Review Magnolia Bakery - New York City

Sakina Huzefa

I know the reviews on the banana pudding are mixed, but we really enjoyed it. We also tried the hummingbird cake and it was DELICIOUS. This place is a no brainer if you enjoy desserts

Hailey

The cappuccino was pretty good. We arrived around 12:30 on a Friday and they were out of all their gluten free goodies except coconut macaroons. They were tasty.

Young Kim

I’m not even a big fan of bread pudding but my coworker said it was ridiculously good so I decided to get one, red velvet cheesecake & a small latte. All super delicious.. but of course it’s inside grand central station so it’s hard to find a spot to sit and eat peacefully without people walking up to you asking for money and etc. but perfect place to pick up some sweets on way home or flight :)

Julia Alex

The greates red velvet cheesecake ever tasted. You will be thrilled❤️ pay attention that there are no tables to sit, only standing tables available at the Grand central terminal.

Nikole Gomez

Got some Great Banana pudding today and the Customer service was great. Noel was great under pressure when we had so many questions. She knew exactly what we needed and helped us with a smile. Definitely need more people like her in NYC.

Bow K. Techataveekijkul

I finally had the chance to try the Banana Pudding from Magnolia Bakery and it was pretty good! I bought the M size because I figured why not, but it ended up being too much for me to finish in one sitting. The flavor was definitely strong (if you like banana), but it was a bit too rich for my liking.

Samina Aziz

Delicious cupcakes and banana pudding! A must try if you are in NYC.

Cryssi Leumas

Stopped by for their famous Banana pudding which was tasty but not my best dessert. The red velvet cake however, caught my eye, and it was absolutely delectable. I'm definitely visiting again for another slice and to try the carrot-cake.

Channyra Than

Always have to have my cup cake fix when traveling through Grand Central. My personal favorite is chocolate cupcake with vanilla frosting.

Seema Mhaske

Had Banana Pudding for the first time and it's really good. Meets the hype. Took the small size and the portion was big enough for one person even though two of us shared it. Will definitely have it again!

Helene

I’m normally not a fan of banana pudding but this was quite good. My husband isn’t a fan either and he finished the whole thing. It did taste sweet but also light at the same time. Service was not the best but they got the job done so can’t complain.

Mary Britto

Must have if you are in NY! The best banana pudding you would ever have! We were too far from the locations in town so this trip we went to the one at grand central station! It was quick and still amazing :)

Ramiro Alejandro Restrepo

Small outpost for the amazing, delectable treats from Magnolia Bakery. I can see how this location could get busy, but it wasn't when I was there on a Friday morning. I also ordered online for pickup, so just go up to the small pickup counter on the side and get your order! I had the seasonal Red Velvet Banana Pudding (probably my favorite of all) and the regular Banana Pudding. Amazing as always.

Alan Varghese

Great sweet treats as you come to expect from Magnolia but a bit pricey. They have multiple varieties of cheesecakes ($8), cupcakes ($4) (red velvet was amazing), pudding ($5-$8) (banana pudding was exceptional and is there most popular product), cookies($2), cake slice ($6-$7), brownies ($3.5) and many more. They also have coffee, tea, hot chocolate, lemonade etc ($2-$4).

W. L.

Maybe just go for the experience, the cupcakes are very sweet and we feel more the sugar taste than its proper taste. I’d recommend the banana pudding (very sweet but the best bakery I tasted at magnolias so far).

Chi Castagna

Get the banana pudding! It’s heavenly. I didn’t know I liked banana pudding until I tried Magnolia’s and now, I’m hooked. Love that they’re located in Moynihan train hall so I can pick some up before I get on the train. They offer many different flavors in cake slices.