Dan Bell
We really enjoyed the chicken and crab cakes. Salads were prepared nicely with more than just lettuce and a cucumber like most places. Nice warm loaf of bread was served with the meal as well.
Victor Pytleski
Little hidden Gem, small inside i was a little worried when we sat and the table was sticky and the place was mostly empty.
It did not disappoint though!
My wife had the Chicken Milanese, I had the prime rib and lobster. There prime rib was awesome! The horseradish cream sauce was delicious. The Broccoli was a bit undercooked but the prime rib and lobster was so good I did not care.
Their key like Pie is TART. Which is how i love it. Very good!
Service was strong but they were so that was easy.
Atmosphere wise it is BLAH, not beach themed, it does not have any TV’s. Even at the bar. It is a nice little gem and the food is great but it fails on the theme and atmosphere.
Ralph Aguilera
Not bad service, but ask questions! So the service person if you ask, the right questions can answer everything, but it doesn’t come voluntary.
Like … “let me tell you what the special are or you try…. It’s my fav.
Pretty cut and dry.
The place is super clean over all.
Andy Aumiller
Great steak and fish restaurant with pleasant vibes and attentive staff. Ordered mixed fish platter and beef tenderloin. Meal sizes were right, not too much. So there is space left for their delicious key lime pie too :)
Frank Parise
Very very good!!!! Our waitress Naomi was fantastic and the food was delicious. I highly recommend it for a nice meal and an easy dinning experience . Very full right now
Taffy DeJarnette
Pleasant waitress, relaxed environment. I had the local fish 'maison' (house) and it came with a very good baguette and salad. Generous portion and was very good.
mrbill7853
Food and service were great. Atmosphere is ordinary and could be anywhere. Nothing for birthday celebrations.
Richard Kraemer
Nice family owned restaurant with authentic and good food. We had the alligator tail as a starter, which wasn't that great. It was deep fried meat, so you couldn't really tell anymore what kind of meat it really was. The main course (local catch fresh fillet) was absolutely delicious and perfectly cooked. It came with a lobster soup and rice, so the price of 32.99$ was also very reasonable. Service was also good and the location is also very nice. I would come here again 🙂
Lindsay Murphree
Great local place. Server was friendly. Salad was very fresh and the house dressing was very good. The hollandaise sauce on the stuffed shrimp was delicious. Definitely recommend
Mark Cardinal
Absolutely delicious! I can't say enough, it was amazing. Had surf and turf and it was melt in your mouth good. Can't recommend it enough.
Nina Estep
The food was excellent, our waitress was very knowledgeable about the menu and was very professional.
Jason Clary
Surf and turf (lobster tail and prime rib) were really good. This is an old school restaurant a little off Duval, but well worth the extra walk.
Jenny P. Giraldo
Food was absolutely delicious, Karina's service was exceptional, great music and great atmosphere. This place is very well located, close to everything and you can walk around. Very Recommended!
Alan V
We really enjoyed the food. The lobster tail was the best part, I probably would only get that if I were to go again. The reason for 4 stars is because they have a young hostess who is learning (which is ok, there is nothing wrong with that) the first night we tried to go there we called and asked if we needed a reservation. She said no. We came and she asked if we could wait 10 minutes. We waited outside for over 40 minutes and she kept letting other people in front of us. Eventually we left and came back the next night. She should have a list or something.
Madeline Cardinal
We searched for a great dining experience on a budget and this place delivered. Best steak I've had in a very long time! I got the Duffy's ribeye and my husband got the Duffy's surf and turf. Both dishes were excellent and the side salads we had were so good! We tried the raspberry cheesecake and it was also amazing. The inside of the restaurant is gorgeous with big arched ceilings and it had a romantic atmosphere. We will definitely visit again!
Rodney Davis
If I could give this place more stars I would. Last night in the Keys and it was amazing
Mike O'Brien
I haven't had a perfectly cooked filet in so long. This place was legitimate. I ordered a prime rib for my spouse and it was eliminated. I've never seen them eat like that...
John Casey
Great place! The conch fritters are LEGIT. Prime rib was amazing. Filet was great. Lobster was perfect. The bernaise sauce here is off the charts. A must have dinner when im in Key west. Thank you duffy's!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes