C Neon
Nice neighborhood pie shop. It features a variety of pie, bread loafs, and drinks. The sour creme walnut apple pie is our favorite, but the sweet potato, key lime, and cheese cakes also are pretty good. The cool thing about this shop is that the owner is there to make sure things are going accordingly to plan and mingle with the customers. A nice touch.
Nicole Louie
Came to little pie co around 7PM and they had a small selection of pies 50% off! I was able to snag a delicious banana coconut cream pie. I also got a triple berry pie and chicken pot pie at regular price. All have been super delicious and I can’t wait to try some more pies
Ana Bassett
We stopped by for an afternoon treat and tried the sour cream walnut apple pie! The sweet and crunchy topping compliments the thinly-sliced apples so well.
The kitchen is visible from the café — a treat to see the bakers do their magic. The service was fast, the space was clean and seating was available. We’ll be coming back here!
Rayhane Tabrizi
Very authentic NUC cheesecake as well as other local specialities.
The coffee and cappuccino are wow like Italy. Highly recommended for the quality of the pastries as well as the kind staff
Courtney Fahn
Nice little eatery with amazing pie! Great service, try the Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie with vanilla ice cream warmed up! The little pies are just right to grab and go. Cupcakes are moist and delicious too! I will definitely come back to try more tasty treats! Love the coziness of the bakery and they bake right in front of you too!
Lena P
Love this place. People are nice. It's clean. Pies and cakes are delicious. These photos are Chicken pot pie and Banana Coconut Cream pie. I also tried the Mississippi Mud, Lemon Meringue, Key Lime, Apple pie with Cheddar crust, and Apple Pear pie. And they provide details for home: cooking and shelf life. Thank you.
Kirstin Leigh
Very cute shop filled with pies, cakes, and cookies! Wasn't in the mood for pie so I got the zebra bar 10/10, lemon cookie 10/10, and carrot cake 10/10!!!
Sade Eastmond
The Little Pie Company was the most beautiful cafe you’ll stumble on. The hospitality starts outside and works its way inside. The neighborhood’s ultimate favorite with outdoor seating available and more.
Victor Wilson
NYC HIDDEN SECRET GEM! Make sure to put this place on your itinerary! Little Pie Company dishes out the most spectacular pies! Both mini personal sized and standard large pies. From Cherry, Mississippi Mud, Apple. Pecan, Key Lime (my fave), Pumpkin you name it! They also have the most legit NY style cheesecake as well as the most delish Brownies, cookies, Bread Pudding, apple filled Coffee Cake, banana bread and mind blowing apple turnovers! I highly recommend the Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie - unforgettable! Just note to pre order these if buying for the holidays (especially Thanksgiving). This is where New Yorkers come for pies as I’ve been for over 30 yrs. Hopefully you’ll be served by Dasia who will not steer you wrong in making the best selections. Little Pie Company never disappoints- the hardest part is not buying one of everything! Guaranteed New York’s Best hands down!
John Vlahos
Great bakery with large selection of baked pies and dessert. Very friendly staff and quick service
Andy Dorman
The chicken pot pie was the best I have ever tasted. We had key lime pie for dessert, and it was perfect. You could taste the key lime with a hint of bitter, and there was the perfect amount of crust.
Felipe Ramos Garcia
I'm not too much of a pie fan. But I must admit that this is the best pie that I've tried. The apple and nuts pie is the best. Highly recommend.
Lesli Klein
I inquired about pies for Thanksgiving. My friend ordered three different ones. They were all delicious. Took home berry one. Ate last piece yesterday.
Butch Hallmark
Had the bourbon pecan pie and Mississippi mud pie. Can't go wrong with either one though I'm partial to the pecan. Highly recommend this place!!!
Stephen Smyly
Nice folks! Excellent baked goods! It's like a little taste of home in the city. The mixed berry pie is great, and so is the Cherry pie. If I could have tried them all, I would have! Great place to sit down, and take your mind off things with a piece of warm pie and ice cream.
Polina Vilderman
Fist real coffee in New York! Amazing cheesecake! And nice service. Will definitely return to this place :)
Michelle King
These folks are Über good! I love their Apple Sour Cream and Walnut Pie! I also love the Cheddar crust apple, it's delish! So much to stay about them, you must visit sometime.
Shari Bowen
Best pecan pie I ever had and their three-berry pie was the bomb!!!!
Nadine Vincent
Sorry to rate so low, but was highly disappointed with the pumpkin (crust like cardboard) and pecan pie (filling tasted like burnt sugar) ordered through Food Direct, last Thanksgiving. Ended up up throwing the pies out.
Ashanti J'aria
Their pie is INCREDIBLE and the coffee is good too .
The staff is very nice. It's quite addictive and I'm not 100% sure there isn't cocaine in the pie🤣🤣🤣. My only complaint is they heat them in a microwave and they taste much better out of an oven.
Lisa Ruocco Grillo
My family loves the sour cream walnut apple pie. It has been a favorite for years and it tastes just as good as the first time that we had it. All the bakery items are delicious �
Kimberly Gatto
The key lime pie was among the best desserts I have ever had in my entire life.
Jazmine Martinez
This is the best place to get some sweets, pies, cupcakes and all that other goodness made with sugar. Sour cream and apple walnut pie is a must!
Susan Fetcho
Stumbled onto this little place on the way to the tour boat from Times Square. Delightful! Friendly service and perfect tiny pies!
Sean James
Love this place!! The selection changes to incorporate seasonal offerings but maintains the standards. Check this place out; you'll be glad you did!
Steve Sussman
Interesting pie-only shop across the street from the Westside Theater. So-so.
Michael U.
Quietly occupying a space at 424 West 43rd Street since 1985 it was as part of a three-stop Breakfast that Little Pie Company was visited, former-actor Arnold Wilkerson’s bakeshop still doing good business in its third decade even though competition has grown tremendously across the five boroughs including the likes of Pies 'n' Thighs, Petee’s, Four & Twenty Blackbirds and Milk Bar.<br/> <br/>In many ways a passion-project for the self-taught baker, years spent at his Grandmother’s elbow fondly remembered as the impetus for this second career, it is through a large window that passers-by are invited into a kitchen where locally sourced ingredients are transformed into rustic Desserts focused on technique and flavor rather than the most recent Instagram fad.<br/><br/>Appropriately located near the Theater District and open until 8pm daily, though guests seeking the largest selection are advised to arrive early, it is by several sizes and styles of Baked Goods that temptation is offered, a Corn Muffin to begin crumbly but not dry and sweetened only a bit by Honey. <br/><br/>Not making any Carrot Cake Cupcakes on this particular morning, Christmas in just three days creating a log-jam of pre-orders, it was instead Coffee Cake with a layer of Apples that was tasted next, the top unfortunately a little over-baked and thus yielding a bitter aftertaste while Little Pie Company’s signature Sour Cream Apple Pie thankfully lived up to its accolades by offering thinly sliced Fruit afloat in semi-savory Custard beneath thick Cinnamon-Sugar Streusel.
Jane Tweety
Sudden hankering for old-fashioned chicken pot pie and the need for not wandering to far from our hotel brought us to Little Pie Company. But don’t let the name fool you as the pie is as satisfying as it can get. The famous to get here is sweet potato but since we prefer salty version, we opt for chicken pot pie and we got what we wanted. Love
Nicola
Great Pie!. Loved their famous sour cream, apple and walnut pie! Absolutely delicious warmed up with a scoop of their vanilla ice cream. We came here on a food tour of Hell's Kitchen, it was so yummy we had to come back and have it again! Great little place for some quality 'home baking' style treats.
Dot
These pies are just okay. the pecan filling was soupy and pecans were not fresh. the three berry pie crust was heavy and soggy. there was more filler than berries. berry pie was not sweet. the pies did not taste freshly baked. i expected better for $30.00 each. pie crust should be flaky.
Rhonda
Good but not great!. I had the key lime & my daughter had the cherry pie. Both were good but not fantastic. $8 for a small individual size pie is way to much! I'm guessing this is because there aren't a lot of places specializing in pie. The shop was more of a take out place & had very few places to sit with any views to the outside. I guess after reading the reviews I was expecting a lot more. Kind of disappointing overall. The staff was nice, however.
SukMon
Granted, I've learned that I'm not a fan of key lime pie - too tart for my taste - but their pie crust is amazing, and the sour cream apple is not bad either.
Jose Morales
Over priced cupcakes... Just the smell is good...
I Just Want To Eat
The Little Pie Company was on my radar for a while and I confess that I lured Jodi to that place, making sure we would pass in front of it when going to the Gotham West Market. Little Pie Company is small, but don't be fooled by its name: the kitchen next to it is of a good size. I was looking around to see what to get, not realizing that they had a banana and coconut cream pie. But trust me, Jodi immediately saw it and ordered it right away as it was the last one and she did not want to see it go to somebody else, leaving me with just couple of minutes to take a decision. I was surely not going for one of the cookies that looked a little sad compared to what you can get at City Bakery or Macchiato. I desperately looked for a cherry pie and then saw a cheesecake with a graham cracker crust. That was my choice. It was pretty good, creamy with the same density as the cheesecake at Junior's. I loved the crust that added another layer of deliciousness and a slight sweetness. Of course I
Fritosandfoiegras
You can smell the Little Pie Company before you can see it. As soon as you turn down 43rd Street, the scent of warm apples mixed with butter and cinnamon fills the air. The open kitchen shows bakers rolling out sheets of dough, sprinkling sugar over fresh fruit, and putting large pies into the oven.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes