The best Ice Cream in Key West | Sluurpy updated in April

Luis Marcano

Ann

"This place has a little something for everyone! Deli for those needing a quick bite. Coffee bar for caffeine fix and cold custard. We had the..."

Whoami 0070

"Great spot with deli sandwiches and Cuban sandwiches. They have ice cream and frozen custard too. Small little convenient store section with drinks,..."

Cee Dupree

"Went in for later night dinner. Friendly lady made us an egg salad sandwich that was amazing and also some pasta salad. Both were very good and..."

Chris Outler

"Sweet little sandwich and frozen custard shop. Friendly service and delicious treats! Must..."

Michelle Guerriere

"This place is wonderful! The people working are always friendly, and they give custard samples. This is one of the only, if not the only places on..."

Alexandra Pevtsova

"So I just got done eating the caprese sandwich. Absolutely phenomenal. The tomato was fresh as can be, the basil combined with the balsamic glaze was..."

Bryan Iadisernia

"They have frozen custard! Unfortunately it's not freshly poured from the machine, but you can get it scooped on a cone or in a pint or quart in a few..."

Cameron Tylek

"We had the Cuban Mix, Turkey Sandwich, and a grilled cheese! It was made fresh and was fantastic! Worth the detour off off Duval St. but was a small..."

Cheralyn Ford

Southernmost Key Lime Shop

Tropical Vibes Cones & Bowls

Wheelchair Accessible

"We came across this local small business while we were in Key West last weekend and decided to give it a try!! I’m so glad we did! It did NOT..."

Kristin Becker

"Every time I go the Key West this is a place I always visit. I bring everyone I know to this great ice cream shop. The rolled ice cream is always..."

Margarita Sorah

"The customer service was amazing!!! The guy who rolled my ice cream kept asking if I wanted different toppings thrown in to make it extra delicious!..."

Kaitlynn Barrus

"Great deal for the price. I thought that the small was a large. It is well air conditioned and feels like a great environment. I tried blue..."

Henry Laun

"The orange and pina colada shave ice was so so delicious that I wish I could buy it locally elsewhere! If you have a sweet tooth, you will love it...."

Anshika Kapoor

"We've been going for years at the brick and mortar and this year at Truman Park with the food truck. My kids LOVE tropical vibes and is there first..."

D S

"When looking for a cute “mom and pop” ice cream place to take my family too, I didn’t realize it was going to be a whole dang experience! Their..."

Madison Ayers

"This place is super chill! The owner and workers are all super friendly and go the extra mile to make sure you get exactly what you want! Great..."

Lc B

"This is one of the many food shops around town! They have rolled ice cream, which can be kind of fun. It's a little pricey and there are stores..."

Glen Morris

"Read a few reviews on this place and decided I had to try it. Definitely glad we did. The flavors were so good and the medium snow cone was huge!..."

Maureen Magner

"Such a fun experience! Delicious ice cream! Great..."

Kate Karja

"Very creamy and tasty Hand rolled Ice cream. Family owned. I love the fruity tootie😍 Honestly they are all my favorites. They also come up with..."

KOURTNEY DENNISTON

"It was so hot while we were walking around Key West saw someone eating shaved ice and so I had to have one. It was cool and air conditioned inside..."

Moaid Alfadeli

"We decided to stop here while we walked around. We opted for the shaved ice. Large portions to keep you cool on hot days and the flavors were spot..."

Jeremy Larsen (Escape Shroom Perspective)

"My kid loved the cotton candy ice cream, this place is a..."

Amol Kedar

"Delicious ice cream and awesome staff. Super friendly and..."

Greg Knox

"Very cute and yummy place! The sizes are huge and syrup is pretty sweet! Staff is very..."

Vicky

"I went to the Green street location with 4 of my grandkids, my daughter and my daughter. They told me the smow cones we're the best they ever had..."

Karen Kindberg

"Huge Shaved Ice for a warm afternoon break. We watched her make rolled ice cream. A nice shop and customer..."

Jen Montgomery

River Street Sweets

"We saw River Street Sweets while on the Conch Train tour and immediately headed over as soon as we got off. We were greeted by friendly staff handing..."

Angeli Pagayucan

"I've been to the one in Savannah and this one is just as good! So happy they built one in Key West, I will definitely be stopping in each year that..."

Lexis Eden

"A great shop love the one in savannah same great candy..."

Andi Schell

"Did some metal work inside the space before it opened and couldn't wait to see the finished product. Owner Glen made an amazing space come to life!..."

Sioux Murphy

"River Street Sweets is great! The staff are kind and friendly. They have a ton of great chocolate, candy, and ice cream. Beautiful and colorful..."

Jack Carello

"It’s a lot of fun. Ice cream was good had a pretty neat selection. I would recommend it. Just don’t go out of your way for it. I would love to..."

Joseph Wantland

"Remarkable place - great for desserts treats and all kind of sweets! The smell that fills the streets from it is out of this world. Everything is..."

Stoyan Nedev

"One of the best candy store I've visited. Excellent store to buy candies and other sweet stuff at Duval..."

SANJEEV JAIN

"We got the candy apple, it was good they even cut it for us, We also asked the customer service to wash the knife before cutting they were happy to..."

John Tseng

"Stopped by this candy store in Key West and WOW! What a really neat place and friendly staff. I asked Monre about a super sized treat and he took..."

JB Courvoisier

"Pralines, gelato, sorbet, Ice cream, candy, candy apples. This dessert shop has a lot. The employees were very nice and friendly..."

Cameron Tylek

"Stumbled upon this place walking in the Keys and the choices were endless! It had something to satisfy everyone’s sweet..."

AL2

"It's funny driving 12hrs to Key West to see a River Street Sweets Candy when we live really close to Savannah, GA where the original river street..."

Luis Figureoa

"The smell that fills the streets from this place is out of this world! The homemade candies and treats are amazing. Prices are a little steep, but..."

Casandra Slusher

"You get your money's worth in yumminess, size and flavor! Their pralines are quite awesome..."

Vicki Carter

"We were so happily surprised to find River Street Sweets here!! Our family visits the one in Savannah when we can, & now it's even closer to home!!..."

Ivette GeeCee

"This is an American shop which is selling a huge variety of..."

Born to travel

"Had been to their Savannah store and loved it! This store didn't disappoint either! In love with their..."

Shruti P

"Gelato is amazing! They use the real Italian machine to make it (Carpigiani). They serve sorbet and icecream too but I highly recommend to try the..."

Filippo Vitale

"Stopped here on the advice of a friend who loves the Sweet Savanahs in Marathon. I’ve now been 3 times for the pecan covered taffy apples….can I..."

Beth Vanderwoude

"Their Praline is by far the best i have ever eaten. Stephanie the assist manager went above and beyond to help me with a dietary restriction and left..."

Kristie Morgan

Le Macaron

Wheelchair Accessible

Takeout

Mid-range

"Shop is meticulous! Everything is so cute and in place. Selection is amazing. I am huge fan of anything pistachio and I asked the owner/chef what..."

AliandAzi Vousoughian

"I was on vacation over Christmas and being gluten free I haven't had any pastries in 6 months. When I walked in I was in flutes heaven! I bought a..."

Viki Patinsky Torres

"Macaroons are to die for, although seemed on the expensive side to..."

Susan Buckle

"This place is super cute and the gelato and macaron I had was..."

Elaine Brady

"This was great ! Best gelato topped with the best macaron � By rallycar69 and..."

Dirk de Groen

"My wife and I loved the awesome macarons and..."

Anthony DelSignore

"best icecream in key west by far!!! the apricot and violet are my favorite, great service..."

Elena Mashtakova

"Love, love, love this place! Very beautifully crafted..."

Vidal

"They always take care of us here! Macarons are phenomenal and the espresso..."

Lori Abramson

"Good place if you want to try some nice French pastries. We just wanted to try out macarons since we have never had one. We tried, as far as I..."

Jay Mehta

"Sweeest macaroons and the sweetest place..."

semini gunawardana

"It's a chain shop, same as the one I visited in Savannah in August this year. The chocolates are as beautiful as they are tasty. The macarons are..."

Heather Steinmiller

"First if all the people running this adorable and sweet establishment we're so incredibly nice and generous. The macrons were beautiful and so..."

Eileen Plocicki

"Macaroons are good. Located right on Duvall Street. My daughter always has to stop in and grab a few different flavors of macaroons. Couple small..."

David Whittinghill

"What a cute shop on Duval St.! So many flavors to choose from it was hard to decide! My favorite was Bubblegum and it was blue! These kinds of treats..."

Rita Pearson

"Picked up some macarons on our adventures down Duval street in Key West. The store was cute and had different types of two-bite desserts to offer..."

Christen B

"Absolutely love this place! Very nice people running it and delicious macarons, best I've ever tasted. Plus, unique ice cream flavors, I'd definitely..."

Helen Bosco

"These macarons were so good the vanilla and coconut ones were very very fluffy and just so gooood in your mouth if you like macarons I would..."

Hayley Fowler

"The best desserts in Key West! Sarah is the most amazing artist. Her desserts are to die for! The lounge area is very inviting. Deff making this a..."

Michael McManus

"Wonderful place for macaroons. I loved their rose macaroon! I wish I had gotten more. Very nice..."

waheeda shaik

"Always delicious but very..."

LeeLee C

"one of my favorite places for ice-cream in key west, the apricot and violet are heavenly good, the service is always great and very personal, keep up..."

Elena Mashtakov

"WONDERFUL authentic French macarons and candies. Absolutely loved this place and their gluten free..."

William M

"Sarah, has an excellent location, everything we tried was excellent! The coffee was made to perfection and a great start for the..."

T Rudzinski

"This place is so..."

Shaquala Rice

"ORDERED BY PHONE MACAROONS FOR XMAS FOR MY GRANDCHILDREN IN KEY WEST. SUCH NICE, HELPFUL PATIENT PEOPLE. HIGHLY..."

marilyn forman

"Got 2 scoops of ice cream and a macaron, it was just delicious. Great..."

Frederic Boissinot

Duetto Pizza And Gelato

87/100 (4340 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Accepts Visa

Wine and Beer

Accepts American Express

"When you need to stop for a moment to cool down, enjoy real gelato here. Their adffogato with a dollop of tiramisu flavored gelato was a treat. Their..."

Epi

"Pizza was delicious. Quick turn around. Nice staff. It's just super tiny. Two little tables and maybe six chairs. Not much standing room either. Plan..."

MAMA Bookasaurus

"BEST PIZZA I've had, ever. So good. I had the Biancaneve and my sister had the spicy salami and con carne. All was delicious. Also had gelato, so..."

Catguer52

"Duettos. My sister and I had an awesome getaway to Key West, FL. We walked a LOT, and one of our food stops was at Duetto’s pizza. Rated as the..."

Felicia Braude

"Excellent pizza - we got a cheese, a sausage/pepperoni and a white bianca pizza. They were all great. Sampled some gelato while I waited - they were..."

Jack C

"Yummy pizza and very friendly staff. I was pleasantly surprised how tasty this was, given its touristy..."

Pbjrhj

"Best pizza I have ever tasted. It was like being back in Italy . I was surprise at the pricing was low considering the..."

Douglas Mudge

"Wonderful pizza and the best gelato I've ever had. Even better the owner is very nice and accommodating. Would go back again and..."

Nicole Vogt

"Good pizza and freshly made pizza. It was all really great. Very friendly employees. They just need more places to..."

Floridafoodie

"SERIOUSLY amazing gelato! The best I have literally ever had. The owners are amazing people and are creating amazing food. I was in Key West with my..."

Amy Heidemann

"DELICIOUS.. I had the ham + mushroom pizza & chocolate coconut gelato- WOW. Great prices, friendly service, best pizza I've ever had. A definite..."

Acb244

"I went to Italy last year so I have tasted real gelato and this is just as good!! Everything here is amazing. Come here if you want a cheap fast..."

Annie H

"Definitely ask for them to cook the pizza well done otherwise I don't think it would have been good. Looked raw. We always have our pizza well done..."

Lisa Markarian

"We were hungry after a boat trip and looking for a quick snack, and wow, this was a good decision. Great handmade pizza for a fair price, way better..."

Martin Fritsch

"Spectacular pizza. We were on a boat all day and wanted pizza. Walked over and ordered a pie. Took about 15 minutes. It was great. Homemade..."

Cori Harper

"As a pizza lover this place is TOP KNOTCH!! 🍕the crust is perfectly toasted and delicious. Service was phenomenal, Gracias! We loved all three..."

Andrea Acosta

"Amazing Pizza place in Key West. Must visit this place. They do have vegetarian options. They have fresh and homemade pizza. Also we had fresh gelato..."

Smruti Kalathia

"Hands down best pizza in Key West. Our big mistake was only getting one slice and then walking 1 mile all the way back to our hotel. The pizza was..."

Mark Slam

"We had some coconut Gelato, it was very good. The service was nice. They let us try some of their other..."

Gard “CampingCoastie.com” Snyder

"I came in here a couple of years ago for a couple of slices with my girlfriend and they were mediocre. Probably because they had an idiot making them..."

Bulky Pug

"Michael took GREAT care of us. LA Suprema overbaked at my request. perfect. Gelato was the real..."

Doc Kovacs

"Their Gelato is amazing, but a bit pricey compared to the other places I have tried. It tastes amazing, though. Their pizza is great in taste,..."

Ankit Sharma

"This is such an amazing pizzeria, the wuality, quantity, ambience, and staff all are amazing. The Pizza was made to perfection, it was served..."

Avais Sherani

"We almost didn’t go here because of a few bad reviews, but so glad we went! It was delicious pizza. The crust has this perfect crunch on the..."

Mandy M

"The universe sent our group of 9 to Duetto for pizza and it absolutely did not disappoint. We ordered cheese and pepperoni, cheese, Hawaiian,..."

Kimberly Hahn

"The food here is REALLY good. The pizza was the best we had in the keys and they had a nice assortment of slices to chose from. We also got talked..."

Jenna Bulmer

"We’re new in town and craving for pizza. luckily we found this pizzeria. They have variety of pizza. We ordered lasagna and Hawaiian. This was the..."

Gennalyn D Christian

"My husband hates pizza because of the grease and heartburn, however he said we can stop because he knows pizza is my favorite! OMG this pizza is on a..."

Kathy Temple

"Great place for quick great pizza. Indoor/outdoor..."

Charlie Brasier

"Great pizza and super nice people, limited seating, much more low key than the other places in this..."

Josh Simon

"We order pizza to our resort near the area and I tell ya this was the best ny style pizza I haven't had in awhile. So if your in the keys on..."

Shawn Dreese

2 Scoops

Wheelchair Accessible

Takeout

Cheap Eats

"This review is focused on their Sandwiches. Holy banana, they are delicious!!! We tried the Cuban Mix sandwich and the turkey avocado and it honestly..."

Luis Marcano

Ann

"This place has a little something for everyone! Deli for those needing a quick bite. Coffee bar for caffeine fix and cold custard. We had the..."

Whoami 0070

"Great spot with deli sandwiches and Cuban sandwiches. They have ice cream and frozen custard too. Small little convenient store section with drinks,..."

Cee Dupree

"Went in for later night dinner. Friendly lady made us an egg salad sandwich that was amazing and also some pasta salad. Both were very good and..."

Chris Outler

"Sweet little sandwich and frozen custard shop. Friendly service and delicious treats! Must..."

Michelle Guerriere

"This place is wonderful! The people working are always friendly, and they give custard samples. This is one of the only, if not the only places on..."

Alexandra Pevtsova

"So I just got done eating the caprese sandwich. Absolutely phenomenal. The tomato was fresh as can be, the basil combined with the balsamic glaze was..."

Bryan Iadisernia

"They have frozen custard! Unfortunately it's not freshly poured from the machine, but you can get it scooped on a cone or in a pint or quart in a few..."

Cameron Tylek

"We had the Cuban Mix, Turkey Sandwich, and a grilled cheese! It was made fresh and was fantastic! Worth the detour off off Duval St. but was a small..."

Cheralyn Ford

Yummy

85/100 (2684 ratings)

"I came in just because of the money that I saw pinned all over the restaurant I went in and met the host host allowed us to go in and take photos and..."

Tosha J

"Had a really good grouper sandwich. Husband and friend both ordered wings. There were so many wings on each plate the 2 of them couldn't eat them..."

Terian Bradley

"My first time visiting Key West and this was the first place we stopped at. We had such a good time we called our friends who were also visiting KW..."

Rhonda Richardson

"This is a must do if you are visiting the keys, live entertainment most if the time and solid talent. You do not come here for the food. You come..."

Victor Pytleski

"Great bar for atmosphere and live music! Live music everyday from 11am til close!! Great food and service with outdoor..."

Do What You Love

"Called to see if we could reserve a table for my wife and me for her birthday, which also fell on the same day as the holiday parade. A huge..."

James Baker

"While visiting Key West I visited a couple of restaurant bar locations, but think I liked this one the best. The food and wait staff were great, and..."

Terry Mabry

"Amazing location on Duval Street with live music and good..."

Chris

"Highly recommend Willie T's!!! They had a great live band going on. We enjoyed a few beers and tried the conch fritters!! Oh Myyyy how they were..."

Meagan S Elder

"Stopped by for some apps, drinks, and patio…surprised me! Prices were good for key west, drink specials, conch fritters had big chunks of conch for..."

Travis Darwin

"Great little spot with awesome live music. Perfect spot to have a beer and people watch on Duval..."

Zachary Glass

"Excellent bar n grill. We've done both, meals and drinking. They usually have someone or a small band playing. They had a dj this past Thursday..."

Stoss Truppen

"Probably the best place we dined in Key West. Kind of bar/outside dining with music. Amazing service. I actually thought I was back in Cancun. The..."

Chris Paige

"Peel and eat shrimp gotta have them. Katie the Rockstar behind the bar ..definitely a cool spot to eat and..."

paul devane

"One of our favorite bars to grab food and drinks! Live music is always good. Very fun interactive..."

Tia Thompson

"Great food and service! Love the live..."

Wanda Torres-Colon

Haagen-dazs

Wheelchair Accessible

Takeout

Drinks

Mid-range

"Pricey, but good. Yes, you do pay through the nose for Haagen-Dazs in a tourist mecca like Key West. Once you're past that, the Peppermint Mocha..."

Rick

"I got the mango sorbet and mint chip sundae - both delicious! Everyone complains about the price but seems to forget the pints of ice cream in the..."

Kirsten Taylor

"$10 for a small cup of ice cream. It was good and very cold which was needed in the hot heat of Key West in the later part of..."

Detective Glenn Cooper

"Good ice creams and combos but overpriced. Banana split Dazzlers and Dulce de leche dazzlers are pretty good and you can have it for about 11$+..."

alain ferracani

"Tykeia was amazing!!!!! She took the word multitasking to another level. She literally handle more than 6 customers all with a smile and in record..."

L J

"I absolutely loved it. I got the Belgian chocolate milkshake and it was delicious. Even better if you get it on a hot day. My boyfriend got the..."

Bailey

"We bought the Mocca coffee shakes here not once but twice. These ladies are so kind. They really helped our vacation experience to be a great..."

chris Kirsch

"A very small store in Key West, the ice was very good but pricey. I loved their milkshake it was the best in a long time, but I might be because of..."

Michel de Ligt

"This is in the perfect spot! My family came here and were so hot. We saw the ice cream and were so happy that someone had been in the right mind to..."

Jack F

"The black lady that helped us was wonderful. She made a banana split and a hot fudge Sunday , and made them delicious.Just a shout out to..."

denise pawelko

"A little understaffed on a busy holiday weekend, but the young man did a good job with the pressure of the long line. Kids ordered the peppermint..."

Rob DenBoer

"My family and I visited Key West (via the Ferry from Fort Myers), 2 days after Christmas. The whole island was jam-packed with people (holiday week..."

Realtor Lisa Phair

"You must have the chocolate milk shake, and be ready to have the best shake. Very clean and super friendly, the lady here did an awesome job taking..."

Peter Collado

"Expensive but very good, as always. Not so busy, this soter offers a great variety of flavors and the service is really..."

Fabio Arbucias

"Pricey but worth it after walking all morning on sight seeing tours. We had the sundaes and they were a GREAT LUNCH LOL..."

Margaret Huls

Antonia's

84/100 (1666 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"We had a nice dinner on Monday. The place was hopping for the day of week and given that it is off season. The calamari we shared to start was..."

Eric Mealus

"Antonia's Restaurant is a culinary gem that undoubtedly earns a resounding 5-star rating! From the moment you step in, the elegant and inviting..."

R Pf (Invest in yourself)

"Staff was exceptional. Knowledgeable about wines paired with specific entrees. I had the lamb boco. It was a full on shank. Be prepared with a..."

Michael Deykes

"We had a great experience overall. The food was delicious and unique. The linguine was made in house and fresh. I would definitely recommend the..."

Anastasia Peterson

"Our waitress Stephanie was AMAZING. The food was amazing as well! Great overall experience we were just not impressed with the overly obnoxious..."

Tara Diaz

"Friendly staff. Attentive. Delicious..."

holly

"Great atmosphere, but mediocre food. Offered homemade pasta, but my linguine was thick, and more of a square than a flattened pasta. Ordered the..."

Daniel McChesney

"This is a good reliable Italian spot in the heart of Duval street. We enjoyed the Caesar salad and the mains, and they were very kind to make..."

C Tedesco

"Food here was good, I was a little disappointed that all seating was indoors and it was chilly. Though everything we had was good I won't be adding..."

Traci Tessone

"The food was delicious and very shareable. The servers and staff were very attentive. We had a great..."

Brenna Gallagher

"Excellent menu. Classic. Traditional. Warm welcoming environment and staff. It is nice to eat at restaurants as such with linen of the table. I..."

Tony Guerra Miami

"As a person living in Switzerland that was in Italy several times I can approve that the taste is definitely authentic. The service was perfect..."

Alex Kis

"We were staying at an Airbnb I. Sugarloaf key when we decided we wanted to go somewhere for dinner. We didn’t want the hassle of key west, and so..."

Gwendy Vanucci

"This is one of my favorite places to eat in Key West. A friend of ours is a local snd a regular here. We went when we were in town this past week...."

Alexandra Pevtsova

"Bartender is the rudest most obnoxious I've ever encountered. This otherwise perfect restaurant has a weak link, and that is the bartender. Nicole..."

James Garamella

Mattheessen's

84/100 (1053 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts Credit Cards

Cheap Eats

"Mattheessen's Homemade Is Awesome! The staff are friendly. The cookies are very big and very good. They also have pies, and ice cream. Without..."

Jack Carello

"Mattheesen’s lured me in with their key lime ice cream. Oh boy, sweet deliciousness! Perfectly located close to the Bight for your ice cream..."

Justa Foodie

"The smell will pull you in and the taste will win you over. YUM. I had a macaroon the size of my fist. It was delicious. My only mistake was not..."

Bill

"Absolutely best Keylime pie and most epic desserts in Key West! This is a must visit at the southern most point of the..."

Eric

"We had to go here since it’s a well known local business. The Key Lime pie was really good. It’s not super tangy so it was perfect, IMO. We also..."

Jordan G

"Delicious ice cream! Between the two of us we had Kailua almond fudge, cake batter, and turtle. We highly recommend you go here when in the mood for..."

Jan Bush

"Their peanut butter fudge cookie was AMAZING!!! We had to go back and get ANOTHER one! Their key lime pie was great, too 😋 The only downside is..."

Skye

"These cookies are amazing. We tried the fudge covered peanut butter one on our first day in Key West and went back every day to get another one...."

Kirk Kasicki

"Best ice cream experience I have ever had. Great costumer service and wow wowwow wow the snickerdoodle cookie blew my mind..."

Andrea christian

"The key lime pie covered in chocolate was delicious. I highly recommend it. Cool huge cookies starting at $7. A must try if in Key..."

Katrin F.C.

Wicked Lick

"After spending time walking in the hot sun we stopped in here for a scoop of ice cream… the positive is that they make their own ice creams and..."

F'burg Foodie

"Cool concept with delicious ice cream and large portions, these are small and they were hard to finish. This is the Cookie Butter (I think that is..."

N FW

"Stopped here for something sweet and it was alright! The ice cream is nitrogen made I believe so it is light and not too heavy on the stomach. You..."

Chef Ahmad

"Never have I had ice cream that was chilled and created right in front of me! I had the coconut agave ice cream, which was delightfully creamy,..."

Zachary Ribner

"Gotta love the name and slogan for this top rated Ice Cream Parlor on Key West. We were lucky enough to stop in and met the owner who was as nice as..."

Paul Boyd

"Loved the atmosphere and staff, my wife and I got 4 different flavors of ice cream. Ghirardelli chocolate YES mint chocolate chip OK key lime YES..."

Audrey Metzger

"Easily one of the best ice creams that I have had in a long time. It's nitrogen icecreams and the flavors are awesome with the right amount of sugar..."

Jay Ravisankar (JK)

"Wicked Lick came onto my radar during my first trip to Key West after doing some research and walking temptingly past it several times right along..."

Raegan Linster

"This has got to be the most delicious ice cream I have ever eaten. The flavor is wonderful and the texture soooo creamy and soft. I love that they..."

Hannahmarie Roesch

"Ice cream and shakes here are yummy. Just the thing you need to beat the heat. However, prices are slightly steep probably because this town is..."

Archit Jha

"Don't get the PB ice cream... Every time I have had it, the fat coagulates and it is super greasy and you have a layer of fat at the top of your..."

Jacob Gottshalk

"The nitrogen ice cream is so cool and they make it in house. The key lime ice cream isn't on the menu but they have it! You have to ask for it. FYI:..."

Jennifer Seifert

"First time in key west and loved walking Duval Street. We spotted this shop and it has amazing nitro ice creams! Love the fact they have dairy free..."

Luis Cadena

"This place is great. All the flavors we tried were made from pure, fresh ingredients. The BEST choice for ice cream in Key..."

Sara Flynn

"It's wicked cool this new liquid nitrogen ice cream shop just opened and I get to review them first! Let me tell you their open bar type service..."

Meredith A

Sweets Of Paradise

Wheelchair Accessible

"Wonderfully kind owner who makes all of his treats. The strawberry ice cream is creamy and delicious and the humongous oatmeal raisin cookie amazing!..."

Wyatt Arvin

"Walt, wanted to say thank you for your kindness. The fudge was amazing. The Blue McCaw was a blast. Thanks for everything from the two ladies from..."

Jodi grant

"Stopped in today and met the proprieter Walt. Let us try any sample we wanted. We ended up with the best cookie ever (penutbutter with chocolate..."

Chris Davis

"THE Best 1/2 lb. Peanut Better Cookie this side of the "Milky Way"! I think Extra Terrestrials should come sample to verify the rest of the Galaxy!!!..."

Shawn English

"This place is amazing. The guy who runs it makes all the delicious desserts and the cookies and ice cream is amazing. I recommend the Cuban coffee..."

Sahith Karra

"Had the Key Lime pie and loved..."

Lynn Sutherland

"Best iced mocha and cappuccino in town. Great staff. Excellent ice cream..."

Ben Schlarman

"Very friendly. The key lime pie was absolutely..."

Dana Myers

"The best fudge..."

Jose Aburass

"Awesome panache..."

Sandi Lightfoot

"Tasty ice cream. Didn't give..."

clapryan321

Adrian Jones

Tim Potts

gustavo espinosa

Chris Thumann

Ben And Jerry's Key West

Wheelchair Accessible

Dinner

Lunch

Cheap Eats

"They just opened today. The shop is beautiful and clean. Had a freshly baked brownie that was really good. The hand painted mural is a must..."

Patricia Neyra

"It was expensive but I guess it made sense given the location. We are big fans of Ben & Jerry’s and always visit if they are nearby. I think they..."

Bhavesh Patel

"Had a delicious s’mores flavor I got to enjoy the walk back to the room. The storefront is tiny but has a really cool vibe because of it. We got..."

Cruiser Plotline

"Went in this evening with my husband .. there were 2 younger girls working, they were happy to help; with great attitudes! It’s nice to see younger..."

Danielle Schmock

"We stopped by with our 3 year old for a late night snack. Really good ice cream with lots of different flavors. The staff were friendly and quick..."

Kavi Wagner

"By far my favorite ice cream in key west. Large selection of flavors and my favorite is the fresh waffle cone they make! Staff is super friendly and..."

yasmin Pito

"Always great cakes and ice cream. It would be nice if there were a larger selection of ready made ice cream cakes. There were only 2 choices when I..."

Heather Fulcher

"My family loves Ben and Jerry's. We go once a month for a treat. Super friendly staff..."

jason hoegle

"Glad they were open! The young girl that works there ( I believe her name is Annalise) is such a sweetheart! good ice cream flavors and Great service..."

A Boddie

"The dairy free Berry Berry Extraordinary sorbet was the best sorbet I’ve ever tried! It was super yummy with the perfect creamy..."

TreeHuggingFoodie

"Nice little B&J with very helpful, quick, and polite staff. Limited seating, as in - 2 bar stools by the window in front of a reciprocating fan is..."

Dawn

"Although they were short staff I waited patiently to receive the best customer service from Maria thank you so so so so so much please give her a..."

Paradise Hipster

"Always friendly staff! We love stopping in to get treats. The cakes are perfect for any..."

Isabel Rodriguez

"Amazing place to eat and have a great and pretty fun time. Colombian and Cuban food,good customer service and the best..."

Rocio De la Iglesia

Kilwins Chocolate Fudge & Ice Cream

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts American Express

Accepts Discover

Mid-range

"Ice cream is good. Staff is AMAZING!! Nicest group of people I've met. You may be able to find equal quality ice cream elsewhere but these people..."

Shelly

"Amazing fudge! Friendly and knowledgable staff. Try the mint chocolate chip! Also love the dark chocolate covered rice crispie..."

Carly Claire

"Came here in November 2022 and completely forgot to give this place a review! I had a great experience, and Richard was so awesome!! It was my first..."

Brandy HK

"Stopped in for a little ice cream and did not regret it. Ice cream was delicious the waffle bowl was ever better I could have eaten just the waffle..."

Malika

"My favorite ice cream on the island. Went in for an espresso, walked out with a scoop of their Turtle and was so happy. As a chocolate lover, it hit..."

Lyndsay Brown

"Quintessential ice cream and candy shop. Large variety of wonderful ice cream. They make their own waffle cones and it smells great! Lots of..."

Julie Schwartz

"Kilwin's is our favorite fudge and ice cream shop. Especially when we are on a road trip. So we made a stop here in Key West. We got the milk..."

Astrida McFarland

"Long time since I tasted such a delicious rum raisin ice cream. Don't be afraid to try the anything because everything is amazingly delicious in this..."

carliover Albornoz (Karl)

"We’ve been trying various ice cream shops in Key West and this was the best! So creamy and delicious. The staff was..."

Beth Stone

"Ice cream was delicious! The staff was so welcoming. I wish I would have gotten the name of the gentleman that helped us. He was so patient and kind..."

Stephanie Coreas

"Yes please! This place rules! Don't miss this fun spot on our sweet..."

Thea Smith

"I am a local Key Wester and have enjoyed Kilwins for many years. Now that it's under new ownership, it is far far more superior. The ice cream..."

Diane Eliopoulos

"Great fudge and ice cream. You can not walk by and not stop in...it smells so good when you're approaching that you get sucked in! I do think $10..."

Toula F

"Great value for your money. Definitely get a size regular because they give so much in one cup. The flavors are really great, although I will admit..."

Anika Agarwal

"This shop smells like heaven and the ice cream was wonderful (I had fudge brownie and s'more and 10 out of 10 would eat both flavors again). The..."

Mariah Murphy

"Made it there at closing, the owner unlocked the door, I was hoping to get a milkshake, but I asked if the machines were cleaned? They were but they..."

Sean and Lauren

"It's very very nice place amazing..."

Serkan Otsuz

"Delicious ice creams devoured on the roadside seating. Worth..."

Anshika Kapoor

"Make it weekly go grab caramel apple routine. Always see new staff. Always someone new to say hello to I like to get a caramel apple.:) Blue ice..."

Adam Johnson

Flamingo Crossing

81/100 (1438 ratings)

Accepts American Express

Street Parking

Accepts Discover

Cheap Eats

"No one makes better ice cream! As ice cream is our family's fave dessert, we relished the texture and flavor of a vast exotic array. True, two..."

Sharon M

"Ice Cream - we scream. LOVE this place! Every time we go to Key West we make at least one pit stop and sit outside to enjoy the ICE CREAM and people..."

Javier

"Fantastic tropical flavors. My wife, sister & kids stopped here after taking our pictures at the Southernmost point in the cont. U.S. down the..."

J

"It's never a late night in keywest but we got here just in time for their closing and had we not rushed we would have missed the amazing goodness...."

Deepak KC

"Ice cream you must have! I’ve been visiting this ice cream shop for over 20 years. I absolutely love their flavors and the taste of the ice cream...."

Veronica Gordon

"Late night sweet treat at Flamingo Crossing Ice Cream in Key West! 🤤🍦 Waffle cones tasted super fresh! Nice crunch and made just right. I had..."

Ramona Bertuso

"This place is phenomenal! The ice cream is homemade and absolutely delicious! There were many flavors of ice cream and gelato to choose from. ..."

April Maxwell

"Delicious! I had French chocolate, coconut and chocolate Kahlua my fiance had mango, lavender and banana. Go big or go home get the three scoops for..."

Peg P

"Every time we go to Key West we HAVE to stop by here. Kids demand it! Even if it's out of our way and it's 7pm and it's another 20 minute walk. ..."

Natalya Frenkel

"Second time here and love the ice cream/sorbet. Delicious and named true to each individual taste. Best creamery in Key..."

Paula Sandoval

"Homemade ice cream and sorbet. Hidden gem in Key West. Love the unique flavors. Cute interior. A little pricey for what you get but so much better..."

M C

"Took my next door neighbor here for a scoop of ice cream for her birthday as it's her favorite place to get it. Joaquin was working the counter and..."

Gold Bond

"I LOVE THIS PLACE!! I got a waffle with 2 scoops and the portion size was so big!! I had coconut with guava. The coconut was delicious with some bits..."

Margaret M. Keller

"The best Ice cream EVER!!! It is so smooth and feels very nice in your mouth! They have a wide assortment of flavors to accommodate everyone! Their..."

RoniDesh

"There's nothing like a double scoop of you favorite ice cream on a sugar cone to cool you off in the Key West sun! There are plenty of picnic tables..."

vonmiwi culvero

"We stopped by for a quick scoop and we liked it. There aren't many flavors to choose from and half of the flavors are fruit flavored which I do not..."

James McInerney

"The best ice cream in Key West especially the tropical fruit ones. I had Guava, mango and Mamey. You can taste the fresh fruits in every bite. ..."

Ellie T

"Stopped in today after a hot walk down Duval to the Southernmost Point. I had the Cuban Coffee flavor and my son had the Key Lime. We both loved..."

Stacey Mrozinski

"Delish! Excellent sorbet, we tried the orange and key lime. It was very refreshing on a hot day. The staff was kind. Lots of seating and tons of..."

Rachel Iverson

"The ice cream are delicious, they have all sort of flavors available for ice cream. Key lime is a definitely worth a stop onto the shop. They also..."

Jonathan P.

"Delicious! They have wide range of flavors, varieties. Absolutely worth to order. Take cash , have an ATM inside. Nice location and great..."

Chanchal

"Gone here pretty much everyday during my visit to Key West. Guava is definitely my favorite. Planning to come here right before I leave for the..."

Aiden And Oreo

Incas Restaurant

80/100 (1103 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts Visa

Accepts American Express

Free off-street parking

"This place is one of the best peruvian restaurants I have tried in the U.S. and definitely has the best seafood in all Key West but what made me keep..."

Cesar Egas

"The best Crevice. A must place to eat. Get their..."

Ray Brown

"Really good Peruvian food.. Service was amazing and the food even better !! So far the best ceviche i ever eat! ... We will be back tonigh ......"

Carlos Espinoza

"Absolutely excellent food, went with a family of 8 everyone ordered something different and no one was disappointed, The only place in Key West with..."

Mndz Lex

"Delicious food and great people. Highly recommend this restaurant if you come to Key..."

Marc LaHood

"Great service, amazing food! Highly recommend this..."

Jennifer Garrison

"We loved the food, location and service. The Brazilian server was extremely awesome....our first time in KW and she made our experience eating..."

Winston Gonzalez

"Absolutely amazing food! First time Peruvian food eaters and all 9 of us loved everything! Great host, great chef and a must try when in Key..."

Selena Adams

"Nice corner restaurant with very kind and helpful..."

Sean Grebey

"1st time visit. Crew of 9 dined, late afternoon with no notice, covered the gamut of the menu and every dish was outstanding! Christopher, our host,..."

JR Whitcomb

"Great service and amazing food! El ceviche está delicioso..."

Juan Antonio Soza

"Great food, great beer, and great service! Please offer Rocoto..."

Robert Jankowski

"Delicious food. Ceviche mixto was spectacular! Definitely coming back for..."

Ha Nguyen

"Amazing collection of authentic Peruvian dishes. Got hip to this place via the locals and they were spot on. Relaxing authentic atmosphere with..."

Riaan Seacrest

"The food here was absolutely delicious. The Tacu Tacu con iomo saltsdo de carne was amazing. Also, as a drink I would recommend the inca soda. The..."

Ankurpuri1974

"Great dinner! Complementary Peruvian "pop"corn with amazing hot sauce. Had the Tacu Tacu with beef for an entree and lacuma ice cream was an..."

Caracalx

"Authentic delicious. I had ceviche my wife had Lomo saltico...beef sautéed with onion and tomatoes with Peruvian spices. Both were as good as..."

Ken Guard

"Great seafood..."

Roxanne Rudeck

"I had the empanadas and a papas a la huancaina and they were great!! The sauce was perfectly mild hot. The ceviche tasted fresh and home made. I..."

Sosam

" The Ceviche mixto-9/10The Jalea de marisco-7/10. Seven because the fried food became chewy as it cooled down. Overall the food was good. ..."

Steve And Jasmine

"Outstanding menu and service. Warm and friendly. The ceviche pescado is..."

Jswh

"Great little restaurant at reasonable prices. Food is very delicious and the portions are perfect. I had the jalea and it was awesome: fresh and..."

Armando

"Excellent authentic Peruvian food! Service was wonderful and prices were great. Will definitely by..."

SolDesigns.net

"Service was brilliant. My expectations were not high at first due to the location and interior but I must say I was truly impressed. The food was..."

Joshua Morell

"What an amazing meal! Good enough to learn Spanish for. Rich flavors and amazing presentation. I will be back to try other menu items. I had the..."

Meagan Stone

"AWESOME local spot 👌 great service and really great Ceviche 👍 The corn appetizer is pretty cool, very unique..."

Marlo Skinner

"If your a ceviche snob, come here! It’s all I had, along with a Peruvian beer. It’s a “hole in the wall” place, which I love. Ceviche is..."

scott hembrough

"Affordable, ginormous servings and DELICIOUS!! We had ceviche mixto, arroz con mariscos and lomo saltado de carne. They we're all good and definitely..."

Marimelle Bueno

"Cevice was amazing but with no pricing on the menu we feel we were taken for a ride. Maybe local and tourist pay different prices. If we go back..."

Steven Clark

"Don't let the outside fool you... this hole in the wall serves up fantabulous dishes! I can't promise I remember the names of them, but I know the..."

Janna Banana

"Excellent food, very friendly and thoughtful staff. Highly recommend this place! My wife had the beef with rice I had the Paella. Both were VERY..."

nathan cox

"Food was super fresh and very good. This was our first time ever eating Peruvian food and we are very impressed. The ceviches are the best I’ve..."

Faith Barcial

"Excellent ceviche and shrimp! The service was equally..."

Darryl Olson

"Do not let the exterior fool you. My wife had the Peruvian ceviche and I had the Fried seafood dish of fish, shrimp and calamari...Best quality of..."

Michael Thomas

"Awesome food and very authentic. Must try if you like Peruvian food. Server always amazingly nice and Carlos the chef was very friendly as..."

Muhammad Ali Arshad

Truval Ice Cream And Treats

Wheelchair Accessible

"BEST ICE CREAM EVER! My wife and I were in Key West for 5 days. We went to Cafe Maton on our first night, then we went back every day of our trip...."

Zac Owen

"Took the Conch Train Tour and we stopped here. My daughter and I got a delicious mango smoothie. Two days later, we couldn't leave town without..."

Joy Sasser

"We enjoyed a late night treat while walking around seeing the sights! Key lime ice cream was good! The mint chocolate chip shake was..."

Desiree Rose

"Incredibly good Ice cream. I got the chocolate and the key lime pie. Price was a bit high, but overall a good..."

Marshall Bennett

"Wonderful experience! Dessert surrounded by French music. Delicious ice cream, cakes, coffee. Highly..."

Helen Brenner

"i have never been so excited for a milkshake in my life, solely from the male worker who is so insanely enthusiastic, giving, and kind hearted...."

Courtney Casey

"Great spot for a quick, refreshing smoothie or ice cream. We stopped with a group of 16, and the owner quickly handled our orders. But it didn’t..."

Cory Cooper

"Great place for a coffee, soda, tea, or beer. Even hand-dipped ice cream. Yep, they have just about to anything to quench your thirst. Friendly..."

Mike Amundsen

"This place was amaizing and i love the ice..."

Dawit Tesfaye

"Ice cream was very tasty. We especially loved the flavor "garbage can" which had 7 different types of candy bars in it. Scoops were large, price..."

Becky Amiot

"My Daughter and I go there often. The milk shakes and Ice cream are wonderful and we enjoy chatting with the women behind the counter. The shop is..."

Melissa Helmholtz

"my sister and i went at least once if not twice a day when we stayed. we loved the food & the service was amazing. the woman working was unbelievably..."

Ava Moser

"The place was amaizing i will suggest you to dine..."

Makeda Teshome

"If you need a sugar fix, stop here for an ice cream cone or dish. Right on the corner of Truman and Duval. Shares a small parking lot with other..."

Raz Mom

Blue Gecko Key Lime Pie & Ice

Wheelchair Accessible

Takeout

Lunch

Cheap Eats

"The key lime smoothies are very good depending on who makes them. The first time I went a man (maybe the owner?) made it and it was very good. The..."

A. Holmes

"Shaved Ice Hawaiian style and the rolled icecream all done with great style and smiles by a husband and wife team. Well worth finding these..."

Ken Smedberg

"Great place, pie was amazing...."

Severia

"Good stop to cool off when walking around Key West on a hot day. The kids enjoyed the ice cream and..."

Jennifer Filmon

"Amazing cotton candy ice cream and friendly..."

Max Taubman

"..."

Jeff Davies

Bob Armstrong

Key West Polar Bear Homemade Ice Cream

Wheelchair Accessible

Dinner

Lunch

Cheap Eats

"The best ice cream on the whole world! Never forget the aroma of waffle..."

Evie Zahalkova

"The ice cream was perfect and in a very big assortment! The key lime pie was gorgeous!Shop has a nice arrangement, clean and tidy. Maria, the lady..."

octavian triboi

"Probably because it is closer to the where the cruises dock, the prices are a bit high. But we liked the outdoor seating and enjoyed the ice cream on..."

Aishwarya Rakesh

"Polar Bear Ice Cream Shop is a delightful treat for anyone with a sweet tooth. The menu offers a wide variety of flavors, from classic favorites like..."

ion bogusescu

"The best ice cream in key west! The taste is delicious and the portions are plentiful. You can't leave without trying it. Excellent service from the..."

Flor Farias

"I'm I come here every week and I am very satisfied with the service, especially with Michaela. Nice approach and with a smile. I recommend..."

Dominik Antman

"The person behind the counter was great. She was helpful and friendly accommodated us without any issues. We sampled quite a few flavors before..."

Lacey M

"I really like this Key West Polar Bear Ice Cream.This is a really goooood spot to stop in a warm day to cool off with a cold treat and Marcela she..."

Eugeniu Moraru

"Excellent quality ice cream and excellent service, Marcela is the best 🔝 A great experience all around. The place is very clean with a awesome..."

Rusu Rita

"Ice cream was a bonus on a hot day!! Very tasty, worth a stop and eat an ice cream..."

Donna P

"Great ice cream! Sure, it’s expensive, but the setting is perfect and the ice cream is better than the “better rated” ice cream down the..."

Scott Colson

"I didn't have any ice cream but I stopped in for the famous Key-Lime Pie. It was alright. A little more tart than I've ever had but it was..."

Mario Alvarado Jr.

"Amazing super delecious ice-cream , especially ORIO Also attendant is super kind and..."

Chaker Amir

"Wonderful ice cream sundaes and service. And close to the cruise..."

John Lavazzo

Dairy Queen

Wheelchair Accessible

Takeout

Cheap Eats

"This is a good Dairy Queen. The workers are always friendly and work pretty fast. The place is clean and you can buy half priced frozen quarts here...."

Howie Groves

"Drive up soft serve run by local teenagers...what's not to like? Really, though, the kids were friendly and I got what I ordered. Outdoor seating..."

Kirk

"Looking for some dessert on date night after dinner. Went with the old classic! Friendly staff and well made blizzards. The thing though I was lost..."

Stephen Burch

"The new ownership is great! They've redone the patio and considered the kids. Even a ping pong table. Friendly, caring. I haven't been in in..."

Kari Julian

"Great place to go! Most of the staff is super nice and friendly and I love what they did to the place. I come to Key West almost every year for..."

Misha Dana

"This DQ has a long list of loyal, long time Customers who had Ice Cream delights here as children, who are sharing it with their own today! I think..."

Kenneth Mayfield

"This feels like a old time DQ with all the ice cream treats you would expect. Friendly service, It was a little confusing with two windows but still..."

Ken Smith

"I like how they have put more seating and a place for the kiddos to play...."

Sylvia A

"Did not expect to randomly run into an old retro Dairy Queen down here! We stopped and had a treat and gave one to the dog..."

Robert Pratt

"Best damn Dairy Queen I never been to. The new owner and family are awesome. And his staff are always friendly and professional. It is always a..."

Dana “Buoy and Jetty” C

"Always yummy treats and fun play area for..."

Tina Phillips

"Love the selection on ice cream and..."

lynn rennicks

"The Southernmost USA Dairy Queen is a “neighborhood” ice cream location that has been serving the locals & tourists since the..."

Run-A-Way Bill

"There is nothing better than a blizzard on a hot summer..."

Michael Dana

"Fun place, great tasting ice..."

Albena Pechakova

"Timi is a lovely and kind lady. Very outgoing. Loved meeting her. Dairy Queen she is a keeper. She makes me chocolate malt milkshakes!..."

Reset

There are 30 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Ice Cream in Key West

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Gioia Laghi Traini

Mell Bello

Mary Grace Laghi

Cameron Tylek

Amber Fox

Yusuf Sema

Kris bishop

Oona Boyle

Tiffany Vroom

X H

Chelsea Zigler

Slv Clml

Tyler K

Vasundhara Bagchi

Hannah Rose

Martha

Salty Seadog

Mike Creed

terri betts

Tanja

Steven Halm

Lisa Kopka

Thomas Pettersen

Gretchen Sukdolak

Odalys Arbelaez

Shay Martello

Summer Bolton

Maria Mae Jeancola

Barb McQuade

Debbie Balsman

Chad Meehan

Dan Schwartzstein

Kristy Woods

Amanda Grooms

Nikki Shields

Dustin Shanley

Juliann Knott

Rezzy

Brian Bradley

Mark Gilson

Andrea Mattern

Grace L

Bill Wamsley

Brittney S

Julie Palma

Mela

Allison Grimes

Ashley Robertson

Hryhorii Sunduk

Barbara Wieteszka

Andrew Stephenson

CMB Caspanello

Liz P

Olga Ramirez

April Maxwell

Carmine Valentino

Raegan Linster

Kyle Hanks

VW Touareg

Ion Gorincioi

Deepak Patil

Kaye Tompkins

CMB Caspanello

Cynthia Rossi

Jack Carello

Rashaad Kauterman

Desiree Rose

Jaylin