Fogarty's

Fogarty's, Key West 227 Duval St - Key West

American
• Seafood
• Sit down

87/100
Give a rating

What's your favorite Fogarty's's dish?

Ratings and reviews

87
/100
Based on 7509 ratings and reviews
Updated

The menu of Fogarty's suggested by Sluurpy users

Ratings of Fogarty's

TA

Trip
Last update on 18/03/2024
4,5
3496 Reviews
Google
Google
Last update on 23/12/2023
4,4
3303 Reviews
Foursquare
Foursquare
Last update on 06/07/2023
4,0
484 Reviews
Facebook
Facebook
Last update on 27/12/2020
4,4
2 Reviews

FM

Find me gluten free
Last update on 06/07/2023
5,0
12 Reviews
Zomato
Zomato
Last update on 27/12/2020
3,9
157 Reviews

Menu Fogarty's

  • Appetizers
    • Taste of Key West
    • Fish Bites
    • Conch Fritters
    • Key West Crab Cakes
    • Peppered Ahi Tuna
  • Salads
    • Chinese Chicken Salad
    • Fogarty's Chopped Salad
    • Caesar Salad
    • Caesar Salad with Blackened Mahi-Mahi Filet or Gulf Shrimp
    • Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken Breast
  • Soup
    • Soup of the Day
    • Bahamian Conch & Clam Chowder
  • . . .
  • Browse the menu

Available menus

Reviews

Zomato
Cesar Phantom
+4.5
this is an awesome place dadsadadasd ada dadad ada dadad adada dasf afafa fsaf aqfqefwef afsfwef werwtwee twegfsdgfds etwtw wefsdfs fwe wtwt wtw
May 08, 2018
Zomato
Melodi
+4
Efendim ne zamandir tatil munasebetiyle yazamiyorum buyrun floridanin minigi key west te ne yenir lezzetli mi lezzetli deniz urunleri basarili
Apr 13, 2017
Zomato
BlockDaddy21
+5
Really, really good food. We had the cracked pepper Ahi Tuna as a starter - quality fish, seared to a perfect rare and with a chili soy, was absolutely delicious. She had the mixed grill with a lime cilantro sauce that was out-of-this-world and scallops that were perfectly cooked. I had the Cuban pork roast - a dish that tasted like it was cooking for 12 hours. Tender, falling-apart, and with a lime marinade - this has been the highlight of our trip to Key West. Even the black beans were so good, we returned the next day for more. Service was on-point, and the frozen drinks were tasty as well. Highly recommend!
Nov 19, 2016
Zomato
Emilee B
+4.5
Great service! Even during the holiday rush my group of 10 got in with no wait. The food was absolutely delicious. Our group's favorites were the lettuce wrap and the chopped salad.
Jan 02, 2016
Zomato
Alletun
+4
Yay! Key West Pride 2015! Dinner at Fogarty's was quite a pleasant experience. The service was good even though there was a large crowd.

As an appetizer, I can suggest the Taste of Key West, which has Conch Fritters, Fish Bites, and Fried Shrimp. The tarter and coctail sauces are good. You may have to ask for extra sauce.

For my entree, I was told to try the Blackened Rib Eye. It is a 14 ounce cut of meat coated with Cajun spices, and has mashed potatoes, veggies, and fried onions as sides. If you are a steak person, you will like this one.
Jun 17, 2015
Zomato
Matt Gorham
+4.5
The crab and corn chowder was some of the best I ever had. That said, Luckie, pick up the pace. Maybe your having a bad day, but try a little harder.
May 05, 2015
Zomato
E
+4.5
Located in the midst of duval street, this establishment was serving up some tasty treats with really friendly service. They have cooling misters which helps when sitting outdoors on those hot days. There is both indoor and outdoor seating with 2 bars. The sandwiches were really good and their fries were spot on. There was live carribean steel drum music which added to the ambiance. Would return again for sure.
Sep 24, 2014
Zomato
Carter
+4.5
Amazing! Catch of the day was red snapper. Got it blackened, with the house sauce drizzled over, rice and veggies. Everything could not have been more perfect!
Jul 27, 2014
Zomato
Walt
+4.5
Good was great! We had the catch of the day (mahi) and we had the ribeye. Both were cooked perfect. The customer service was spot on.
Jul 08, 2014
Zomato
Birdiebyrd
+4.5
Good food... Great service, i went with 2 other friends.. we ordered the shrimp po' boy, the pork ribs and the fogarty burger.. all 3 things were cooked perfect, tasted great and i will def be returning to this place....

just a great find, and cool place.. a must visit..
also good people watching.. we sat on the actual porch, because it was raining.. but even there, we had a good time and it was just perfect
Jan 06, 2014
5
Kay Meyer
+5
We came for an anniversary and was not disappointed! The ribs were AMAZING! My husband had the fish tacos and was so impressed with them. The banana breeze frozen adult drink is to die for. Prices are good for the quality you receive
5
Eric
+5
Great place to grab a very strong slushy drink! Classic stop on Duval Street. Stop by and grab a Rum Runner, Banana Chocolate, or one of their numerous flavors. Food is pretty solid and service is awesome!!
5
Cloe Mohsen
+5
Delicious! Portions were generous and food was fresh. Service was great. Would recommend stopping here for lunch or dinner while in KeyWest. The key lime pie was so good!
5
Alessandra Distefano
+5
Classic American style restaurant with seating areas and high stool tables. Very friendly and knowledgeable staff. Luke helped us with the menu and suggested the perfect amount of food we needed. We came in right when the storm came and we found a table for four quite easily. The burger, ribs, and tacos were huge and delicious. One of the best restaurants in the area.
5
Jeff Shore
+5
I've had many meals here. Our sever Natalie was perfect. Mahi tacos, shrimp po boy, and conch fritters. Everything perfect.
5
LLO Legal Assistant
+5
Generous delicious portions of food and tasty pina coladas. My only dislike was they use high fructose corn syrup ketchup. I meant to order bacon on my burger but forgot so it eould be good if the wait staff were to ask if I wanted bacon like they did the day before when we ate here. Otherwise lovely and highly recommend!
5
Sabrina Locke
+5
Fogarty’s is an absolute must in KW. The atmosphere of the restaurant is so fun and enjoyable. The menu is not overly complicated like a lot of places are nowadays, the food is fresh and delicious, the drinks are so refreshing (and fun!), the music choices are great, and ALL of the staff is attentive and friendly. As a manager in the Food and Beverage industry, this place hits all my marks. I visit at least twice every trip, and will continue to do so every time I’m in town! I would even dare to say it is my favorite in Key West!
5
Steve B.
+5
My conch fritter appetizer was amazing! Best on the island, and the remoulade sauce A+ I don't remember our servers name, a redheaded guy. He was 💯 did a great job! Good people are hard to find.
5
Daddy Hordel
+5
Well I can’t remember all the names of the foods precisely we got but Fogarty’s is easily the best place we have ate at in Key West so far and a few of the drinks we had were just as good, the dirty monkey and the grape ape. The service was great and our blonde waitress was awesome, sorry, forgot your name. We got a fish sandwich, some kind of pecan fish, 3 cheese pasta and blackened fish tacos. I substituted fries for my rice n beans, I’m just not a rice and bean guy. I sampled all 4 dishes and they were all Amazing. My vegetables with my dish were also cooked to perfection. This is definitely a must stop while you’re in Key West. I’m pretty hard to please because I’ve eat country cooking and Cajun food(thanks to my bayou work buddies) all of my life and it’s some of the best food in the world but Fogarty’s definitely met my high expectations.
4
Peter Commerford
+4
Fogarty's is pretty good and has a great location right on Duval street. The food was great but the drinks were not. The service was slow and almost inattentive. When we asked our server a few details about the food before we placed our order, she said she honestly had no idea. I do admire the honesty, and in the end, the food was great. I ordered the key lime shrimp and my wife ordered the three cheese pasta. Both meals were delicious and visually appealing. For the drinks, my wife order the Pina colada and I the Rum Runner. The rum runner was far too frozen and kept plugging up the straw. I ended up removing the cover and drinking from the top but it tasted like a little kids freeze pop. Way too much sugar and I could not taste any rum. I would still recommend this place as a good place to grab lunch while walking along Duval street.

Timetable

Monday:
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Tuesday:
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Wednesday:
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Thursday:
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Friday:
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Saturday:
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Sunday:
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

Hours with higher turnout

Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
Sun
6AM
9AM
12PM
3PM
6PM
9PM
12AM
3AM

Order online with

Zomato
Zomato

Book a table with

Zomato
Zomato

Read the reviews on

TA

Trip
Google
Google
Foursquare
Foursquare
Facebook
Facebook
Zomato
Zomato

Info

Compare the best restaurants near Fogarty's

bianca Sluurpy rate Google rate Facebook rate
TA

Fogarty's

88 4.4 4.4 4.5
Prime Steakhouse 86 4.6 4 4.5
Tavern N Town 85 4.5 4 4.5
Santiago's Bodega 87 4.7 4 4.5
The Cafe 86 4.6 4 4.5
DJ's Clam Shack 85 4.7 4 4.5
Off the Hook Grill Key West 94 4.7 4.9 4.5
Key Plaza Creperie 83 4.7 4 4.5

QR Code Menu

QR Code

Our aggregate rating, “Sluurpometro”, is 87 based on 7509 parameters and reviews

If you need to contact by phone, call the number +1 305-294-7525

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT
1