Sluurpy
Reset

There are 39 restaurants

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in St. Augustine

There are 39 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Carmelo's Marketplace
90/100 (864 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Cheese and Pepperoni Slices
Pasta
Supreme Pizza by the Slice
Salad
Wings
Kids Spaghetti & Marinara
Meat Pizza
Peppers
Fried Mushrooms
Meatball Sub
Italian Sandwich
Tiramisu
Veggie Supreme Pizza
Cheesesteak
Veggie Pizza
Meatballs
Garlic Knots
Lasagne
Fried Zucchini Sticks
New York Style Pizza
Sandwiches
Calamari
Pesto
Spinach Pepperoni Calzone
Wine
White Pizza Slice
Greek salad
Ham and Bacon Pizza
Stromboli
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"We go to Carmelo's often, mostly for the pizza. We live in Palm Coast and have tried pizza from about 10 places in town and none can measure up to..."
June Allen
"I had the Carmelo's stuffed pizza, it was very flavorful. While I was in line for my take out order all 3 people ahead of me said it was the best ..."
Tammy Cruikshank
"Delicious pizza! Don't let the connection to the gas station fool you- this place is a fun atmosphere with great..."
Sara Boden Pickering
"Second time in 3 years we have eaten here! Great food with generous portions. And the pizza is served on a raised silver tray giving it the..."
Rhea Allard Kennelly
"Always a great place to eat! Great food & friendly..."
Carol Kline
"The pizza is incredible and the buffalo wings are the absolute best wings I've ever had! I always come here whenever I visit St...."
Violet Olsen
Pizzalley's
89/100 (3010 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Hawaiian Pizza
Pesto
Eggplant
Antipasto Salad
Calzone
Pasta
Salad
Slice of Pizza
Beer
Crab
Cheese Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Calamari
Veggie Pizza
cheese pizza
Calamares
Meat Lovers
Great Pizza
Cannoli
CrĆØme BrĆ»lĆ©e
Calamari
Bruschetta
Manicotti
Garbage Can Pizza Slice
Alfredo
Shrimp
Bloody Mary
Meatballs
Pizza de Burrata
Lasagne
Peppers
Bruschette
Lobster
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Dog Friendly
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Accepts American Express
Table Service
Live Music
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We arrived in time for Happy hour. Two for 1 drinks and a slice of delicious pizza. Then ordered dinner. Decided to order the vodka pasta to share..."
Debi Shannon
"Fabulous New Yearā€™s eve dinner. Anybody in Saint Augustine I highly recommend this place you get a lot of food at a great value fabulous atmosphere..."
Michael Vaughn
"Had the Lobster ravioli in roasted red pepper sauce. Was excellent! I have had their pizza which I highly recommend! Great service, great food! ..."
Kelly Gracey
"Great food and fast and courteous service The pizza crust was good. Iā€™d recommend the ā€œgarbage canā€..."
Alan Enquist
"6 of us were there on Monday celebrating a birthday and had a good time. The happy hour is the best! And of course šŸ•pizza is excellent. Great..."
Zarka Wynn
"The food was fantastic! We had some breadsticks that were the best breadsticks I have ever eaten. Pizza was so fresh and cooked perfect. Everything..."
Tina Marie Crawford
"We used to walk by & get a taste of their pizza outside on the tray. We always brought Our friends over too. Then we finally started going inside for..."
Gayle Brown
"The best pizza and I request cesar salad the best salad I haved in my..."
Angel Filion
"We tried the extra cheesey, extra crispy sample and we had to go inside for a couple of slices. Honestly some of the best pizza we have ever..."
Steve Gent
"Absolutely awesome! Ordered way too much food but the pizza made me think I was back in NewYork. Bread sticks to die for, dont miss a chance to eat..."
Judy Roberts
"Never disappointed! The Pizza is the best and freshest in town and the beer is ice cold! Go visit. It is a..."
Margo A Bennett
"The pizza was amazing the staff was awesome A real nice place to eat .We try to stop in every time we are in..."
Mike Kohler
"This place is awesome you got to try it if you're in St Augustine great crust on the pizzas great cocktails just an all-around great atmosphere we..."
Willie Shamas
"We celebrated my mothers birthday here and it was awesome. Our server Mary was a sweetheart and the food, amazing! My family absolutely agrees that..."
Erik Aponte
"We have eaten pizza all over the south, and this is still our favorite! Each slice can be personalized- family winner when it comes to our family of..."
Jennifer Parkman Tadlock
"Without question the best pizza in town, including Jacksonville. Ā I would recommend the Chicken Caccetore pizza or the Foccacia or the Meat..."
Chris Namelast
"While shopping with our kids we decided to stop in. The service there was awesome! Our pizza was hot & fresh. We all 5 agreed it was the best pizza..."
Norma
"Best pizza ever! I'm a pizza aholic and this place..."
Jessica
"Excellent Pizza. The made-to-order pizza was delicious. The crust was sheer perfection. The charming young lady who made our pizza clearly enjoyed..."
Scott
"My husband and daughter loved it. It was just okay to me but it is only because not enough sauce on pizza. I love a lot of sauce. I still ate all 3..."
Crystal
"Best pizza in the SouthEast, sorry Vito &..."
Christopher Abbey
"Good find. Service was fabulous. Wings were perfectly cooked. Pizza had really nice crispy bottom, soft on..."
Brenda
"Yummmm Yummmm. When sauntering down St George Street, I'm often beckoned to try a sample from an employee with the duty or hawking their fare....and..."
Lisa Averill
"So yummy. We were walking down St. George Street when a woman asked if we wanted a taste of the pizza. I had read some of the reviews already and..."
Amanda C.
"Great atmosphere for kids. Excellent..."
Leslie
"Great pizza place. We will be coming back..."
Vicki
"My Favorite Pizza. My family rotates our vacation destinations through several of our favorite coastal selections, but when we visit Florida I make..."
Fixed IT
"We go here every time we are in town. Great pizza, sauce is very tasty and crust is very good. Recommend this place to all. We had two in our party..."
Sunil
"Service is good. Pizza is fair but the calamari with Pomodoro is perfection! The absolute best Pomodoro sauce I've ever had. They say "carrots" are..."
Debbie Rommeney Lowe
"Tasty!. Large portions, fresh ingredients, nice outdoor seating. Service can be hit or miss but for the most part they run a tight ship even when..."
Hollie Ann Mahadeo
"Pretty good pizza. The pasta is also good. I like their interior with its wooden booths. Quite honestly, I eat at Pizza Time now that there in town...."
Knh
"So good!. Whats not to like about this place?! I have gone may times and ordered many a pizza and have never been disappointed. We often eat on the..."
Devon
"Best Pizza Around......... Great pizza, friendly people, good atmosphere. Yes, you have to order at the counter but it only takes a few minutes...."
Lg50
"My Favorite Pizza Place in FL. There's never been a time where I walked away from this place less than thrilled about my experience. Love and miss..."
Milosa B
"Was wanting some Italian food and my buddy tells me about this place. He says he hasnā€™t been here in a few years so we both decided to see if it..."
Joshua C
"My husband and I LOVED the pizza from Pizzalley's!! We got the 10' to share, but definitely wish we got the 17' to bring leftovers home.. so well..."
MaryHelen Bostwick
"This place is amazing. The food is the best in Saint Augustine and weā€™ve never been let down. But, what makes us keep coming back is the service...."
Bryan Jones
"This place is amazing! Super friendly hostess, comfy booth and great atmosphere. Our server (Karen) was the best! She never let our drinks go empty;..."
Jenny Finley
"What lovely place for lunch with the family. Lovely atmosphere and staff. We sat outside and service was quick. We got the ā€œGarbage Dumpā€..."
Gator Doc
"Amazing!! Ooh the burrata and pizza della nonna.. yum! Remember they only accept cash or you'll be stuck using their..."
E Hopkins
Al's Pizza
88/100 (1149 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Wings
Calamari
Calamares
Alfredo
Meatballs
BLT
Lasagne
Sandwiches
"Amazing place! The food was so good and the staff was so nice. Love the views from the windows and the historical pics on the wall. I highly..."
Karen Lancaster
"Great experience on a crowded day. Superb customer service, food was excellent and delivery of food was timed on point. Highly recommend to anyone..."
Jean Marie Cooper
"Best food and service we hadin the 4 days here in St. Augustine! Topnotch! Oh and great prices..with an awesome menu..."
Perry Dan
"Excellent crust, remarkable actually. Great service tonight too! Need to open one in..."
Joe Hitterman
"Came here 5 years ago while visiting, came back today and this place is just..."
Matt Slaga
"We had a large group in the middle of a festival and all around busy day. They were so accommodating and had great service. Thank you Josh and..."
Shannon Parcel Casebeer
"Pizza was excellent!!! Service was good!! We will definitely come..."
Denia Clay Barrier
"Pizza was great, prices very cheap and great friendly..."
Nicki Vargas
"We came in 1 minute before closing. They showed us a great time. Thanks Al and your crew. Rarely order desert we had cheesecake and canolies with a..."
michael yarmy
"Great pizza, try the pizza by the slice and add whatever toppings you want. It's beautiful inside, but you should sit on the balcony upstairs. It..."
Dana Hill
"The best tasting pizza I have ever had! The slice was bursting with fresh veggies and toppings. Even the base tasted good. This is one healthy slice..."
Bobby Nitty
"We had a great experience with the staff and food. Even being it was crazy due to the increased tourist traffic for the holidays our salads came out..."
Josslyn Barns
"Absolutely amazing pizza! Al's Atlantic Beach Pie was to die for! (I think that was the name- the Philly pizza) The view from the deck was..."
Ashley Lamb
"We were very surprised how much we actually enjoyed the food! We had calzone - chicken and vegetable.. DELICIOUS! And that's not all - we decided to..."
Pola Elmir
"Love the place, the food was great and the waitress was very attentive. For the price it was a lot of food, better of what I was expecting. My new..."
francine boglio
Carmelo's Pizzeria
87/100 (2715 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Kids Spaghetti & Marinara
Meat Pizza
Wine
Greek salad
Peppers
Stromboli
Fried Mushrooms
Meatball Sub
Italian Sandwich
Veggie Supreme Pizza
Veggie Pizza
Garlic Knots
Fried Zucchini Sticks
Calamari
Spinach Pepperoni Calzone
White Pizza Slice
Ham and Bacon Pizza
Salad
Cheese and Pepperoni Slices
Wings
Supreme Pizza by the Slice
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"We go to Carmelo's often, mostly for the pizza. We live in Palm Coast and have tried pizza from about 10 places in town and none can measure up to..."
June Allen
"I had the Carmelo's stuffed pizza, it was very flavorful. While I was in line for my take out order all 3 people ahead of me said it was the best ..."
Tammy Cruikshank
"Delicious pizza! Don't let the connection to the gas station fool you- this place is a fun atmosphere with great..."
Sara Boden Pickering
"Second time in 3 years we have eaten here! Great food with generous portions. And the pizza is served on a raised silver tray giving it the..."
Rhea Allard Kennelly
"Always a great place to eat! Great food & friendly..."
Carol Kline
"The pizza is incredible and the buffalo wings are the absolute best wings I've ever had! I always come here whenever I visit St...."
Violet Olsen
"I love this place!!!! The place is nice, the service really good, took a little bit of time to get the food because we went in a busy hour, but the..."
Luis Enrique GQM
"Ok my wife is a self proclaimed Stromboli expert and she seriously keeps talking about Carmelo's version. It's her #1 or really close. The Margherita..."
Sean Donovan
"Fantastic food and family-friendly atmosphere! Highly recommend!!! We stumbled upon it after our chocolate factory tour with two VERY grumpy, hungry..."
Karen Pannell
"Awesome pizza with cauliflower crust. Keto and Adkins friendly!! The place was packed. Highly..."
Dr. Norbert W. Benson II
"If you are in St Augustine FIND THIS PLACE! It is one of our must haves when we visit. Located attached to a gas station on a corner it is a hidden..."
Zina
"Sort of a gas station, convience store, take out with a dine in restaurant on the side. The menu offers many different options which include pizzas,..."
john gotowala
"Friendly staff, prompt service, great food, and large portion sizes. Food was brought out immediately instead of all together (only a minute or two..."
Melissa Hahn
Romano's On The Beach
86/100 (993 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Meatballs
Lasagne
Cannoli
Prosciutto
Pesto
Sandwiches
Antipasti
Eggplant
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Delivery
Takeout
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"This place is a must on our yearly visit to St. Augustine. We have yet to have a bad meal here. Amazing food, friendly service and the biggest (and..."
Christy Cannon Boyle
"Stopped in for dinner tonight and was greeted with smiling faces and a hello! The food, especially the garlic knots, pizza and desserts are top..."
Lauren Bonar
"This was literally the best pizza I have ever had! Order the Grandma! They were super busy and made room to fit our party of 6. The waitress was..."
Justin Caldwell
"Our favorite beach pizza joint! Go for lunch, and for a few dollars you can have pizza, a salad and a drink. The pizza is always hot and..."
Eva McClelland Medved
"Great tasting pizza, nice crispy crust. Lots of toppings to choose from. We had a White Pizza and a Meat Lovers. Both were awesome! And best of all..."
Louis Konowal
"Traveled to this establishment with about 14 friends on a Saturday afternoon and were we ever impressed. Although it is a small restaurant they..."
James Tarleton
"LOVE Romanos On The Beach pizza. For an occasional treat I go in and have a slice and sometimes a side salad. Special place for me. Lovely staff...."
Janylee Elsa McGlinchy
"Delicious pizza and their Mediterranean salad is the best!! Very friendly staff too- definitely..."
Jenny Weinberg
"Simply the best! Romano's is fresh and authentic food, family friendly atmosphere, and world famous pizza... how could you go wrong?! #unmatched..."
Davey Hartzel
"Fantastic pizza and wings! We carried out in order to relax with some pizza on the beach! The Spicy Island Baja was incredible (as long as youā€™re..."
Savanah Seevers
"Their pizza is amazing, the pasta and meatballs are unreal, but the eggplant parmesan sub is the best I've EVER had...EVER!!!!! Great staff, good..."
Krista N. Smith
"I just posted something on my Facebook page about how years ago they used a picture I had taken of a pizza I got one night and put it as their main..."
Chase Burnett
"This was the best pizza i have ever ate. We will definitely be..."
Felicia Spires
"This is our favorite casual dining place. Great food and..."
Su Amodeo
"This place is awesome! Loved everything about it! Waitress is great and the food is..."
Janet Mckinnerney Clearo
"We just picked up a pie after a long day in the beach. It's excellent. Cooked perfect. Perfect amount of sauce and cheese...."
Jenn Downey
"Garlic knots were the best. Pizza was great as well. Really wish they would bring it to..."
Justin King
"Friendly and accommodating staff. My wife and I came in unknowingly around closing time, we were able to sit and eat our meal. Our dinner was..."
Derrick
"Good family italian food, but a little pricey. Could use a little more garlic and..."
Dr Woody
"The best Pizza in St Augustine. Samantha and Anna always. Makes my visits the best. Paul Kevin and Kevin. Make the best pizza..."
Mike Elkin
"Meat Lovers Was Best Pizza Ever Had. Pizza was so good I slept with the..."
Jay Feemish
"We are moving to the beach and gave this a try. So glad we did! Best pizza since leaving New England. The subs won't disappoint, so much meat unlike..."
Djpessina
"The staff are all very friendly and attentive, the food is delicious. I've had several different things at Romano's on the island (chicken parm sub,..."
Ashlee R
"Horrible experience !!! Food took 1 hr and 25 minutes to be delivered 4 miles - Girl answering phones VERY rude actually hung up on me - Forgot..."
Rae1981
"Closest to NY Sicilian pizza! Excellent crust with that crunchy bottom and that sauce was outstanding! If you're ever in the area go by and have Anna..."
Natalie
"Went the other night with a group of friends and everyone enjoyed the food, atmosphere and service! We have been coming here for years The new owners..."
Sylvia Jones
"Great pizza, lots of options. We ere on vacation and decided on takeout for a break from seafood. It was really great! The pic is..."
Ajax
"Amazingly delicious food from the pizza to the pasta. Locally owned gives it warmth as the staff is nice and friendly. Outshines any other Italian..."
Rachel
"Great Food. My husband and I stopped in on during our road trip. We LOVED the pizza. The staff are friendly and helpful. We'll be back again..."
Linda
"The food was absolutely wonderful I had spaghetti ala vodka. The service was perfect very warm and friendly place that makes u feel like..."
SharonLynn Valentino
"Great Pizza finally. This restaurant is hidden in the plaza corner,we dropped in on the off chance as we were advised to try this place whilst..."
Gazza
"The BEEESSSSTTTT!!. I love this place. I have never had a better sandwich in my life!!! I always get the chicken Parm it is insane. The only problem..."
Audrey Rose Kemp
"Romanos pizza. Went to have dinner at Romanos on UA1 and their pizza is the best pizza by far in St. Augustine, fresh and so delicious. Service was..."
Yessy Salgado
"If you like sicilian pizza, this the place for it in St. Augustine. The pizza is always fresh and hot when it arrives at your door, and imediatly one..."
Max
"Romano's Deli & Pizza. Best Pizza in St. Augustine try MiMi's eggplant parmegania to die for. Fresh mad mazz cheese make the deal. Deli subs are so..."
Harry L Nolan III
"Great pizza and now beer!. My husband and I decided to eat here after hearing that they had good pizza. Tucked into the corner of a shopping center..."
Dc_tx_fl
"What took so long.. We order from there at least once a week. Finally I great Northeast style pizza. The hogies are true REAL hogies, where the bread..."
Tim Kelly
"Awesome!. Coming from up North, this is a little piece of home. Great pizza and you HAVE to try their..."
Jerseygal733
"Best Pizza. It's the best pizza in St...."
Furino1
"Try this place. Great Pizza - best on the island, coming from Philly this place is the real deal. Try their pasta or huge 22" sandwiches. You won't..."
Jimmy B.
"Great Food. I have never had a bad meal at this place,I have been eating at Romano's since they opened about a year and a half ago. Family owned and..."
Ozenda
Pizza Time Of St Augustine
84/100 (3331 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Fast food
Pizza
Fast Food
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Eggplant
Salad
Lasagne
Cannoli
Ice Cream
Gelato
New York Style Pizza
Sit down
Italian
Fast food
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Seating
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Pushy staff and cash only but very good pizza. Very crowded but I guess that's what you get when your voted 2nd best pizza in the USA. Love the..."
Abigail Renee' Davis
"Best pizza in the south east!! The line is typically out the door during lunch time but do not panic it moves fast and is worth the wait. The..."
Ximena Barnes
"Pedimos 4 trozos diferentes de pizzas y todas estaban deliciosas. Tienen una masa fina y crujiente, y suficientes ingredientes que no decepcionan. La..."
Francisca Orellana
"The pizza's are great here. They have so many different types of gourmet pizzas - Eggplant pizza, Hawaiian, Lasagna pizza, Chicken and Spinach, Pizza..."
Alayna Shergill
"This pizza place is good not excellent.WHATCH OUT THEY ONLY ACCEPT C A S Hand if u dont have cash, dont worry, the also will..."
Elle
"The pizza was really tasty. The have the really nice red pepper blend that added heat and flavor to any slice it was added to. I'd definitely go..."
Nicoli Delchimsky
"Amazing pizza!! Our family of 4 ate really well on $30!! We will definitely be coming back. Only thing to know ahead of time is that's it's CASH ONLY..."
Holly Ford
"I was visiting St. Augustine and stopped for dinner at Pizza Time on St. George Street. St. Augustine's Christmas parade apparently happened earlier..."
Watch Me Eat
"So, if someone would have told me I would make this statement, I would deny it to the very end, but I am here to put it in writing today. ƂĀ I..."
Anna Heise
"These guys have a trip advisor review stating that they have the second best pizza in America and after trying the "grandmas" and the pepperoni I'd..."
Dan Meadows
"I'm not a pizza fan, but boy oh boy has pizza time converted me! Amazing is all I can say. Has all the Brooklyn flavor and then some. Thank you for a..."
LeLe D
"Night = made!. When we got there around 9:30, there was only a few selections of pizza left. I'll preface this by saying that I eat like a 3 year..."
Sam H.
"5 stars. Pizza Time not only has the best pizza in town, it has the best restaurant owner I've met in my 72 years. He was very graceful to my family..."
Robert Bob Smith
"Grandmas style pizza was so amazing. As weere the garlic..."
Zachary McDonald
"Love this place! Huge slices of delectable, flavorful pizza. Margherita pizza was awesome! Great place though not a lot of seating inside. But the..."
Visitor
"Beyond amazing, probably the best pizza I've ever..."
Mikaila Hall
"Never ate a new york style pizza before, and is 10 time better than all pizza..."
Lisa Negron
"Great pizza always. Love the garlic rolls. Yes you have to pay with cash and there is a ATM on the premises. Don't be discouraged by the line to get..."
Krystal
"Pizza time is phenomenal!! The owner, Domenic, is very personable and makes the experience memorable! There are other pizza options in St Augustine..."
Ken B
"We tried a bunch if slices, white, lasagna, pry outta, pepperoni, cheese, they were all really..."
MJ
"Delicious large slices of pizza! (Not much seating in restaurant..."
FrasJF
"Excellent! Great flavor. Loved..."
K
"Most amazing pizza we've even ate cant wait to bring the kids..."
Jennifer Crawford
"The best pizza in town.. Hands down Pizza Time has the best pizza in St. Augustine. It.s done just right. I've been there a hundred time, and can't..."
Mike F.
"Hands Down: The Best Pizza in St. Augie. As a transplanted New Yorker, I often pine for the type of pizza I grew up with down at Sal's on Mam'k..."
Table For Two
"Great pizza. No need for long winded stories with this place, probably the best pizza that I have ever..."
Bob Zingloc
"Best NY Style Pizza in St Augie!! Staff were awesome!!!Not your average pizza joint, we ate here almost everyday of our..."
Jennifer Finch
"Loved it! My husband and I each got a slice and shared them. It was huge and only $4 for a slice. The employees were friendly. We also tried a..."
Aubrey
"Best pizza in Florida!!! The owners are great & are actually from NY! Real NYC pizza..."
Jennifer
"Pizza Pizzaz. I have not yet eaten a pizza slice there that did not hit the spot in all the right ways!By far, Pizza Time is THE BEST PIZZA..."
Lisa Averill
"THE BEST pizza place in St..."
Barb Leaders
"By the slice quality. Outstanding pizza with lots of variety, reasonable price and great service. Had a slice of lasagna pizza and a slice of the..."
BillPG
"Divine! Not an exaggeration. I had the breaded eggplant pizza Perfect sauce. Perfect amount of basil. Perfect crust. Best pizza I've had in a while...."
Erin Hope
"Best in Town. When the pizza guy across the street from you needs a carnival barker(pizza alley) just to get people to come in the door then you know..."
Ross
"Love it!. My boyfriend and I went recently and I had their white pizza and he had the Hawaiian. The white pizza was INCREDIBLE! We also got some..."
FoodFan
"Best Pizza in St Augustine!! Direct from Brooklyn, this true New York pizza is the most tantalizing pizza in town for your..."
StAugustineLocal
"The best pizza I've had. This place is about ten times better than most pizza places. They have a great creative selection. Remember, cash only and..."
Knh
"Best pizza in town!. You can't go wrong with the grandma's pizza, breaded eggplant, or meatball contandino!If you want to go in for a slice..."
Chunt
"Hands down the best in town. I am from New Jersey and have had the best of the best when it comes to food. Let me tell you this is legit New York..."
Elizabeth Betancourt
"Pizza tastes awesome!!! Staff was very friendly. Will return for sure when I come back. Like bringing Brooklyn to..."
Weaksauce
"Finger-Licking Good!. This pizza is amazing! from the thick dough to the sauc to the cheese and other fresh toppings. its definitely a must if your..."
SimplyDelicious
"This place when it first opens a few years ago was great now the staff all seem to have bad attitudes and never smile only the owner is nice and he's..."
Cara
Nonna's Trattoria
83/100 (1574 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Chicken Alfredo
Pesto
Eggplant
Pasta
Fish
Salad
Calamari
Mussels
Calamares
Alfredo
Tiramisu
Meatballs
Bolognese
Sandwiches
Lasagne
Cannoli
Chicken Parmesan
Shrimp
Fettuccine Alfredo
Sit down
Italian
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"My son and I are frequent out of town visitors to St. Augustine and we discovered Nonna's Tratorria by accident on one trip.Ā  We were so impressed..."
Janet Krawczyk
"Stopped in late on a Sunday after arriving in St Augustine guys were very accommodating. Pleasant service and food was good. Loved the chicken..."
Dan Meadows
"Incredible service, atmosphere, and food! horses pass by on the cobblestone road. if you're looking for Italian food I would definitely reccomend!!..."
Shelton McCollough
"Worth stopping by!. A pretty little place on a beautiful street in a convenient part of downtown St Aug. Decent+ food, exceptionally pleasant..."
Jon M
"Cute location, excellent service, phenominal food. We had the eggplant parm & the grouper piccata. The eggplant was excellent with several layers of..."
Chuck Nuskey
"Good restaurant. Excellent service. Great food and wine. Generous portions at a good price. A definite lunch or dinner stop if you're wandering down..."
Vincent Link
"This quaint family run restaurant was amazing! The veil and spaghetti were superb and the service was friendly and informative. You MUST order the..."
Megan
"Friendly staff, good service and good food. Chicken Parmesan and Eggplant Parmesan are both excellent. The complimentary bread was..."
TimR
"Best Italian food in St Augie. My girlfriend and I eat at Nonna's quite often. It's quaint, cozy, and easily the best Italian food in St Augustine...."
Mike F.
"Best lasagna!!!!. Came with the family, party of 7, and the owner was very nice and accommodating even on a very busy night. We LOVED the food and..."
Stephanie Jones
"I work downtown at a restaurant and frequent Nonnas often. I always order the kids spaghetti and meat sauce, with sauteed onions on top. I had to..."
Jacquie Fox
"BEST ITALIAN FOOD EVER!!!. My husband and I eat at Nonna's as often as possible. We drive to St. Augustine about 2 times per month and I literally..."
Cristan Carmon
"Good food good service. Ordered the chicken parm and it was out of this world good, the wine is good and the price is very reasonable. Great addition..."
Adam
"Great food and..."
Ken Proper
"Great. The food was good and the family made us feel at home. We went back several nights and recommended it to our friends. Two friends went to the..."
Crystal.painter
"La Dolce Vita " The Sweet Life". It was magic and love at first sight when I stumbled into Nonna's Trattoria. Every sensation is heightened at this..."
Wraith
"Had lunch over the weekend and the food and service were out if this world . Making reservations for Friday night to go have the Mussels special and..."
Sally Sturmfels Nitz
"I was visiting St. Augustine for a wedding last week and Nonnas was recommended by the locals. I give it two thumbs up! service was excellent and the..."
WorldTraveler80
"The food was absolutely excellent and the staff was very friendly. They serve authentic Sicilian dishes that I have not seen anywhere else in North..."
Asalazar
"AMAZING!!!. We ended up at Nonna's on accident and ended up being one of the best dining experiences I've ever had! We were going to Ale works but..."
Shannon
"A TASTE OF HOME. I recently returned from a visit to St Augustine and I must say TRULY AUTHENTIC!! I live in New York and am a true foodie. I am half..."
Sonrisa07
"What a Great Glass of Sangria! Lots of fruit and not too much wine. Spiced well with plenty of flavor in a really cool glass. The street side seating..."
Examiner 007
"Nonnaā€™s Trattoria!!! Italian restaurant at its best. In the historic district of St Augustine Florida. We were looking for an Italian restaurant..."
Charles Kenny
"So lucky to have stumbled upon this fantastic restaurant! Beautiful sidewalk seating with views down the street toward the plaza. Easily one of the..."
Kayla Mullins
"It was a small quaint restaurant. The service was good assisted right away. I had the chicken Alfredo it was well portioned definitely shareable. ..."
Josie Rios
"Iā€™ve lived in the area for 12 years and just now discovered the culinary bliss of Nonnaā€™s Trattoria. The service from Brittany was..."
April Kerlew
"Holy AMAZINGšŸ¤¤šŸ¤¤šŸ¤¤. BY FAR the best Italian place in St. Augustine. The food has so much flavor and plates are HUGE. Will forever go to them..."
Lola Graxirena
"Located in the southern end of downtown St. Augustine, my wife and I found Nonnas Trattoria offering Italian food as good as we've had anywhere in..."
Steven Stell
"Such a great experienceā¤ļø Food, service, and atmosphere were all amazing, felt like home. Homemade tiramisu was delicious and the chicken Alfredo..."
Marissa Martin
Uptown Scratch Kitchen
83/100 (1383 ratings)
Quick Bites
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Italian
Seafood
South American
Cajun & Creole
South American
Gluten Free Options
American
Cajun & Creole
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Beef
Fish & chips
Salad
Fried shrimp
Wings
Cheesesteak
Philly Cheesesteak
Salmon
Cuban Sandwich
Etouffee
Fish & Chips
Shrimp and Grits
Tapas
Sandwiches
Po' Boys
Fish Taco
Burger
Fish
Tacos
Hamburgers
Pork
Cod
French Fries
Shrimp
CafƩ
Italian
American
Cajun & Creole
South American
Waterfront
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Accepts Credit Cards
Dog Friendly
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Outlawed in 49 states says a lot. Very addicting! Driving an hour from Jacksonville and happy to wait in line when I get here. The menu creator is a..."
Jason Jones
"After reading the reviews of this place I decided I better give it a try... I've been in the food industry for over 20 years and to say I'm a..."
Jennie Mowry
"This place serves some of the best food Iā€™ve eaten in Florida. So much food for the money too. Flavours are amazing. An absolute must for anyone...."
Suzanne Taylor
"Waited almost a year to eat here since my son discovered this gem. It was well worth the wait. The food was outstanding. They could teach..."
Craig Borrelli
"Of all the road trips I have taken, this may be my favorite food spot yet. Reading all the rave reviews left me a bit skeptical at first, but it is..."
Lou Oriondo
"Wow this place was a 10. Yes, its a food truck, so what. They had excellent food, big portions, piping hot and totally delicious. Very reasonable..."
Michael C Fox
"People were great. Attached to it was a Coffee and Wine Bar so you can order a beautiful bottle of wine food was amazing can't recommend it enough if..."
Marilyn Capel
"As a local in St. Augustine, this place has amazing food, amazing specials, amazing atmosphere. The owner was there when we were and she was so..."
Danielle Easton Gavronsky
"Some of the best food I have ever eaten. I had the mac and cheese and fried chicken. Unbelievable. The wait once we ordered was 35 minutes, which..."
Sherri Roff
"We had the fish and grits with shrimp and the fried chicken and rosemary fries and it was outstanding! What a great place surrounded by great..."
Mary Jane Klempay Beeson
"Traveling with two kids with food allergies can be difficult, especially when eating out! Well, not only was the food delicious, these guys were so..."
Angela Lovering
"Yesterday, my wife and I decided to try this place out since itā€™s number one on TripAdvisor for eats in St Augustine. We can definitely see why..."
Adam Mitchell
"My favorite lunch spot ever!!!! Fresh and delicious food. Everything Iā€™ve ordered is always on point. Food is so addicting. I crave it everyday. If..."
AnthonyJessica Guadalupe
"Iā€™ve eaten here twice now and after the first time I have been thinking about this food truck ever since! I went again yesterday and I was not..."
Sara Cox
"The fish and chips are hands down the best I have ever had! The breading is crispy and non-greasy. The staff was helpful and friendly. I really..."
Emigdio Valdovinos
"The best Food Truck in St. Augustine. Seafood is fresh everyday. Philly Cheesesteak is amazing. Shrimp Po Boy is delicious. I crave it everyday...."
Harmonyjess
"What a gem! So glad I found this place while visiting St. Augustine. ! I had the shrimp po' boy, and my husband had the etouffee. Both dishes were..."
Irina Shapiro
"Great place, food is fantastic and the owners very sweet. Off the beaten path but worth the drive. Being attached to DOS a wonderful coffee shop..."
Stephan Tobias
"Another fantastic meal at Uptown Scratch Kitchen. Chef Vinny and Christina are the most gracious restaurant owners I've ever known. Wouldn't..."
Teri Hartwig
"The place is just Wow. But its overcrowded almost all the time, except when they are out of food. The burgers are just too good - juicy and large...."
Alayna Shergill
"Good food. My husbands burger was burnt on the outside but to be fair he ordered it well. I had BBQ pork butt sandwich and it was very good. The wait..."
Emily Walton Faber
"If your heading to St. Augustine this food truck strip with picnic tables and water views is worth a visit. Uptown Scratch Kitchen is seriously the..."
Alex Angulo
"At Marina Munch in English Landing is Uptownā€¦.Goā€¦..Seriously ADDICTING food. Like stupid amazing rosemary garlic friesā€¦ really cloves of crispy..."
Breeana
"Really enjoyed the meal at Scratch. Had fish and fries and shrimp tacos and both were excellent. The only thing that kept this from being a 5 star..."
Random Rambler
"DECEPTIVELY delicious. Believe the hype. Husband and I shared a shrimp po boy for lunch and it was definitely enough for the two of us. You also get..."
Dani Johnson
"Literally the best Philly cheesesteak I've ever had! It was so flavorful and has a unique twist on the sandwich that you don't expect from looking at..."
Mara Minor
"When Iā€™m deciding what I want for lunch, my first question in my head is... ā€œis this restaurant/ food truck better than uptown scratch..."
Richard Girton
Amici Italian Restaurant
82/100 (936 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Tiramisu
Eggplant
Meatballs
Pasta
Cheesecakes
Salad
Lasagne
Scallops
Cannoli
Clams
Chicken Parmesan
Calamari
Baked Ziti
Minestrone
Calamares
Cakes
Salmon
Pesto
Fish
Cheesecake
Shrimp
Alfredo
Lobster
Sit down
Italian
Table Service
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Reservations
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Seating
Accepts Visa
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"My niece and I had the most fabulous dinner experience at Amiciā€™s last night. We started with an artichoke appetizer served with crispy Italian..."
Peggy Accurso
"Casual family restaurant serving delicious food with true Italian flavor. Started out with fresh, hot, roasted garlic and warm bread, enjoyed a..."
Maggie Teske Segert Lester
"We had our son and his fiancee's Rehearsal Dinner here. It was wonderful! Benedetta worked with me on the menu and she was so kind and helpful. She..."
Barbara Acer Mazone
"Great little local place to eat dinner! Probably the best service I've had at a restaurant! The food is delicious. I really enjoyed the atmosphere...."
Natasha Pfeffer
"We walked in without notice with a large party. (19 people). They only had one waitress working at the time. The manager stepped in and served us...."
Tiffany Martin
"What a great find, off the beaten path of Main St but well worth the trip. Our service was fantastic, the food was amazing from rhe vread with fresh..."
Paula Bellocchio Klein
"The food is amazing. Everything tastes fresh and authentic. Had a wonderful last night in St. Augustine eating and drinking Italian beer here. The..."
Denise Vargas
"Amici's recently hosted the reception following my Mother's memorial service. Her passing was sudden and the staff was extremely sympathetic and..."
Sheila Sweet
"It was good Italian. We were able to make a reservation for 8 tonight a few hours before arriving to eat. The roasted garlic and oil for the bread is..."
Jordan & Rachel Jeeping Life
"Last minute stop with my wife as I was craving pasta and we happened to drive by. We both went with the "build your own pasta." I had cheese..."
Rob Hernandez
"We had a wonderful server named Lesley who made our dining experience very enjoyable and the food was just outstanding. Complements to the chef! ..."
Sam Hagler
"Wow...our server was friendly and knowledgeable, the food was DELICIOUS, and plentiful. I definitely recommend visiting, I'll be going back the next..."
Chris Ottum
"My brother in law and I had the Chicken Parmazone! Oh my goodness it was delicious! I could only eat 1/3 of it! The margherita pizza, Angel hair..."
Wendy Peters
Pizzalley Chianti Room
82/100 (4518 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Tuscan
Central-Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Alfredo
Eggplant
Tiramisu
Pasta
Meatballs
Salad
Lasagne
Crab
Cannoli
Calamari
Chicken Parmesan
Mussels
Minestrone
Cakes
Calamares
Bruschette
Pesto
Fish
Crab Cake
Mediterranean Chicken
Shrimp
Roast Beef
Lobster
Sit down
Central-Italian
Italian
Tuscan
Pizza
Seating
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Table Service
Live Music
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Lunch
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"Stopped here on a whim. Excellent place to eat! We got a pepperoni pizza, nothing fancy, but it was piping hot fresh. The dough was delicious and..."
Aut W
"The pizza here is great, the crust is my favorite! Calamari was not what I was expecting- extra crispy- but the flavor was delicious still. The lemon..."
Taylor H
"Absolutely great! The Alfredo sauce is to die for....if you love garlic its the dipping sauce for the freshly baked bread sticks. Entrees include a..."
Suzanne Brodnix Hoelscher
"You might miss Pizzalley's amongst all the touristy spots in downtown St. Augustine if you're not looking hard enough, but you definitely don't want..."
G Neal
"Ammmaaazing! Lovely atmosphere, Great service, even better food! I had read some reviews that the Alfredo was a bit strong on the garlic, I like it..."
Sarra Heart
"WOW! AMAZING FOOD. The fettuccine with shrimp and broccoli is incredible. My girl friend had the Mediterranean chicken w mash and vegetables also..."
Nic Printing
"Great food as always. One of my favorite places to eat while in old..."
Ginny B
"One plate is way more than we can eat. They have a split a plate option. They split it for you. This is how it came out. Wonderful food. Great..."
John Yergin
Romeo's Cafe
82/100 (629 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Ribs
Alfredo
Meatballs
Lasagne
Chicken Parmesan
Ice Cream
Sandwiches
Shrimp
"Really delicious food and I was surprised at how quick it came out. The staff was really attentive and nice. The Ziti was fantastic and overall the..."
Boyd Waldrep
"Wow...is all I can say!!!! From the stuffed peppers to the entrees and finally the ice cream...it was wonderful. The food is excellent 5 all the..."
Jacki Bennis
"Dinner last night at Romeo's was amazing! The lobster ravioli melted in your mouth and the veal parm and lemon cake with lemoncello was a wonderful..."
Kim Robertson
"One of my favorite restaurants in Saint Augustine! Generous portions of exceptionally prepared, authentic Italian cuisine. Baked ziti, chicken..."
Darcy Bennett D'Errico
"Everything was great!! The server went over and beyond for us, including going next door to get me a mountain dew since they didn't have it. We..."
Krystal Harrell
"Hannah was amazing. Very friendly and helpful. We loved her. We had the Baked Ziti and Manicotti. They were both delicious. Iļø am Italian and have..."
Timothy George Jr.
"Romeos is by far the most authentic Italian Restaurant ! Amazing food, stellar service. A must in ST..."
Kate Hayes Casey
"Very enjoyable time and delicious food. The wait staff were very capable and friendly. Try the..."
John Bolton
"Decided to try this place because of a greeter! The best choice I've made in a long time! They had a great atmosphere and the food changed me. I..."
Autumn Nicole
"Great place for a relaxing time, or you want to impress a date. Friendly staff. Try the manicotti.. so much..."
Lahi Salas
"Excellent all the way around. The chicken cutlet is exactly like Nana used to make, and it's also the only place intown to have angel hair and..."
William Keohane
"Wonderful place. Great food..great service a must go to...Aaron was our wonderful..."
Michelle Butler
"Awesome food, great service and the best ceaser salad in the..."
Loretta Davey
"Lasagna, dude. Lasagna. Get the lasagna. Why is there a minimum amount of words you must write to submit a review? I just wanted to say "lasagna"...."
JosƩ Farinos
"We stopped in for a little something yesterday. My son and friend enjoyed their ice cream very much, but, my chicken-lemongrass soup was..."
Stephanie Susie Hyde Kilpatrick
"Tanya was excellent!! The food reminded me of when I was in Italy. If you make it to St. Augustineā€™s, take to stop in Romeoā€™s. Itā€™s worth..."
Jill Ramsey
"Wasnā€™t particularly impressed with my pasta dish but my friendā€™s lobster ravioli was ~divine~. Super friendly service and nice environment..."
Jasmine Baker
"AMAZING FOOD! My boyfriend took me here on a date, the food was great and the service was absolutely amazing. Our waitress was so sweet and funny,..."
Zachary Wluka
"This was really great Italian food. I had the baked ziti and my gf got the eggplant Parmesan. Both were amazing. The wait time for the food was a bit..."
Dougie Thrash
"Romeos is awesome! We have dined there many times and usually take visitors or other local couples with us to introduce them to Romeos. Every person..."
Sherri Maetozo
"If youā€™re looking for authentic Italian food. This is the right place. The flavors are so great and the House wine on 5 dollars is a really good..."
jose L Hernandez F
"We have been twice and it has hands down been outstanding! We had the hand made mozzarella sticks and pepperoni pizza and both were the best we've..."
Dennis Cunningham
Casa Benedetto's Ristorante
81/100 (3269 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Italian
Southern-Italian
Sicilian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Lasagne
Pasta
Cannoli
Salad
Clams
Chicken Parmesan
Calamari
Cannelloni
Mussels
Ice Cream
Calamares
Gelato
Crepes
Fettuccine Alfredo
Pesto
Cheesecake
Fish
Pork
Caponata
Alfredo
Shrimp
Tiramisu
Meatballs
Cheesecakes
Eggplant
Sit down
Italian
Southern-Italian
Sicilian
Wheelchair Accessible
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Street Parking
Live Music
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Best meal I've had in ages! Chicken parm with angel hair pasta was incredible! Bright tomato sauce. My husband had the antipasti salad. Large chunks..."
Brandy Meetze
"It's Like Sunday Dinner at Grandma's!. Love this restaurant! I have been here a number of times, have always ordered a different dish and have always..."
Sheriden
"Seriously Splendid & A Happy New Yorker. Me and my Papa Vinny love dining at Casa Benedetto's - it is "Our Spot" for dining out. Papa Vinny is..."
Mermaid In Stilettos
"It doesn't look like much, but you will think you are in Little Italy in New York City. Made to order, best Italian food I have had since the last..."
Chad Converse
"One of our favorites when we visit.. The first time we pulled up we were a little leery - it is not a fancy building - but it did not take long for..."
Jrohrbeck
"My experience with Casa Benedetto's was very good! It was cozy and relaxing just like at home. The food was so delicious. I ordered stuffed mushroom..."
Olivia
"Relaxing & Delicious. ALL of our visits have been fantastic from beginning to end, Main Course thru....... Wonderful Dessert !!! Robin and Jay..."
Lmcteresa
"One of the Greatest Secrets in St Augustine!!! This small A-frame house has just a few tables but it is some of the best italian food around! This is..."
StAugustineLocal
"Casa Benedetto's is the Best!. I can not believe food of this quality is available in this area.The Cannelloni is to die for, and try to get..."
Jim DeVito
"Kris&rick. Wonderful little secret spot! Who wants the ordinary! Home cooked flavor,personable service,clean,and don't even try the desert sampler..."
Kris
"Great Food. We have dined here for lunch and dinner. Our lunch experience was incredible! The owner waited on us, she was just adorable and really..."
GaryD
"Everything was fantastic from the fresh bread and Italian dipping sauce to the perfect eggplant parmesan. My other half had the shrimp scampi and..."
Tracy Bier
"First visit to Benedettos and it was a pleasant surprise. First off the wait staff and owners are top notch. Courteous, friendly, efficient and..."
Rob Edelman
"This amazing place will turn you Italian. First time here. Started with homemade Sangria. Red and White. Heavenly. Soup and salads made fresh...."
Darlene Weatherbee
"Had a late lunch. First time dining this establishment. We've been putting it off for a while. My expectations were not high as I not have not had..."
Tom W
"Incredible dinner and excellent attention. Those who serve us are older people, something that I loved, I felt that my uncles or grandparents were..."
Ilsa FĆ© Reyes GarantĆ³n
"Amazing local gem. Everything is made from scratch and the service was impeccable. Their marinara sauce was so good. Defintely a lick your plate..."
Mary Trenty
"Went today for my birthday & LOVED IT. The bread , everything was freshly cooked. This is real Italian food. If we lived here I would go here every..."
Ariana edmonds
Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine
80/100 (4644 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
American
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Bar
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Salad
Wings
Meatballs
Hoagie
Sandwiches
Sit down
American
Bar
Pizza
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Seating
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Mid-range
"Awsome food! Great Beers! We had the pretzle bites for an appetizer and the beer cheese that comes with it is the best cheese sauce I have ever had..."
Brendan Bernhard
"Fantastic Pizzas (I have never tasted a crust so truly delicious); Greek Salad was freshly made and the portion size was more than generous; Pretzel..."
Ja Ceasarl
"Food, service, and atmosphere are excellent. Our party had tofu hoagies, pizza, and spinach & artichoke dip. All was delicious. Highly..."
Jennifer Lee Smith
"Very good pizza, we just donā€™t have that many good pizza places, but this was a bit different and very fresh toppings. Red, our bartender and..."
Cris Soubasis Everetts
"This place absolutely amazing great service great food and a reasonable price very friendly service I would go there again in a second. Definitely a..."
Lynne Hall
"Absolutely loved our experience at this location! We wish we didn't live so far away from it. The pizza was delicious as always! Our waiter, Jacob,..."
Samantha Wiseman
"AmazingšŸ„šŸ„ The pizza is the best around. We visit each time we are in St Augustine. The also have great gluten free choices -to us that is..."
Rebecca Burke Fenton
"great craft beer. Highlander was a good suggestion by our server. And awesome pizza, of..."
Jerome Go
"Delicious food, very affordable, wonderful atmosphere, seated promptly, and our server was awesome! Couldn't ask for..."
Amy Davison
"My wife and our 3 kids stopped here for some dinner after some fun in town and have had Mellow Mushroom before at other locations, our expectations..."
Christian Hatton
"Food was great. Staff incredibly friendly. Love the gluten free..."
Joy Whitley
"Awesome staff fast service. Have always had great service and food at all mellow..."
Andy Powers