My wife and I had the best date night at PaPa J’s Michael and his staff are absolutely amazing. We had the best appetizers and dinner! Everything so fresh and delicious. And the gelato was out of this world awesome place great food 5/5 recommend
Very cool! Excellent service. Great atmosphere. Decor is perfect for the vibe there. Absolutely immaculate open kitchen. I rarely post about a restroom but the restroom was immaculate as well! Menu is everything you want it to be. We just ordered an appetizer. We got the greens and beans with Romaine and Northern beans. Comes with bread and dipping oil! OMG! Fabulous!
You can find delicious Greek-style pizza with a medium-thin, crunchy bread crust at this place. Additionally, you can indulge in their gelato, which is a bit on the pricey side but definitely worth the taste! I plan to return and try their pasta next time.
The entire establishment is clean and aesthetically pleasing, including the well-maintained bathrooms.
The food is truly incredible!!!! Pizza, past, bread, and salad were all so delicious. They offer so many wonderful authentic Italian items. Our server Dominic was the best! He was so kind and helpful. Highly recommend
Visited Papa J's for the first time over the weekend with some friends. We were blown away with Michael's service - best dining experience we've ever had! He made sure that our visit was memorable. Great atmosphere, we did not feel rushed between drinks/appetizers/entrées. Food was amazing - the Divine sauce in particular. Also, the burrata appetizer and espresso martini! We will definitely be back!
Excellent pizza in the town. We tried four flavors, sweet sausage and onion, spinach and feta, BBQ chicken, and mushroom, all of them are delicious!
The crust is thin, crispy, yet chewy and lightly fluffy. Every bite is a joyful experience. Pizza are packed with flavors.
The guy working behind the counter is very friendly. We watch him make pizza while eating, he clearly has passion and skills in pizza. No wonder all of their pizza taste so good.
Will be back for other flavors.
Papa J’s was the single greatest dining experience that I have ever had.
We reserved a spot for a party of 21.
The owner, Michael reached out to us and was extremely accommodating to our party and worked with us to create a dining menu that fit our party well. We could not have been more pleased!
We had a red sauce pasta, a white sauce pasta, garden salad, and 14 different kinds of Roman pizza! Everything was absolutely delicious!
We also added on some of their fresh made gelato!
Michael’s family has been in Pittsburgh for a hundred years and he is running an absolutely phenomenal restaurant!
Everything is fresh, made in house, and made with care. The service, food, and establishment was all incredible!
Side note, we also had a gluten free member of our party and they were super accommodating.
I cannot recommend this place enough!
This place has incredible food. The veal parm and the divine sauce are drool-worthy. Leah was our server this time and she was so so lovely and attentive. Can't recommend this place more.
The guy who served us gelato (on the side with the bar) was so friendly and funny, he totally made our day. The gelato itself was also great!! Totally reminiscent of Italy. And the focaccia was delicious. I would love to come back here to try more food and drink.
Michael was such a pleasure to be around. He was so extremely kind and helpful. The food was so amazing! I really appreciate the way he took care of us today. We’ll absolutely be returning!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Pittsburgh
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes