Michelle Labriola-Parolari
+5
Excellent place, great menu...so different and fresh and plentiful..my family and are making this our get together spot.
Great service, cocktails not cheap but worth every dollar
Was there for the first night of the 2017 season. The weather was awful, but the food delicious . I especially enjoyed the steak skewers and the halibut. I tried a few other dishes, chicken with avacado and cilantro purée, rice and artichoke "cake, little peppers stuffed with shrimp risotto, crab cakes, every dish was awesome. The bartenders were attentive and friendly. Can't wait to go back when the weather is warm.
Nice little waterfront restaurant.
Food was so good , I was not a fan of the style of the salmon but the texture was top quality.
The dessert was very nice . Ice cream and almonds are a great combination.
Will happily return.
I meet friends here every summer and we're never disappointed. Every dish and drink is beautifully presented and delicious- good portion sizes, perfectly seasoned and freshly prepared. Waterfront view from patio cannot be beat because you are right on the Great South Bay (interior is air conditioned, open and airy if you prefer). Service is courteous if a bit slower than we preferred (parking lot is metered). Shrimp in Trench Coats w/aioli appetizer is a must have!!
My fifth or six visit here and never disappointed. Service is always great as well as the bay views. Wines by the glass offer excellent choices. Have had a variety of mains and appetizers too many to list here. All were well seasoned and cooked.
Dana Varricchio - Long Island, NY
+5
My husband and I went with another couple and had a bunch of delicious appetizers! We had not been here in years and I am not sure why because the food is amazing!! We had the octopus, baked clams, calamari, oysters and seafood salad. Will be back again soon!
Restaurant has a lot of potential. Great location and atmosphere. Food is average, but reasonable price.
Beautiful spot on the water with a lovely team that runs the show. We came on a Sunday and sat on the covered patio.
The food was tasty, but the fish portions were on the small side
This is a lovely setting with great views of the bay and the passing boats. The food was delicious 😋 and the service was fantastic. Our server, Jordan, was great! He was attentive but also personally engaging and a great sense of humor. By the time the evening was over, we had adopted him into our group. Our evening meal at Fatfish was a highlight of our trip. I give this restaurant high praise and a hearty recommendation.
This place is really not for everyone, considering how expensive it was. Food was good, the service was super attentive and quick, and you can’t really beat eating right on the water.
The food portion was not much generous for the price and it didn't impressively taste good for me..
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
+4
What a fabulous night with the family. Beautiful setting. Dinner was pricey but worth it. I had the swordfish. Also had a beet and goat cheese salad, simple but amazing. Dessert was a cappuccino and cheesecake, also very good. Service was great. Would have loved to sit outside but they couldn't accommodate at the time. We sat inside with doors open and it worked enough. Drinks were good, I had a Margarita. It is a very beautiful place to go.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Bay Shore
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes