The best Paella in Key West | Sluurpy updated in May

Nine One Five

83/100 (4661 ratings)

Restaurants

Italian

Vegetarian Friendly

Mediterranean

Gluten Free Options

Contemporary

Italian

Seafood

American

Seafood

American

Mediterranean

Vegan Options

Contemporary

Vegetarian Friendly

Gluten Free Options

Vegan Options

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Pork

Tortillas

Tuna

Shrimp

Tortelli

Calamares

Beef

Salmon

Lobster

Duck Confit

Confit

Crab Cake

Pasta

Octopus

Tapas

Tacos

Salad

Bolognese

Tortellini

Filet Mignon

Crab

Tortelloni

Ribs

Scallops

Key lime pie

French Fries

Clams

Ceviche

Curry

Duck

Cheeseburger

Paella

Calamari

Burger

Cakes

Pesto

Risotto

Fish

Polenta

Mussels

Sit down

Contemporary

Seafood

Mediterranean

Italian

American

Outdoor Seating

Accepts Mastercard

Accepts Visa

Reservations

Accepts American Express

Street Parking

Seating

Table Service

Serves Alcohol

Accepts Discover

Wine and Beer

Gift Cards Available

Full Bar

Accepts Credit Cards

Non-smoking restaurants

Dog Friendly

Late Night

Dinner

Fine Dining

"This place is great. Delicious appetizers and entrees. The chicken is very good. Also the Grouper svchi is really good. The deserts are really good..."

Kylerobik

"My mom and I recently ate at Nine One Five 4/5/16 the food was fabulous the staff were friendly and attentive we sat outside it was..."

Kathleen Oconnell

"Good option on Truman Street when hungry and decided to eat in peace and well;)Service is good,we both ordered filet mignon ravioli which..."

Gmerk

"A little cramped layout. However the food and service is great. The hamburger is one of the best I have had in a while. The asparagus is also really..."

Scott

"Best of Key West. Nine One Five has everything great going for it: Location, space, design, great menu and a rocking wine bar upstairs...."

BN

"Upstairs is point 5 their pizza, bar, and small menu items. We had good service and loved the view. But the salad was bland and the pizza margaherita..."

American_sweet

"Sunday Night, service a little slow. Appetizers and Entree' good. Dessert way too sweet. Go for the food, especially the..."

Brian C

"OH MY GOSH!!! Amazing! We went and just got a bunch of starters and snacks and sides. They were great. I recommend Devils on horseback, crab cakes,..."

Annie H

"Superb. Quaint, centrally located restaurant with a great menu. Tapas are available upstairs. Service is OUTSTANDING!!!!You must have the fried whole..."

George Peterson

"My husband and I recently enjoyed a delicious dinner and great service at 915. We started out outside under an awning but the staff took initiative..."

Sk

"Fabulous food!! Highly recommend Orange & Chipotle Braised Pork; Dungeness Crab Chowder; Devils on Horseback; Crispy Duck Confit...all Starters & all..."

Bente Humphrey

"Great service, interesting blend of euro and asian seafood dishes. Don't miss the Thai whole fish with ginger fish sauce or the grouper with beliga..."

Tom Hyland Robertson

"Duck confit is fabulous. Good..."

Mary B.

"High Living. The prices may be higher, but you truly get what you pay for with the taste, presentation, service, and atmosphere.MUST-HAVE..."

Shapes

"915. Six of us had a great meal here. The Tuna Bomb was very good and the grouper on risotto and spinach. I had soup and salad because we were..."

Glenda Boudreaux

"LOVE it WELL!. I owned a restaurant callled "Savannah," Good Home Cookin' in the same location back in the 80's, and though 915 is nothing like..."

Garth

"A Must Stop For Any Foodie!. I eat here every time I am in Key West. To me,this is the most relaxing place on the whole island to have a meal. The..."

Punks

"We (two couples) did a tapas style dinner and found the food to be creative and well-prepared. The wine list was fine with a good range both in terms..."

Todd

"I love the passionate expressions used in all these reviews. 915 is quite good at rousing passion. We local folks are proud to claim this totally..."

Toni Davis

"Food was excellent! Grouper had a spicy potatoe coumin flavor. Filet melts in your..."

ArtEnvee'ist

"At there on a recommendation of hotel staff. Extensive wine list. Great lounge atmosphere...casual and in a way urban chic. I had the grouper while..."

Mildude

"Impeccable food, steak and whole fish were amazing. Calamari was done..."

Chris Mehr

"Never mind the "foodie" and the uptight "had to pour my own wine" below. The food and service at 9-1-5 was excellent. The place was packed when we..."

D Rock

"PERFECT EXPERIENCE. This restaurant was hands down the best meal we had in Key West. We had late reservations and sat on the upstairs balcony. Fun..."

Heidi

"Excellent food and service. A top choice for dining in Key..."

Bryan Fuerst

"Quite possibly the best meal in key..."

Photogirl

"Very good tapas. Relaxing upstairs with friendly..."

Radman

"I will make this easy...if you have dinner plans any where else, cancel them. Quite simply..."

Jhout

"Nice spot right on the main street. It's in an old house and is quaint inside. Lots of outdoor seating available as well. Service was great as was..."

Rob Q

"Had a wonderful dinner at this place. All the shareable items are delicious and great to share with good company. Loved the Lobster mini tacos and..."

Manisit Das

"Very good restaurant right on Duval where we found the service to be excellent and the food very good as well. If you’re considering 915 vs their..."

C Tedesco

"Outstanding meal. Best lamb chops i ever tasted. Very unique take on the ket west key lime..."

joe celona

"I'd rate 915 as a 3.5 right in the middle. The food was definitely good. I had a burger cooked a perfect medium rare and the fries were solid. The..."

Richie Pawlowski

"We came here at 10:45 for a late dinner and it was outstanding. Highly recommend the Grass Fed Burger with truffle fries. Also the asparagus was very..."

Josh Eidenberg

"Excellent food and nice atmosphere. The servers were fantastic and the fish couldn't be any fresher. They offer the fresh catch of the day 🐠 and..."

Phil Sigler

"Perfect location for people watching on Duvall…while grabbing a delicious meal! Menu was creative and not overwhelming…dishes we tried were very..."

T CH

"Came in for dinner after someone recommend we give it a try. Oh boy did that recommendation not disappoint. Hubby had grilled octopus appetizer, I..."

Jennifer Susko

"My wife and I picked up a reservation to this spot on OpenTable as our "date night" while in Key West and it delivered! The menu was varied and each..."

Will Powell

"The building and setup is really nice, quaint, and romantic. We sat in a table right next to Duval St, they had a ton of fans to make it very..."

Ryan InMIA

"Amazing hidden gem. Make a reservation you won’t be disappointed. Service and food were 6 stars. Best black grouper and wagu beef burger. The..."

David Pfeffer

"One of our favorite spots on the island, we've never had a meal here that wasn't amazing. Great place to go for a "blue" stake if you like yours that..."

Casey Gandy

"I was told by the concierge at our hotel that this place had the best key lime pie on the island. But I found all the food here to be delectable...."

Terry Mohammed

"Anna is an exceptional server. We had the special of black grouper with a creamy crab risotto. It was wonderful. Great atmosphere, excellent dirty..."

Sarah Kindinger

"Above average meal. The ambience and service were lovely. The 80’s music playing didn’t really fit the atmosphere, IMO. The food was overall..."

Jenny Jacobs-Taylor

"Exceptional staff. Exceptional food whole fish was perfect. Beet salad was to die for. Cauliflower dish was amazing. Truly fresh. Chef was on point...."

Phil Grimes

"One of, if not, our best meals of the week! Everything was excellent from the calamari appetizer, the whole fried snapper, and the grouper day boat...."

Clint Teasley

"Had an excellent experience here. There was a wait so we actually went upstairs to Point Five. They allowed us to order from the nine one five menu...."

Reset

There are 9 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Paella in Key West

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Malika

Steve X

Jazzmin Cabrera

Hina Yu Cao

Nadjalisse Rodriguez

Zachary Williams

Shannon Richards

brittany hemingway

Brett Timms

Thomas Atwater

Linda WhiteWolf

Tanja Breckwoldt

Antonio Santiago

Christina guilh

Kathleen Tynes

Tammy Siebert

Julia Kapfensteiner

Amanda Bailey

carol maurer

Oleg Drokin

Breanne Tyre

Lauralei Burnette

Casey Saiz

Phat Girl Eats World

Milly Gomez

Nathaniel Lutes

Maddie Olson

Qi Li

Ash Thimmaiah

jmike 45acp

Weston Hood

Katrinka Tezyk

Amanda Grace

Becky Porter

Heather East

Sean Matthew Whitfield

Britney Ormond

Nikki Shields

Anto Yauwanta

Tomata Travel

Rod CeFu

Chris Yust LaClaire

Alisha

Mahjabeen Rahman

Dan-O The Mad Scientist

Dallas Mallory

Robert Berg

Danielle Rolfe

Bekka Garcia

Sean Young

Geidy Alfonso

Lu V

Karthik Sivakoti

Rachel Edds

J. Winfrey Culbertson

George Panayiotou

Mark Kahle

Chris Scott

Alyssa Peretin

Collette

Monika Day

Andrew J

Tatiana Panova

AmbeRR

Brittany Ross

Ryan Beverly

Maureen kelly matyczuk

Mark