Lisa Markarian
Definitely ask for them to cook the pizza well done otherwise I don't think it would have been good. Looked raw. We always have our pizza well done anyway but definitely needs it here. Once cooked to our liking it was delicious. Flavorful and a great dough. We didn't have the Gelato but heard customers saying it was good.
Martin Fritsch
We were hungry after a boat trip and looking for a quick snack, and wow, this was a good decision. Great handmade pizza for a fair price, way better than average. It even seems to be one of the best places to eat pizza in America (based on a Tripadvisor ranking). That's impressive, so go for it!
Cori Harper
Spectacular pizza. We were on a boat all day and wanted pizza. Walked over and ordered a pie. Took about 15 minutes. It was great. Homemade crust. Watched the guy hand toss it and load on all the toppings. It tasted as good as it looked. They did offer slices to go. Had drinks and Gelato. Not a lot of places to sit. The staff was very friendly and gave us Plates and silverware. They had freshly created Parmagan. Overall a great place for pizza.
Andrea Acosta
As a pizza lover this place is TOP KNOTCH!! đthe crust is perfectly toasted and delicious. Service was phenomenal, Gracias! We loved all three different slices. Canât recommend enough!!!
Smruti Kalathia
Amazing Pizza place in Key West. Must visit this place. They do have vegetarian options. They have fresh and homemade pizza. Also we had fresh gelato ice cream as well. It was really delicious.
Mark Slam
Hands down best pizza in Key West. Our big mistake was only getting one slice and then walking 1 mile all the way back to our hotel. The pizza was so good we had to walk the one mile back and get another slice. So 3 miles for 2 slices. It was worth it though.
Gard âCampingCoastie.comâ Snyder
We had some coconut Gelato, it was very good. The service was nice. They let us try some of their other flavors.
Bulky Pug
I came in here a couple of years ago for a couple of slices with my girlfriend and they were mediocre. Probably because they had an idiot making them that day. Jump to last night and was watching the game next door and was hungry. I ordered a pepperoni at halftime to have at the bar and it was excellent. We could tell the dough was fresh with a great tasting sauce and just the right amount of cheese. Pizza preferences can be quite personal but we think this is a great version of NY style pizza.
Doc Kovacs
Michael took GREAT care of us. LA Suprema overbaked at my request. perfect. Gelato was the real deal.
Ankit Sharma
Their Gelato is amazing, but a bit pricey compared to the other places I have tried. It tastes amazing, though.
Their pizza is great in taste, perfect thickness with amazing flavor and crunchiness to it. Highly recommend.
Avais Sherani
This is such an amazing pizzeria, the wuality, quantity, ambience, and staff all are amazing. The Pizza was made to perfection, it was served (heated) within no time, the staff was very helpful to all the customers. The seating space is not much but they have a couple of tables outside the store as well. Visited this place as recommended to be top rated and it definitely was top class. The gelato looked amazing, although didn't try it.
Mandy M
We almost didnât go here because of a few bad reviews, but so glad we went! It was delicious pizza. The crust has this perfect crunch on the outside with soft dough on the inside. The slices are huge and taste so good. Highly recommend!
Kimberly Hahn
The universe sent our group of 9 to Duetto for pizza and it absolutely did not disappoint. We ordered cheese and pepperoni, cheese, Hawaiian, margarita, and supreme pizzas and they were AMAZING. Seriously some of the best pizza Iâve ever had and our group agreed. We liked it so much, in fact, that we decided to get the exact same order the next night. Donât think- just do it!
Jenna Bulmer
The food here is REALLY good. The pizza was the best we had in the keys and they had a nice assortment of slices to chose from.
We also got talked into trying the gelato and weâre glad we did as it is really good. We have visited Italy a lot over the years and the consistency is just as smooth and creamy.
The inside needs a bit of TLC but for grab and gos this place is awesome!!
Gennalyn D Christian
Weâre new in town and craving for pizza. luckily we found this pizzeria. They have variety of pizza. We ordered lasagna and Hawaiian. This was the first time I tried lasagna pizza. Their pizza really good. I highly recommend if your are a pizza lover.
Kathy Temple
My husband hates pizza because of the grease and heartburn, however he said we can stop because he knows pizza is my favorite! OMG this pizza is on a whole different level from any pizza Iâve ever eaten! Itâs so authentic and made perfectly, not greasy and the best pizza Iâve ever eaten! We had a few different kinds of slices and we will def be stopping a few more times this week while weâre on vacation! ABSOLUTELY RECOMMEND!!
Charlie Brasier
Great place for quick great pizza. Indoor/outdoor seating.
Josh Simon
Great pizza and super nice people, limited seating, much more low key than the other places in this area!
Shawn Dreese
We order pizza to our resort near the area and I tell ya this was the best ny style pizza I haven't had in awhile. So if your in the keys on vacation looking for that authentic my big slice nyc pizza that just melts in your mouth definitely check out this place and ask for Paul because he's the guy that will give you great service that you're in need. I highly recommend this place!!
Epi
When you need to stop for a moment to cool down, enjoy real gelato here. Their adffogato with a dollop of tiramisu flavored gelato was a treat. Their sandwiches are served on wedges of sliced focaccia and stuffed with lots of greens. A good choice all around. Staff were good about providing a lot of water. Very limited seating.
MAMA Bookasaurus
Pizza was delicious. Quick turn around. Nice staff. It's just super tiny. Two little tables and maybe six chairs. Not much standing room either. Plan on getting it to go. Has cornmeal bottom so corn allergy people beware.
Catguer52
BEST PIZZA I've had, ever. So good. I had the Biancaneve and my sister had the spicy salami and con carne. All was delicious. Also had gelato, so good. Staff are so nice and helpful.
Felicia Braude
Duettos. My sister and I had an awesome getaway to Key West, FL. We walked a LOT, and one of our food stops was at Duettoâs pizza. Rated as the best pizzeria in Key West, we couldnât resist.<br/><br/>Since it was a slow Saturday, I was nervous to order the slices that were sitting out in the display case, although there was a nice variety. The only way I could have gotten a fresh slice would have been to order a whole pizza... which didnât happen. Ariel got the standard cheese slice. I ordered the Sicilian. We learned the Sicilian was a new slice for them... but really enjoyed the standard cheese slice.<br/><br/>Cheese Pizza: The crust was STELLAR, flavored, and lightly seasoned cheese. Crunchy although reheated. All the flavor was still there. Quite impressed!<br/><br/>I thought I would be adventurous and try the sicilian, but the cheese lacked flavor. You can see it looks pretty bland, and it tasted the same. Although the slice wasnât super thick, it was still cooked well. I didnât mind the charred crust. They said they were working on this recipe, so Iâll give them lots of credit. I liked the crust! But sauce/cheese didnât really give much flavor, but great to know they are working on it!!
Anne Frentz
Great casual place. On a recent visit to Key West we walked by this place every day and stopped for gelato. Very good. On our last day we had some pizza and it was one of the best pizza we have ever had!! Too bad we didn't try the pizza earlier!
Juli.c
The best pizza on the island!. Great service, lovely people, fabulous food and the best coffee!
Tayloe.sanderson10
They do not open at 8.. In key west they advertise opening at 8am I went in at 9 to get a cup of coffee. Doors were unlocked. The lady cleaning couldn't answer me the time<br/>They would be open to get coffee.
Jack C
Excellent pizza - we got a cheese, a sausage/pepperoni and a white bianca pizza. They were all great. Sampled some gelato while I waited - they were awesome. Can't wait to go back to get more for dessert. Can't go wrong here!
Pbjrhj
Yummy pizza and very friendly staff. I was pleasantly surprised how tasty this was, given its touristy location.
Douglas Mudge
Best pizza I have ever tasted. It was like being back in Italy . I was surprise at the pricing was low considering the product.
Nicole Vogt
Wonderful pizza and the best gelato I've ever had. Even better the owner is very nice and accommodating. Would go back again and again!
Floridafoodie
Good pizza and freshly made pizza. It was all really great. Very friendly employees. They just need more places to sit.
Amy Heidemann
SERIOUSLY amazing gelato! The best I have literally ever had. The owners are amazing people and are creating amazing food. I was in Key West with my family for five days and came here three out of those five days. Don't miss out!
Acb244
DELICIOUS.. I had the ham + mushroom pizza & chocolate coconut gelato- WOW. Great prices, friendly service, best pizza I've ever had. A definite go-to in Key West.
Annie H
I went to Italy last year so I have tasted real gelato and this is just as good!! Everything here is amazing. Come here if you want a cheap fast meal
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes