The best Grilled cheese in Key West | Sluurpy updated in May

"Cool place, unique. Not sure what type of sex y'all having though lol not that great. Love the taste on what I tried. Liked that the owners did it..."

Howie Groves

"What a unique idea, a restaurant that focuses on sensual gourmet deserts. Plus the name "Better Than Sex". You know I had to check out this place..."

Andrew

"Great place to experience decadent and sinful dessert. Perfect for birthday blowout or a romantic date. Outstanding key lime pie. Definitely try the..."

Alexis B

"A must try if you are in Key West and are looking for something out of the ordinary. My favorite dessert that I tried was the peanut perversion...."

Stephen

"Excellent time, everything from service to drinks to dessert was flawless and delicious. We will definitely be back and recommend to all we know. ..."

Brian Vanyo

"Fun place. Reservations a must. Drinks are sweet and unique. Caramel used to dip the glasses is super yummy. Good variety of desserts. Good flavor...."

HungryGirl

"My family and I went to this dessert spot, yes I know and yes my parents did make plenty of jokes. We really enjoyed it and it was friendly for older..."

Natalie

"So good! I got the Better Than Sex (chocolate bread pudding) and it blew my mind. Boyfriend got the chocolate grilled cheese and it was excellent as..."

Thomas Rice

"Does it live up to its name? Well, no... But it serves excellent desserts and it has a cute theme. Eat light before you go. This is incredibly..."

Internet Shopper

"A great reason to skip dinner. The Irish Cream is really good. The grilled cheese with chocolate was really good. We also tried the chocolate chip..."

Scott

"My husband and I are honeymooning in key west and as soon as we saw this restaurant/dessert place and knew we had to come. The atmosphere was..."

Carrie Moore

"Amazing! A must-go place in Key West! Went with my parents thinking it may be odd to go as the idea of the bar seems sensual, however it felt very..."

Sarah Jessica Pulaski

"Rate this place a 5.0 for dessert. I knew the name was a lie but I get where they are coming from. The hardest part was choosing from the decadent..."

FoodJunkee

"Amazing service and amazing..."

Kaite Stapleton

"Fun! Great folks! Fabulous experience! Everything on menu is a winner! When in KW, ya gotta..."

Rusty

"Definitely one of a kind.... Wine with Chocolate! The Shocker was very complimentary and the grilled Brie cheese was fabulous .. Thanks..."

Jerome Stone

"Awesome Desserts and Staff. After being seated and giving us the menu (which in itself is fun) when ordering our server (Taylor) asked if we were..."

Smj_54

"Such a fun and tantalizing experience! Service was awesome and if you are looking for a unique and sexy/romantic experience this is worth the stop!..."

Andersonbets05

"Absolutely fantastic and creative desserts and specialty drinks. MAKE RESERVATIONS. Great, speedy service. I would take anyone here as a..."

Cody Cragnolin

"Indulgence. Luxuria (lechery/lust)... we had to get in; gula (gluttony)... we ate too much; avaritia (avarice/greed)... and wanted more; acedia..."

Peanutgallery

"Oh yeah, Baby! Soooo good! My hubby had the Kinky Key West Cream Pie (tart and creamy) and I had the Better than Sex bread pudding! It was the..."

MsFoodie

"Amazing!!!! A must-go in Key..."

Dhara Shah

"Make this a "Must!" in Key West. Oh, the keys to love. Well, at Better than Sex, it literally is. Whenever we visit Key West, my husband and I always..."

Allyssa Evergreen (Arissa)

"The desserts are great. The drinks are fun- but even if you do not do alcohol-this is the place to go after any meal anywhere else. Romantic..."

Joye Cranfill

"Oh my god! So wonderful! I couldn't even stop eating it to take a picture! Great, I would definetly recommend..."

Amelia Coates

"I had driven by this restaurant on previous trips and had always wanted to stop in. I am SO glad I finally made it! Upon walking in the staff was..."

Elizawfeddy

"A-MAZING! We both had an Cream "In My" Coffee with a white chocolate rim. Delicious and lots of fun to lick the rim! (no pun intended) I had Jungle..."

Jennifer B

"I made reservations for my boyfriend's birthday. He was very impressed with the theme, the waitress, and the desserts. Our favorite was the red..."

Millicent Moum

"Worth the wait! An hour wait but they text you when the table is ready, & held it until we could make our way back. Romantic atmosphere, and a wide..."

TGK512

"Had a great experience at Better Than Sex. Very cosy place, good drinks, and great desserts. Waitress was very attentive and took great care of..."

Tag Smith

"We celebrated my girlfriends birthday and it was amazing! The staff was super friendly and informative on all their delicious choices. This was her..."

Jay Gomel

"Delicious red velvet cheesecake. Went there on vacation and was not disappointed. Great concept for a..."

Powersposse

"First of all, I thought for a place named Better Than Sex, it was cleaner and more classy than a walk down Duval, or hey, go read some tshirts at a..."

Jamie Elizabeth

"Fantastic you gotta go..."

Jon

"Perfect valentines dessert dinner for three single girls ---wine glasses with caramel are a must! friendly, attentive service..."

Michelle Niezabytowski

"Yummy! Delicious desserts. Clever menu - sexy descriptions of the desserts and drinks. Great atmosphere. I you had a great meal, a relaxing day on..."

Jennifer

"Very fun! Good desserts and great drinks. How decadent-Port with dark chocolate dripping from the rim!!! Over the..."

RRR

"Luv It. Would really like to see a restraunt o f ths calibre serve equally exquisite..."

Saundrac9

"This has been the most amazing place my wife and I have been to in Key West. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful. The menu had great..."

Robert

"Great experience. Desserts are delicious, portions are big that you can..."

Gus Barres

"Pricey but worth it. A must-do when visiting Key West. Go extremely hungry for sweets when ordering here. I recommend sharing a dessert and getting..."

Rebecca Daniel

"Amazing!. On of my favorite little places to eat on key west. Last time I visited key west I was told by a local friend to visit this dessert..."

Stacey

"Can't wait to go back. Better Than Sex is seductively unique. Love the atmosphere, the staff, and of course their decadent menu! We started off with..."

Mogos11

"Did not live up to hype so I was disappointed... Would not go..."

Julia

"A great experience. We had finished our dinner at a nearby tapas place (Santiago's Bodega) that had provided us with decent food, and insensitive,..."

Bdb

"Wonderful! Well worth the hassle of making a reservation. My husband is a notorious sweets hater, but he got the Lava Cake and ate until he was..."

Turtle Blossom

"Loved it. All the locals love this place, myself included. A little loud with a rowdy table next to me but still a great time. Very unique! Who knew..."

Shelly

"Wrong location. Location is wrong on map. It is next to Blue..."

Nate

"Great place. We tried most of the menu and I got to tell you: it is delicious. Shout out to Kelly: your namesake drink was..."

EatingWellisAnArtForm

"Fun place. Interesting and fun ambient restaurant. Desserts are very unique and..."

Wnorton

"There's a common entrepreneurial axiom that states, "Find one thing and do it exceptionally well." No better is this realized at this establishment...."

Aaron Godshall

"Romantic and decadent. Mood lighting takes on a whole new meaning at this place. Candles light each table, but only provide enough light to look into..."

Tracy Mallett

"Ok, it really was sinfully good red velvet cheesecake and Kelly's Klimax was awesome but not sure if the tab was worth it quite frankly. A nice..."

TheQueenHasSpoken

"Sinful! Best desserts I have ever..."

SolDesigns.net

"Sexy, fun, and incredibly..."

KL

"Crazy Cool. Wow - worth the wait! Although make it east on yourself and make a reservation. This place was all we talked about when we returned home...."

Jen G

"Decadent delight off the beaten path. Dark and draped in fabric for atmosphere (they provide flashlight to read menu). Both desserts we shared were..."

Kate K

"Very cool concept. Atmosphere is fantastic. Desserts are huge and I would definitely share next time. I'm not much of a dessert person, but this..."

Kirk

"Dessert restaurant. Our group of 6 got 5 desserts. Everyone like Cookie Nookie the best. The Key Lime was more like a mousse that a true key lime..."

Glenda Boudreaux

"Best Key LIme Pie. Period.. Their key lime pie is the best we have had in 30+ years. We were in KW 2 years ago, shortly after BTS had opened, and..."

Elaine

"You'll be left wanting more :). Choco Rimmed Cab...AMAZING. There's also the Caramel lined Riesling if you don't drink red. Dani's desserts are..."

Danielle

"This restaurant is so much fun! It's dark and romantic, but the staff seem to have a great time working there. We had the cookie nookie pie and red..."

Ktford

"Food was pretty good, but the experience was something else. It was awesome! Not only is it romantic, but it is also insanely fun. I definitely would..."

Trevor Wayne

"Everything on the menu is amazing. Come here hungry and you'll still leave with a to go bag. Great atmosphere and the staff is very..."

Honomac

"Very unique and wonderful!. We went here after a dinner at Blue Heaven and were a bit stuffed but managed to still have a good time. The service was..."

S_dub

"Decadent desserts & romantical..."

ArtEnvee'ist

"The most Romantic, and coolest place you can go to eat in Key West!. So my husband I came down to Kw for our honeymoon. We heard about this place and..."

Feed Me

"Neat atmosphere and yummy desserts and drinks! However, definitely make a reservation (esp on weekends) and I'd wait a little after dinner so you..."

Sara

"Amazing! If you are going to have dessert in key west you have to eat at better than sex. Great service, amazing..."

Jadyn Smith

"Found this restaurant using urban spoon and went just because of the catchy name, However it is an amazing experience! Knowledgeable friendly staff..."

Andrew Chase

"Truly cool place. After hearing from another guest in our B&B about this place we decided to visit for a late snack. We loved the look of the lounge..."

CowTown ChowHound

"Wonderful!. All of the desserts are sex-themed and it was both hilarious and incredibly tasty. All of the menu items are presented in a really class..."

Meg

"This place is ridiculous – in a really amazing, awesome, slightly dirty way. If you go to Key West you really need to give this place a go. Well,..."

Andrew

"For dessert I got the Twist and Stout chocolate cake served with Irish Cream ice cream on the side in a mini beer mug. Adorable and to die for. I..."

FoodieOnTheSide.com

"We were led to our table by a woman carrying a flashlight. This place was amazing - you must visit it if you are in Key West. I was a little..."

Megan Wood

"Food-wise, I wasn’t quite sure the restaurant lived up to it’s name. But then I realized — this place wasn’t just about the food. It was..."

Katie - Domestiphobia.net

"This was my first time at this restaurant and I can honesty say it was amazing! Visiting from DC on our honeymoon and we decided we would come to..."

Linda Pena

"This was our fourth trip to Key West where we walked by the dark windows of this dessert bar and thought: “I wonder what it’s like inside.” So..."

Ginny Holden

"Alyways a great experience, our waitress Vivian knew her stuff and answered every question for us. There was a short black out and you barely even..."

Scott Manley

"What a fun way to spend a bit of quiet time with the one you love over a bit of drink and some fantastic desserts. My husband made the reservation,..."

David Silva

"Went on an anniversary date. I screwed up the reservation time and the host solved the issue and got us a table instantly. Amazing everything. The..."

Cody McKinney

"We made reservations for my husband and I since it is very small. The decor is dark, with candles and chandeliers all over. There are erotic..."

Bere Arrie

"The whole experience was fun and relaxing! The desserts were amazing and the Love Potion 69 shot was my absolute favorite! I would go back just for..."

Julie Hopkins

"If your wondering how our 31 year Anniversary evening went, well we couldn’t decide between Caress My Carrot or with the Perfect Partner. My..."

Orlando Valdes

"The experience didn’t quite meet the hype. Although I’m glad we went as the DESSERT was so delicious! Definitely need reservations! It was a nice..."

Bridgette Z

"Second time at this location! The first time I went with a friend and now I took my boyfriend. I have never had a dessert here that disappointed me...."

Samantha LeRoy

"Our desert and drinks were excellent, and the service was great. All staff were super friendly and warm. Seating in main room has a better..."

Doug Meyer

"The service at BTS Key West was incredible. Rene was attentive, personable, and funny which made the experience that much more enjoyable. The..."

Erika Wilcox

"Absolutely amazing place. Super cute decor loved the candles. We got the dessert sampler and all of them were amazing and the details on each one..."

Shannon Chiles

"What an amazing experience. From the moment you open the door you get the feeling like your stepping into a super intense experience!!! The host..."

M Kellis

"Definitely worth the visit. I reserved a table via google and they texted to reconfirm an hour or so ahead. My husband and I are newly weds and these..."

Alex M

"Simply amazing! Their handcrafted liquor was delicious and the desserts were even better. We were impressed alone by the atmosphere. They covered..."

Allison Frickanish

"Amazing! We had to wait 2 minutes for our reservation while they cleaned our table, which is absolutely normal and fine but the host (possibly..."

Danielle Bellia

"My first experience was truly memorable, and I’m already looking forward to returning. Vivian provided exceptional service, offering great menu..."

Reset

There are 6 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Grilled cheese in Key West

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Gabi Jung

Jamie Quintanilla

Kim Gibson

Justin Macneal

Montana Gow Dunton

Nancy O. Porter

Scott Pope

Stephanie Laws

Sharlene Walker-Skocny

Ashton Gill

Karen Easley-Froberg

Susan Vale

Madison Lee

W Russell Overman

Amy Macneal

Karen Sinclair Ellison

Kelly Lee Hansen

Marco Loyola

Lori Miller

Greg Ayers

Hope Brown

Mary C

Nina K

Lyndsay Brown

J. Allison

Rhonda M

tC

Brittany Wiggins

Allison Chave

Joe Dukes

amy thompson

Gillian Fox

Andrew Price

Lauren Armstrong

Jughead'z Hemp

Casie Raines

Patrick Cody

Dave Peterson

Lily Anderson

Matt Lamb

Howie Groves

Andrew

Alexis B

Stephen

Brian Vanyo

HungryGirl

Natalie

Thomas Rice

Internet Shopper

Scott

Carrie Moore

Sarah Jessica Pulaski

FoodJunkee

Kaite Stapleton

Rusty

Jerome Stone

Smj_54

Andersonbets05

Cody Cragnolin

Peanutgallery

MsFoodie

Dhara Shah

Allyssa Evergreen (Arissa)

Joye Cranfill

Amelia Coates

Elizawfeddy

Jennifer B

Millicent Moum