Rosemary's was fantastic. I had smoked lamb shoulder. It was served like pulled pork inside squash. It was really good. I never had lamb served like that before. My wife had their fish special which was also very good. They have a huge wine list and a small beer selection. We were very happy with our experience.
Went here upon the recommendation of a friend who lives in the neighborhood. Was tired, thirsty, not wanting to make decisions. Found a two-top outside and Ronald, my server, welcomed me though I was only one. He chose a lovely white wine so I didn’t have to think about it. The menu was unique but not complicated. Ronald made sure I was well tended to. I used to think MY New York was gone and only existed in my head. Sitting outside Rosemary’s eating alone and watching the neighborhood brought back some of that to me. I purposely asked Ronald to take my phone inside to charge so it would not be a distraction. Very nice experience.
In a word…SPECIAL. Rosemary’s is cozy, fresh verge rustic, utterly romantic and delicious! They give the most genuine care and service I haven’t felt in some time and during the holidays it is MAGICAL! Rosemary’s needs to be on every New Yorker’s short list. This neighborhood haunt even has their own tree lighting ceremony, with the beautiful Jefferson Market Library in the background. The cocktails and food are as good if not better than grandma’s. We were waited on by Madina and she was amazing - we felt in very good hands. There are even personal outdoor dining rooms. Even a rooftop for warmer days. For a memorable night, make Rosemary’s your next stop….. it is unquestionably EXTRAORDINARY.
(See pics of 3 course dinner and cocktails)
Went w a couple friends for dinner on a Friday night in December. The interior decor was the perfect amount of festive. Lots of little lights and greenery. The place was poppin w large groups of women celebrating. Given how many people were in a large space, the acoustics were surprisingly great. We could hear each other and not yell across the table.
The service was absolutely excellent. We ordered a drink at the wine bar when our server came over to seat us. They had the drinks promptly delivered to our table and we didn’t even have to say anything. Felt really nice to be so taken care of!
I got the rigatoni and it just wasn’t great. The chicken Milanese was on the thicker side. The ricotta and eggplant were excellent.
I would absolutely go back though. Great holiday vibes and the staff works so hard!
Definitely a 5 star restaurant! Service & food were great. The atmosphere was beautiful, clean and big enough to have a good amount of space between tables. Apparently I was told that they grow their own herbs on the rooftop. It’s a wonderful place to dine- cozy, could be romantic or even family friendly. I absolutely love the place and will be back.
Lucky to snag a ‘day-of’ reservation during the Christmas holidays! The restaurant was festively decorated with many groups enjoying a great time. We were well taken care of.
I know it’s a busy time of year, but our meals arrived while we were only half way through our appetizers - there was no room to put the meals so plates were awkwardly consolidated to make room the the mains.
Firstly.. to the staff of this restaurant. Thank you! You all repaired my awful day in NY.
This place is absolutely adorable and the relaxing atmosphere is amazing. The staff were phenomenal. And the food was out of this world! Great choices and spectacular flavor!
Will be recommending this to any person coming to NY, even for a single day. Make it a priority to stop by!
This place is HUGE! I came for brunch date and immediately noticed the large dining tables.
The staff here is absolutely lovely. Our server had great recommendations for us. Apparently a lot of their herbs and produce come from their rooftop garden!
All of our food was super tasty and fresh. My favorite was the whipped burrata!
Staffs were good, food overall is good, wine is also good, just the carbonara could have been more authentic. I love the atmosphere the most we went there on Christmas so the vibes is really good
Cute brunch spot with fresh ingredients. Really enjoyed the food. Had the burger which tasted great. Really enjoyed the red onion marmalade.
The olive oil cake and focaccia were amazing. Legit had dreams about the cake.
Mango sorbet tasted like pure mango. So much flavor. The coconut sorbet wasn't as good imo, it was icy and didn't have as much flavor.
Super cute place to eat, chat, and get some delicious drinks!
We were able to join for the tail end of happy hour and $9 for an aperol spritz? Amazing. I’ll be back for that alone.
The food came quickly and everything tasted really good. I definitely recommend adding the Brussels sprouts as a side if you can. Bummed I didn’t get to try a pasta so I’m excited to come back and try more!
love love love this!! the food was amazing and fresh, and the place has a very bright and sunlight atmosphere. You can see the fresh ingredients on their little garden on the roof. service was very kind and patient as well! Pictured are the pesto, chicken, and rigatoni dishes.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in New York City
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes