Best meal I've had in ages! Chicken parm with angel hair pasta was incredible! Bright tomato sauce. My husband had the antipasti salad. Large chunks of provolone. Yum. We also ordered pistachio gelato. Creamy and delish.
It's Like Sunday Dinner at Grandma's!. Love this restaurant! I have been here a number of times, have always ordered a different dish and have always been delighted. The bread, the soup, the entree's, the desserts - all fabulous. The wait staff is very friendly and attentive. I cannot imagine the bad reviews came from anyone who really had a meal at Casa Benedetto's, but here's to them: stay away!! More for us!!
Mermaid In Stilettos
+4.5
Seriously Splendid & A Happy New Yorker. Me and my Papa Vinny love dining at Casa Benedetto's - it is "Our Spot" for dining out. Papa Vinny is Sicilian and originally from New York - he knows Italian food! The Owner of Casa Benedetto's and his Lovely Wife ALWAYS make us feel like we are having dinner with family. The cozy atmosphere, pictures of the Owner's family throughout the dining room , stories of the "old neighborhood" and the incredible entrees leave us feeling like we were transported back to a gentler time when families gathered around the kitchen table and passed on their family traditions & recipes.
Our favorites are the Rice Balls, Chicken Parmigiana, Veal Piccatta, Fusilli Meatballs and after dinner Espressos, Cappuccinos and Cannolis.
Casa Benedetto's is Seriously Splendid Italian Food for the Saint Augustine Beach area & a Magnificent way for me to see my Papa Vinny Happy!
It doesn't look like much, but you will think you are in Little Italy in New York City. Made to order, best Italian food I have had since the last time in NYC. don't be in a hurry, they make every dish to order, but it is worth the wait.
One of our favorites when we visit.. The first time we pulled up we were a little leery - it is not a fancy building - but it did not take long for our concerns to be set aside. My wife has a gluten intolerance and they provided made to order dishes to accommodate her dietary needs. The food was amazing! We now make this a regular stop whenever we visit the area. The place has a relaxed, homey feeling and the owners have been exceptionally cordial.
My experience with Casa Benedetto's was very good! It was cozy and relaxing just like at home. The food was so delicious. I ordered stuffed mushroom for appetizer. It is a must! I ordered eggplant entree and it was excellent! I enjoyed it and I would come back again.
Relaxing & Delicious. ALL of our visits have been fantastic from beginning to end, Main Course thru....... Wonderful Dessert !!!
Robin and Jay are like visiting Italy through your taste buds.
One of the Greatest Secrets in St Augustine!!! This small A-frame house has just a few tables but it is some of the best italian food around! This is a MUST try!!!
Casa Benedetto's is the Best!. I can not believe food of this quality is available in this area.
The Cannelloni is to die for, and try to get Briasole anywhere.
If you can't go to italy or Little Italy NYC, you can just go to Crescent Beach and you will be happy.
Kris&rick. Wonderful little secret spot! Who wants the ordinary! Home cooked flavor,personable service,clean,and don't even try the desert sampler ,unless you want to faint with delight!
Everything was fantastic from the fresh bread and Italian dipping sauce to the perfect eggplant parmesan. My other half had the shrimp scampi and devoured every bite. Absolutely sensational . We will be back to try more wonderful things off the menu. Our service exceeded our expectations and she was informative and so kind . Can't wait to come back with room for desert ♥️♥️♥️
First visit to Benedettos and it was a pleasant surprise. First off the wait staff and owners are top notch. Courteous, friendly, efficient and knowledgable. The cuisine is what I would classify as italian comfort food and there are quite a few places between st augustine and jacksonville that fill that void. Only casa benedettos I found to be one of the best. Items we tried included chicken francaise, ravioli with meat sauce, sausage & peppers, & chicken marsala. Let's not forget the fresh baked bread which was outstanding. To a person everyone enjoyed their homemade Italian dish that I would put up against any other Italian eatery. Plenty of parking in this strip center as well. Inside and outside dining. No liquor license so it's beer and wine only. This would be our new go to italian restaurant.
This amazing place will turn you Italian. First time here. Started with homemade Sangria. Red and White. Heavenly. Soup and salads made fresh. Chicken Francaise was out of this world. We will definitely be back. Staff is very knowledgeable and friendly. If you ever get the chance….go. You will not be disappointed.
Had a late lunch. First time dining this establishment. We've been putting it off for a while. My expectations were not high as I not have not had much Italian food from St. Augustine that I really wanted to go back for. The place is small and quaint. The food was really outstanding. Fresh bread and butter to start off.
I had eggplant parmesan over penne pasta which was cooked perfectly al dente with plenty of sauce. My wife had a meatball sub that was money!!! Service was excellent, the waitress made us feel like we were regulars. Definitely want to go back and try a few more things and also find out if they have chef specials.
Ilsa Fé Reyes Garantón
+5
Incredible dinner and excellent attention. Those who serve us are older people, something that I loved, I felt that my uncles or grandparents were serving me, very warm and familiar.
Amazing local gem. Everything is made from scratch and the service was impeccable. Their marinara sauce was so good. Defintely a lick your plate restaurant!
Went today for my birthday & LOVED IT. The bread , everything was freshly cooked. This is real Italian food. If we lived here I would go here every week if I could ! Delishhhhhh!!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in St. Augustine
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes