Sluurpy > Restaurants in New York City > City Cakes

Review City Cakes - New York City

Maggie Rossetti
One of my favorite cookies in the city! So many great flavors and seasonal varieties that keep me coming back. Their COVID-19-friendly setup is perfect for a grab and go, and it is incredibly safe for both customer and staff. I haven’t tried everything there, but I sure am working on it!
Maura Consedine
City Cakes is just the best. Their cookies are top notch, their cupcakes are delicious, and their customer service is absolutely wonderful. If you’re searching for a great bakery in NYC, look no further. I will never stop coming here because I am always blown away by the food quality and lovely environment/vibe.
K L
These cookies are out of this world! They arrived carefully packed, individually wrapped and placed inside lovely gift boxes. Super friendly and responsive staff. Definitely my new go-to for cookie gifting.
Baldwin Kayla Marie
INCREDIBLE COOKIES. I have been going to City Cakes for a few years and always take friends/family here. A cookie for everyone. They're HUGE, so you get your money's worth and are actually good. Soft, thick, chewy, buttery...everything a cookie should be. Plus they have specialties so check them out on Insta!
tms
Love the funfetti cakes and cupcakes! Also had a Reese’s pieces peanut butter cookie. Everything is delicious and not too sweet. Friendly and helpful staff!
Raymond Knudsen
Great cookies! Had the Dark Horse Salted Double Chocolate Chip and Signature Sugardoodle. You’re paying $5-$6 for one, but they’re huge cookies.
Kelley Wheeler
Hands down, the BEST cookies! The shop is cute and so many flavors and treats to choose from. I was in NY for 4 days, and came here twice. Ugh, so good!! I would say I wish we had one in Texas, but no need when you can order online and have them mailed to you. Dangerous for my wallet, but sooooooo worth it!! Yum yum yymmmmmm
Yelena Gelzayd
Great experience ordering birthday cake for my kid! I got lemon flavored cake with chocolate frosting. The cake was moist and the frosting was perfect - not too sugary and very nice chocolate flavor. But the best thing was the design! I asked for a birthday cake with a monkey on top and the execution could not be more perfect, the monkey was adorable. I didn't even get a chance to take a picture of the whole cake since a bunch of children swarmed me and demanded to eat the monkey.
Acai Bowls Alfredo Aligot Apple pie Arancini Arroz Negro Artichoke Salad Baba Ghanoush Baby Back Ribs Baccala Bagels Baguette Baked Ziti Bananas Foster Bangers And Mash Bass Beef Beef Bourguignon Beef Cheeks Beignets Bento (Lunch Box) Bibimbap Biscuits and gravy Blood Sausages BLT Bolognese Bouillabaisse Bread Pudding Breakfast Burrito Breakfast Sandwich buckwheat crepes Burger Burrito Burrito Bowl Cakes Calamares Calamari California Roll California Style Pizza Cannelloni Cannoli Carbonara Carrot Cake Cashew Chicken Cassoulet Catfish Caviar Cesar Salad Ceviche Cheeseburger Cheesecake Cheesecakes Cheesesteak Chicharrón Chicken Alfredo Chicken And Waffles Chicken fried steak Chicken Kiev Chicken Parmesan Chicken Sandwich Chicken Wings Chili Chili Crab Chilli Chicken Chocolate mousse Chow Mein Chowder Churrasco Cioppino Clam Chowder Clams Club Sandwich Cobb Salad Cockle Cod Cod fritters Confit Coq au Vin Corn dogs Corned Beef Corvina Couscous Crab Crab Cake Crab Legs Crab Rangoon Crawfish Creme Brulee Crepes Crispy Pata Croque Madame Croque Monsieur Croquettes Crostini Cuban Sandwich Cucumber Salad Cupcakes Curry Deep dish pizza Dim Sum Donburi (Rice Bowl) Doner Kebab Donuts Duck Duck Confit Dumplings Eclairs Eggplant Eggs Benedict Entrecote Escalivada Escalope Escargot Etouffee Fajitas Falafel Fattoush Fava Beans Fettuccine Alfredo Filet Mignon Fish Fish & Chips Fish Sandwich Fish Soup Fish Taco Focaccia Foie gras Fondue French Dip French Fries French onion soup French Toast Fried Artichokes Fried Clams Fried pickles Fried shrimp Frog Legs Frozen Yogurt Galettes Gazpacho Gefilte Fish Gelato Goat cheese salad Green Curry Grilled cheese Gyros Haddock Hake Halibut Halloumi Ham Croquettes Hamburgers Hanger steak Hoagie Hokkien Mee Hot Dog Hot Pot Hummus Ice Cream Italian Beef Jambalaya Japanese Curry Juice & Smoothies Kabobs Kale Salad Kare kare Key lime pie Kobe Beef Korean Fried Chicken Kung Pao Chicken Laksa Lamb chops Lamb Shoulder Lasagne Lechon Lemon tart Lettuce Wraps Lobster Lobster rice Lobster Roll Lumpia Mac and cheese Macarons Macaroons Mandarin Duck Matzo Ball Soup Meat Paella Meatballs Meatloaf Meringue Minestrone Mortadella Moussaka Mushroom Croquettes Mussels Nachos New York Style Pizza Noodle Octopus Okonomiyaki & Takoyaki (Flour Dish) Omelette Osso Buco Oxtail Croquettes Oyster Pad Thai Paella Paella Valenciana Pancakes Pasta Pastrami Sandwich Patatas Bravas Peking Duck Perogies Philly Cheesesteak Pho Po' Boys Poke Bowls Polenta Pollock Porchetta Pork Cheeks Pork Loin Pork Roll Pork Tenderloin Porterhouse Steak PORTERHOYSE STEAK Poutine Prawns Pretzel Profiteroles Prosciutto Pulled Pork Sandwich Quail Quail Eggs Quenelle Queso Quiche Raclette Ramen Razor Clams Red Curry Reuben sandwich Rib Steak Ribs Rice pudding Risotto Roast Beef Roast Chicken Roe Roquefort Salad Salad Nicoise Salmon Salmon Salad Saltimbocca Sandwiches Scallops Schnitzel Seafood Paella Seafood Platters Shawarma Shellfish Shrimp Shrimp and Grits Shrimp Salad Sirloin Steak Sisig Snails Soup Dumplings Souvlaki Steak Frites Steak Sandwich Steak Tartare Steamers Suckling Pig Sukiyaki & Shabu Shabu Surf And Turf Swordfish T-Bone Steak Tacos Tagliatelle Tandoori Chicken Tapas Tarte Tatin Tataki Tater tots Tempura Tikka Masala Tilapia Tiramisu Toasts Tomato Bread Tonkatsu Torte Tortellini Tortelloni Tortillas Tostones Tres Leches Tripe Tuna Tuna Melt Turkey Burger Turkey Sandwich Udon & Soba (Wheat & Buckwheat Noodle) Unagi & Dojo (Eel & Soil) Veal Kidneys Veggie Burger Waffle Fries Waffles Waffles & Crepes Wings Yakiniku (Japanese BBQ) Yakitori (Grilled Skewers) Yellow Curry
Share on WhastApp
Share on Facebook
Browse the menu
Add review