A Booth
Consistent always good Italian restaurant for pizza, pasta, and wine.
It’s massive inside so great for a last second choice any night of the week because you can usually get a table quickly even on a Friday night.
Up front is a bar area with a lot of seating and food service if there is a long wait.
Affordable wine list too.
This is a great place for groups of 6-8 because of the large round tables for that size as opposed to a long table. If you’re making a reservation for that size make sure and ask for them.
Shay Williams
Really authentic Italian restaurant, great vibes and delicious food. A little pricey for the special that were too too special. The desserts were all amazing, get the gelato (three scoops recommended).
Karen Williamson
Fantastic. All the food was delicious. Brian/Bryan was a fantastic server. He was very friendly and helped us learn a bit about the area and answer our questions. He even had a dish made for us that wasn't on the menu to accommodate us. Can't wait to return.
Cindy Schulz
Always great service and food is phenomenal. Meats and cheese, salads, truffle homey is to die for. Pizzas are great whether savory and decadent to simple and classic. Oh and you must not forget the olive oil sorbetto.... Must get even if you're stuffed.
Katherine Chin
The service was attentive, and the food was great: my spinach salad with truffle honey was amazing and aromatic. The gelato and affogato were both good, although quite expensive for the size. They also offer gluten free pasta.
Alisha Varde
This place is lovely! If you like Italian wines, you’ll love this wine menu! While my uncle and I were eating pizza, another guest knocked over our wine glass, spilling wine all over my pizza. The staff is so attentive and kind, that they replaced my pizza right away and gave me some veggies to munch on while I waited. Definitely coming back for wine tasting!!
Ana Colliton
Hand-made, goat cheese agnolotti pasta. Need I say more? Absolutely incredible job @ottopizzeria 😋 This #pasta dish was absolutely delicious, like biting into little pasta poppers of cheesy joy. Sounds crazy, but that is an accurate description 😂 If you don’t believe me, try for yourself!
Melanie Cardona
Great energy. Extensive wine list. It's a big menu overall. We tried a lot of different things and enjoyed them all. I think my favorite was the anchovies with the croutons!
Douglas Kim
Enjoyed the truffle pasta, but liked the Carbonara even more. The four cheese pizza was also good.
Michael Tcheyan
This wonderful Italian bistro serves a terrific pizza and great appetizers. perfect for a large group order a lots of different meals and share them with a good bottle of wine or even better the rose prosecco. it's located right near Washington square park in Greenwich village. make sure you take a walk around walk and see the arch and the fountain and listen to the musicians that are always playing in the area.
Merissa Kochanski
2nd time I've been here, this time for the pizza which I'd give a 6-7 it's good. I remember the pastas being better. They also give you a nice bread basket and olive oil.
Gregor J. Rothfuss
Super busy spot, but the dishes are solid, with attentive service. The thin crust pizzas and the fresh pasta are the highlights.
Gregor H
Very good Napoli style pizza (had the Quattro formaggi), fairly good pasta in a lively setting. Service is reasonable efficient but it does get busy.
Very extensive wine selection, but priced a bit high for my taste. I guess I may be spoiled from Italy where the restaurant mark-up on wine is generally moderate. Here a €10 Verduno comes out at $50 and Brunellos run in the hundreds.
Kris H
Great place to share a pizza and a pasta. Really enjoyed it and the extensive wine list. Just around the corner is Washinton park so you can enjoy a bit of people watching before or after dinner. Typical pricing and service for a mid to higher end restaurant in the area.
Francesca Caviglia
Good cocktails, an excellent Negroni, and decent Italian food. The food missed the mark a bit overall, for those experienced in Italian cuisine - the pasta was good but the sauce wasn't great (bucatini), the pizza is alright but the crust is a bit too crispy, no bite (we had the prosciutto arugula). Ambiance is good and reasonably priced (cocktails, pizzas, pastas all around $15) but nowhere near the best Italian food you can find.
Chris
Absolutely impeccable. Personal and professional service from Dennis at the bar made my son and me feel like old friends when we stopped in for lunch after a visit and university tour at NYU. If I ever had a place where I wanted to be a regular, this is it... no question. Try the Meatballs & Fresh Chilies (brisket meatballs) paired with the Colli Tortonesi Rosso. Outstanding!
Adams_coffee
Easy going. Traditional Italian restaurant (though expensive) right near Washington Square Park. Love this place!
Jessica Staller
Best thing here is always pizza. Any time I order anything else it pales in comparison. I'd recommend getting a few pizzas and sharing. The cacio e pepe pizza is amazing. The desserts are also great. Haven't had a bad one yet. Huge wine list. Grab a bottle or two for the table.
Mithun Bhat
Great food with a varied selection of wines. Can get a bit loud during peak hours.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes