Yesterday I had a pizza TO DIE FOR! It was the best I've had, and I eat pizza every week. Wish they delivered to our neighborhood. Friendly and courteous staff, lots of fun while having a fabulous meal and great value. Loved it!!!
Awesome pizza! Had the T-REX pizza and my friends I finished this monster pizza. Highly recommend this place.
Not a bad place to grab some pizza quick. However, with Mineo's just a couple of buildings over, it's difficult to choose to eat here instead. The ambiance is far better at Mineo's, and their pizza is not easy to trump. So Aiello's must play to their strengths to stay in the game; like faster service times and longer operating hours (especially late at night).
Closest thing I have had to a proper East Coast pie. Great crust. Right amount of cheese and sauce. It's simple and reminds me of the great pizza I am able to get when I visit NYC and New Jersey.
Good, Fresh pizza. The pizza is made with fresh ingredients and is good. It is overpriced, however for the amount that you get. Salads are great. Restaurant quality with really good italian dressing. Service was good and the guys were friendly.
What can I say. The spot.
Recently moved to the burgh and out of the 10+ pizza places I've tried, this place is hands down delicious. Any one else that has a negative review on here are pretentious twits. Awesome pies.
Very good pizza. This is a basic pizza joint with a few tables. The atmosphere is simplistic, but the pizza is outstanding and they have a nice beer selection. This place is worth a visit or at the least a take out order. The service was friendly and professional.
Just ate here with my brother and mom. We get pizza from lots of different places and I'm ashamed to say I've never been here before! The inside is simple and exactly what a you think pizza shop would like. We had a pepperoni pizza and an Italian hoagie. Both were very yummy and fresh! Although I loved the pizza, I personally prefer less sauce, which I could just ask for next time. If you want to try a pizza place that has fantastic(!) crust, hot bubbly cheese, and tasty sauce stop here!!
Best Pizza in Pittsburgh. We have had pizza at numerous pizza shops over the last 22 yrs. of our marriage and this is by far the best pizza and sauce of any pizza shop I have ever eaten at. Also they sell the sauce by the quart, how great is that. Aiello's is number one in my books.
For sauce fans. Of course, the debate between Mineo's and Aiello's rages on eternally, like an unholy standoff between the Hatfields and McCoys (with oregano sprinkled in). I eat pizza for sauce, not cheese, therefore, Aiello's is the clear winner in my book. I love the sweet sausage they use. And, if you happen to talk to Joe Aiello about the time he met Brett Favre, he might get sweet on you and try to sell you bootlegged DVDs. So, there's always that.
My family eats pizza every weekend. This is by far the best pizza in Pennsylvania. Service is friendly and fast. Dine in area is limited
This place does very delicious pizzas with large portions and many different options. The pizza we took was crunchy and very tasty. It is guaranteed that you will not leave hungry from there. There are many options for the drinks and the service is excellent. I recommend it without any doubt.
Perfect pizzeria pizza. Crispy crust. Ooey gooey cheese with the pepperoni and grease underneath. This pizza is soooo tasty!! We also ordered a small Stromboli with ham and pepperoni. The sauce was inside, that was new for me. Fried mushrooms as an appetizer-decent portion size. Clean restrooms, clean dine in. Great atmosphere!
Neat pizza history on the place and its neighbor
Aiello's by far is in the top 3 best Pizzas in Pittsburgh. My favorite is Anchovy and cheese. Craft 🍺 🍻 This time, I bought a pie with pepperoni and sausage and mushrooms. For my little ones. It was not a good pie! must have been new personal ,because it's the first time I've ever had less than average pie! So besides this event, it is one of the world most famous pizzas experiences in Pittsburgh.
We went to the pizza place next door first but there was a horrible chemical smell, not like a pizza place at all. So we walked out and came Here instead. It smelled good, was clean and bright and the pizza was quite good. I loved the crust. I had the the stuffed meat and my husband had the stuffed vegetable. We both really enjoyed it and would come back.
My family and I purchased wings and pizza. The white pizza is superb; we would definitely purchase it again (a large white pizza was $23 and worth it), and the wings were delicious.
Had a stuffed vegetable pizza - absolutely amazing! Not at all greasy, and very flavorful. Excellent cheese and mushrooms, onion and peppers. Highly recommend! Friendly and efficient staff.
Best Pittsburgh style pizza in Squirrel Hill. It's always cooked well. The not to much cheese, the right amount of time in the oven, and the right amount of toppings. Their pizza dough is so good. I don't think I've eaten such a delicious crust! The people are so kind as well. They always greet you. Their restaurant is clean and welcoming, even during the pandemic. Oh yeah, I'm not a fan of Hawaiian pizza, but my husband loves it so I get it. We ordered it this past weekend from Aiello's and I enjoyed it a lot! Using bacon and canadian bacon did the trick 👌
One of the best pizza , I have ever tasted. You can't beat the freshness of the pizza, directly served from oven.
Stuffed pizza & Stuffed pepperoni roll are awesome. You will also get huge variety of beers.
This place is cash only, there is ATM inside.
There is street side parking & paid parking near by.
I came here with some friends from France. They really liked the pizza and so did I. The counter staff was friendly. The manager stopped by our table a few times to make sure we were satisfied. The restaurant was clean and so was the bathroom. We stayed until closing but no one shooed us out. If you're looking for good pizza in Pittsburgh, this place should be on your list.
Most Excellent! Cathy & staff, thank you for the community love and for supporting the Environmental Charter School high school student government! Our gratitude is overflowing! Pizza is a local favorite for a reason…off the charts, delicious! Thank you 🍕💗
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Pittsburgh
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes