Had a great day here ! Southbound played here upstairs on the roof ! What a beautiful view ! The crowd there was awesome both line Dancers & people just enjoying this beautiful day ! I had the Tuna Taco's awesome! Most definitely will come back for dinner & drinks �! Hope Southbound plays there again this summer!
Breathtaking view, great music and great food. Loved it and can't wait to go back. I wish there was a more extensive menu for rooftop dining.
This was my first time here and everything about this place was amazing!
We sat outside and watched all the ferries go by while sipping a delicious espresso martini.
The lobster roll was amazing highly recommend!
The food is still amazing and spectacular service and a nice view of the ferries and boats! This time around I was able to have a perfect view of the Harvest moon.
For a starter try: MUSSEL POT DU JOUR chefs speciality
Entree:
LOBSTER ROLL: warm: butter poached, lemon aioli, handcut fries
omg ！this is best seafood restaurant I ever been to!oyster is so fresh! Personally I hate oysters! But I had half dozen! That’s how fresh they’re .So good so fresh!! Also that lobster roll really good and fresh.
This new food they have is light years ahead of the old menu. We had the burger, lobster roll, chop chop salad, and salmon with a few apps. Thanks to the staff and managers who took time to make small talk as well.
Deborah Carleton-Tierney
+5
Nice place on the water to watch the boats come and go. Baked clams and calamari were very good. I had fish and chips, which were good. My husband enjoyed his tuna.The staff made the dining experience even better. Our waiter was very friendly and attentive. Employees seem to enjoy their jobs which is a testament to the establishment, and enhances the dining experience.
Brett “El Guerrero” Harte
+5
First I would like to give a shout out to Sherry our waitress for the outstanding service and the small talk we shared. Everything was beyond delicious.
Fantastic food. From the first to the last bite it was absolutely delicious. I had the special which was the salmon w summer pasta. I loved it. The ambiance was very nice as well because your right on the water, very romantic if you go around sunset. Definitely can be a more casual dining experience. They have indoor and outdoor seating and a rooftop, that was not open when we were there. The only reason I'll be giving it 4 stars is because even tho the drinks were great, it took us quite a while to get a second. Service was a bit slow and we weren't checked on or taken care of as much as we should have. Other than that it was a very nice date night, but can also be a very family friendly place as well.
We loved it. The fried clams are their specialty and the portion was huge. Great prices too. Everything was covid safe and the service was on point. Not a long wait. Beautiful on the water outdoor seating with a sea breeze to cool the day. Today we had the lobster rolls. And the baked clams. Huge chunks of delicious lobster
![5]( "Recensione")
Nestled beautifully along the water's edge, Nicky's On the Bay is a beacon for those seeking an exceptional dining experience combined with breathtaking views. The restaurant masterfully captures the essence of seaside dining, blending culinary artistry with the mesmerizing ambiance of the bay.
Upon entering, guests are instantly drawn to the panoramic vistas of the waterfront. Whether you choose indoor seating or opt for the outdoor deck, every spot promises a visual treat of nature's splendor. Sunsets here, with the sky painting itself in shades of gold, crimson, and lavender, are particularly spellbinding.
The menu at Nicky's On the Bay is a delightful blend of classic favorites and innovative creations. Seafood, as expected, takes center stage. From succulent lobster dishes to freshly caught fish specials, every plate showcases the bounty of the waters that surround. For those who favor terrestrial delights, the menu also boasts a range of expertly cooked meats, poultry, and vegetarian options, ensuring there's something for every palate.
A dining experience is never complete without commendable service, and Nicky's doesn't disappoint. The staff is attentive, well-versed with the menu, and genuinely strives to make every meal special. Their recommendations, especially for the day's specials or the catch of the day, are often spot on.
The beverage list is a curated selection of wines, cocktails, and non-alcoholic delights designed to complement the food. Whether you're toasting a celebration or just unwinding after a long day, their drinks elevate the dining experience.
In essence, Nicky's On the Bay is not just a restaurant; it's a destination. It's where gastronomy meets the serene beauty of the bay, creating memories that linger long after the meal concludes. Whether for a romantic date, a family gathering, or a quiet meal by oneself, Nicky's promises an experience that tantalizes the senses and soothes the soul. Highly recommended for anyone seeking the quintessential bay-side dining experience!
Definitely coming back to Nicky's for Fried Calamari (tasted fresh and was crispy), Steamed Mussels (delicious!), and crab cakes! I ordered the Lobster Roll and it was okay.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Bay Shore
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes