Best Restaurants in Old Saybrook

Discover 87 restaurants with browsable menus, verified reviews and prices. Complete guide updated August 2026.

⭐

79/100

Avg Rating

🍴

28

Cuisine Types

20 of 87 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

Walts

💬 230 reviews

📍 178 Main St

Sweet Luna's Frozen Desserts & Bubble Tea

Sweet Luna's Frozen Desserts & Bubble Tea

💬 336 reviews

📍 139 Main St

Kim's She Shore Shed Foodtruck

📍 Harvey's Beach

Mystic Market Kitchen & Eatery

Mystic Market Kitchen & Eatery

American Cafe Soups

💬 667 reviews

📍 70 Mill Rock Rd E

Saybrook Soup And Sandwich Co.

Saybrook Soup And Sandwich Co.

American Soups Deli

💬 381 reviews

📍 745 Boston Post Rd

Alforno Trattoria

Alforno Trattoria

💬 721 reviews

📍 1654 Boston Post Rd

James Pharmacy Bed & Breakfast And Gelateria

James Pharmacy Bed & Breakfast And Gelateria

Italian American Cafe

💬 87 reviews

📍 2 Pennywise Ln

Saybrook Pizza & Restaurant

Saybrook Pizza & Restaurant

💬 381 reviews

📍 1550 Boston Post Rd

Himalaya Cafe

💬 472 reviews

📍 1456 Boston Post Rd

Shakahari

Shakahari

💬 194 reviews

📍 1458 Boston Post Rd

Five Guys

American Fast Food

💬 477 reviews

📍 28 Spencer Plain Rd

La Marea

Italian Mediterranean

💬 434 reviews

📍 732 Middlesex Turnpike

Tj's Restaurant And Pizza

Tj's Restaurant And Pizza

Italian American Pizza

💬 864 reviews

📍 735 Boston Post Rd

Liv's Oyster Bar & Restaurant

Liv's Oyster Bar & Restaurant

American Seafood

💬 1099 reviews

📍 166 Main St

Luigi's Restaurant

Luigi's Restaurant

💬 1541 reviews

📍 1295 Boston Post Rd

Penny Lane Pub & Restaurant

Penny Lane Pub & Restaurant

American Bar British

💬 1423 reviews

📍 150 Main St

Fresh Salt

American Seafood Contemporary

💬 2806 reviews

📍 2 Bridge St

Red Hen

Red Hen

💬 237 reviews

📍 286 Main St

Skippers

Skippers

💬 260 reviews

📍 688 Boston Post Rd

Fenwick 'n Chicken

Fenwick 'n Chicken

💬 21 reviews

📍 1395 Boston Post Rd

🍴

Explore by Cuisine Type

American 29 Italian 13 Cafe 12 Seafood 8 Bar 7 Pizza 7 Fast Food 5 Soups 5 Asian 4 Deli 4 Pub 4 Greek 3 Thai 3 Chinese 2 Contemporary 2 Diner 2 Indian 2 Mexican 2 Vietnamese 2 British 1 Cajun & Creole 1 Healthy 1 Japanese 1 Korean 1 Mediterranean 1 Southwestern 1 Steakhouse 1 Sushi 1

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📋

41 Browsable Menus

📅

Aug 2026 Last Updated