Amanda Grooms
Fantastic Restaurant! We came at an “off time” and had Sophia as a server. She was phenomenal and offered recommendations that were ‘on point’. The food was delicious! The corn and crab chowder and fish tacos were so good. The burger was huge, juicy and full of flavor. It could easily be split. Very reasonable pricing and good beer selection of local flavor and common options. If we get to Key West again, this is a must do!
Nikki Shields
Gluten free options were amazing! Started off with crab and corn chowder. Then I had the Italian pizza on a gluten free crust and a side of plantains. The bartender Billy made us his signature old fashioned that was great as well. Hubs had the mole chicken entree and said that was delicious as well. Great experience, will definitely be back!
Dustin Shanley
What a great place to eat. Very clean everywhere. Had the triple tail (Jamaican jerk) Seafood Mac and some scallops. All cooked and seasoned perfectly. A little classier than what you find off Duval St. Would highly recommend. Also the espresso martini and the bloody Mary (spicy) were worth the visit alone.
Juliann Knott
Hi Off the Hook Grill,
I went on a busy Thursday evening and chose to sit at the bar since there wasn’t any table seating’s available. I felt weird at the bar due to not knowing anyone at the bar. It seems like Key West locals come to the bar a lot. I couldn’t enjoy my meal when there was a lady screaming and talking so loud at the bar. I guess I should have waited to get a table instead of having to deal with a lady being disrespectful.
The staffs were super friendly and gave us good options on what meal to choose from if we couldn’t decide. I ended choosing the Ahi Tuna BLT Burger. I thought my burger was really delicious! The Lobster Mac and Cheese was alright. I wish the flavor was better. Maybe my tastebuds were off that day.
Overall, if I’m ever in Key West I would highly try his place. Their food is good and came out quick! The staff here are highly knowledgeable about the restaurant!
Rezzy
The Ahi Tuna BLT Burger was divine. We ordered it rare and it's been the best thing we have had this month in the keys from a restaurant. It was juicy with a perfect balance of flavors involved. We chose the sweet potato tots and m.... So yummy. We hope that we will be able to have this again. 3:30 on a Saturday was pretty quiet. A great spot next to the parking ramp makes it a great place to wait for family coming in via plane.
We sat at the bar where Tim took great care of us. Good luck battling cancer.
Brian Bradley
Off the hook is an excellent restaurant an Old Town Key West just a bit off the path of Duvall. I had the the gobbler which was fantastic. It was like a turkey open-face Sandwich where the stuffing I've been turned into a waffle and everything was on top of that--turkey, mashed potatoes, gravy. Like an upscale version of Thanksgiving on a plate. Also their rendition of a espresso martini it's one of the best I've had in Key West. It's definitely worth eating here and I would come back again.
Mark Gilson
Overall we enjoyed the service and atmosphere at Off the Hook Grill. Our waitress was incredibly helpful with dietary needs, and they even have a separate menu (ask for it) for those who are gluten free. Couldn't have been more happy with our service and the ambiance. My wife ordered the tripletail dinner and I ordered the ceviche. The tripletail was nearly 40$, and I don't think it was worth that. My ceviche was 15$ which was relatively reasonable, but not much of a meal (which was what I was going for). I'd recommend this location, however, I do think the owner needs to adjust the pricing a bit.
Andrea Mattern
We had dinner here right after the Dry Tortugas trip. We are so glad we chose this excellent restaurant. The food was amazing. We liked it so much we came back a few nights later after we had tried many others. Best menu, best food!
Caesar salad with grilled Mahi and coconut shrimp. Good bloody mary too!
Tip for football fans: they have a secret bar in the back behind the restaurant with TV screens and a happy hour ... great bar. Had the lobster goat cheese pizza. Amazing!
Grace L
On vacation from Pennsylvania, we stopped in for dinner. The lady who served us was so nice, and enthusiastic with helping us through the menu. She recommended the shrimp and lobster gnocchi, telling us it was her favorite thing, and boy did she steer us right! It was fantastic! The fried green tomatoes were delicious (my first time trying alligator), and the duck pizza hit the spot as well. At the end we just had to share a piece of their blueberry mint key lime pie.
We had a wonderful experience here!
Bill Wamsley
Probably the most enjoyable of our trip. Was not a gimmicky place like most here. Very nice and friendly staff (thanks Tim for being out server), food was absolutely delicious, drinks were very good. The scallops over pork belly over fried green tomato were outstanding. Also some nice deserts blueberry key lime pie and a key lime ice cream sandwich.
Put this place on your list as a don't miss.
Brittney S
Great place! Worth the price. Wonderful food. I had the scallops over pork belly and loved it. Awesome servers
Julie Palma
So good, we ate there twice. I’m celiac and they had a lot on the menu I could choose from. They were super sensitive to my needs which I appreciated. I had their gluten free Greek pizza with lamb, homemade crust!, it was outstanding. My family, who aren’t celiac, couldn’t believe how good it was. They loved their meals and raved about how good it was. Everything we had was delicious. Service is amazing and attentive. Go there if you’re celiac or not!
Mela
ITS CLEAN- down to the bottles of ketchup!! well stocked bar, great tater tots... friendly bartenders...with a heavy pour🙃. great spot
Allison Grimes
We had a party of 5 and made a last minute reservation. They made accommodations for us and even stayed open a little late. Sang happy birthday to our friend as well (they helped us keep it a secret). As you can see in the photos the food looked amazing and tasted even better. The dinners were melt in your mouth good. The blueberry mint key lime pie was divine. Thank you for a wonderful experience, made our night.
Ashley Robertson
Excellent presentation, flavor combinations, and quality! My BF and I were able to try some elusive triple tail and it was the best fish we'd ever eaten. The blueberry key lime was was also excellent!
Hryhorii Sunduk
Great food, unusual combination of ingredients, but very, very tasty. Friendly staff, fast service. It is better to call in advance and book a table, you can choose between two halls and a bar in the fresh air. It is cozy and tasty, I recommend it.
Barbara Wieteszka
First time visiting. Loved everything we ate! The fresh shrimp appetizer had huge shrimp! Everything was fresh, and my food allergy was addressed prior to ordering. Highly recommend. Atmosphere was casual and cozy.
Andrew Stephenson
Very friendly, lovely atmosphere, and great food--what else can you ask for. I did a quick search for gluten-free menu options and Off The Hook hooked me with the deviled eggs, which did not disappoint! One of the better gluten-free pizzas I have had. I was in early for dinner with the old folks after a day of fishing, the bartender was friendly and welcoming. You can't go wrong here.
Steven Halm
Amazing dinner to end the vacation with my fiancé. We busted our asses in the gym all week to make sure that we could have a good dinner. This is by far the best meal that I’ve had in probably forever. Never seen a menu that you couldn’t decide what you wanted to eat. We just split everything and ate a little of each and packed the rest up to take to our friends. Great service. Our server Aimee was awesome. Not an over packed place being smaller and off the main road. For sure a hidden gem in Key West. If/when we come back to Key West we will be back for sure.
Lisa Kopka
Great little Key West restaurant. Four nights in KW and we enjoyed two dinners and one breakfast here. Whether you choose to eat breakfast, lunch, or dinner you won’t be disappointed. They offer some really good gluten-free options for any meal. Loved the food and they have a terrific staff.
Thomas Pettersen
Amazing food and the best service possible. The gnocchi and lobster "mac n' cheese" is to die for! Just do not eat a huge lunch somewhere else 3 hours before...
Sheila Roit
Great place. A tad tight for seating. Hubby had grouper and loved it. Only chicke. On menu had nuts mixed in. Ended up with a plain cheese pizza. Thick crust and a tad bland.
Gretchen Sukdolak
We have been to Key West numerous times & my husband has been here to many times to count with the USAF. We just ate the best meal we’ve ever had at “ Off the Hook”- Scallops cooked to perfection, short rib ravioli, pesche pasta, grouper ceviche-all to die for. Impeccable service...outstanding food. We are from New York and will make this a must on each return trip. Wow! Be sure to make a reservation -don’t miss this!
Odalys Arbelaez
Best breakfast ever, hands down! Fresh food, delicious. 2 for 1 mimosas. You must reserve your spot for the evening, even for happy hour! Favorite spot for locals.
Shay Martello
This is a hidden gem in Key West. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable. The food was presented well and cooked to perfection. Thank You Jackie for giving us 5-star service.
Summer Bolton
Great non typical food in Key West. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable. The seafood was fresh and the space was great. Living in/near NYC our standards are high and this did not disappoint!
Maria Mae Jeancola
Without a doubt the best meal I’ve ever had at a restaurant...and that’s a BOLD statement. The service was wonderful and the food left us nearly speechless!
Barb McQuade
Wonderful service and the meal was to die for. I highly recommend.
Debbie Balsman
We had lunch and it was amazing a must while in Key West! It’s off the path but excellent food and service was top notch
Chad Meehan
Would give this place 10 stars!!! Excellent service!!! Amazing food!!! The best food we've had ever!!!
Dan Schwartzstein
110% would visit again. Small place, but the menu is fantastic and the vibe is great. Good for date night. The ceviche was delicious. Had the fish and chips, both of which were amazing and I kept wanting more. You won't be disappointed with Deuce's.
Tami Virgin-Horton
We had the Stone Crab and Vonch fritters. They both were delicious. The staff were great and we had an awesome time. We highly recommend it
Kristy Woods
Amazing food & great service with a quaint cozy atmosphere. Small so I would recommend reservations.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes