nikki
WOW! Get to this restaurant immediately. We had a late lunch on a Friday after a couple of museums in the area. Covered sidewalk tables were available to make it more special.
The service was impeccable and so friendly and helpful for tourists.
The food - top meal in Manhattan. I ordered the watermelon and burrata salad and it was seriously one of the most amazing meals I’ve had. My companion ordered a meatball calzone and was more than delighted. He has a heartily appetite and couldn’t quite finish it - definitely something to share.
I cannot say enough good things about this place and cannot wait to go back on my next trip.
Isabella Cauley
We love the food so much we decided to have our wedding reception here. They were amazing, kind, and wonderful. The food was great. All our guests were raving about how delicious and well prepared the meal was.
Despite having a 20+ guests, they were able to bring out all our food hot and in a timely manner. No one went unsatisfied. We also had an incredible amount of dietary restrictions for individuals and they were able to accommodate us all.
brooklyn eve
This is a sophisticated pizza restaurant with a great range of food and drink options. It was a lovely place to have dinner as the sun set, and there were really cute fairy lights all around the outside area, making it an even more magical experience. Everyone at my table very much enjoyed their meal, and we hope to come back here at some point.
Nick Yoo
We went here after searching for a place to eat, and thank goodness we came to this spot. We ordered the 12” Margarita Pizza and the Rigatoni Bolognese. The pizza was delicious, the crust was crispy and flavorful and the sauce with the melted mozzarella was sweet and savory. The Rigatoni was to die for, it had such a exquisite meaty taste with a sweet and herbal taste from the tomatoes and spices. Lastly we also got the Chocolate mousse from Harlem Baking Co., and it was fabulous. The mousse was not too sweet and the soft airy texture melted in your mouth. Sammy was very friendly, informative and a great server! I would definitely recommend this place!!
N G
I was on the eat side of Harlem and was in the mood for pasta so a friend recommended this place. They offer both in door and outdoor dining and it wasn’t super fancy or upscale which was great. I had on my work clothes and didn’t want to feel out of place. The service was great and my food came pretty fast. I ordered the spaghetti carbonara which was delicious. I’ll definitely be coming back to try out some of the other pasta dishes.
Ayodeji Otuyelu
This is a hidden gem, something about the name that makes me to always walk passed it with no interest. But when I finally tried their food it was absolutely delicious. Their artichoke is a die for. The owner was gracious and kind. Their happy hour is ridiculously good
Tracy Chan
Food was alright. The chefs gave my little brother a dessert on the house.
Alee AR
So I really liked this place. The ambience here is good and the food is amazingly delicious. We ordered a pizza “Di buffala & arugula” which was super tasty, we also had two Sicilian slices one of chicken and the other of four cheese.
The only reason why I give just 4 stars is that the prices are in some way high, I mean $22 for a thin crust pizza is a lot even more that there are places that serve oven pizzas as delicious as this place with the same quality and they don’t charge that much.
We ended up paying around $40 just for one pizza and two Sicilian slices, no drinks.
So if you want to come just keep in mind the prices.
A feed back for the pizzeria: you should add tomato sauce to the Sicilian four cheese. We liked it but it would be way better with tomato sauce on the base.
Angie Lee
I’ve dined here and delivered from here a few times. Overall great, but there are some times when the taste is mediocre. Nice outdoors brunch spot, but were visited by many bees who were obsessed with my food in picture. I removed the orange thinking that must be what they were after, but turns out it’s the hollandaise sauce
cociamo71 49
The customer service is amazing! This restaurant has outdoor seating. The cheesecake is a MUST, they come in adorable little mason jars and the flavor is just out of this world! The food was great as well. Definitely coming again!
Angela Ramirez
Brunch was amazing. Service was great ! 10/10 recommend.
Cara Polte
Such a great place! Truly a gem. Amazing staff, great service, and delicious food. Always happy to have it!! Pictured is the penne vodka! Super yummy!
Carmen Plaza
I like this place. Been here several times. Cute place. Outdoor seating. Good food and service. They have a nice brunch. And the cheesecake ohhh yummy love the biscotti crust one.
Diana Zuluaga
We went to this restaurant because they were participating in an Open Streets weekend. They had spacious sidewalk seating, awnings and umbrellas to protect from the sun. We had an uneven number so they graciously rearranged a table and chairs for us. The staff wore masks and gloves at all time. We arrived for brunch because of the unlimited cocktail option and the mimosa that I purchased came in an individual carafe. The brunch dish I chose, Le Sandwich, was a wonderful combination of eggs, bacon and mozzarella cheese nestled between two slices of french toast with a maple dipping sauce. With the drinks flowing, we closed out the brunch window and ended up staying through for an early dinner. I ordered two really fantastic dishes, the mushroom rice balls and the seasonal burrata which came with watermelon and toast points. I look forward to dining here during the colder months if indoor dining resumes.
Diviana Crispin
What an Amazing place. Authentic, good quality tasting food. What’s not to like at all about the place?? I truly recommend a must place to come and enjoy good Italian food!!
Terry Boyd
Best service! Patrick and Maria are so customer service oriented you'd think it was their kitchen! The sauce is what I base an Italian restaurant on and theirs tastes like my Nanas! Was there no less than 8 times on my previous trip to the city, never dissapointed!
Yonacary Wingard
The best pizza in town hands down! Thank you! Well be back next time we are in NYC
Lourdes Gigi Yusal
i will keep on coming back. another authentic italian place.
Perrine Darroman
We tried their Pizza, Pasta and their famous Artichokes and everything was perfect!
Jason Francis
One of the best restaurants in Manhattan!! Highly recommend. Food is great and the service is incredible! Very friendly and hospitable. A favorite when I'm back in the city!
Debra Caines
Love love love this place!!! Food is amazing and the service is the same!
Ro Con
So super close to mount Sinai hospital and it's the best Italian around the neighborhood! It's my new go to spot!!!!
Abbey Plotkin
To Charles and ALL the staff at this FANTASTIC restaurant, THANK YOU for making my Birthday even MORE FABULOUS!!! The food at your establishment is SUPERB and the service IMPECCABLE!!!! Our group couldn't have picked a better restaurant. EVERYONE was impressed!!! I KNOW I'll be back and I think all of the folks who were with me will, as well. So happy I lucked out and found such an amazing spot!!!
Jonathan Bergman
WOW! Another AMAZING dinner! The tomato sauce is just wonderful and I want it on everything.
Aracelli Ibasache
great food and price
Elle Young
Unfortunately I had a really TERRIBLE experience at Lexington Pizza Parlor with some of my Mount Sinai family and friends. From the moment we walked in, we were treated like second class citizens at this restaurant. We are a younger crowd (mid-20s, medical students) but were not taken seriously as customers from the minute we entered LPP. We were given PAPER plates to eat off of, not given silverware or napkins, nor offered bread and olive oil like the rest of the customers and the staff completely ignored us the entire night. Everyone else in the restaurant was eating off of ceramic plates with real silverware, cloth napkins and offered free bread and olive oil as part of their meal. The worst part is that I have been to LPP before with my boyfriend and had a great experience (complete with ceramic plates, napkins, real cutlery and bread and olive oil and an attentive wait staff.) However, tonight was just HORRIBLE. Maybe the paper plates/no cutlery/terrible service doesn't sound like a big deal to someone, but it is completely disrespectful to your customers to treat them differently from your other customers, no matter their race (we all happened to be Asian as well), age, sex or other factors. No customers should be treated differently based on their appearances. DO NOT SUPPORT LEXINGTON PIZZA PARLOR.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes