My page
Exit
×
×
Reset
There are 10 restaurants
Cuisine
Dietary restrictions
Meals
Structure
Dishes
Home
Restaurants in United States
Best Gelato in Key West
There are 10 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Key Best Pizza
98
/100 (268 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Breakfast
Ice Cream
Gelato
Gelateria Nuovo Fiore Key West
97
/100 (731 ratings)
Dessert
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Ice Cream
Gelato
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"The best ice-cream i ever eat . Very tasty and healthy. Do not miss to eat a great italian gelato if you go to key west..."
Gioia Laghi Traini
"I could eat this everyday. Too bad it's far away. Loved the coconut..."
Mell Bello
"The REAL Gelato!! ARTIGIANAL , Natural and fresh!!..."
Mary Grace Laghi
"It's homeade, and the flavors are great! You can taste the fresh ingredients, I was surprised at how awesome it tasted! You can get ice cream..."
Cameron Tylek
"My husband and I have tons of food allergies, including corn, so we never get to enjoy ice cream. Gladiators ice cream signs caught my attention when..."
Amber Fox
"Really good Ice cream. The attendant was very friendly. Had some interesting flavours, would highly recommend. I would not get the Kiwi Slush again..."
Yusuf Sema
"This is the Best ice cream I’ve ever eaten. My credentials? I live next to 3 dairy farms and all of them are fantastic. I’m sorry they are not in..."
Kris bishop
"Even besides the fact that this is a family-run, handmade, local gem (especially compared to run-of-the-mill Haagen Daz next door), their ice cream..."
Oona Boyle
"Best ice cream my husband and I have ever had. We drove an hour from where we were staying and would do it again just for this. We got watermelon,..."
Tiffany Vroom
"Hands down, the best homemade ice cream I've ever had. I wanted to try them all but opted for the Cantaloupe. It was incredibly..."
X H
"Seriously, hands down, the best ice cream in the states. Creamy, rich, and delicious! I've been traveling to the keys for several years and always..."
Chelsea Zigler
"This is our second time driving 1hour down from Marathon and we plan to come back that distance again just for this ice cream! We had no idea how..."
Slv Clml
"Saw this little ice-cream shop by Malloy Square in down town Keywest. Sign said ice-cream made from scratch. It also said it has been open since..."
Tyler K
"Super fresh, creamy ice creams! The key lime, strawberry, and mango flavors were all absolutely delicious. Would highly recommend to support a local..."
Vasundhara Bagchi
"This is the BEST ice cream I’ve ever had!! During my family’s stay in key west we went every night. I highly recommend trying either the key lime..."
Hannah Rose
"This was the BEST ice cream I've ever had. I've had homemade before, I've had gelato, I've had authentic Italian ice; this by far surpassed them all...."
Martha
"Tucked away on Front Street you will find one of the hidden gems of Key West. Gladiator Ice cream makes probably the best ice cream that you will..."
Salty Seadog
"This was a great stop on our visit to Key West… the ice cream was AWESOME!! Highly..."
Mike Creed
"The best homemade ice cream I've ever had. This is the only place I've found cantaloupe ice cream and it is too die for and so refreshing. I go to..."
terri betts
"The peanut butter ice cream is worth the trip to Key West. I will dream of this ice cream until I return to Key West! Fresh homemade. The best ice..."
Tanja
Mattheessen's Candy Kitchen
93
/100 (1192 ratings)
Dessert
Bakeries
American
American
Late Night
Ice Cream
Gelato
Key lime pie
Macarons
Macaroons
Cakes
Sit down
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Late Night
Cheap Eats
"I cannot say enough about how good these cookies are to eat! I have ordered online twice and shipped out of state because my family loves them so..."
Kaye Tompkins
"Ordered fudge cookie, priced higher than the other cookies, as well as a chocolate chip cookie. As my husband put it, this was beyond the best..."
CMB Caspanello
"Cookies were huge and actually delicious. I got the chocolate chip with pecans. Sometimes when cookies are that big they loose their flavor, not..."
Cynthia Rossi
"Mattheessen’s Candy Kitchen Is Awesome! The cookies are delicious. They also have ice cream, and a bunch of other great desserts. Without any..."
Jack Carello
"You can tell the key lime pie was homemade. The crust was thick but the filling was..."
Rashaad Kauterman
"The cookies are huge and the ice cream was tasty! It was fun to see them making all the treats right there in the shop! I put my hand in the photo to..."
Desiree Rose
"Mattheessen's peanut butter fudge cookie was, by far, the best cookie I have ever had in my life - it's unrivaled. Their portions were generous,..."
Jaylin
"Wow!!! I initially would have rated this place as 4 stars, but after a return trip it is definitely a 5 for treats! I was not a fan of their key..."
Ron Lilly
"We got fudge, an M&M cookie and also key lime pie. The ranking was Fudge, Key lime pie, then the cookie was probably the worst one. I wish it was..."
Richard Nelson
"Hands down the best chocolate chip cookie I have ever had! Their cookies are HUGE so you might want to share! Ask for their ice cream sandwich - YUM!..."
Suzanne Piskadlo
Meet Burger Usa
88
/100 (611 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Grill
American
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Wings
Gelato
Wild boar
Burger
Hamburgers
Shrimp
Beef
Salad
Le Macaron
87
/100 (200 ratings)
Restaurants
Dessert
French
French
Ice Cream
Gelato
Macarons
Macaroons
Café
French
Takeout
Wheelchair Accessible
Mid-range
"Shop is meticulous! Everything is so cute and in place. Selection is amazing. I am huge fan of anything pistachio and I asked the owner/chef what..."
AliandAzi Vousoughian
"I was on vacation over Christmas and being gluten free I haven't had any pastries in 6 months. When I walked in I was in flutes heaven! I bought a..."
Viki Patinsky Torres
"Macaroons are to die for, although seemed on the expensive side to..."
Susan Buckle
"This place is super cute and the gelato and macaron I had was..."
Elaine Brady
"This was great ! Best gelato topped with the best macaron � By rallycar69 and..."
Dirk de Groen
"My wife and I loved the awesome macarons and..."
Anthony DelSignore
"best icecream in key west by far!!! the apricot and violet are my favorite, great service..."
Elena Mashtakova
"Love, love, love this place! Very beautifully crafted..."
Vidal
"They always take care of us here! Macarons are phenomenal and the espresso..."
Lori Abramson
"Good place if you want to try some nice French pastries. We just wanted to try out macarons since we have never had one. We tried, as far as I..."
Jay Mehta
"Sweeest macaroons and the sweetest place..."
semini gunawardana
"It's a chain shop, same as the one I visited in Savannah in August this year. The chocolates are as beautiful as they are tasty. The macarons are..."
Heather Steinmiller
"First if all the people running this adorable and sweet establishment we're so incredibly nice and generous. The macrons were beautiful and so..."
Eileen Plocicki
"Macaroons are good. Located right on Duvall Street. My daughter always has to stop in and grab a few different flavors of macaroons. Couple small..."
David Whittinghill
"What a cute shop on Duval St.! So many flavors to choose from it was hard to decide! My favorite was Bubblegum and it was blue! These kinds of treats..."
Rita Pearson
"Picked up some macarons on our adventures down Duval street in Key West. The store was cute and had different types of two-bite desserts to offer..."
Christen B
"Absolutely love this place! Very nice people running it and delicious macarons, best I've ever tasted. Plus, unique ice cream flavors, I'd definitely..."
Helen Bosco
"These macarons were so good the vanilla and coconut ones were very very fluffy and just so gooood in your mouth if you like macarons I would..."
Hayley Fowler
"The best desserts in Key West! Sarah is the most amazing artist. Her desserts are to die for! The lounge area is very inviting. Deff making this a..."
Michael McManus
"Wonderful place for macaroons. I loved their rose macaroon! I wish I had gotten more. Very nice..."
waheeda shaik
"Always delicious but very..."
LeeLee C
"one of my favorite places for ice-cream in key west, the apricot and violet are heavenly good, the service is always great and very personal, keep up..."
Elena Mashtakov
"WONDERFUL authentic French macarons and candies. Absolutely loved this place and their gluten free..."
William M
"Sarah, has an excellent location, everything we tried was excellent! The coffee was made to perfection and a great start for the..."
T Rudzinski
"This place is so..."
Shaquala Rice
"ORDERED BY PHONE MACAROONS FOR XMAS FOR MY GRANDCHILDREN IN KEY WEST. SUCH NICE, HELPFUL PATIENT PEOPLE. HIGHLY..."
marilyn forman
"Got 2 scoops of ice cream and a macaron, it was just delicious. Great..."
Frederic Boissinot
Duetto Pizza And Gelato
87
/100 (4340 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Tiramisu
Ice Cream
Sandwiches
Gelato
Focaccia
Paninis
Salad
Risotto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Digital Payments
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Late Night
Lunch
Drinks
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"When you need to stop for a moment to cool down, enjoy real gelato here. Their adffogato with a dollop of tiramisu flavored gelato was a treat. Their..."
Epi
"Pizza was delicious. Quick turn around. Nice staff. It's just super tiny. Two little tables and maybe six chairs. Not much standing room either. Plan..."
MAMA Bookasaurus
"BEST PIZZA I've had, ever. So good. I had the Biancaneve and my sister had the spicy salami and con carne. All was delicious. Also had gelato, so..."
Catguer52
"Duettos. My sister and I had an awesome getaway to Key West, FL. We walked a LOT, and one of our food stops was at Duetto’s pizza. Rated as the..."
Felicia Braude
"Excellent pizza - we got a cheese, a sausage/pepperoni and a white bianca pizza. They were all great. Sampled some gelato while I waited - they were..."
Jack C
"Yummy pizza and very friendly staff. I was pleasantly surprised how tasty this was, given its touristy..."
Pbjrhj
"Best pizza I have ever tasted. It was like being back in Italy . I was surprise at the pricing was low considering the..."
Douglas Mudge
"Wonderful pizza and the best gelato I've ever had. Even better the owner is very nice and accommodating. Would go back again and..."
Nicole Vogt
"Good pizza and freshly made pizza. It was all really great. Very friendly employees. They just need more places to..."
Floridafoodie
"SERIOUSLY amazing gelato! The best I have literally ever had. The owners are amazing people and are creating amazing food. I was in Key West with my..."
Amy Heidemann
"DELICIOUS.. I had the ham + mushroom pizza & chocolate coconut gelato- WOW. Great prices, friendly service, best pizza I've ever had. A definite..."
Acb244
"I went to Italy last year so I have tasted real gelato and this is just as good!! Everything here is amazing. Come here if you want a cheap fast..."
Annie H
"Definitely ask for them to cook the pizza well done otherwise I don't think it would have been good. Looked raw. We always have our pizza well done..."
Lisa Markarian
"We were hungry after a boat trip and looking for a quick snack, and wow, this was a good decision. Great handmade pizza for a fair price, way better..."
Martin Fritsch
"Spectacular pizza. We were on a boat all day and wanted pizza. Walked over and ordered a pie. Took about 15 minutes. It was great. Homemade..."
Cori Harper
"As a pizza lover this place is TOP KNOTCH!! 🍕the crust is perfectly toasted and delicious. Service was phenomenal, Gracias! We loved all three..."
Andrea Acosta
"Amazing Pizza place in Key West. Must visit this place. They do have vegetarian options. They have fresh and homemade pizza. Also we had fresh gelato..."
Smruti Kalathia
"Hands down best pizza in Key West. Our big mistake was only getting one slice and then walking 1 mile all the way back to our hotel. The pizza was..."
Mark Slam
"We had some coconut Gelato, it was very good. The service was nice. They let us try some of their other..."
Gard “CampingCoastie.com” Snyder
"I came in here a couple of years ago for a couple of slices with my girlfriend and they were mediocre. Probably because they had an idiot making them..."
Bulky Pug
"Michael took GREAT care of us. LA Suprema overbaked at my request. perfect. Gelato was the real..."
Doc Kovacs
"Their Gelato is amazing, but a bit pricey compared to the other places I have tried. It tastes amazing, though. Their pizza is great in taste,..."
Ankit Sharma
"This is such an amazing pizzeria, the wuality, quantity, ambience, and staff all are amazing. The Pizza was made to perfection, it was served..."
Avais Sherani
"We almost didn’t go here because of a few bad reviews, but so glad we went! It was delicious pizza. The crust has this perfect crunch on the..."
Mandy M
"The universe sent our group of 9 to Duetto for pizza and it absolutely did not disappoint. We ordered cheese and pepperoni, cheese, Hawaiian,..."
Kimberly Hahn
"The food here is REALLY good. The pizza was the best we had in the keys and they had a nice assortment of slices to chose from. We also got talked..."
Jenna Bulmer
"We’re new in town and craving for pizza. luckily we found this pizzeria. They have variety of pizza. We ordered lasagna and Hawaiian. This was the..."
Gennalyn D Christian
"My husband hates pizza because of the grease and heartburn, however he said we can stop because he knows pizza is my favorite! OMG this pizza is on a..."
Kathy Temple
"Great place for quick great pizza. Indoor/outdoor..."
Charlie Brasier
"Great pizza and super nice people, limited seating, much more low key than the other places in this..."
Josh Simon
"We order pizza to our resort near the area and I tell ya this was the best ny style pizza I haven't had in awhile. So if your in the keys on..."
Shawn Dreese
Antonia's
84
/100 (1666 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Italian
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Pizza
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Ossobuco
Pasta
Tiramisu
Salad
Escargot
Bolognese
Crab
Lasagne
Scallops
Osso Buco
Clams
Ice Cream
Calamari
Prosciutto
Mussels
Gelato
Calamares
Shrimp
Key lime pie
Beef
Lamb
Bruschette
Fish
Chowder
Pesto
Pork
Filet Mignon
Lobster
Antipasti
Lamb chops
Ragu
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Drinks
Dinner
Fine Dining
"We had a nice dinner on Monday. The place was hopping for the day of week and given that it is off season. The calamari we shared to start was..."
Eric Mealus
"Antonia's Restaurant is a culinary gem that undoubtedly earns a resounding 5-star rating! From the moment you step in, the elegant and inviting..."
R Pf (Invest in yourself)
"Staff was exceptional. Knowledgeable about wines paired with specific entrees. I had the lamb boco. It was a full on shank. Be prepared with a..."
Michael Deykes
"We had a great experience overall. The food was delicious and unique. The linguine was made in house and fresh. I would definitely recommend the..."
Anastasia Peterson
"Our waitress Stephanie was AMAZING. The food was amazing as well! Great overall experience we were just not impressed with the overly obnoxious..."
Tara Diaz
"Friendly staff. Attentive. Delicious..."
holly
"Great atmosphere, but mediocre food. Offered homemade pasta, but my linguine was thick, and more of a square than a flattened pasta. Ordered the..."
Daniel McChesney
"This is a good reliable Italian spot in the heart of Duval street. We enjoyed the Caesar salad and the mains, and they were very kind to make..."
C Tedesco
"Food here was good, I was a little disappointed that all seating was indoors and it was chilly. Though everything we had was good I won't be adding..."
Traci Tessone
"The food was delicious and very shareable. The servers and staff were very attentive. We had a great..."
Brenna Gallagher
"Excellent menu. Classic. Traditional. Warm welcoming environment and staff. It is nice to eat at restaurants as such with linen of the table. I..."
Tony Guerra Miami
"As a person living in Switzerland that was in Italy several times I can approve that the taste is definitely authentic. The service was perfect..."
Alex Kis
"We were staying at an Airbnb I. Sugarloaf key when we decided we wanted to go somewhere for dinner. We didn’t want the hassle of key west, and so..."
Gwendy Vanucci
"This is one of my favorite places to eat in Key West. A friend of ours is a local snd a regular here. We went when we were in town this past week...."
Alexandra Pevtsova
"Bartender is the rudest most obnoxious I've ever encountered. This otherwise perfect restaurant has a weak link, and that is the bartender. Nicole..."
James Garamella
Mattheessen's
84
/100 (1053 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Ice Cream
Gelato
Key lime pie
Macarons
Macaroons
Cakes
Café
American
Takeout
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Credit Cards
Cheap Eats
"Mattheessen's Homemade Is Awesome! The staff are friendly. The cookies are very big and very good. They also have pies, and ice cream. Without..."
Jack Carello
"Mattheesen’s lured me in with their key lime ice cream. Oh boy, sweet deliciousness! Perfectly located close to the Bight for your ice cream..."
Justa Foodie
"The smell will pull you in and the taste will win you over. YUM. I had a macaroon the size of my fist. It was delicious. My only mistake was not..."
Bill
"Absolutely best Keylime pie and most epic desserts in Key West! This is a must visit at the southern most point of the..."
Eric
"We had to go here since it’s a well known local business. The Key Lime pie was really good. It’s not super tangy so it was perfect, IMO. We also..."
Jordan G
"Delicious ice cream! Between the two of us we had Kailua almond fudge, cake batter, and turtle. We highly recommend you go here when in the mood for..."
Jan Bush
"Their peanut butter fudge cookie was AMAZING!!! We had to go back and get ANOTHER one! Their key lime pie was great, too 😋 The only downside is..."
Skye
"These cookies are amazing. We tried the fudge covered peanut butter one on our first day in Key West and went back every day to get another one...."
Kirk Kasicki
"Best ice cream experience I have ever had. Great costumer service and wow wowwow wow the snickerdoodle cookie blew my mind..."
Andrea christian
"The key lime pie covered in chocolate was delicious. I highly recommend it. Cool huge cookies starting at $7. A must try if in Key..."
Katrin F.C.
Flamingo Crossing
81
/100 (1438 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
Gelato
Frozen Yogurt
Café
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Seating
Gift Cards Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Cheap Eats
"No one makes better ice cream! As ice cream is our family's fave dessert, we relished the texture and flavor of a vast exotic array. True, two..."
Sharon M
"Ice Cream - we scream. LOVE this place! Every time we go to Key West we make at least one pit stop and sit outside to enjoy the ICE CREAM and people..."
Javier
"Fantastic tropical flavors. My wife, sister & kids stopped here after taking our pictures at the Southernmost point in the cont. U.S. down the..."
J
"It's never a late night in keywest but we got here just in time for their closing and had we not rushed we would have missed the amazing goodness...."
Deepak KC
"Ice cream you must have! I’ve been visiting this ice cream shop for over 20 years. I absolutely love their flavors and the taste of the ice cream...."
Veronica Gordon
"Late night sweet treat at Flamingo Crossing Ice Cream in Key West! 🤤🍦 Waffle cones tasted super fresh! Nice crunch and made just right. I had..."
Ramona Bertuso
"This place is phenomenal! The ice cream is homemade and absolutely delicious! There were many flavors of ice cream and gelato to choose from. ..."
April Maxwell
"Delicious! I had French chocolate, coconut and chocolate Kahlua my fiance had mango, lavender and banana. Go big or go home get the three scoops for..."
Peg P
"Every time we go to Key West we HAVE to stop by here. Kids demand it! Even if it's out of our way and it's 7pm and it's another 20 minute walk. ..."
Natalya Frenkel
"Second time here and love the ice cream/sorbet. Delicious and named true to each individual taste. Best creamery in Key..."
Paula Sandoval
"Homemade ice cream and sorbet. Hidden gem in Key West. Love the unique flavors. Cute interior. A little pricey for what you get but so much better..."
M C
"Took my next door neighbor here for a scoop of ice cream for her birthday as it's her favorite place to get it. Joaquin was working the counter and..."
Gold Bond
"I LOVE THIS PLACE!! I got a waffle with 2 scoops and the portion size was so big!! I had coconut with guava. The coconut was delicious with some bits..."
Margaret M. Keller
"The best Ice cream EVER!!! It is so smooth and feels very nice in your mouth! They have a wide assortment of flavors to accommodate everyone! Their..."
RoniDesh
"There's nothing like a double scoop of you favorite ice cream on a sugar cone to cool you off in the Key West sun! There are plenty of picnic tables..."
vonmiwi culvero
"We stopped by for a quick scoop and we liked it. There aren't many flavors to choose from and half of the flavors are fruit flavored which I do not..."
James McInerney
"The best ice cream in Key West especially the tropical fruit ones. I had Guava, mango and Mamey. You can taste the fresh fruits in every bite. ..."
Ellie T
"Stopped in today after a hot walk down Duval to the Southernmost Point. I had the Cuban Coffee flavor and my son had the Key Lime. We both loved..."
Stacey Mrozinski
"Delish! Excellent sorbet, we tried the orange and key lime. It was very refreshing on a hot day. The staff was kind. Lots of seating and tons of..."
Rachel Iverson
"The ice cream are delicious, they have all sort of flavors available for ice cream. Key lime is a definitely worth a stop onto the shop. They also..."
Jonathan P.
"Delicious! They have wide range of flavors, varieties. Absolutely worth to order. Take cash , have an ATM inside. Nice location and great..."
Chanchal
"Gone here pretty much everyday during my visit to Key West. Guava is definitely my favorite. Planning to come here right before I leave for the..."
Aiden And Oreo
Blue Gecko Key Lime Pie & Ice
78
/100 (76 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Dessert
American
American
Lunch
Ice Cream
Gelato
Key lime pie
Café
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Seating
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"The key lime smoothies are very good depending on who makes them. The first time I went a man (maybe the owner?) made it and it was very good. The..."
A. Holmes
"Shaved Ice Hawaiian style and the rolled icecream all done with great style and smiles by a husband and wife team. Well worth finding these..."
Ken Smedberg
"Great place, pie was amazing...."
Severia
"Good stop to cool off when walking around Key West on a hot day. The kids enjoyed the ice cream and..."
Jennifer Filmon
"Amazing cotton candy ice cream and friendly..."
Max Taubman
"..."
Jeff Davies
""
Bob Armstrong
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred!
Please try again in a few minutes
Sign in with Facebook
Sign in with Google
Sign in with Apple
By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
-
Privacy policy
-
Terms of use
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes