Nonna's Trattoria
2 Aviles St, 32084-4405 - St. Augustine
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#122 of 484 restaurants in St. Augustine
Updated on
Italian
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
59/100
Data Completeness
61/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
815
Google reviews
What a Great Glass of Sangria! Lots of fruit and not too much wine. Spiced well with plenty of flavor in a really cool glass. The street side seating is quaint and cozy. Our server was a sweet very professional and pretty lady. Who made our drinks by the way. The side street setting is the perfect place to relax and enjoy the beautiful scenery with flowers everywhere and the smells from the kitchen fill the street.
Read more
Google
Nonna’s Trattoria!!! Italian restaurant at its best. In the historic district of St Augustine Florida. We were looking for an Italian restaurant for dinner and decided to try Nonna’s. Went in at 5pm to make a reservation for 6pm and happy that we did. They have outside dining with heat lamps which reminded me of little Italy in NYC. The inside dining was cozy and inviting and the decor was great. They give you garlic rolls with olive oil and spice which was very tasty. I ordered the Chicken Picatta with spaghetti and marinara sauce which was excellent. Being an Italian from NY I know good Italian food. My wife ordered the Chicken Parmigiana with Penne Alfredo and a Pinot and she said it was delicious. I highly recommend eating at this restaurant if you are in St Augustine visiting for the day or on vacation. While we were there a party of 6 came in and sat across from us. We notice one of the gentleman seemed to be the owner. He got up went to the kitchen which is visible and started cooking for his party. We watched him as he cooked and he waved to us asking how is everything. When he was done he came over to our table to chat. I asked were he was from which was Palermo Italy, I told he my family was from Cosenza Calabria, Italy and we spoke briefly in Italian. He asked how was the food and we told him excellent and me being an Italian from NY I know good Italian food when I have it. The owner’s name is Adamo and his restaurant is definitely a place you should visit.
Read more
Google
So lucky to have stumbled upon this fantastic restaurant! Beautiful sidewalk seating with views down the street toward the plaza. Easily one of the best restaurant experiences we have had. Delicious made to order home made Italian dishes. They may have a small menu but they have perfected what they serve. We had the bolognese and fettuccini Alfredo and calamari appetizer and it was the best Italian food I’ve ever had. This place is so worth the wait if you love authentic Italian food!
Read more
Google
It was a small quaint restaurant. The service was good assisted right away. I had the chicken Alfredo it was well portioned definitely shareable. My wife had the chicken Parmesan and it was delicious and also well portioned. Tiramisu was stupendous.
Google
I’ve lived in the area for 12 years and just now discovered the culinary bliss of Nonna’s Trattoria. The service from Brittany was outstanding—so attentive, right down to the wine pairing suggestion. I will be back many times over, and I intend to try everything on the menu. The limoncello cake alone is worth the trip. It’s divine!
Nonna’s ambiance feels old world, as it’s on an old brick road surrounded by historical buildings (that aren’t shops or bars) and is well away from the kitschy restaurants in the main touristy area.
Read more
Google
Holy AMAZING🤤🤤🤤. BY FAR the best Italian place in St. Augustine. The food has so much flavor and plates are HUGE. Will forever go to them when in town. I’m pregnant now and craving them all day long😭😭😭 You guys need a location in Tampa 😂❤️
Google
Located in the southern end of downtown St. Augustine, my wife and I found Nonnas Trattoria offering Italian food as good as we've had anywhere in the US or Italy. In a rustic and comfortable storefront, the restaurant offered a limited menu with wonderful flavors. The food was prepared fresh in an open kitchen where we could watch the chef cook each individual meal. We started with the fried ravioli appetizer and then enjoyed the pasta bolognese and grouper in light lemon sauce. While I lack the culinary vocabulary to properly describe the nuance of flavors delivered in our dishes, suffice it say we happily finished everything. We were fortunate to get walk-in service but the number of tables inside are limited. They also offer some outdoor seating on the street, but I would recommend reservations to be sure you get the opportunity to enjoy all that Nonnas has to offer in great food and wonderful service.
Read more
Google
Such a great experience❤️ Food, service, and atmosphere were all amazing, felt like home. Homemade tiramisu was delicious and the chicken Alfredo was great as well. Definitely will be coming back!
Google
Explore more in St. Augustine
By cuisine
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: