We were looking for a quite spot with water views for breakfast on Monday and came across of Star Island Grill. It was a good choice! We loved the ambiance, the setting with water views and reasonable prices. Great value for the money!👌 One thing I strongly recommend: they don’t allow tips to be added if you are using a credit card so you will need cash to tip the waiter. If you don’t have cash on you, that is a major inconvenience!
I went for out breakfast with my husband and our dog. The place is in the Yacht Club Marina. Pet friendly and warm welcome. The morning we went wasn't busy at all and it was raining but we were happy to have place to sit. The breakfast was American style, and the view was extraordinary! I can't imagine in summer night this place is probably pack!
I had an absolutely fantastic experience at Star Island Grill in Montauk! The moment I stepped in, I was captivated by the relaxed yet vibrant ambiance. The menu was a delightful fusion of flavors, offering a range of options to suit various preferences. The seafood dishes, in particular, were incredibly fresh and flavorful, showcasing the essence of Montauk's coastal charm. The staff's friendliness and attentiveness added to the overall positive experience. Whether you're dining with family or friends, Star Island Grill provides a perfect setting with its scenic views and mouthwatering cuisine. I can't wait to visit again and indulge in their culinary delights. Definitely a 5-star dining destination!
Like many years, we dropped off 5lbs of fluke/seabass fillets for the takeout “you hook’em we cook’em” deal…..they did a fantastic job (Blackened, General Tao’s and Tempura), delicious and doesn’t come any fresher then that!! Staff were very accommodating, food trays were well presented…..added rice and we had more than enough for our group of 5 with leftovers…..hence why we keep going back to them!!
Best fish tacos I've ever had. Fish and chips were great too. They told us it was fresh striper. Not expensive either
Excellent food and drinks while watching the sunset, clam chowder and tuna sandwich were very good
Very nice place and dog friendly. The gift store/fishing store is cool too.
A little pricey but, you get what you pay for in service, food and atmosphere!!!
the only place in town that will cook your freshly caught fish for you and they did a fantastic job. tempura fried with a variety of sauces and " bang bang" style were both delicious
An ideal place to eat their or you hook 'em, we cook 'em" at any time of day. Chef Tom and the staff will keep you happy and be sure you leave overfed with outstanding, delicious, fresh food
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Montauk
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes