This place is definitely of my favorites. A hidden hideaway in Plum. It’s a must try 😍
OH!!! Great place for a celebration! Plenty of room, waiting staff was extremely attentive, and oh, the food!!! Delicious--absolutely! quantities mare than adequate--if you left there hungry, it's your own fault. Have been there twice, and both times were pleasant experiences.
We love John Anthony‘s for the delicious food and great service but this weekend we were happy to host a baby shower there!! The newly remodeled banquet room was absolutely beautiful!
Gina, Marissa, Anna and everyone was so helpful… and the food was as delicious as always!!! We had the Chicken Romano, green beans amandine, stuffed shells and roasted potatoes. Everything was amazing!!
The prices are so reasonable and they are accommodating with decorations, etc.
If you are looking for a place to host a private event do not look any further!!
The service was fantastic. Was a nice a chill environment. I had a full course. Fried mushrooms today tasted great and was fried just right.
I had the veal parmesan it was so tender and had very good flavor.
The loaded potatoe soup was very good and had a little heat to it but not much.
The chocolate eruption cake was a good dessert though I think it needs vanilla ice cream to balance it out.
Over all I'd highly recommend the food and the service. They have daily deals so check before coming in to make sure you get your best deal.
Stopped here to eat a late dinner with my son. We were promptly seated, ordered our beverages, looked through menu. When we got our beverages, we ordered the fried zuchinni planks appetizer so we can look through entire menu. I got the Eggplant Parmsean and my so got the John Anthony's platter. Both came with side of Pasta and 1 other side dish.
Prices were reasonable with the portions we received. We even split a piece of Chocolate Russian cake. Everything was delicious. Only thing I would change is adding bread rolls or garlic toast to each meal. I will definitely recommend anyone who's looking for something different to try other than the normal restaurants they dine at. 7/12/23.
I’m always pleased with my meal at John Anthony’s. On this visit I had the John D Sandwich - fried eggplant and chicken on a hoagie roll topped with marinara, cheese, and John Anthony peppers, and it was terrific. The only problem was it was so big that I couldn’t finish it, so I brought the rest home. My wife had eggplant parmigiana and she was very pleased with it. But the hit of the table was my friend’s Buffalo Chicken Calzone. That will be on my short list of choices on my next visit.
Always have a good meal here. Gina and staff are great
Nice atmosphere & attentive service.
Not many people there, but we were there about an hour earlier than the dinner hour. As we were leaving more people were coming in.
John Anthony’s,
I give this location a Five Star,, they have a very large menu,, this restaurant has been here for a long time,, but they seem to take good care of it,, good parking,, restrooms are clean,, the staff is very professional,, the food is great,, we in joyed everything,, they have a full bar,, I recommend this place..
They recently updated their menu. The place has great food! The updated menu is smaller which is much easier to read and more sensible.
Amazing service, My waitress was a pure goddess named Ally, she is very friendly & really helpful. Her service is as flawless as she looks. Highly Recommended!!
Great place! Good food, friendly staff, few TV’s around to watch the games.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Pittsburgh
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes