Sluurpy
Reset

There are 5 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Tortellini in Key West

There are 5 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Virgilio's
85/100 (903 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Italian
Bar
Pub
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Tortellini
Tortelloni
Pesto
Fish
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
Bar
Italian
Live Music
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Late Night
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"Awesome!. Food exceptional, atmosphere just as good, martinis to die for. Love this place. One of my favorite places of all time. Even better than..."
Jerzeegirl324
"Antipasta plate - Killer!. Stopped in for a quick glass of wine and a snack. Sat at the bar and enjoyed lively conversation and a top notch..."
KendraG
"$5 martinis on Monday nights. Eat at the..."
Tommodern
"We went dancing on Thursday Latin Night and it was so much fun. The drinks were descent but the music made it worth it. Lots of people came out to..."
Hector Pina
"While strolling in Duval Street, we ended up discovering this beautiful, cozy restaurant. My friend and I thought of eating just pasta. But the..."
Purabi Mahapatro
"This place is amazing. Order the ossobuco. And then get one to go. Because you're gonna need that. Or you'll ask when they open in the morning for..."
George Gross
"Weight staff was excellent, the carpaccio was excellent, fresh baked bread was outstanding, the linguine with clam sauce was too overwhelming with..."
L
"We enjoyed the bar in the back behind the restaurant. Drinks were delicious and the live music was..."
Vivian Schiff
"Great live music for dancing. A little too much merengue. The bar has fantastic drinks. Best place to get your Latin dancing on Thursdays in..."
Pablo Tapia
"This is the bar section of La Trattoria. Really nice quality Italian food (good bread!). Had carpaccio, the house lobster ravioli and osso buco. ..."
James Balaguer
"Martini Mondays are ok. The crowd is snowbirds over 70 waiting in line before it opens. With all the bad hips - you will not get a chair but the..."
Annie LaVa
"Virgilio's is always amazing. Very tasty food, incredible martinis, and a house band that plays a variety of music, and all of it well. Martini..."
David Parkhurst
"After searching many hours I found Virgilio’s. Great service, very accommodating prior to closing to accommodate dinner. Flavorful and best a key..."
Omar Brown
"My husband and I went here twice in our 3 night stay in Key West 2 weeks ago. The food is amazing!! I love the bread with the oil, balsamic, and..."
Alicia Westfield
"As many have said - awesomeness of Martini's. I am letting the "secret" out - Martini Monday!!! Back in the day they were a steal at $5 each....now..."
Sandy Paxton
"Alex is the best bartender in Key West! Attention to details is incredible. Personable and very good at his job. Doesn’t..."
Dan Pooler
"Good martinis. Mondays are buy one, get one and music. Tasty and affordable. Had a great..."
Kimmy K
"Best martini we have had, not just in the Keys but elsewhere. This is a must visit when in key west. The food was great as..."
Steven Rowan
La Trattoria Restaurant
84/100 (6175 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Tortellini
Salad
Tortelloni
Crab
Osso Buco
Scallops
Cannelloni
Clams
Key lime pie
Chocolate mousse
Fettuccine Alfredo
Cheesecake
Bruschette
Filet Mignon
Pesto
Shrimp
Fish
Beef
Antipasti
Alfredo
Tortelli
Ossobuco
Tiramisu
Escargot
Lobster
Bolognese
Eggplant
Lasagne
Pasta
Sit down
Italian
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Waterfront
Reservations
Accepts Discover
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
"Overall a lovely dinner at La Trattoria. Very nice atmosphere and delicious food. Well worth the price. A lovely take on the traditional caprese with..."
Micha Aviani-bartram
"👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 Excellent service, very well prepared food. The attention of the waiters is very good. The atmosphere of the place is..."
Kel Ruiz
"We dined two nights, and the food is wonderful. Walter was our server the first night, and Ameth was our server the second night; both were..."
Charlotte Karolenko
"Fantastic. Excellent Service and Fair. We highly recommend it as a must when you are visiting KW. Be sure to check out Virgilio's which is in the..."
Rich Carpenter
"We had a wonderful meal here and loved our waitress. I wish I remembered her name. She was so helpful and attentive. She even suggested a smaller..."
M.E. Gray
"This was our best meal of the week. It is a casual place, but with white linen tablecloths. Our service was very good and the food was outstanding. ..."
Bill Peacock
"Coming here for 20 years whenever we are in key west. Always wonderful creative dishes. Loved the isalata paesano, August 1 grouper special dinner..."
Joan B
"La Trattoria on Duval Street exceeded all expectations during my recent visit. The highlight of the evening was undoubtedly the pan-seared grouper in..."
Suly Sabina
"We came here for dinner, the host was alright, because my boyfriend was very specific about the seat. Server was friendly but the most amazing part..."
KIM H
"One of the best meals we had in Key West. Absolutely delicious. After a crazy week of outdoor patios and bars, an amazing meal in a nice, quiet,..."
jenabena2012
"Very nice Italian restaurant. The waiter was on point with his service. We never had to ask for a refill on drinks or bread. The food took a little..."
Kim Garrison
"Went to LaTrattoria to celebrate our 50th anniversary. Best restaurant in Key West! Food is incredibly delicious and the service and ambiance..."
Doris Gibson
"I've been going here for years, tables are very close together, was sat and order taken quickly, food was very good, local snapper and it was..."
Henry Kokenzie
"The keys are one of the last places I expected to visit an Italian restaurant at but I was here for 7 months so I figured why not. We went here for a..."
Nico
"Amazing chicken Alfredo and Lasagna. Amazing service and food was so good. Very reasonably priced as..."
Karson Hoot
"We walked up and down Duval St looking at reviews and judging were to eat. We settled here and could not believe our luck. The food, service, and..."
mike loyd
"I have dined-in at this place a couple times already, so far every dish has been very well balanced on presentation, size and price of it. We had..."
Juan Cruz Anselmo
New York Pasta Garden
83/100 (6068 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Soups
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
American
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lasagne
Calamari
Tortellini
Mussels
Tortelloni
Tuna
Fried Artichokes
Calamares
Bruschette
Pesto
Fish
Filet Mignon
Ribs
Shrimp
Lobster
Alfredo
Eggplant
Omelette
Pasta
Torte
Salad
Meatballs
Scallops
Sit down
American
Italian
Seafood
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Live Music
Serves Alcohol
Reservations
Accepts Discover
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Seating
Free off-street parking
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Dinner
Mid-range
"New York Pasta Garden is an outstanding Italian restaurant that truly impressed us. Our server, Fletcher, was not only awesome but also incredibly..."
Bhushan Sonaje
"This place is a hidden gem. My husband and l stayed in Key West for 5 days, we ate here twice!!! The outside is gorgeous, the staff and owner is very..."
Laura R
"My husband and I went there for dinner for our honeymoon weekend. Fletcher is hands down amazing and so up lifting. Food was amazing and hot!!!..."
Jessica Newman
"Our food was fantastic. I had the steak salad and my husband had the egg plant..."
Amy Culligan
"The food was amazing, the only thing better than it was the service by the incredible nice staff! We'd give it a 10 star rating if we could! The..."
Vivien
"My wife and I had dinner last night. It was raining so we initially sat inside. While we were waiting a group of young ladies decided to brave the..."
Fred Harpell
"We just happened to stumble upon the restaurant while we were walking down duval street. The server was awesome ( never got his name). We were just..."
Christopher Guertin
"A small establishment that has quality food for a great price. At the time of writing you could get a nice glass of wine for around 11 and a bottle..."
Alaina Del Real
"My husband and I were visiting Key West with friends and returned again after eating at NY Pasta Garden the first time in 2021. The food was great..."
Pamela Kramer
"Just amazing! We.stopped in for a late dinner. (about 8pm) Atmosphere was charming, we sat outside under the lights, there was a wonderful breeze..."
Lynn M
"The tortellini was absolutely delicious and wine pours are very generous! Fletcher was very personable and service was terrific!! Would definitely..."
Hailey Persina
"Probably one of the most fine dining-ish restaurants you’ll find in good ole Key West. The outdoor courtyard is just adorable with lights strung up..."
Raegan Linster
"We came here for our honeymoon, and the food was great and the service was even better! Lukas was very attentive to our honeymoon and took quite a..."
Alyssa Farineau
"Good food made with lots of love. The restaurant is a great Italian restaurant that serves excellent quality food l. The portion sizes are generous..."
Adam Pollack
"Fletcher you are an awesome server he will treat you right. Huge portion fresh food nice atmosphere we will be..."
Super trim Tree
Nine One Five
83/100 (4661 ratings)
Restaurants
Contemporary
Contemporary
Italian
American
Italian
Seafood
Mediterranean
Vegan Options
Seafood
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Mediterranean
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Lobster
Cakes
Crab Cake
Pesto
Tapas
Pasta
Fish
Tacos
Salad
Pork
Tortelli
Filet Mignon
Crab
Ribs
Scallops
Clams
Duck Confit
French Fries
Duck
Cheeseburger
Confit
Curry
Calamari
Burger
Octopus
Risotto
Bolognese
Mussels
Tortellini
Polenta
Tortillas
Tuna
Shrimp
Tortelloni
Calamares
Beef
Key lime pie
Salmon
Ceviche
Paella
Sit down
American
Contemporary
Seafood
Italian
Mediterranean
Non-smoking restaurants
Dog Friendly
Outdoor Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Reservations
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Seating
Street Parking
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Accepts Discover
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Late Night
Dinner
Fine Dining
"This place is great. Delicious appetizers and entrees. The chicken is very good. Also the Grouper svchi is really good. The deserts are really good..."
Kylerobik
"My mom and I recently ate at Nine One Five 4/5/16 the food was fabulous the staff were friendly and attentive we sat outside it was..."
Kathleen Oconnell
"Good option on Truman Street when hungry and decided to eat in peace and well;)Service is good,we both ordered filet mignon ravioli which..."
Gmerk
"A little cramped layout. However the food and service is great. The hamburger is one of the best I have had in a while. The asparagus is also really..."
Scott
"Best of Key West. Nine One Five has everything great going for it: Location, space, design, great menu and a rocking wine bar upstairs...."
BN
"Upstairs is point 5 their pizza, bar, and small menu items. We had good service and loved the view. But the salad was bland and the pizza margaherita..."
American_sweet
"Sunday Night, service a little slow. Appetizers and Entree' good. Dessert way too sweet. Go for the food, especially the..."
Brian C
"OH MY GOSH!!! Amazing! We went and just got a bunch of starters and snacks and sides. They were great. I recommend Devils on horseback, crab cakes,..."
Annie H
"Superb. Quaint, centrally located restaurant with a great menu. Tapas are available upstairs. Service is OUTSTANDING!!!!You must have the fried whole..."
George Peterson
"My husband and I recently enjoyed a delicious dinner and great service at 915. We started out outside under an awning but the staff took initiative..."
Sk
"Fabulous food!! Highly recommend Orange & Chipotle Braised Pork; Dungeness Crab Chowder; Devils on Horseback; Crispy Duck Confit...all Starters & all..."
Bente Humphrey
"Great service, interesting blend of euro and asian seafood dishes. Don't miss the Thai whole fish with ginger fish sauce or the grouper with beliga..."
Tom Hyland Robertson
"Duck confit is fabulous. Good..."
Mary B.
"High Living. The prices may be higher, but you truly get what you pay for with the taste, presentation, service, and atmosphere.MUST-HAVE..."
Shapes
"915. Six of us had a great meal here. The Tuna Bomb was very good and the grouper on risotto and spinach. I had soup and salad because we were..."
Glenda Boudreaux
"LOVE it WELL!. I owned a restaurant callled "Savannah," Good Home Cookin' in the same location back in the 80's, and though 915 is nothing like..."
Garth
"A Must Stop For Any Foodie!. I eat here every time I am in Key West. To me,this is the most relaxing place on the whole island to have a meal. The..."
Punks
"We (two couples) did a tapas style dinner and found the food to be creative and well-prepared. The wine list was fine with a good range both in terms..."
Todd
"I love the passionate expressions used in all these reviews. 915 is quite good at rousing passion. We local folks are proud to claim this totally..."
Toni Davis
"Food was excellent! Grouper had a spicy potatoe coumin flavor. Filet melts in your..."
ArtEnvee'ist
"At there on a recommendation of hotel staff. Extensive wine list. Great lounge atmosphere...casual and in a way urban chic. I had the grouper while..."
Mildude
"Impeccable food, steak and whole fish were amazing. Calamari was done..."
Chris Mehr
"Never mind the "foodie" and the uptight "had to pour my own wine" below. The food and service at 9-1-5 was excellent. The place was packed when we..."
D Rock
"PERFECT EXPERIENCE. This restaurant was hands down the best meal we had in Key West. We had late reservations and sat on the upstairs balcony. Fun..."
Heidi
"Excellent food and service. A top choice for dining in Key..."
Bryan Fuerst
"Quite possibly the best meal in key..."
Photogirl
"Very good tapas. Relaxing upstairs with friendly..."
Radman
"I will make this easy...if you have dinner plans any where else, cancel them. Quite simply..."
Jhout
"Nice spot right on the main street. It's in an old house and is quaint inside. Lots of outdoor seating available as well. Service was great as was..."
Rob Q
"Had a wonderful dinner at this place. All the shareable items are delicious and great to share with good company. Loved the Lobster mini tacos and..."
Manisit Das
"Very good restaurant right on Duval where we found the service to be excellent and the food very good as well. If you’re considering 915 vs their..."
C Tedesco
"Outstanding meal. Best lamb chops i ever tasted. Very unique take on the ket west key lime..."
joe celona
"I'd rate 915 as a 3.5 right in the middle. The food was definitely good. I had a burger cooked a perfect medium rare and the fries were solid. The..."
Richie Pawlowski
"We came here at 10:45 for a late dinner and it was outstanding. Highly recommend the Grass Fed Burger with truffle fries. Also the asparagus was very..."
Josh Eidenberg
"Excellent food and nice atmosphere. The servers were fantastic and the fish couldn't be any fresher. They offer the fresh catch of the day 🐠 and..."
Phil Sigler
"Perfect location for people watching on Duvall…while grabbing a delicious meal! Menu was creative and not overwhelming…dishes we tried were very..."
T CH
"Came in for dinner after someone recommend we give it a try. Oh boy did that recommendation not disappoint. Hubby had grilled octopus appetizer, I..."
Jennifer Susko
"My wife and I picked up a reservation to this spot on OpenTable as our "date night" while in Key West and it delivered! The menu was varied and each..."
Will Powell
"The building and setup is really nice, quaint, and romantic. We sat in a table right next to Duval St, they had a ton of fans to make it very..."
Ryan InMIA
"Amazing hidden gem. Make a reservation you won’t be disappointed. Service and food were 6 stars. Best black grouper and wagu beef burger. The..."
David Pfeffer
"One of our favorite spots on the island, we've never had a meal here that wasn't amazing. Great place to go for a "blue" stake if you like yours that..."
Casey Gandy
"I was told by the concierge at our hotel that this place had the best key lime pie on the island. But I found all the food here to be delectable...."
Terry Mohammed
"Anna is an exceptional server. We had the special of black grouper with a creamy crab risotto. It was wonderful. Great atmosphere, excellent dirty..."
Sarah Kindinger
"Above average meal. The ambience and service were lovely. The 80’s music playing didn’t really fit the atmosphere, IMO. The food was overall..."
Jenny Jacobs-Taylor
"Exceptional staff. Exceptional food whole fish was perfect. Beet salad was to die for. Cauliflower dish was amazing. Truly fresh. Chef was on point...."
Phil Grimes
"One of, if not, our best meals of the week! Everything was excellent from the calamari appetizer, the whole fried snapper, and the grouper day boat...."
Clint Teasley
"Had an excellent experience here. There was a wait so we actually went upstairs to Point Five. They allowed us to order from the nine one five menu...."
Nicole Jasperson
La Trattoria Oceanside
74/100 (4267 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Brunch
Drinks
Tortellini
Salad
Tortelloni
Crab
Osso Buco
Scallops
Cannelloni
Clams
Key lime pie
Lamb
Bruschette
Cheesecake
Shrimp
Pesto
Beef
Fish
Antipasti
Alfredo
Tortelli
Tiramisu
Lobster
Ossobuco
Escargot
Eggplant
Torte
Bolognese
Lasagne
Pasta
Sit down
Seafood
Italian
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Live Music
Reservations
Waterfront
Seating
Beach
Table Service
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Dinner
Drinks
Mid-range
"Excellent dinner and service. We highly recommend both locations for an excellent dinner experience. Be sure to try Virgilio's at the downtown..."
Rich Carpenter
"Absolutely FANTASTIC place! The staff was genuinely friendly. The drinks were amazing (martinis & wine). And the food was absolutely INCREDIBLE..."
Jim Ryder
"This place gets five stars because our server was wonderful. Went here for our one year wedding anniversary and we mentioned it in conversation to..."
Kelly Kelly
"Absolutely wonderful dinning experience! The food is incredible and so fresh! The staff is extremely attentive to every need and so friendly! I do..."
Hiro Holmes
"Came here for Christmas Eve dinner. We had a 5:00 reservation for 5 on OpenTable, but the restaurant claimed that we only had a reservation for 4..."
Zachary Allegretti
"Oh this place is fantastic! The food is absolutely incredible. The ambiance is cozy, charming and exactly what you picture when you think of Italian..."
Justin
"The food was just okay. The bruschetta had a cucumber that didn't really go with the rest of it. The Bolognese sauce was dry, but the flavor was..."
Nick Villanti
"Wonderful customer service. They're very nice! We dine with our two pups and they are kind enough to accommodate us. The food was amazing!..."
Analyn Escobar
"Our server was great. He had too many tables to provide intimate attention. Food was good, ravioli was a little fishy. Atmosphere was a bit loud, but..."
Sheri Ann
"OH-MY-GOD! This place is amazing. Really good bread to start with and the gnocchi pasta was out of the world. Service was really good too. Only con..."
savita c
"This restaurant is located near the airport, which makes it very convenient to find it.The prices here are quite reasonable, if you do not order..."
Tatiana Panova
"The location is excellent for an ocean view. We made reservations to be safe but could have walked up and still got in before 7 without any issues...."
Ronda Stede
"Very good Italian food. Reminds me of my grandmother's cooking, who is 100% Italian and put alot of love into her food. I ordered the Veal Marsala..."
Tyler K
"I can't say enough good things about La Trattoria! I've ordered takeout from there twice, and both times, the food was simply outstanding. Their..."
Rachel Bond
"Truly a 5-star experience. Sits on the coast looking over the ocean, our experience started with an excellent, classy server well versed in the full..."
Joe M
"Everything about our experience here was great except our waiter. He wasn't horrible but lots of room for improvement. He would walk until about 5..."
Cory B.
"First time and won't be the last! Great service from our server Josh and 2 personal visits to our table to check on us! They even made a special dish..."
Kristi Kluba
"Delicious food and excellent waiter. Escargot outstanding, Caesar salad a must have..spaghetti with meat sauce, Italian sausage, veal marsala with..."
Sharyl M
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use