Vegetarian Friendly: THE Best in Bay Shore

Skyblazer

Ariel Kombor

"First time eating food from this establishment and I ordered through Uber Eats. I was a little hesitant because of my last two experiences ordering..."

Sharon Hendricks

"My son chose Fratelli's as the next restaurant on our pizza adventures. Great pizza, knots & service. We will definitely be..."

Vashti Persad

"Great spot for near NYC Pizza on Long Pennsinsula. Great selection of pizza and other staple Italian dishes and service that's top notch. Highly..."

Rich Haste

"Best shrimp parm I have ever had. This place is incredible. Everything is fresh and staff is so..."

Leandra Mueller

"Great family owned restaurant. Service and food was perfect. Baked clams were more clams oreganata, but were so good....I haf the monto carlo..."

desiree jackson

"Great food and service. They make you feel like family here. Will definitely..."

Ray Rosa

Salt & Barrel

84/100 (1097 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"I love everything about this place!! The drinks and food are amazing. The service is the best service I’ve had in awhile. My favorite spot right..."

Danielle Kristen

"My wife picked this awesome restaurant for my birthday dinner! Was totally surprised! The oysters were really fresh and delicious, our drinks were..."

Eric J Auer

"Wonderful, attentive service, I believe Paul was our server, but the entire dining room responded to any request we had. We all loved our meals, and..."

Karla Michelle

"We love this place !! It’s the best !!The oysters are always fantastic . Great wine � Beautiful atmosphere and great great music..."

Elyse Herr Halpern

"Food and service were perfect. I would recommend the lobster pot.the bay scallops were..."

Richard Schoppmann

"High end excellent trendy seafood and pub fare. Wonderful hidden..."

Paul DeStefano

"Excellent oysters - everything fresh . Ordered lobster special with coconut rice absolutely delicious. Best time to go for oysters is at Happy hour..."

Cherise Castagna-Gilberto

"Vincent was the best server! Thank you Sir for your hospitality� food was..."

Darla Álvarez

"This is my TOP place to get oysters. They are fresh, delicious & they know how to properly clean them. The drinks are always great. We love to sit at..."

Gina Pannone

"Oysters are on point with a very good selection. Didn't have the wine we ordered/wanted, prices are quite steep for what you..."

JV Young

"Awesome spot for Happy Hour. Eric is the best bartender on Long Island! Great service, food, and atmosphere. Stop in for Happy Hour and you’ll..."

Christian Miller

"We had a family of 6 at our table. The flavor, temperature and quality of all of the entrees was top notch. Although for the price of each did not..."

Dave Havenick

"Salt & Barrel exceeded our expectations for our wedding rehearsal dinner. Their team was incredibly accommodating, working with us to create a custom..."

Lauren Kulbit

"some of the best oysters I’ve ever had, especially the specialty cooked ones. incredible cocktails. Even more amazing service & staff. great spot..."

Piyush Banker

"Quality beyond words. Highly recommend. Food was great, but the attention to detail in service was exceptional. Thanks mike our waiter made the..."

dirty jedi

"We sat at the bar and out bartender was amazing and he had a great personality. The food was delicious and the drinks were tasty. The happy hour was..."

Fabielle Daniel

"Went here for happy hour with a large group. Lots of great happy hour specials on oysters and cocktails. Highly recommend! There were several..."

John DiModica

"Food is great. Service is great. The wait staff is younger than your average staff but its cute to see them at work and they work well! Very kind,..."

Kiara Castillo

The Pie At Salvatores

Wheelchair Accessible

"It was my husband and I first time there and we absolutely loved the Supreme pie we ordered. We will definitely be regulars at Salvatore's. Can't..."

Lori Martin

"Atmosphere was very nice and cozy. The service was excellent. The food was delicious and the staff was very friendly. Excellent place to bring family..."

Leresa Pearson

"Napoleon. I mean it was good yes, but did they take one piece of basil and tear it up? I was expecting a little more from such a nice place. I'll..."

Alexea Rivera

"Worst pizza I have had. What happened ?This was my go to place when I wanted a brick oven pizza. Extremely soggy and thin pizza. Barely any basil..."

Maria Velez

"I stopped in for lunch and had the Baked Ziti Salvatore. It was a bit soupy for my taste and the tiny bits of sausage were kind of a disappointment...."

J F

"We got the neopalitin and loved it! They serve it so hot that you need to let it rest for about five or 10 minutes. The garlic bread was awesome!..."

Nick Bierman

"Omg the best pizza ever!!! I did half white/half Napolian and the greek salad with the tastiest olives- to. die. for!!! My bf raved about the baked..."

Kary D

"Our recent dining experience at The Pie at Salvatore's in Bay Shore was a culinary marvel. From the moment we entered, the tantalizing aroma of..."

James Wood

"A long time spot of ours for over 8 years.... Great for family & friends to enjoy nice meal comfortable & nice restaurant, and a great Pie. As well..."

Joy Be

"Consistently the BEST pie and food around.. They use Real mozzarella which is so good! Calzones the size of the box If you’re not happy with..."

Raymond Magliulo

Mediterranean Express

Wheelchair Accessible

"Fast service reasonable priced Clean setting The soup very tasty and salad..."

Monsieur Carib

"What counts here is the food. Consistently delicious and lots of it. The prices have skyrocketed but so have they everywhere. I gave "service" 4..."

Diane P

"Ample portions of beef and lamb on a gyro for less than $10. This small restaurant only has a handful of tables so if you plan to dine in, don't..."

Ed Rose

"Love this place, great greek food and awesome service. This place is in the shopping center and easy to miss if your passing by. Definitely worth a..."

Nolberto Aguilar

"Yummy Authentic Greek food, and I'm Greek..."

Daphne Stamoularas

"Really great greek food! Their salads are second to none! The gyro platter was stacked high with everything! The Eggplant Greco sandwich is..."

deb T

"my first time having greek food and it was good the falafel sandwich was really really good would go..."

Hector Mejia

"Excellent place food, service and..."

Angel Manuel Rivera

"I had not been here in awhile primarily because I had not been going out much and they are not on Door Dash or Uber Eats. I had an appointment today..."

Sharon Hendricks

"While somewhat expensive, Mediterranean Express packs a punch with their delightful gyro and pita bread. Will most definitely be coming..."

Lee D

"I ordered dinner from the Mediterranean Express for years with good results. Always satisfied with my order. Yesterday I picked up a pre order for 10..."

Diane McConnell

"Greek salads are my go-to here! I very rarely order from a place that doesn't deliver because I am incredibly lazy....but I will always make the trip..."

Jessica Murray

"Really more set up as a place for take out but they do have a couple tables. Great clean and delicious..."

Douglas Lloyd

"Jeanie is so nice food is delicious we really like it..."

Diane Sheridan

"We absolutely love Mediterranean Express. Their food is made to order and so delicious. Best Hummus I've ever had. Our favorite dish is Chicken..."

J V

"I have had the gyro salad and was satisfied with the first time. The prices are reasonable and worth every dime for your food. They also have..."

Evelin Vaughns

Aji 53

84/100 (1010 ratings)

Sushi & Sashimi Combo

Oyster

Yellowtail Jalapeno Roll

Tuna

Beef Negimaki Bento Box

King Crab Avocado Tobiko

Wheelchair Accessible

"Our favorite place for a family celebration. Japanese fusion at its best, beautifully presented. The only negative for us is that the bars can be..."

Christopher Irving

"Love this place second time here and i absolutely love it ... Lobster bisque to die for ...... Specialty rolls are amazing and rib eye teriyaki..."

Georgia Tzoumas Colon

"Love ❤️ Aji 53. I had sushi 3 times in 3 days in 3 different places. Aji is by far my favorite. The service is excellent. The food is excellent...."

Nicole Russo Marino

"Food was sooo good and the staff was the nicest ever!! Thank you so..."

Jennifer Sanford Spina

"Crispy duck salad is amazing. All sushi is fresh and delicious. Beautiful atmosphere and friendly..."

Maria Cutrone

"Absolutely a wonderful experience great atmosphere and awesome representation of great dinning� With delicious food, can't wait to..."

Linda I Grant

"Amazing food, great service, awesome drinks, would highly..."

Jessica Longo

"What's not to like? We love the food and atmosphere. The staff are always friendly and smiling. Whether we're dining in or taking out, it's always..."

Emidio Scarfogliero

"The food is fresh and delicious I go there all the time for my sushi...They deliver..."

Carol Ann Paris

"Best sushi in the bay shore/Babylon area! It's hard to go anywhere else for sushi..."

Sarah Jones

"Beautiful presentation, attentive staff, delicious food! Whether it's the Bay Shore location or the Smithtown location, I have always had a great..."

Annie Pham

"First time ordering a couple of specialty rolls and a Hibachi Chicken and Scallops Dinner. Delicious! Mochi Ice Cream was amazing! Rock Shrimp for..."

Alexandra McGleese

"When visiting LI, we often come here to eat or order out. Delish either way but I truly love the atmosphere at the restaurant! Staff is friendly,..."

Samantha Cole

"Came here for dinner on a Friday night. If you’re dining in on the weekends, make sure to reserve a table because it was a full house. Our sushi..."

Rhea M.

"Aji has been providing excellent service and excellent food for years in downtown Bay Shore. A staple of Japanese Cuisine on Long Island with a large..."

Nicholas Swain

"Went there for a casual lunch, the sushi rolls were made thinner than other restaurants which I liked because it made them more bite friendly. The..."

Laura B

"Our favorite place for sushi. Love the lecechee martinis. A little pricey, but worth every penny. Their Christmas rolls are out..."

Pat B

"Aji 53 never ceases to please me. Even their takeout is prompt and perfect. The fish is always fresh, the rolls are beyond mind blowing and the..."

J W

"Nice ambience. Sushi rolls were..."

J K

"Aji 53 is a hidden gem right on Main Street Bay Shore ,the staff is always a pleasure to be around . We’ve gone there for years and have never..."

Gee Hightower

"Food was really good and the service was great. The waiter was very attentive to..."

Carlos Urquilla

Tullulah's

84/100 (1145 ratings)

Truffle Arancini Crispy Burrata

Salad

Octopus and Shrimp Tacos

Mac and cheese

Buttermilk Quail Rabbit Confit Pork Lion Cavatelli

Tailor Made and Smoke and a Pancake

Truffle Manchego Fries

Off Shore Fire Island Risotto

Wheelchair Accessible

"I first came here a few years ago and to this day I always recommend this restaurant to people that ask me for good places to dine. The food here is..."

Jenn Sanabia

"The food here is consistently amazing. New seasonal items keep the menu fresh. Great craft beer and cocktail selection. Staff is knowledgeable and..."

Peter Fox

"Moving to Raleigh, sure going to miss this place . The best food in town , well worth every penny , and the brunch is to die for..."

Alan Corps

"I stopped here for a low key dinner with a friend while in the area on business. Excellent vibe, great service and even better food. The summer menu..."

Ben Modeen

"Always great food and a fun atmosphere. The service was excellent. We were happy with the expanded menu that had lots of vegetarian choices. Lots..."

Susan Henderson

"Food, atmosphere, service all excellent! Highly recommend it. Wine was delish and reasonable! Love this place. Try..."

Frank Misiano

"Great location in Bayshore. The staff and owners are very friendly and attentive. Def going back. Highly recommend Sunday..."

Daniel Randolph

"Great food and one of the best beer menus I've seen on the island. Will definitely go..."

Phil Peluso

"Every time you are there you eat the best food. Everything tastes clean and fresh, wonderful flavor combinations. My favorite brunch spot too...."

Theresa Camacho Zarcone

"Great bartenders...excellent craft beer selection. The crispy Brussels sprouts were sublime..I'm a vegetarian so my veggies are my mainstay. Many..."

Carol Cerabino Kenney

"I just had my daughter Jessica's baby shower there on Sunday and it was amazing! We had a fabulous time! The waitress was excellent, the owner was..."

Vivienne Callahan

"Wow all the staff are so friendly The drinks are so delicious especially the Pisco Sour. The bartenders are great and help full the food is so..."

George A Sayers

"The service there is amazing Very friendly Food amazing Always a good meal..."

Pat Carroll Yacenda

"The food was amazing! Such fun drinks! Our server Jamie was absolutely amazing so accommodating and nice, gave us a delicious dessert extra for our..."

Savanna Bredekamp

"I had my daughter’s bridal shower here last weekend. From the moment I made the call to reserve the place until the last person left, the..."

Diana Gardner

"This has quickly become our favorite restaurant on long island. It's up there with good restaurants from the city. The staff is all great and they..."

Roberto Poo

"Everything we ordered was delicious and prepared perfectly. Service was very good. Small menu that changes seasonally. The area we were seated in..."

J V

"I've been to this establishment a couple of times now and I look forward to returning. We sampled the autumn menu on one occasion and were absolutely..."

J P

"Another amazing dinner at Tullulah’s. Starting with some classics bacon wrapped dates, chorizo, the crispy buratta. Moving on to the small plates...."

Stacey Tierney

"Creative, if you like something different! A delightful revolving menu! They are attentive and wonderful with recommendations. I cannot recommend..."

Melissa M

"Came for my birthday brunch. The waiter was super nice and helpful!! We had their version of an old fashion which was good (never had one before) I..."

Stephanie Zephirin

"The place is ideal for smaller groups. The bar tenders are great, service is on point and the drinks and food are great too. Get the macaroni with..."

WKUK B

"Lunch at the bar was perfect. The menu looks awesome. Fun, funky and intriguing. I had fried chicken sandwich with pork belly and truffled manchego..."

Michael DiSalvo (Mike D)

"Knocked off one star for a burnt dessert(that they ended up not charging us for :-) ). All other food I had was delicious( crispy burrata and..."

Amanda Vargas

"That was one of the best dinners I've had in a long time...My wife and I went and had the Pork belly mac and cheese, mussels, truffle fries, and the..."

Brandon Guerrero

"AMAZING food! Love how the menu is seasonal! The food is out of this world! Great date night or family..."

Tori

"Came here for a birthday brunch. Ordered the Apple Spiced Pancakes, Wild Mushroom Hash, Mac n’ Cheese, Red-Eye Benny, a side of Berkshire pork..."

Jess Jow

"My family and I went for brunch to celebrate mine and my twins birthday. Our waiter Jaime was wonderful. The food runner was also very pleasant and..."

Rhiannon Denaro

"Consistently one of our favorite spots. Their seasonal menus never disappoint, and the small plates vibe is perfect for sharing (the portions are..."

Dylan Smith

"We LOVE Tullulah's. It's a comfortable spot for low key brunch and dinner. The brunch servings are hearty, the dinner servings are enough to..."

Brie Duarte

"Walking into the restaurant, you noticed that it needs a little TLC,but the staff was friendly and knowledgeable, the food was very good, I asked..."

Tony Aguirre

"first here and will definitely be back. Had the fried chicken sandwich and added vermont cheddar. Cocktails were great too. The atmosphere is..."

Lauren Barbella

Whalers

82/100 (2289 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"First off, the decor inside of this restaurant is absolutely stunning. Add that along with a great view of the bay and it's just simply amazing. Now..."

Frank Wu

"Great place food was amazing and the service was on point highly recommend this..."

Angelo J. Raucci

"Great time at Whalers. The band, Souls on Board, were Awesome as usual. The venue is great, with room to dance or just watch the band. The crowd and..."

John Lennon

"I have been there several times. The menu is great and the nautical atmosphere makes me look forward to summer!! Can’t wait for the outdoor patio..."

Suzie Q Oconnor

"The service was great and the food was delicious!! The view wasn’t bad either! I highly recommend!!!..."

Terry Wiegand Virga

"Was great , service and food was fantastic . Sea scallops were awesome . Highly..."

Robert Tamburello

"We had our engagement party at Whalers last Saturday and it was absolutely amazing! Nikki was so awesome to work with and helped us plan an amazing..."

Shauna DeFeo

"Great place and food smelled awesome... hoping band this past Saturday will be rescheduling... as I will be back for that and dinner next..."

Rich Ryan

"The food is delicious! We ordered the “Surf and Turf”, the coconut crusted cod and finally as a dessert, the bread pudding. The plates are well..."

Michele

"Came here for our 6 year anniversary for the first time. We did not make a reservation and wanted to sit outdoors. The hostess expressed they were..."

Vanessa Gonzalez

"Food is good as the view! From the appetizers to desserts, everything was wonderful. So many options on their menu & the lunch menu has a delicious..."

staci manning

"Where do I start… we planned a rehearsal dinner for my son and future daughter in law . Kelly made everything so easy . We had a fixed menu dinner..."

AnnMarie L

"Everything was excellent! We had a beautiful table overlooking the Great South Bay, we always make sure we get a seat upstairs when available. All..."

James Wood

"A good restaurant near the sea with a marvelous view and a pleasant atmosphere, and very tasty food, although a bit expensive..."

Meidos De Jesús

"Went there to check out the catering hall as a possibility for our wedding. The space upstairs is beautiful. We decided to eat at the restaurant to..."

Chris Almeida

"The place is definitely inviting and has a wonderful atmosphere. Cocktails were great, food even better. Jenifer the manager/owner came to our table..."

Tai Vicari

"We had a fantastic experience at Whalers. Everything we ordered was delicious and the staff was super friendly! I had the burrata salad and the tuna..."

Bridget Coolick

"If your in Bay Shore & looking to have dinner by the water. Stop in at Whalers. No better duo then Gianna greeting you with smiles at the door and..."

Alexander Rivera

"I've dined here many times, I often order the same entrée and it has never disappointed. We started with the baked clams 5/5, and the seafood..."

Cindy Romero

"Beautiful atmosphere inside and out with great views and amazing food. The potstickers and lobster roll are my favorites. Great drink menu too but..."

J Shea

"Gorgeous views and exceptional service from Joseph. The food was delicious and the drinks were out outstanding!! And also the complimentary valet..."

Brett “El Guerrero” Harte

"The best experience in Bay Shore. We always come to this restaurant for our anniversary and the food is always delicious, the staff is always nice..."

Jefferson Bien-Aime

"This was our first time out since COVID started and I have to admit their Korean Lettuce Wraps with Beef Bulgogi was to die for! My wife thoroughly..."

Trav Ramkissoon

"Came here last summer. This place is packed,but we made reservations ahead. Though we had to wait, we didn’t wait long enough. Plus they have a bar..."

Tiny

"Started with a Coconut Margarita 🍹 & dozen oysters. Main was Shrimp Pappardred Great Food, Great Place and Great..."

Laura Kenny

"We ended up here due to a terrible experience at The Lake House next door and what a blessing that was. Alissa the hostess was amazing as due to..."

Dawn Strain

Galanga Thai Style Cuisine

82/100 (1054 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Was a little nervous bc the place was empty but we were pleasantly surprised with our food! I had beef with mushrooms and spinach which was very..."

Bee Kay

"Visited this restaurant for the first time on 2/26/16 and if I can make it there weekly I sure will... had the mango chicken and the pineapple rice..."

Clarivet Isidore

"A hidden gem. I have loved every dish I've picked from here. I like that you can choose a range of spiciest from level 1-5, 5 being deadly hot. Big..."

Ryan

"Now its called T&O ...named after the new owners daughter s. Food was very good. Authentic Thai flavours. Drunken noodles , Thai red curry chicken..."

Pooja Gupta

"I like this restaurant a lot! I have been coming here for 2 years now and the staff and food have always been great. No complaints here. Just great..."

Mariah Smith

"Good for the price. It's not really Thai food in the tradition sense: I would say about 70% Thai, with the remainder something that could be called..."

ClockworkSoul

Toast Coffeehouse

82/100 (1414 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"I am obsessed with everything about Toast, can’t go wrong with any choice. And if this location replicates the other two it will be a huge success...."

Robyn Romanoff

"THE BEST Breakfast/Lunch place anywhere!!! We NEED you to..."

Janet M. Araneo-Maffucci

"Can't wait if it's like the patchogue or port Jeff locations it going to be a big hit..."

Matteo Maniaci

"I love the way how the inside looks in this place, gives 100% country vibes and the posters they have is very nice! My partner order a coffee latte..."

Kelv

"Just had a brunch here and it was amazing. The service was the best we had in a long time and Jessica R was just awesome. She made our experience so..."

Lani Olsen

"Fast service, friendly staff and the greatest atmosphere. Vegan menu offered. Ample parking outside. Toast has a lot of seating inside - two large..."

Audrey

"Great experience and our waitress was so friendly and polite. She went out of her way to accommodate us. And the food was delicious too. I highly..."

Christine K

"The search for the perfect coffee house has finally come to an end after visiting Toast! It’s the kind of place that makes me wish google had a 10..."

Nick Renna

"HUGE fan of Toast. Not only is the location visually stimulating; but I've never had a bad meal there! Crazy combinations that will tantalize your..."

William Kucmierowski (Brimstone)

"Amazing serving size and the menu is loaded with unbelievable options!!! I would go every weekend! Loved the pancakes, the toasts, their omelets, and..."

Amir Mullick

"The best brunch I've had in a while! The staff was super friendly, the atmosphere is beautiful, the food and drinks were to die for! Definitely try..."

Annie Pham

"Great experience at this restaurant! The server was friendly and it was good service all around. The food was good and flavorful. It was my first..."

Rose Mathieu

"The hostess wasn't very friendly when we walked in. She didn't smile and it felt like she didn't want to be there. That was the only part of the..."

DD

"We had the best time at toast! Our waitress Jasmine was so sweet and had the best recommendations. Try the Miss Lucy’s skillet, Huevos migas..."

Mackenzie Campbell

"Hard to put into words how amazing this place has become from the ambiance to the most fantastic staff I’ve chatted with in Bay Shore. *Our..."

Rodino Janowski

"First time here. This was an amazing cozy breakfast spot, right in bayshore. They had fresh squeezed OJ. I didn’t know what I was missing. This..."

TheRJWilliams

"Had a wonderful time at Toast for a work event. Staff was friendly and attentive. Food was absolutely amazing! There were about 8 of us and we were..."

M. Evans-Henry

"One of my favorite breakfast spots with my son. The option to join waitlist is so convenient, and saves time as it gets pretty busy on weekends...."

Tionna P

"I am so happy I showed up for 8:30am; by 9:30am it was packed. Fast service and delicious food. I love the circus themed decor and..."

Vashti Persad

"Simply amazing. The food, the drinks, the service, the coffee, the ambience, the decor, the vibe, everything is..."

Rob Rothman

"My new favorite breakfast spot! My sister and I ate here for the first time today. Food was delicious and plentiful - we couldn't finish. Staff was..."

Janice Klein

Mulberry Street Bay Shore

Amazing Mussels with Roasted Peppers Red Onion Garlic & Butter

Wheelchair Accessible

"Great food. We got baked ziti, and the pasta combo. Mozzarella sticks too. The bread with the oil and tiny pizza strips are a great start that..."

Tommy Christianson

"Place can easily seat parties of 4 or less. The pizza here is sublime. The flavor for the pizza is unmatched and their other dishes are superb as..."

WKUK B

"Nice and local is the only way these days, love to support the small guy! This place is one of the few places that still serves a meal at a great..."

David S

"The best pizza, garlic knots and chicken rolls. Their salads are also fantastic and they don't skimp on the toppings. The staff is very helpful..."

Megan Gardner

"MULBERRY STREET has the best pizza and Italian food in town, and I am not exaggerating, I kid you not. I believe it is in the sauce. But that's me. I..."

Jayne Marrs

"Stopped in for dinner and had a nice meal. I had lasagna with some red wine. Great combo and both tasted excellent. The staff were very friendly..."

Art “A2Jr” Angst

"Some of the best pizza in town! The staff is as friendly as the owner Mike! It is always an enjoyable experience wether I dine in or..."

john ceramello

"I work with an individual with Autism and we come here for take out once a week. The staff is incredibly patient, friendly, and kind to us. Their..."

Dylan Owens

"Ever craving good pizza? This is the place to come. Also, awesome dining room with a great menu of lots..."

Jonathan Friely

"The food was great and the service was excellent. Nice place to eat..."

Bruce Fogel

"I attended a baby shower here. The food and service was very..."

Karen Silvestri (Inspired By God's Beauty)

"I’m here on vacation, a young lady named Angela She was super nice & very beautiful also VERY polite. Gave us our pizza and salads an asked us if..."

Samantha Tedesco

"This place has some of the best food on Long Island. The portions are huge and worth every penny. My favorite is the grilled chicken with spinach..."

Avanti Fugetaboutit Montana

"I am a very particular person when it comes to pizza and this pizza was amazing. From the crust to the cheese to the sauce it was so full of flavor...."

Sharon Hendricks

Pico Tequila Grill

Wheelchair Accessible

"Tried this place for the first time with my girlfriend and it was absolutely amazing. Our server was great, extremely attentive and friendly. We will..."

Kenny Miller

"I have never been disappointed with anything on the menu. The burritos are my favorite on the island, the margaritas are delicious!! I recommend the..."

Dana Marie

"Creative menu, great staff. You should try Pico. The owners are great, friendly people. Oh & if you like tequila this is the place to..."

Eddie Knox

"This was my first tex-mex restaurant experience, and I loved it! Due to their great staff, the atmosphere was very warm and welcoming. Their..."

Ayesha Rahman

"Good food reasonably priced. Great happy hour. Friendly bartender. Makes a great..."

Jim Brady

"Hermoso ambiente, la comida excelente, me encanto los tacos de pescado muy deliciosos , las bebidas exquisitas especialmente las margaritas..."

Fabiola Bermeo

"Fresh ingredients, fun menu, great tap beer and margarita's. I really like the vibe at Pico. Pico's fills a void in the Bay Shore restaurant scene...."

Kyle Mulhern

"Great place for a drink or quick eats. Service is friendly. And the burrito bowl is awesome. Cat where have yoy..."

Celeste Stella

"Great cozy space. We were looking for a few apps and drinks. Luckily, happy hour is until closing on Saturday nights. $2 tacos and $1 off tap beer..."

Leah Stamatiades

"The staff is genuinely friendly. The guacamole and the buffalo chicken burrito were..."

Stephen Bellone

"Went here for taco Tuesday deal and the tacos were legit crazy good. Might make it a tradition to just go there Tuesdays when I'm hungry with the..."

WKUK B

"Spring rolls in and all of a sudden the urge to go out and take a walk in Bay Shore is so appealing...especially when on the way to lunch! I..."

Glenn

"Pork steak fish and southern chicken tacos, didn't care for the pork steak was burnt but the fish and chicken tacos were really good. So not bad. On..."

Samantha Kronenbitter

"Real good place, happy hour specials we're a good deal..tacos we're tasty.. wife liked the drinks.. we had the pork nachos and they were excellent....."

Richard Ruggiero

"Tacos ala cart. I ordered 4 only made it through 3. Tuna, bang bang shrimp, and pork were all excellent. I took a bite from the ground beef to taste..."

Joey D

"The pico burrito and the bang bang tacos do not disappoint. I’ve come here several times and I always get the same ones because they’re just so..."

Daniela R

"Services was very good. I enjoyed the food as well..."

I is Gamerz

"My first time there and I will be back. Staff is so friendly. Food was great and drinks..."

Natalie Gordon-Lomax

"Everything was great! Fried ice cream is a..."

PHILLIP HARVEY

"So many gluten free options, friendly staff, and very delicious food make this a new favorite spot for the husband and I. Check out how they plated..."

Melissa Posada

Blaze Pizza

Blood Orange Lemonade

Build Your Own Pizza with Pepperoni and Bacon

Juice

BBQ Sauce Chicken and Peppers

BBQ Chicken

Double Cheese and Double Pepperoni

Sausage Artichoke

Specialty Pizza with Olives Mushrooms Possibly Yellow Peppers

Pepperoni Bacon Cheese Jalapeños Garlic Sauce

Cauliflower Crust Pizza Vegetarian

Wheelchair Accessible

"Google couldn’t wait for me to review. Sent me request by the time I got home. I’ve been here once before after it first opened. Sorry it took me..."

Joe Vigna

"Excellent little pizza shop. The shop offers a multitude of selection in terms of what kind of pizza you want. They have several different cheeses,..."

Christian Acevedo

"I brought my girls because of a school fundraiser. They didn't disappoint. Even though they were swamped with both in-person and online orders, the..."

Kate Kearney

"Chipotle of pizza basically, build your own and they cook it on the spot. Pizza wasn't the highest quality but it was pretty cheap and they have a..."

Tom Dascole

"Hands down, this place has the BEST pizza! I love it when I'm able to customize my own pizza and this place has everything you can think of. The..."

Dawn Williams

"Busy location... So upset they closed the 1 in west Babylon!!! Please open it back up!!! Amazing..."

Michael greco

"It's exactly what you expect. Tons of toppings, a thin crispy crust and fast pizza. Got zero complaints. No surprises and the pizza is good just get..."

WKUK B

"Just ate a whole pie to myself because I Dared to Be Daring. It was BBQ chicken pepperoni, onions and banana peppers. Love the char to the crust just..."

FREDDYG_NY

"I visited this place yesterday and its great I love pizza 🍕 and they are really friendly. Yummy..."

Axel Xavier

"Wait was long but was worth the wait will just go not at dinner..."

Debra Domino

"Great service pizza was good love you can put whatever you want on the pizza and ingredients were of good..."

Joseph Lanzarotta

"First time and won't be my last. I'm very very picky about pizza since going to Vegas years ago and having pizza at 800 degrees (no longer at the sls..."

Shenae Campbell

"This place is amazing. Everything is fresh, the service was great and the price is..."

annette del monte

"Very good pizza. I thing I could eat this every day. The build your own is a great value. You can Put as much as you want on of any topping. There..."

Thomas McNamee

"The best pizza ever in the world I..."

ahmed m

Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

81/100 (2150 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Lunch

Dinner

Mid-range

"I enjoyed the lunch special of four tacos, plus soup, salad or a side. I had two barbacoa (brisket) tacos and two pulpo (grilled octopus) tacos, with..."

Rahadyan Timoteo Sastrowardoyo

"I love everything about this place, but especially the happy hour specials! The drinks are always incredible and the price is right! You can taste..."

Stacie Camirand

"WOW! Where do I start... I was Blown Away with the Fantastic service! I was setting up my bridal shower and the Tartaglia brothers couldn't have been..."

Nicole Marie

"Being a Bay Shore resident this is our all time favorite place to eat in town! We dine here at least once a month if not more. Food is amazing as..."

Mike Cardascia

"Every time I go to Verde's Kitchen & Cocktails I have a top of the line experience! The great service, great food, and awesome ambiance is unlike..."

Melissa Anne

"We had the original and pomegranate margaritas, they were amazing!!! The 3 salsas and chicken flautas, and the 4 taco lunch special. Ryan our server..."

Tammy Randazzo Sweeney

"The fish � so fresh, I've had fish tacos so many times before elsewhere, nothing compares to Verde… The ambience is quaint, the staff is..."

Laura Caputo

"Went for Cinco de Mayo (cliche, I know). Super glad we did. Food is phenomenal, cocktails are on point and the atmosphere is laid back. Try the..."

Peter Vaccaro Jr.

"Taco Tuesday is the best! Half price and $5 margaritas as well. They are fresh and delicious! Service is reliable and..."

Lou LaFleur

"I went to Verde with 4 friends for dinner, and we wanted to go for 1/2 half tacos on Tuesdays as well as happy hour! Normally you have to sit at a..."

Jane Gulla Angileri

"Delicious food and amazing margaritas. The staff is top..."

Debbie A Burack

"To start, the host was very accommodating, finding us a seat outside, the waitstaff happily guided us through Falls new menu options. The options..."

Heather Kristy

"Guacamole was amazing! Our waiter was great. Overall great experience. I had the steak and rice. The summer sangria was good too! Can't wait to go..."

Kim Kondak

"Went there for the first time yesterday for dinner and loved it! Friendly staff, excellent food and the margaritas were delicious. The atmosphere is..."

Debbie Genin Beberman

"Their happy hour is the best deal in town, by far. Great drinks, tacos, and quesadillas at great prices. Try the whole fish, I've had many whole fish..."

John Charvat

"Came here with my boyfriend for my birthday a few months ago and it was hands down the best experience ever. The server was amazing! The food and..."

Erika B

"We had the baby shower, The staff was great, and the waitresses were so inventive and caring to everyone. They took extra care to all my grandkids..."

Robert Schaefer

"The food is absolutely delicious.. but I have to rave about the staff! The entire staff was so helpful and pleasant all around. Justin took care of..."

Minela Mueller

"Had a beautiful date night here mid-October 2023. We ordered the Oaxacan Market for two (pictures), which was wonderful. Superb food, we couldn’t..."

Tim Walsh

"Had an amazing girls night, with the perfect ambience. Our server John was absolutely fabulous. We sampled a few different margaritas which were..."

Bonnie Neidecker

"I've been coming here for quite a few years and I must say that I have had nothing but the absolute best experience every single time!! Drinks and..."

Dr Wilfredo Morales

"I cannot stop talking about Verde. The drinks , appetizers , entrees and desserts are all heavenly. And they also have an excellent Happy Hour. The..."

Ariel Brunot

"Excellent customer service, every single employee was very attentive and courteous. I will have to highly recommend the Carne Asada. A marinated..."

jorge lam ki

"This restaurant has two areas, one bohemian type, the other patio type with gardens, the service is very friendly, the cooks are excellent… the..."

M&M

"Staff is very pleasant. . Restaurant Ambiance was perfect. Restroom not the cleanest. The Market on the menu => not worth the price. Charred..."

NG B.

"Went there for dinner we had shrimp tacos and brisket tacos, excellent. We also had the plantain and the rice and beans excellent. Angelica our..."

Joe Mosc

"Great atmosphere and good drinks. Food was very average but not bad. Not plain but could use more spices especially for Mexican food. FINAL VERDICT:..."

WKUK B

"My Taste Buds and I went to Verde a few weeks ago. We loved the atmosphere. We wanted a spot in the back, but it was being used. It was ok, though,..."

Taste Buds

"My go to spot. I get the Oaxaca steak with a side of chorizo. Absolute banger every single time. The subtle flavors in their rice and tortillas are..."

Alt

"I’ll start with the hostess, Taylor. She was absolutely the best! I mentioned to her that I had never been to the restaurant before and she decided..."

Melissa Lowe

"First time here, excellent service at the counter. Outdoor area looks nice. Brisket tacos were tender and juicy but sauce was loose and soaked the..."

Joey D

"Verde is consistently top notch! As a Realtor I often stop for food in the road during a long day of work, but often make it a point to come here...."

Dominique Dalia-Rudolph

Swept Away

Wheelchair Accessible

"Wanted to try something new and came upon this adorable place. DEE was our server and truly made the whole experience She was so sweet and truly..."

Rita Orlando Goodman

"Loved the food ! The prime rib was to die for! Cooked to order and the potatoes and spinach were great! The service was very professional and kept us..."

Patricia Holzmann McMillen

"We had a delicious meal with my husband and friends. Wait staff was very attentive, live music was wonderful! Just a fabulous..."

Christine Maben

"Great food and people in an unpretentious environment. Reasonable prices. Like chilling on the back patio in the summer. Been coming here for..."

Mike Ferrari

"This is such a classy place...the food,people,location and service is everything you would expect from a five star..."

Matt Slater

"Food is great, service fantastic and you’re not rushed through your..."

Alice Wylibaum

"My friends & I love this restaurant! Food is delicious! Waitresses are welcoming & attentive! Atmosphere is charming. Prices are very reasonable!!..."

Kathy Korba McCormick

"Great atmoshere. Love the menu. Looking foward to going back to try more dishes. Had thai chicken kale sliders. Great taste, Drinks were great, reaso..."

Karin Loomis Bongiorno

"Great place. Great service. Great food. Great live �. Opposite of the marina. Oh and great nautical..."

Lynn Ingenito

"The boys from Verde, Costa Grill and the new BWI do it again with this latest addition to Bay Shore’s ever growing array of restaurant choices...."

Marc Johnson

"Decided to try LaLa’s Lounge in Bay Shore with my fiancé and what a great place! Immediately greeted by one of the owners with a big smile and a..."

Jade_Star

"It is no longer Lala's lounge when we went recently, but I have been to both. The current restaurant had a small menu, and we ordered an appetizer,..."

Clare Sullivan

"My wife and I went there for lunch and had a great meal, the guacamole is very good, my wife Taco's and my Lala Smash Burger w/special French fries..."

Chuck Martin

"Great Restaurant and Bar. Food was delicious. Friendly attentive service. Good value. Great Happy hour..."

J V

"We have loved this property for many years The owner has a great menu, super servers Taylor and Cheyenne..only negative was the hip hop music that..."

Bob Coletti

"New restaurant by an established restaurateur family. Food is incredible! Fresh with some nice twists on classic dishes. Recommend the guac and..."

Kristina Markovitch

"Casual and delicious! Fair pricing, friendly service and a warm place on a rainy night for a family dinner at the holidays! The largest pork chop..."

Glenn

"Was looking for somewhere to grab a drink and a quick bite this place was great. The drinks were on point, I actually ended up staying way longer..."

Brian Batista

"I've been here when it was Swept Away and let me tell you, they've done a great job revamping the place. The vibe is great and so are the food and..."

Cecillia Barr

Kumo Sushi

80/100 (1365 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Food and drinks were outstanding, and Kevin was a warm and welcoming host! He made our group feel special. We can't wait to go..."

Joseph Salierno

"We used to frequent Kumo and were relatively pleased with our experience there. A friend told us that Kumo had closed down and was being renovated..."

Christopher Manuel

"I have passed this place several times and never bothered to try them out. Well we tried. We were pleasantly surprised and enjoyed the food so much...."

Cynthia Boston

"I've been here over 15 times and never once have I been disappointed. Never tried the hibachi, only sushi and their drinks. The sushi is VERY fresh..."

David Grant

"Lovely environment, courteous and polite staff as well.The food selection was outstanding with something for everyone, portions were perfect too and..."

Kevin Cruz Moreno

"Food was excellent, Amber was fantastic . This will be our new sushi..."

Frederick B.

"Food was tasty. Service was friendly and attentive. Prices are competitive to nearby restaurants. Would consider..."

Glittering Farmer

"Went here with friends last night. Everything was mostly delicious honestly. They all loved the sushi and I got the hibachi steak which was..."

Hailey Cooke

"I’ve been going to this place for at least 2 years now, it’s one of my favorite Japanese restaurants by far. Every time we get something to try..."

Giovanni Lovo

"Great environment ! So glad to find an amazing sushi place close by. We ordered the tuna tar tar appetizer , a few specialty rolls and sashimii with..."

Elaina

"Food took a little longer than usual to get to our table, but was worth the wait. Everything tasted delicious and was very fresh. The only thing that..."

Patricia Powers

"Kevin was our Itamae, he was absolutely wonderful, the food was delicious. We went for our daughter Ashlee's Birthday & he made it a lot of fun!!..."

Sherri Maas

The Cheesecake Factory

76/100 (2301 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Wherever I go cheesecake factory is always my go-to spot. I came about one and afternoon on a Wednesday which is awesome because it wasn't crowded...."

Dread InNY

"Second time hear but first time for breakfast Good food good service clean fse Great coffee Next tine i will sit by window its too dark for breakfast..."

Rosey Rodriguez

"Came here on my birthday and it was great food was amazing and the customer service was..."

Jacob Taylor

"Had a great time celebrating Mothers Day with Mother Roberta Turner. The restaurant is amazing our server wonderful and Orange Chicken was "lit" aka..."

Alvee Turner

"Not my first time at a Cheesecake Factory, but my first time here. I’ll just say, this is THE Cheesecake Factory, if you’re going to go to one...."

TheRJWilliams

"Akram was a fantastic waiter. He was attentive, sweet and knowledgeable about the offerings. My family was well taken care of and we will be..."

Jessica Hardial

"*Bayshore location Large food portions for your buck! Always good drinks never watered down. Love that my Gingerale came in a bottle along with a..."

Tiffany White

"First time time coming knowing of the big menu I expected a mediocre experience but ended out with a great one! Ordered the truffle honey chicken and..."

- Goldband-

"Ordered takeout. Perfectly packaged. The food at any Cheesecake Factory is always on point. Ordered my favorite staples. Americana burger and Buffalo..."

Foodie Chopin

"Came in from Philly PA for Mothers Day and took mom's to Cheesecake Factory in Bayshore Long Island NY. She had the time of her life! The restaurant..."

alvee turner

"Made a reservation and when I got there I had made it for the wrong location. We were eating dinner before seeing a play so I didn’t have time to..."

Erin Scileppi

"Food was delicious, and came out fast. Vast selection process different types of dishes. The seats were comfortable. Adequate for toddlers. Our..."

Abideen Mohamed

"Oh! my goodness. The Classic Basque Cheesecake is my favorite cheesecake ever. The burnt top was a perfect contrast to the creamy center, and the..."

Gail Melisa

"Fantastic waiter ! THANK YOU KYLE! Food was delicious. Manager Christopher came by to make sure we were having the best time. Highly recommend this..."

Lisa Skett

"We were a party of four. Very impressed with the food, and our waiter Joel couldn’t have been more attentive than he was …. You can tell when..."

William Powers

Captain Bill's

76/100 (3286 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Views and good food. This place has a great location and it really nice to take visitors to. We enjoyed several fish dishes here and will definitely..."

Loving Long Island

"Wonderful. Captain Bill's is a gorgeous restaurant with handsome decor and a wonderful view of the waterfront. Their seafood is excellent, their..."

CharlesM

"Very up class yet down to earth place food was very..."

JimEJames

"The appetizers tasted great. The spinach dip almost had a buttery consistency which went well with the..."

Long Island Restaurant Review

"Visited a Sunday afternoon and restaurant was not too busy. Restaurant is by the water and would be great to sit outside on a summer day however its..."

Kay S

"Captain Bills made our dream night come true. We had our wedding reception at the Bayview House on 8/18/2023. The venue is beautiful and is located..."

JD Sheets

"Love crab cake here,big chunk of the crab meat, oyster rocketfeller, I think too much cheese thrn I didn't taste the oyster.... Ordered Magarita ,..."

fone Anan

"Overlooking the water, it is a beautiful restaurant and has many great seafood dishes. This is where we were supposed to have our wedding reception,..."

Frank Lynch

"My wife and I had lunch at Captain Bill's- we used to visit here when we were dating, but hadn't been here in probably 30 years. We've been trying to..."

Terry Parrett

"Nice resturant, calamari was very good. The clam chowder also great. Nice views of the marina. Blacked grouper was great too. Didn't have anything..."

Vibes & Good Times

"We got married at the Bayview House on 10/8/23, and it was an absolutely beautiful event! Annie, our Maitre'D, made sure that the entire evening ran..."

Nicole Perlman

"Wow just wow. From the view, to the staff, to the delicious sea food dishes, to the drinks (that made me do a double take look into my glass from the..."

Russell

"A favorite dining experience for me! The food is AMAZING! Nice size portions. The special for Octoberfest was $37-$38 pp You received soup or salad,..."

A Gordon

"Outstanding drinks, food and service! Loved the Espresso Martini, Oysters, Stuffed Salmon, Lobster Bisque and Linguini with Shrimp &..."

Jessica PrestigeRecruits

Fatfish On The Water

74/100 (1924 ratings)

Lemon & Thyme Roasted Chicken Wings

Crepes

Beef Carpaccio

Salad

Oysters Rockefeller 2

Fish

Vanilla Bean Creme Brulee

Alaskan King Crab Legs

Shrimp & Scallop Fettuccini

Shrimp

East Coast and West Coast Oysters

Fish & Chips

Vanilla Toasted Almond Crepe

Lobster Roll

Fish & chips

Whole Fish for 2 – Daily Special

Wheelchair Accessible

"Excellent place, great menu...so different and fresh and plentiful..my family and are making this our get together spot. Great service, cocktails not..."

Michelle Labriola-Parolari

"Was there for the first night of the 2017 season. The weather was awful, but the food delicious . I especially enjoyed the steak skewers and the..."

Kathy Lynch

"Amazing food, friendly and helpful staff, gorgeous view and a casually elegant vibe. For a special occasion or just to celebrate a relaxing summer..."

B.A. Fagerland

"Beautiful location, good band with excellent food and service. Will go back and highly..."

Val VG

"The atmosphere of being on the water is fun!! The food was great and the service even better! My daughter didn't like her dinner so they immediately..."

Maria Ribaudo Caturano

"Went for lunch with my mom. Had great wine (recommended by our waitress), great view, relaxed atmosphere. We loved..."

Linda M. Papagna-Ackley

"Nice little waterfront restaurant. Food was so good , I was not a fan of the style of the salmon but the texture was top quality. The dessert was..."

Thomas

"I meet friends here every summer and we're never disappointed. Every dish and drink is beautifully presented and delicious- good portion sizes,..."

Kirsten Ostrofsky

"My fifth or six visit here and never disappointed. Service is always great as well as the bay views. Wines by the glass offer excellent choices. ..."

J RL

"My husband and I went with another couple and had a bunch of delicious appetizers! We had not been here in years and I am not sure why because the..."

Dana Varricchio - Long Island, NY

"Restaurant has a lot of potential. Great location and atmosphere. Food is average, but reasonable..."

Kyle Schlesinger

"Beautiful spot on the water with a lovely team that runs the show. We came on a Sunday and sat on the covered patio. The food was tasty, but the fish..."

Maria

"This is a lovely setting with great views of the bay and the passing boats. The food was delicious 😋 and the service was fantastic. Our server,..."

Dave Leach

"This place is really not for everyone, considering how expensive it was. Food was good, the service was super attentive and quick, and you can’t..."

William Hum

"The food portion was not much generous for the price and it didn't impressively taste good for..."

RL LEE

"What a fabulous night with the family. Beautiful setting. Dinner was pricey but worth it. I had the swordfish. Also had a beet and goat cheese salad,..."

Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino

Panera Bread

Wheelchair Accessible

"Been here ever since it opened and it's just an overall great Panera especially since you think the service would be packed at the mall but it's not...."

WKUK B

"Great place for a quick grab. Not..."

ricki tavor

"I would like to see them clean the tables. I know it's not a fancy restaurant but it could be kept cleaner. I love the soup. I'll just take it..."

Simmons having fun

"Just love coming here with my son always great..."

M B

"We dined in and our food was warm and delicious. The staff were very friendly despite the lunch rush. Our food was prepared in a timely manner so..."

Reyna Granados

"It is ok. Convenient because it is inside a..."

Ludmila Liriano

"Love to come here to meet friends, to study and to have a good..."

Phil Foo

"The Chai tea here is always spicy and delicious..the soups ( tomato, butternut squash and broccoli cheddar) are great as well..."

Dav RoZ

"I just joined the sip club here, I enjoy being able to get a coffee in the morning, refresher for the afternoon, and a tea b4 I go to bed. I think..."

Tracy Moore

"Food is good . Service friendly. Just one note .looks like they need to clean vents in ceiling. Looking pretty neglected . Perhaps needs..."

Robert Miccio

"Food is good but unfortunately I didn’t see anyone cleaning tables after customers left specially now that we are all more conscious about cleaning..."

J H

"Panera is an excellent place for a quick bite. The soups, salads, sandwiches and baked goods are all prepared well and of high quality. Service is..."

Roy Seher

"I have been in many Panera locations in NY state and loved every one! The counter help is professional and friendly. The restaurants are all very..."

Angela Cooke

Nicky's On The Bay

70/100 (2469 ratings)

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

Nicky's Fried Calamari

Lobster Roll Sweet Potato Fries and Cole Slaw

Fish

Clams

Free Range Chicken Paillard

Mojito

Oyster

Linguine & White Clam Sauce Coming Soon

8 Ounces Burger and Fries

Wheelchair Accessible

"Had a great day here ! Southbound played here upstairs on the roof ! What a beautiful view ! The crowd there was awesome both line Dancers & people..."

Elizabeth Byrne

"Breathtaking view, great music and great food. Loved it and can't wait to go back. I wish there was a more extensive menu for rooftop..."

John Lennon

"If your going here for a gourmet meal, turn around, if your gonna bitch about the prices, stay home. This is where you go to enjoy the best thing..."

Charles D'Angelo

"First, the view and atmosphere are perfect. The server I had was excellent and the shrimp scampi was as good as I've ever had. I will definitely come..."

Mark Mariano

"Great place and the food was delicious! Our waiter was outstanding and so friendly! I believe his name wad CJ-sorry if I got the name wrong. We were..."

Rosemarie Mccarthy

"We love Nicky's on the Bay! Great atmosphere, good food and the owner Nicky always makes time to say hello & introduce himself to any new people we..."

Dana Persico

"Excellent food and view! Good variety on the menu. Friendly..."

Felicia Rybak Adorno

"This was my first time here and everything about this place was amazing! We sat outside and watched all the ferries go by while sipping a delicious..."

Michele Stokes

"The food is still amazing and spectacular service and a nice view of the ferries and boats! This time around I was able to have a perfect view of..."

Shenera Boodie

"omg ！this is best seafood restaurant I ever been to!oyster is so fresh! Personally I hate oysters! But I had half dozen! That’s how fresh..."

wayne weng

"This new food they have is light years ahead of the old menu. We had the burger, lobster roll, chop chop salad, and salmon with a few apps. Thanks to..."

kenny powers

"Nice place on the water to watch the boats come and go. Baked clams and calamari were very good. I had fish and chips, which were good. My husband..."

Deborah Carleton-Tierney

"First I would like to give a shout out to Sherry our waitress for the outstanding service and the small talk we shared. Everything was beyond..."

Brett “El Guerrero” Harte

"Fantastic food. From the first to the last bite it was absolutely delicious. I had the special which was the salmon w summer pasta. I loved it. The..."

Jessica Seegolam

"We loved it. The fried clams are their specialty and the portion was huge. Great prices too. Everything was covid safe and the service was on point...."

Annie Pisapia

"Nestled beautifully along the water's edge, Nicky's On the Bay is a beacon for those seeking an exceptional dining experience combined with..."

Const Const

"Definitely coming back to Nicky's for Fried Calamari (tasted fresh and was crispy), Steamed Mussels (delicious!), and crab cakes! I ordered the..."

J K

"Very nice place next to the water.I had to wait a bit on the waiting list.But the wait was worth it.The food was very tasty.A bit pricey though.But..."

Tatiana Panova

"Very romantic, food was extremely fresh, homemade dipping sauces extremely fresh great quality, professional and persistent staff. Beautiful scenery,..."

Davina Wynn

"Great location on the water, food was delicious and service was very attentive. They had long island Vinyard wine, which was a nice surprise. Perfect..."

Reset

There are 24 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Vegetarian Friendly: The best in Bay Shore

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Kathleen Green

Laura Caputo

Philip Weisbroat

Catherine Demenus

Maggie Martinez

Michele Nolan

B.A. Fagerland

Vanoy Harris

Jihane Thervil

Regina Benoit

Lorraine Maloney Curry

Anthony Cerabino

Jennifer Kelly Bellone

Christina Chionchio

Jaclyn Neary

Suzie Dunn

JV Young

Johan Chabrel

Samantha Vongerichten

Bee Marshall

Albert Miller

Renata Kutsyk

Randy Solomon

Danielle Adames

James Collier

Nicolette Garofalo

Blanca

puravi patel

Brittany Pietrafesa

Marina Melillo

Jj Prete

Grace Tribble

Rick White

Robert RKNY26 (PresRKNY)

Annie Pham

Dave Nespoli

Ann Marie Barrett

Danielle Montesino

Gail Melisa

Amaya Whitfield

peggy inserra

William

Natalia Giancola

Ashley Perez

Tom Olenick

Eric Lee

sandra valdebenito

Gary Moore

Jessica PrestigeRecruits

Alicia Escalante Polizotto

Michael Tillman

Ron Santram

Zab Ros

Clarisse Laigo

Todd Patrick

grace accardi

Kimiko

Tom Eng

Steve C

Steven Toomey

Shanette Catapano

Jey Z

Charles Mooney

Gerardo Avelar

Tammy Blaszkiewicz

andrew petti

August D'Alessandro

Winny