Sluurpy
Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Shellfish in Key West

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Sarabeth's Key West
88/100 (4701 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Seafood
American
American
Seafood
Healthy
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Drinks
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Shellfish
Key lime pie
Calamares
Lobster
Salmon
Pancakes
Shrimp and Grits
Crab Cake
Pasta
Cakes
Meatloaf
Bruschette
Salad
Fish
Mac and cheese
Polenta
Eggs Benedict
Crab
Burger
French Toast
Scallops
Toasts
Duck
Omelette
Calamari
Risotto
Shrimp
Waffles
Tuna
Bread Pudding
Sit down
Healthy
Seafood
American
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Dog Friendly
Mid-range
"Ate the shrimp and mozzarella omelet and it was so good. Cute little location and nicely cooked omelet. It wasn't quite as scrumptious as blue heaven..."
Kylie Jo Hood
"Easy find and what a nice surprise right off duval. Breakfast was our meal of choice and it was a good one. Menu doesn't seem flexible but the food..."
David Ewing
"This is a really nice place for brunch; the food is great and so is the service! Be prepared to wait in line for a table. Lots of choices on the..."
Barbara
"Fantastic breakfast! If in the Keys this place is a must dine. Great homemade everything and friendly service. I jade the shrimp and bacon omelette..."
Lisa MACK
"Food and service was exceptional! Having subpar experiences at other recommended restaurants for brunch, this place was a breath of fresh air...."
Joel Garcia
"You won't be disappointed with the service or the food here. We had Sara's velvety cream of tomato soup and the had the yellowtail snapper and the..."
MD_Terpfoodie
"Our favorite restaurant in Key West. We found Sarabeth's on a past visit and it was our favorite restaurant in Key West. After another wonderful meal..."
Bill Joyce
"Wow! Can't believe it's taken us this long to get here. Great breakfast; looking forward to dinner here. Thanks to @Sarabeths for the @twitter..."
RRR
"One of my favorite places for breakfast in Key West. Always friendly service, great food, and good coffee. Who could ask for anything more? (Oh...and..."
AZ
"Breakfast was really good. I had the Goldie lox and it was the perfect amount of food with amazing orange marmalade on the toast. My friends really..."
Megan
"Have You Ever Had Such a Fantastic Meal You Dream About It?. Not only did I dream about it... but having dined there on several occasions, I've more..."
Sharon
"After eating for four days in semi-decent restaurants in Key West we found our way in the middle of a down pour to Sarabeth's. So nice to not have..."
ClosetFoodie
"Good Food. The service is efficient with a great sense of humor. The breakfast is typical breakfast - nothing special and a bit pricey for what you..."
Sarah
"Our last stop.... Had never been to Sarabeth's and stopped on our way out of town headed back to Ft. Lauderdale Sunday morning. This is a little bit..."
Mikie Steve
"Very quaint setting. Food was very good. Main breakfast dishes priced fairly. Very expensive to order sides and extras ( ex: $7 for a small cup of..."
Carry
"This place is phenomenal. Don't mind the critics. Excellent food and service every time we've been..."
DJ
"Excellent... Breakfast all day on Saturday. Really enjoyed the jam with a tight but quaint..."
Top Chef Junky
"Good service. Pricy coffee (even for a Starbucks lover). Buttermilk pancakes with real mapel were good. Turkey and her sausage with apple butter were..."
Kgraziano33
"Great atmosphere be sure to sit outside. The french toast and pancakes are..."
Gal Fieri
"Excellent refined breakfast food! Good flavor without a boatload of..."
Glenn
"Great pancakes - lovely outdoor seating - attentive service - reasonable..."
Charles Call
"Great food. Wonderful atmosphere. Loved the owner. Would like to see a bigger wine..."
Jackie Boisvert Murray
"One of my favorite breakfast places in Key West. I love their pumpkin muffins, homemade marmalade, and ommelettes (spinach and goat cheese is my..."
Alli Deneweth
"Sarabeth's was recommended by a friend and really lived up to our expectations. The service and setting were excellent and everything we ordered was..."
Dennis F
"YUMMO!. Loved the atmosphere and the friendly staff...Hubby found this place for us for breakfast: I ordered the flower juice and it is really good..."
Forkingitup
"Great place to escape the hustle and bustle of Duval Street and feel the real "Old Key West". Hidden gem on a quite street with EXCELLENT service...."
K Ward
"Great brunch spot. My husbandsndi split a pinkshrimp Gouda cheese omlette that was delicious Sourdough toast was perfect andcrispy The host was..."
Sharon Harwood
"Amazing food I had the Goldie Lox salmon cream cheese & eggs so so delicious also the flowers juice is great!!! I will be back everytime I visit the..."
Jenna
"Outstanding food and service. This really lives up to the rave reviews. Food is tasty and made daily from local, fresh ingredients. The creamy tomato..."
Lisa F
"Just plain yummy. This has become a must-do for every trip to Key West. The staff are fantastic and the food is the best. Sarabeth's is the..."
CatLauderdale
"Outstanding service. Really liked Sarabeth's. The skirt steak was very interesting, but good. I'm very funny about calamari, if it's overcooked by..."
Richie Rich
"The food was good but they crammed my leftover sandwich in a tiny box and squashed..."
Jamie
"Delicious!. I loved the atmosphere (inside a house in the entrance with the comfortable outside breeze gently wafting in). The food was so perfect!..."
Whit
"Sunday Brunch Favorite. We were in Key West for Easter Sunday and decided to walk to Church and found this great restaurant on the way back. Great..."
TK
"Very quaint, very clean restaurant with eclectic menu. Wholesome, healthy, & fun choices! Awesome breakfast menu, loved the shrimp, bacon omelette &..."
Jess
"Another great find on Key West was Sarabeth's for breakfast! The place had a lovely patio in front on a quiet sidestreet. The Goldie Lox was..."
Erin McGrath Shook
"Best fried chicken ever !!!! Nice setting in Old Town Key..."
George P
"Highly Recommend. Great food and service. Turkey club sandwich and Goldie Lox both excellent. We'll be..."
R. Schwartz
"Quaint Old Town Setting. Big city attention to detail shines on this Key West..."
Greg Dickinson
"Very few places can live up to such high expectations and Sarabeth's definitely did that. On a quiet street just off of duval street this place is a..."
Vargas
"I was craving grits and took a chance that this special would be featured based on reviews. The shrimp and grits should be a menu staple. They were..."
Keli Smith
"During our Keys trip for my dad's birthday in May we stopped into Sarabeths thanks to a friend's recommendation. I got the lobster omelet and my dad..."
Michelle Lynn
"Brad is the best server I've had in all my trips to Key West. The key lime French toast was phenomenal and because my birthday was the day before, he..."
Anthony Loreno
"Wow what a delicious experience! Definitely recommend the cheese grits and blueberry muffin. We had the shrimp and bacon omelette, ham and Gruyère..."
K9 Bath Center
"This was such a welcoming and relaxing place! We so enjoyed our time at Sarabeth's! My absolute favorite was the goat cheese appetizer. Let's just..."
Canda Mueller
"Amazing food and service!! We just had one of the best breakfasts on key west so far! I had the lobster omelet special that was unbelievablely..."
chris weber
"When my wife and I are on vacation, we almost never visit the same restaurant twice, as there are too many we wish to experience. However, we made..."
Derek Dawson
"Service was excellent. Started with a refreshing “Grinch mimosa”. I gave it a shot to the Key Lime Pie French Toast and it was a pleasant..."
Ana Irene Romero
"I don't know. The server was so awesome, I really wish the rest of the restaurant followed suit. I had surf and turf Benedict, and it was just ok. I..."
Deric Peace
"One word, AMAZING!! Not only is the food amazing but the customer service is out of this world!! My husband and I loved the shrimp and grits which I..."
Angela Williams
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use