this place is a must the bruschetta is to die for...it's not just about seafood the burgers are Devine and the prices are reasonable and the atmosphere is great classy bit laid back can't wait to come back :)
SLGY
Highly recommend eating here while vacationing in key west. Would recommend the shrimp poboy and conch fritters. Impressive bloody marys. A must eat while in key west.
Emily Pernal
Huge juicy burgers.. Cooked to order and fabulous toppings. Enough said.
Sheryl
Food was outstanding and large portions. We had fish tacos and the sloppy grouper. Friendly fast service. Great spot to people watch
FA Jenn
Good! Had ahi appt, grouper sandwich (huge-it was shared and great) and mahi tacos. Lots of bang for the buck. Nice atmosphere outside. Service was mediocre but worth the stop for the food.
KellyR
Great food. Reasonable prices. Our server, Samantha was excellent. And the best part? The coldest beer I've had all week!!
Ronnie
TOP NOTCH!. Fogarty's, without a doubt is the best restaraunt in Key West! Wonderful decor along with a kind wait staff; one could not be anymore pleased. The Grouper de Caren is PHENOMENAL! In comparison w/ Blue Heaven . . . I wish I would have tried Fogarty's first; a better taste and an extra $25 in my pocket I would have.<br/><br/>The outside setting on Duvall is purely magical. The staff again is sweet and pleasureable. We also had the ahi tuna app and were knocked off our feet. SO SO GOOD. One of the best I have had. My wife had the Salmon and she too was blown away.<br/><br/>I wish we had a restaurant in Virginia Beach of Fogarty's caliber for the price. It truly is one of the things I will most miss about Key West.
Hatguy
Liked it very much. The Ahi tuna appetizer was delectable, as was the Key West sampler. Service was excellent both times we were there. 3-stars
Stephanie McClain Boyd
Great view of Duvall but not the standard Duvall fair. We had the peppered Ahi tuna appetizer-excellent. Also the shrimp BLT & the shrimp po boy were great sandwiches! The service was knowledgeble & polite.
TJ Benoit
Great food, reasonable prices, great wait staff
Jason B
Beautiful outdoor setting for dinner on Duval Street. Good, reliable food.
Ryno
Fresh seafood, great service, and good frozen drinks...what more could you ask for?
Randall Mahon
The Flying Monkey drinks connected to Fogarty's has some of the best frozen drinks on the Island.....raspberry drinks with seeds, Pina Coladas with chunks of pineapple and plenty of liquor- worth the visit!
Tabithaluvr
Food was good and service was good! Got the "key west feeling" when you sit outside!
Joe C.
We didn't actually eat at the restaraunt but rather drank numerous frozen cocktails at their outside bar called the Flying Monkey. You must try the Banana drink, which is like a banana smoothy with alcohol. Bartenders were very friendly and it's a perfect spot to people watch on Duval St.
Alli Deneweth
Very disappointing. Overpriced, and the service was lackluster. Many superior resturants in Key West to puck from.
Carmelo Salazar
Very good option to lunch or dinner if you are looking for something quick and tasty in the middle of Duval st. Appetizers are very good!!
Mike C
Fun spot to sit and eat while hitting up the bars on Duval St. Recommended by our taxi driver we sat outside had good drinks and food at the right price
WAherron
A Tour Stop. 3 Stars - <br/><br/>We dined at the patio of Fogarty's while on a "Taste of Key West" excursion tour that we booked through our Cruise Line. The food and service were good. We snacked on the conch fritters and the dolphin fish (mahi mahi). The dolphin was the better of the two and was exceptionally tasty. Fogarty's patio is shared with the Flying Monkey Bar which has a large selection of frozen drinks. We had a drink called the Howler which was like an adult Limeade. Very good.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes