Peter Pan Diner
999 Sunrise Hwy - Bay Shore
€€
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
🍺
Alcohol
🍹
Cocktails
🍷
Wine
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
♿
Accessible restroom
😊
Casual
🛋️
Cozy
👥
Good for groups
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews (10)
My friends and I were looking for a kid-friendly diner that we could all agree upon so that we could catch up for a bit over lunch. The little guy was very impressed by the christmas decorations and enjoyed his pancakes without a fuss. The food was on par with what you would expect from a Long Island diner. The chicken wrap was great. The reuben was even better than expected, and the fries were nice and crispy.
The only gripe that we had was with the service staff and how they communicated with the kitchen. Two members of our group had dietary restrictions that were explained to the server, but were not fully understood. Three out of the five of us got exactly what we asked for, so I'm giving a three out of five service rating.
Read more
Google
An all time favorite of mine as they transport me back to my childhood with their Chocolate Chip/Peanut butter chip Pancakes which are amazing. Every other dish I’ve gotten here has been just as good. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the prices are reasonable.
Google
I've been away from Long Island for a year. It was so good to visit and eat great food! Also nice to see Peter! My late husband and I started eating here in the 6o's. Always a good experience!
Google
Peter Pan diner is the best diner in Long Island!!! My family and I always go here and enjoy it every single time!! Service is great every single server is wonderful! Food is delicious and always comes out hot!! Only thing bad about Peter Pan is the parking lot is kind of small
Google
What a surprise find!! You can pass it by easily if you have never been there before. Food outstanding selection. Staff upbeat and funny. Atmosphere-- all decked out for Halloween AND very clean. Looking forward to returning!!
Google
I absolutely love this place. The staff is awesome and love to chat with customers. The food portions are huge and their desserts are out of this world. If you never been here, give it a try, you won't be disappointed.
Google
It's one of my favorite restaurants on the island! Great food, reasonable pricing for the amount you get! 10/10
Google
Excellent Diner, Delicious food and Spectacular service. Highly recommend!! Roxy is one of their best waitresses.
Google
Great spot for breakfast, their pancakes and omelets are delicious! They also have a great selection of cakes and baked goods.
Google
One of the best diners on the Island. I have been dining here for over 15 years. There are lots of regular customers. Favorites: Belgian waffle with fruit salad, matzoh ball soup, turkey bacon
Runners up: chicken noodle soup, omelettes
Staff is friendly and professional. Highly recommend
Google
📊 Compare with Other Restaurants
| Restaurant | Score | Tripadvisor | Reviews | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The LakeHouse | 86% | 4.5/5 | 4.5/5 | 3,180 |
| Tula Kitchen | 87% | 4.5/5 | 4.5/5 | 1,245 |
| Captain Bill's | 77% | 4.4/5 | 4.0/5 | 3,286 |
| Tullulah's | 85% | 4.4/5 | 4.5/5 | 1,145 |
| FatFish On The Water | 75% | 4.3/5 | 4.0/5 | 1,924 |
| The Pie at Salvatores | 85% | 4.6/5 | 4.5/5 | 595 |