Sluurpy
Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best New York Style Pizza in Key West

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Big John's Pizzeria
87/100 (1274 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Salad
Wings
Alfredo
Meatballs
Lasagne
Sandwiches
New York Style Pizza
Pesto
Shrimp
Eggplant
Pasta
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"We got the Hawaiian, Blue Pie, and the Margarita pizzas. I loved the Blue pie but no one else in our party liked it. Strong Gorgonzola flavor. The..."
Rock’n A
"Delish! I must say we have encountered really terrible service at most every place we stopped at in The Keys. This restaurant was incredible; from..."
Dee M
"Big John’s Pizzeria Is Great! Their pizza is good. The interior is decorated beautifully with the lights, and all the great Italian decorations. ..."
Jack Carello
"I have eaten in and had delivery from here. So good!!! The ultimate we had in restaurant and was absolutely delicious, so much flavor. The stuffed..."
Meredith Ammer
"One of the best mom and pop pizzerias in the Florida Keys! Everything was delicious! The all-the-way pizza couldn’t have been better. Loaded with..."
A Muncie Experience
"Amazing pizzeria! Wings, pizza, and garlic knots were so good. I heard the garlic knots are a popular item here and I can see..."
Sheneeza Misir
"Pizza was so good , the marinara was also tasty . I would definitely go back when in town..."
Cocoa Rose
"Photos should speak for themselves. For 25+ years of experience, this place knows what they’re doing. Best place for good food & a good time. Next..."
Nicole
"As a Conch Local that's traveled and eaten lots of good Italian.. Omg what a surprise, this was so good! I'm stuffed and so happy I tried this place..."
Michael Logan
"This is the best pizza I have tried in all of the keys. You can tell that the ingredients are fresh and very good quality. It's very cliche to say..."
shawn lasher
"Had the chicken parm sandwich, I highly recommend it. The ratio of chicken to sauce and cheese was perfect. Seasoning was very good and the bun..."
Jeremy Medinac
"Located in Key West, Fla. I was told by the locals that this was the place to go for pizza in Key West, and they were definitely correct. This is a..."
Quikdraw 72
"Let me start with, Pizza is my favorite food. I am in town for a week, and I’ve tried pizza at a few places, big John’s pizzeria exceeded those..."
Christopher Renteria
"In Key West and found this little jewel. We were here for 5 days & we ate here 3 times. Pizza crust was amazing. Pasta was good, ( could have used..."
Tracy Gray
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use