Good food, good portions, good value. I went and had their pasta special, which included a large portion of pasta and sauce, 2 pieces of garlic bread and a nice sized garden salad. It was also considered their happy hour so appetizers were half off (and I think drinks too although I didn't have any). The inside is small but clean with tables and booths. They have a nice menu and I look forward to going back. Overall, it was a good value and I left with 2 takeout containers.
Really good pizza with great dough and excellent pepperoni. I can see why this place has been open for so long.
Found this gem while visiting from Ohio. Some of the best wings and pizza I’ve had. Lucky we found this place and they had an open table! Thank you!
Very pleasant woman answered phone. Delivery time to Sharpsburg was very quick during weekday lunch. I liked pizza crust and cheese. Inclusion of a small courtesy cup of ranch was a welcome surprise! I also ordered red velvet cake which looks delicious! Lost a star because their mushrooms are canned - barf. I'd pay more for fresh mushrooms. Overall I probably will order again.
Very pleased to see their back open as they have a delicious pizza with just the right sauce, dough recipe and thickness and quality toppings. A pizza that I eat entirely, no crusts left behind.
During there brief closure I wet to Caliente in Crafton once.. they'll never see me again. Inferior and over priced in my opinion
Love everything about Sammy's Pizza. Highly recommend the restaurant. You will not be disappointed. The spaghetti and meatballs are to die for. Delicious 😋
Little on the pricey side but the pizza was excellent amd the staff was nice
Fantastic pizza! The crust, sauce, and cheese are so tasty and all in the right amounts.
Moved into this neighborhood recently with a habit of enjoying local handmade pizzas and Sammys didn't disappointment me and going to a regular 😋
Only got pizza delivery/pickup but their pizza is very good!
We usually are pleased with the food that we get but tonight was a disappointment. We ordered a large veggie pizza and it was very undercooked. The dough actually stuck to the paper so we couldn’t get it picked up. We also ordered a small cheese pizza and breadsticks and they both were wonderful.
The manager reached out to us to offer us another pizza next time we are there.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Pittsburgh
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes