The best Baked Ziti in New York City | Sluurpy updated in April

"Coupons are here..."

Disne

"The entrance door gives no hint of the world inside.The crowds,the ambience,the old church architecture with stained glass windows were all a big..."

Hungry Cow

"Bom serviço, pizza boa mas que não se destaca de outras tantas. Preço ligeiramente caro para a refeição. Em relação a quantidade, muito bem..."

Antonio Miguel Ribeiro

"Excellent pizza! There aren't many true authentic NY style pizza restaurants in the tourist areas, but this one of the best. Coal fired ovens make..."

Foodliness

"Very indifferent sort of pizzas. The rightly cooked pizzas with am amazing blend of taste. Loved the food and loved the ambience. The size is huge..."

Ritika Arora

"I Love pizza, believe my friends johns pizza is best this place. i will visit john pizza with my friends and family next week. and i will invite my..."

Md Amzad Hossain

"The pizzas are tremendous! Size of a US Manhole, a lot of sustenance at the cost, the main thing I would propose is ensure the cheddar on the pizzas..."

FoodMyMood

"Believe me friendsThis place is just "the best" for pizzas!!Pizzas along with garlic bread can give you some serious taste bud..."

Dhruv Bhardwaj

"Great buzzing ambiance, muscular friendly service (NY style) and of course flying saucer pizzas landing hot, spicy and deliciously on top of your..."

Hal Carim

"We came to New York eager to try some authentic NYC pizza, and decided on John's. They didn't disappoint. Authentic style pizza's, really well cooked..."

Ana Pedic

"Muy buen lugar para ir en un grupo grande.Las pizzas son bastante contundentes, recomiendo la pizza clásica de mozzarela.El lugar es..."

Nicole Marie Roiter Clément

"BEST. PIZZA. I'VE . EVER. HAD.I can still remember the taste of that extra cheesy pepperoni pizza in my mouth. I can't wait to go to NYC..."

Jen

"Good quality, delicious food that you will like. Large variety, good drinks, spacious, comfortable. Service was good, people were friendly. Prices..."

Can

"Ambience was great! We arrive and have to wait for table for 10 minutes so we went to the bar. The guy was not very friendly to us. After a beer, we..."

Pedro Brás

"Great food! The service was pretty good for the amount of people there. Would highly recommend! Very close to Times Square and several other..."

Morgan Zander

"Stumbled upon John’s Pizzeria while walking through the theater district, in search of authentic New York style pizza. Somewhere between Shubert..."

Anviksha Singh

"This place was fantastic. We had the margherita pizza, and it was simple, fresh, and executed perfectly. The crust was extraordinary. The wait time..."

Steve

"Think about pizzas in Times Square and I would strongly recommend John's pizza which has a brilliant atmosphere, mouthwatering aroma and..."

Dr. Foodie ..

"Ambiance: this pizza place is massive! There are two floors for seating convenience. The lighting is dim, but romantic in a way. The aroma of freshly..."

Krishna Sanjay

"John's was recommended to us by a friend. Popular place near the Broadway shows. It is in a reconditioned church. Our wait was supposed to be 1hr,..."

TroyRad

"Always a fantastic pizza experience. The pizza is made fresh to order in a brick oven and the crust has an amazing chew and charred taste. Classic..."

Choppa

"Pizzas muy ricas y sabrosisimas... Cuando fuimos el lugar estaba lleno y esa pudo haber sido una de ñad razones del porqué se demoraron tanto en..."

Javiera Fich Cubillos

"We really enjoyed the pizza at John's pizza of time square. Well I had a few minutes before our theater time to eat and they prepared one to go which..."

Jack L Slentz

"Pizzas de gran calidad y tamaño, la masa es increíble! Probamos la Margaritha, simple pero deliciosa. Probé también la sangría, no es la mejor..."

Goncorleone

"Nice place for pizza .. thin crust .. huge 12 inches (small) and 16 inches (large) pizzas.If you are at times square.. it is a 5 min walk....."

Nirav Ranpuria

"The food was fantastic, had calamari for an appetizer that was great, and a huge pizza that fed three people. The service was slow, and he restaurant..."

Sydney

"This was the only pizza place we tried in NYC and we weren't impressed with the taste. The servings were huge though for just the two of us. Clearly..."

Foodbook

"This place is BANANAS!!! Amazing pizza! Fresh Mozzarella. Fresh abundant toppings. Baked to perfection! The atmosphere is nice and the wait staff is..."

PickyEater69

"I'll keep it simple. Best pizza in the world! Have the sausage pizza any time I'm lucky enough to get by there. Last trip was to New Jersey, but made..."

Mike Wood

"We visited in May 2010, but I still can remember the taste and the joy I had at eating these extraordinary pizzas! The service and the ambience is..."

Swati Chitalia

"Margherita pizza was very good. I really did enjoy the margherita pizza here. They got the sauce just right. Cheese and herbs were fresh and..."

Meglarson

"Holy Pies! We swung by John's after catching a Knicks game (partly because it was the only thing open that late) and not knowing what to expect we..."

IMONGRY

"Good pizza, might not be worth the wait.. This place has a sweet location, so expect a wait on many occasions. It is a good slice, though. There are..."

Ianorlo

"Lunch review. At first we went there on Friday at around 7pm... And the line was ridiculous. 2 hour wait to be seated for a party of 2. Went there..."

Pr0xy2600

"The dining room is large and open, something unique in a city with tables crowded together. We were seated on the upper level, which afforded us a..."

Randy_A

"Very nice pizza, we'll made and tasted good. Service was so-so. Wait staff could use some food handling safety refresher. I'd go back..."

Adele

"Garlic rolls are outstanding. Pizza is good too. Ranch leaves something to be desired. No Coke or Dr Pepper is a bummer for this Southerner. Building..."

Flint

"Fantastic NYC..."

Rayanne DuChane

"Best thin pizza in..."

Courtney Cerrone

"If you are looking for great pizza this is the place in Midtown New York..."

Michael Daniel

"This place is massive upstairs and down stairs. Need to wait however the pizza is very good... Will enjoy it and only a stone throw away from Times..."

Food 2 Run

"We got the Chicken Parmigiana w/ ziti, pepperoni pizza, baked ziti w/ drinks. Very very good. The place used to be an old church. Very nice. Great..."

Brian

"Great Food!. Seeing the crowds this place draws I thought it would take over an hour to get a table.... Only waited about 25 minutes until we were..."

Matt

"Solid pizza ... no guff about it .... Went here late the first night we arrived. Ordered a standard pie with mushrooms. The pizza came out in 15..."

Leigh

"Great for the family. This is our first time to NYC as a family. My wife, three boys and I have just returned back to the hotel following a long day..."

Canuckinaus

"Probably the best pizza I've had in New York. Awesome food, and a good beer selection on tap. Very convenient location and large restaurant. Highly..."

Joe

"John's Pizza on 44th St. A NYC treasure. Good pies (pizzas) PLEASE DON'T EVER ASK FOR A SLICE! True thin crust pie that we have shared with friends..."

Mike

"Awesome pizza! Beautiful restaurant located in an old church, great service, and hot pizza right out of a brick oven! Can't get any better than that..."

Erin T

"I've tried more 12 step programs than Lyndsey Lohanny to control my pie addiction. Ohhh, this pie rocks...it's hard to argue with that oven..."

Richie Naq

"Hey!!!! As a true Texan who knows ZIP about pizza.....This Pie is a Religious Experience!!!!!!! SIMPLY..."

Chris P.

"Dessert is yummier than pizza. I consider myself a pizza snob, having gone to at least half of the top 10 zagat rated pizzerias in NYC like Joe and..."

NodAicrag

"Great atmosphere, good pizza. Loved the space. Church turned pizza house. Short wait, but great bartender that got the beer out quick. I wouldn't..."

Rodger

"We are staying at the Marriot at TS, heard good things about John's. We decided to just order and pick up. We got a large cheese, garlic rolls,..."

SGamble

"Great food, good..."

Love Eating

"Good Italian Food. My wife and I visited John's Pissa on 44th st. about a year ago. We found the pizza to be fantatastic. It was thin crust and quite..."

Don

"Really good pizza. Nice ambiance. Service is ok. We were there for..."

Miami Spice

"I would like to say how much I miss this place..generous toppings and cheesiness all around. Was a nice setting to reunite with dear friend who also..."

Forget_love-id_rather_fall_in_chocolate

"Fantastic authentic Italian pizza served by great servers. Very enjoyable. Wine list appropriate for the menu. Celebrity sighting was a..."

MtnBrookMum

"Amazing tasting wings and pizza with pepperoni . Waitress Hayley was a pleasure and nice to guests. Would come back again and again and again!!!!..."

Alex Gilkis

"Very good!! Pizza is amazing and very cheesy, the ziti is extraordinary, and the service is excellent. Definitely go with a..."

Maddie

"Love the pizza. Pasta dishes are great too. Service can be hit or miss. Tonight our garlic rolls appetizer was served with out meal and and a request..."

Songbird1329

"Amazing brick pizza and best calamari I've ever had...and I have had a lot of..."

Craigle Bagel

"Church of Pizza!. Fantastic atmosphere and better yet, awesome pizza. My family and I ended up ordering more! I think we started with one pie, and..."

Erin

"Having salad and..."

Becky Morehead

"Wow! Beautiful setting with the glass dome, very friendly service(gave us a jug of root beer on the house!) Excellent pizza, wait for table might be..."

Jaime Dostar

"No garlic powder, no slices. They do not service Pizza by the slice. The Pizza was good. Disappointed that they do not have garlic powder. The..."

77Cobra

"Return Visit. Each time I come back to NY, this is a must for me. I love the pizza. This place can get noisy, but I just love the..."

Sue Ward

"Excellent pizza, lively environment, and not bad wait time even when crowded. However, our server was not particularly personable and was not always..."

Matt

"Good Pizza. The service was good, and the pizza was as well. We were seated and served quickly. Plenty of space and I would go back... but nothing..."

BRANE

"Quick and easy. Great lace to start or end an evening in the village.No frills, just good basic pizza in a warm..."

JP

"The best pizza ever. This place was beautiful. It was packed, but the service was impeccable. The garlic bread was a phenomenal starter and the pizza..."

Micha

"Insane Good Pizza. This is not your typical pizza joint, here you are seated in what use to be a church, you are smack right in the middle of the..."

Fallen

"1/2 and 1/2. Half pepperoni/Italian sausage and fresh mushrooms....delicious! Just enough flavorful sauce and tons of cheese! Piping hot, served just..."

Kimberly Lockwood Moore

"And they deliver!. Have had John's delivered twice and on both occasions the pizza arrived hot with amazingly crisp crust. The sauce is bright and..."

Brent Byers

"Pizza Heaven. Very popular spot, so wait lines are common. Fantastic pizza is super rehab'd interior. Service could have been faster, but overall was..."

Marc A

"The famous coal-fired brick oven thin crust cheese pizza lived up to it's claim. We had john's traditional and it was the best cheese pizza I have..."

Savanna

"Loved it. We loved the pizza. It was cooked exactly how it should have been. The cheese, sauce, and pepperoni were delicious and the amount of each..."

Leo

"Let's Go to Church. Literally the midtown sanctuary of pizza, this former gospel church with stained-glass dome ceiling now boasts two coal-fired..."

Amuse Bouche

"Perfect NY Style Pizza. I generally avoid restaurants near uber-touristy areas like the plague, as they have no incentive to provide even mediocre..."

Mariposa

"Just happened on to this place as we were looking for a pizza and beer to unwind after a day of shopping in the city. I will definitely recommend..."

Jane S.

"Great NYC pizzaria...kid friendly, fast and fantastic. Pizza, salad and drinks for four - $50.00. Great location. We will be..."

Holly

""HOW to DO John's - an Education". 1. This is considered, among true NYers and those who know what NY pizza should taste like, to be some of the best..."

Nycvagabond

"Good Pizza, Great Location!. The pizza is good at John's, not great. This is the kind of place you go to... just to see the unbelievable..."

Alfonso Narcolo

"Great after theater dining. Good food and fun little place in the theater..."

Melissa Roney Freebern

"Not only the best pizza- Also the best place to get a bottle of Chateau Julien..."

Robert Brower

"Very good pizza, a little on the expensive side but still worth it. I wasn't impressed with the garlic bread but it was OK. Lots of tables but they..."

Tim Raymond

"Top notch pizza in a former broadway play house. Really is a cool..."

Voldar

"Great crust and cheese but the sauce could be tastier and more abundant. Like it better than most in new York but still prefer mellow..."

Rezisluh

"Great experience all around. Ordered a 'customized' pizza (chicken and broccoli) that hit the target. Best Midtown pizza I have had yet. Fun old..."

Scrap Fe

"Always preferred Chicago pizza over NY but after this restaurant I may change my..."

Keith A. Greer

"Good pizza and salad and the atmosphere is nice. Get a table..."

Dane Falgout

"Good but not great. Our lunch came out to $50. Small pie, salad, and..."

BIG Ant

"I luv this place!!!! The food is great na great dessertn the shape of a bear!!! Its soooo..."

Caitlyn

"Amazing pizza. Not so amazing service. Pizza trumps service so I'd go back. Just won't leave..."

RonB

"Miss this place. Used to live pretty close to John's but I moved away... and regret it. In retrospect, I should've moved directly into Johns...."

RL

"I love this restraunt it's amzing. they do the best sobet and they serve the pizza on stands. I'm not going to spoil it to much..."

Gabriel Hynes

"We love this place,it is huge but with buzzing atmosphere.the staff were delightful and the pizza the best I have had in New..."

Anna M

"Great Food and Atmosphere. Food is very good and a great price for Manhattan. They don't do slices, so you must get a full pie-but totally worth is..."

Dmo00277

"Fun place to eat in midtown. I love Johns Pizzeria. Their pizza is hot and gooey and perfect every time. Pizza not your thing? Their other entrees..."

Destiny J

"New York City pizza is, hands down, the best pizza on the planet. Chicago natives will try to argue this, but I will stand firm. MUST GET PIZZA,..."

Fantasticfood

"Next time you’re in New York walking around Times Square looking for good pizza please do yourself a favor and hit up John’s Pizzeria. John’s..."

Big Ass Kid

"I was a bit confused with the pizza menu at Johns, with two pizzas that looked the same, the traditional and the margherita and when I asked with the..."

FoodMeUpScotty

"Easily one of the most famous pizza restaurants in the city, John's sits in the heart of the Theater District. It's located in a beautiful building..."

Songbird1329

"The crust was good, crispy and not floppy, with a nice char. My favorite was the pizza bianca that fortunately did not have garlic. I also..."

I Just Want To Eat

"So overall, this pizza was honestly one of the best I’ve ever had and I recommend anyone in the Times Square area to make a stop at John’s..."

Adam Bryan

"After some recommendations, Chris and I decided to get pizza for lunch at John’s Pizzeria, which was on the same street as the theater. Our plan..."

Jen Masa

"We strolled over towards time square/ broadway and walked through this hidden door into a huge restaurant with brick pizza ovens in the dining..."

Anthony

"The Pizza came out very hot, the topping portions, cheese and sauce were perfect all..."

@PghBrian

"We visited John's of Times Square on the advice of my Sister in law, who visits when she's in New York City. The restaurant is housed in an old..."

Captain Midnight

"Amazing pizza and great atmosphere. The whole place looked stunning, with an amazing feeling. The staff were average and friendly. I got a salad..."

Alex Yang

"Who would think that in the middle of Times Square there would be a great pizza place in an old converted church. Well here it is. The owners..."

A.L. Harris

"The history of this place is what's so captivating. I highly recommend to go read about it on their website. The service here makes you feel like an..."

Kimberly Fuentes

"Had to stop in here. Stopped in on a Friday night, busy as heck. I was able to get a seat at the bar. All I wanted was a pie. The service was fast,..."

Kalvin Thompson

"Good pizza. I would try to tone your visit during an off hour. Like a brunch or a linner time. It gets very busy. The building used to be an old..."

Luke Carlson

"The pizza was very good. It was not too soft or floury, the crust was so good, I usually don’t eat crust. Service was good, nothing extraordinary,..."

CE Begay

"Beautiful place! Only my third time ever. Good tasting pizza, but a little too much flop IMO. We asked for "thin and crispy" and server said "that's..."

Joey FLORIDA

"We came to John’s of Time Square right after the show, we were sited right away. We had the Margarita Pizza and the Mozzarella ricotta pizza it was..."

Laire Avila

"Apparently at one time John's on Bleecker and the John's on Broadway were part of the same store but they are separate now. Yet they use the same..."

Reset

There are 12 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Baked Ziti in New York City

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Debbie Jaffee

Carrie Cardis Gynn

Susan Marie

John Fix

Dina Keyte Scungio

Gina Hughes-Thomas

Chelsea Brach

John Hight

Robert Presar

Willie Reyes

Melanie Ford

Mark Cidade

veronica sparrow

Susan J H

Bruno Seixas

jenny weller

Amy Cole

Patricia Gonzalez

William O'Neill

Magnus Mootoo

Jane Leung

Mayra Salinas

R L

Diana Eide

Aaron Collymore

Denis Mantsurov

Sonali Bhatnagar

Jim Secker

Foodie327!

J Y

Michelle

Blake Smith