American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Montauk

"We had chef and owner Shawn Christman at our home as a private chef for our anniversary and I am speechless. He is professional, friendly, kind and..."

Dylan Harvey

Maureen Cruz

All Day At Breakers

Sandbar Montauk

Star Island Grill

"We were looking for a quite spot with water views for breakfast on Monday and came across of Star Island Grill. It was a good choice! We loved the..."

Igor Krasnoperov

"I went for out breakfast with my husband and our dog. The place is in the Yacht Club Marina. Pet friendly and warm welcome. The morning we went..."

Melissa Naja

"I had an absolutely fantastic experience at Star Island Grill in Montauk! The moment I stepped in, I was captivated by the relaxed yet vibrant..."

Michael Kessler

"Like many years, we dropped off 5lbs of fluke/seabass fillets for the takeout “you hook’em we cook’em” deal…..they did a fantastic job..."

Steven Lewandowski

"Best fish tacos I've ever had. Fish and chips were great too. They told us it was fresh striper. Not expensive..."

Chris

"Excellent food and drinks while watching the sunset, clam chowder and tuna sandwich were very..."

Stephen Bibbiani

"Very nice place and dog friendly. The gift store/fishing store is cool..."

B Christopher

"A little pricey but, you get what you pay for in service, food and..."

Kim Hammerschmitt

"the only place in town that will cook your freshly caught fish for you and they did a fantastic job. tempura fried with a variety of sauces and "..."

John DeMelio

"An ideal place to eat their or you hook 'em, we cook 'em" at any time of day. Chef Tom and the staff will keep you happy and be sure you leave..."

Robert Horowitz

The Point

"We grabbed some easy dinner here after visiting the lighthouse few miles away. The sandwiches and burgers were pretty cheap and the taste was..."

Mashiro S

"We were greeted at the door with WARMTH & a SMILE.. Maria, our server had a smile & demeanor that would make customers return.. The food also was..."

Henry Bradley III

"One of the few places in Montauk that offers simple but very tasty and flavorful food at reasonable prices. I highly recommend this restaurant: all..."

Denis Mantsurov

"Really liked the food and the ambience here. They have a large selection of menu items to choose from. We tried their Cajun calamari (super quality..."

Anushka Banerjee

"Finding a restaurant open on the east end is a bit tough on a Tuesday night. We have walked past this restaurant for many years without going in...."

Robert Martin

"Great place, Friendly staff and great food. Tried a few craft beers which where great too. Visiting from UK and loved the whole Halloween vibe. Would..."

Steve Rogers

"Quiet but open during off season. Awesome. Very friendly server. Plenty of brews. Great selection of house cocktails. I was surprised by that...."

H. Jules

"Opening day for football season. I was trying to get a seat at the bar, shame on me for coming late. The place was packed! They found me a table..."

KGB (KGB)

"Cute bar but the food was amazing. Had the Cajun burger and it was cooked exactly how I asked and everything was delicious. Fries also cooked..."

Toria Banco

"It has been atmosphere and the attention is good. the boys were able to see their game and we enjoyed a good wine and an excellent meal. It has an..."

LaLatina EVERYWHERE

"I love the food here! I come here a few times every summer and every time the food is delicious. The service is fast and friendly. It’s also a..."

Stephanie Alegado

"Been coming here for years. Great food. Nice atmosphere. Recommend the sliders...."

Laura Steeneck

"Great food, service a little slow at times but definitely a good spot to eat!! Thank you for your..."

Charles SSS

"I stopped by the other day for lunch. This is a real cool spot. Food was delicious and the service was great. Staff is friendly and the establishment..."

Lisa S

"Food was excellent. The Fish Reuben was different but very tasty and filling. Tables were spread out nicely and drum roll... after months and..."

randall h

"My family loves this great slice of Montauk . Excellent, large bar, boothes and tables can accommodate large groups. Food is good, prices are..."

Craig Casey

"Excellent food and service! Server did pay a lot of attention and drinks came floating our way. Had Philly steak which was great. My wife did have..."

Havi Harv

Naturally Good Foods And Cafe

Accepts American Express

Street Parking

Seating

Accepts Discover

Wheelchair Accessible

Wine and Beer

Gift Cards Available

Free off-street parking

"This is an amazing shop, they have good healthy options for breakfast, lunch and brunch, also selected products at the grocery part, friendly staff,..."

Livia Eastman

"Came in just expecting a quick bite but was pleasantly surprised by the quality and the flavor. I had a Cajun Fish wrap, nachos and a mango smoothie...."

D Euro

"Service with a smile! The Hulk juice was perfect and their special grilled cheese was delicious. Will definitely visit..."

Dan Rivera

"My favorite place in town. The Torta-Rican breakfast burrito is the best I’ve ever had. Great spot to grab reasonably priced but thoughtfully..."

Caitlin Richard

"Cajun tofu sandwich (got it as a wrap) absolutely phenomenal. Fast service. Cute back patio area with tomato plants and flowers as well. Looking..."

Becca Andersen

"Great menu, delicious food, great products. Vegan panna cotta is..."

Zeynep Gunbay

"Delicious sandwiches and wraps. Stopped by on all three days this week during a short winter getaway to Montauk. Friendly service, great selection..."

saumikde

"Great pre-made salads. They also have space in front and in the back to eat the food you buy in the deli..."

Alejandro Fernandez

"This place is always fresh and consistently delicious. From fresh juices & smoothies to wheat Sprout bagels and delicious salads, to sweet little..."

christine

"I got the hummus wrap and chips. This place had a few more vegan options and is located in a store with vegan..."

Miranda Thomason

Swallow East Restaurant

Wheelchair Accessible

"Nice place for small plates. We had them mussels in curry sauce mini octopus tacos. We also had the lamb kebabs and the French fries. We sat out on..."

Barney Simon

"Reggae Sundays & Tuesdays on the back deck, music all summer. Small plates are the specialty, nothing over $18. Fish tacos, lamb kebabs, quinoa..."

Mary McPartland

"Let's get started with the unreal asparagus fries and thai calamari that comes in a takeout box. Snag a frosé while you still can this Summer!!!..."

Megan Cox

"I loved the location in the harbor. Food was great and beer and wine selection was good. The small plates were not small at all so if you order the..."

Annsofie Fasth

"My husband and I booked our rehearsal dinner at Swallow and had a wonderful experience! The reason we booked here was because I actually used to be a..."

Cambria Gould

"Nice place to go with family and/or friends, especially since they specialize in tapas-style dishes. This way everyone can try different foods off..."

Mark Nealon

"My husband and I had our wedding here. It was perfect! The staff is so amazing and was so accommodating with all the crazy changes we had to make..."

Moira O’Connell

"Food tastes good, small plate style (sharing is the modus operandi), beer selection was pretty good. We went before peak season (May) so it was..."

Max Tener

"I used to get drinks and small plates at the location in Huntington next to the Paramount and was always a fan. I happened to be in Montauk for the..."

Chris M

"Thank you beautiful Allison (Allie) for the quick service, your positive and upbeat attitude and your great picks! The food was delicious and the..."

Natalie Lynch

"Great place for lunch right on the water, tuna poke, chicken tostada, mac and cheese, and schrimp grits are fantastic! Really enjoyed the cocktails..."

Michael Russo

"I just had dinner at swallow East tonight and it was amazing to say the least! The Beautiful setting added to the incredible food and service! My..."

Riley Walrath

"Amazing service, the food was phenomenal and unlike anything I've had before! The owner James is so kind and really cared if I enjoyed my food and..."

Alexa Potish

"Pretty tasty and nice atmosphere. Cocktails: Aperol Spritz is my top recommendation. Tapas Menu: Must have is the braised beef, Mac and cheese, miso..."

Kimiko The Female

Hooked

Free off-street parking

"We got the fish and chips and the soft shell crab sandwich after a hike through Shadmoor State Park - both dishes were fresh and well done...."

Melissa Fergusson

"A pleasant outdoor dining experience and they had my favorite, Mexican Coke on hand. I had the fish and chips that came to the table hot but it’s..."

Teresa Pittman-Wall

"10/10 calamari! CALAMARI was so good! Cracked pepper in the breading and the red sweet pepper sauce was the best part. Best I’ve had ever. The fish..."

Nick Bierman

"Pretty nice place for a quick pit stop to get food. I got the fish and chips and it was very filling and appetizing. I would rate the fish and chips..."

Dannel Yang

"This is a good place! I went here three years in a row I was in Montauk, and the food is amazing!! The staff were helpful as well, and Hooked has..."

Michael M

"Absolutely delicious and fresh food. Clams were amazing! Owner gave us a few treats, including a tasty dessert, given our order got off track due to..."

Kate Davies

"We ordered half a dozen oysters, the tuna poke bowl and fish and chips. The food came fast, fresh, and delicious. Prices were reasonable and they had..."

Josephine Foong

"Hooked’s lobster roll is stuffed with lobster, has minimal mayo, and is just plain delicious. Definitely my favorite lobster roll in the Montauk..."

Jennifer LaFreniere

"Delicious! Yummy! Delightful! But.. not sure if it was worth $27 for one lobster roll🤔. Maybe we are just lobster foodies, but the best Lobster..."

AndiamoAdventure

"For such a little place, the food was just amazing! The lobster roll best i had so far as it is low on mayonnaise so you actually taste the lobster...."

zeina awedikian

"Soft-shell crab sandwich was great. Appreciate the vegan option (Dr Praeger’s frozen pattties) where options are typically limited. Prices were..."

Nick Jacobson

"This place does fab food. I got a hooked house salad with prawns and it was absolutely gorgeous. Really very filling too. I will definitely be back..."

Sarah Durnin

"I said I’d write a review and it’s my pleasure. Hooked is clean, fresh, easy, yummy and one of the least pricey we found in MTK over the years. ..."

Eleni LaSenna

"They have an extensive menu of fresh seafood. They cook everything to order. I had an awesome fresh caught grill Mahi sandwich. You can get to go..."

Eric Flanagan

"Wife had fish and chips, I had soft shell crab sandwich, and we split lobster Mac. It was all really good. That lobster Mac and cheese is dangerous...."

Lawrence

"I’m so glad we found this place. Food is very simple and delicious, music is great and owners are very friendly and are always there. I highly..."

Alex Ceban

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Dinner

Fine Dining

"Great food and super nice staff! They even brought my kids blankets when they were..."

Rachel Pullman Amalfitano

"Wonderful! Great service, attentive staff, beautiful ambiance, and deliciously prepared fresh and tantalizing food! A home..."

Vittoria Crea Buzzetto

"Cebrated our 10th year anniversary last night at Arbor. Great food and service. Also accommodating for families with..."

Marta Sobotka Gabrielli

"Arbor is amazing. The food is outrageously delicious and the staff is super friendly. The atmosphere is a feel good..."

Lisa Golden

"Nice ambiance. Delicious food. Our waitress, Sophie L. was patient, friendly and..."

Christina Marie

"Great atmosphere and very good pizza and drinks right off the Montauk train line. 1 minute walk from the train..."

The BTONE Show

"brooklyn style in a montauk vibe. delicious apps, great pizza and speciality drinks to match. a word of mouth find that lived up to the..."

jakuvded

"Absolutely the best pizza in Montauk, hands-down! These people get it! The dough, the sauce, and the mozzarella are on point! The appetizers were..."

PEL Laura

"Roberta's Montauk proved to be a late-night savior during our Hamptons escapade. While the prices reflected the Hamptons standard, the pizza was..."

Lloyd

"Faithful reproductions of the originals plus some additions. The Stracciatella is..."

David Laster

"I decided to come for one hour while waiting for my train. The service was incredible, and the staff made me feel at home. They were smiley and also..."

Marek Waldin

"Incredible atmosphere, perfect pizza and wine. Gabriel at the bar took really great care of us we love..."

Presley Strong

"Food and service and both excellent. We had a white pizza and bee sting. They are thin Neapolitan style pizzas cooked to perfection. Our favorite..."

Xiangyu Yin

"My favorite pizza in NYC and when in Montauk was excited and surprised to see they had a location here too. Lives up to same standards. Order the Bee..."

Adam Hill

"Robertas! thank you for coming to Montauk. so refreshing to experience some good food , excellent service in our little one horse town. Persia,..."

nightowl baker

"Calm, nice vibe, a bit on the expensive side. Pizza and drinks were..."

Niclas Hell

"Great pizza, got seated immediately even though we were a party of 9, pizzas were great (and we are huge pizza snobs haha), great crust, perfect..."

Rashmi Pappu

"High quality pizza, fun comfortable family atmosphere. Nice outdoor seating (a bit noisy..."

C Dlhopolsky

"Fantastic cocktails from the team imported from The Garret in NYC, and a great bar vibe. The food can be hit or miss earlier in the season, but is a..."

Clayton McGratty

"A super chic spot where the decor and style were only matched by the food. Tuna tartare is a standout. Wine offerings from the in-house wine cellar..."

Erinn Blicher

The Beach Club At Gurney's Montauk

"Solid vibe in Montauk. This is definitely the spot if you're looking for an elevated experience in Montauk. The amenities are wonderful and it's the..."

Heather Dolland Tamam

"A very nice and clean beach for everyone to go, whether it is in Spring, Summer or Fall season. The blue sky, the fine sands, the soothing sound of..."

Gigi McCoy

"Had a beautiful beach getaway for the night and woke up to a gorgeous sunrise on the Atlantic. Came despite it being winter and still loved being..."

Jessica Zapotechne

"Had salmon bagel. Pretty good and..."

David Lee

"Hotel great room service and clean room little bit over..."

seo woo lee

"Gorgeous setting. Beach was empty. Mostly private homes. Rooms. Simple , clean comfortable. On the expensive side. But well worth it..Food also..."

Carl Kempner

"Service was top notch ! Always a memorable meal/dinner at Gurney's Montauk Restaurant. Go early or stay later after dinner to enjoy the firepits..."

Caroline McGurk

"One of my best meals on vacation was here! I can't remember what I ordered, but it had handmade pasta, shrimp, zucchini, and more. It was the winner..."

Jessica Comfort

"Spent the day at the beach club for my girlfriends bachelorette and it was the best time EVER! Not only is the resort gorgeous, but the service is..."

Amanda K

"The food here is absolutely outstanding. I could not get enough! It was easily in the top three meals I've ever eaten. I ate at the bar, and the..."

Allister McGuire

Montauket

"Fist time going. Staff very friendly, extraordinary views, amazing live music, incredible food. ❤️ Burger and the flounder were bothe cooked..."

christina marie

"The view is definitely the high point of taking in a meal here. Service was friendly and accommodating if a touch slow. The food is certainly good..."

Steven Wilson

"The best sunset view in Montauk, kind of quiet on a weeknight in September, except for the bartender, the staff and waitress were very friendly and..."

Jeff Fulcoly

"Just had dinner here and I'm blown away with the breath taking views! Clams over linguine are the best I've ever had and the BBQ ribs were equally..."

Gerard

"Great spot! Wait staff was super friendly, food and drinks came super fast despite them being very busy. Chicken sandwiches are..."

Anthony Domingo

"Great spot! But check your bill. They “miscalculated” ours the last two times we were there… by a lot. Not a..."

amy lyons

"Rustic Montauk bar/restaurant with possibly the best sunset view on the east end. Outdoor area w tables and..."

Rich Straus

"Amazing food and SUPER view! The Montauket restaurant has great seating, and usually the wait isn't that..."

JohnPlayz

"Great view, good food, good service. Could be crowded at times, with the live music, which was..."

Jeff Koo

"Great little spot over looking the water from the cliff to stop for a drink or..."

The BTONE Show

"Pricey menu but worth it for the view. The outdoor seating is right on the shore so you have a beautiful ocean view. The food was decent. Great..."

Jessica D

"Right on the water and one of the only places north of Florida with sunset over the water. Food is excellent bar food and very good service..."

Steven Polesovsky

"Been going here since I was a kid, miss the golf challenge, but the views are still spectacular. Best elevation for the sunsets with a..."

Lee Jackowsky

"Had the Vegetarian Wrap and a club soda with cranberry and lime. Food and drink were good! Service very friendly! View fantastic! Note:During the..."

Premananda

The Market

85/100 (81 ratings)

Restaurants

American

"The Market at Montauk Harbor carries everything I could possibly need for a delicious, healthy dinner or lunch for my family. It’s so great to be..."

Valerie Hoffmann

"Small place with an amazing selection and really nice people that work there. Their breakfast combinations are delicious and farely priced, not..."

Bree Colon

"Montauk is expensive. With that being said-this place does have almost everything and it's in somewhat of a "low-key" location-not sure of the hours..."

CPNY

"Great place for lunch or breakfast of pancakes or waffles with the best tasting maple syrup straight from the Catskill mountains! ..."

Lori Dippold

"The best Market on the East End I could sure go for one of those turkey jalapeno wraps right about..."

Michael F

"Cool place. Decent selection. A little..."

Sam Jacobs

"Fresh stuff and reasonable..."

christopher kyriakides

"Quick and..."

John Imbriano

"Loved it..."

John

"..."

Joseph Muncey

"Nice..."

Edgar Ramirez

"Everything..."

John Imbriano

Robert Burkard

Marcus Scruggs

Vincenzo Maimone

Eddie Caro

Robinson Wolff

Surfside Inn

Tillie's At Gurney's Montauk Resort

Wheelchair Accessible

"Loved it!! Great food, and the service was..."

Cristina Munda

"Avacado tartine so good! And the Vermont creamery butter with sea salt crystals on toast is..."

Brandy Duncalf McLam

"With ocean views everywhere and fresh LARGE portions, you can't go wrong with this cheerful and bright restaurant where we enjoyed lunch and..."

Susan G

"The right place to start your day. We came here for breakfast. Everything was so delicious, fast and super nice stuff. Including valet parking. We..."

Olena Garasymiv

"They are avocado toast with smoked salmon and poached eggs was absolutely winner for me until I had crab Benedict! Either you having a dinner or..."

Alexandra Rozhdestvenskaya

"We went to Tillie's for breakfast on a rainy weekend morning in April and even though the summer season has yet to kick in, they were packed. In case..."

Rose Mass

"Fiance and I stopped by Tillie's for lunch. Great vibe, and she had Lobster Roll, said it was best she ever had! My turkey in was very tasty too...."

Christopher Long

"Enjoyed the great food, but for the price only worth it to sit outside on the deck overlooking the ocean. Chicken pita and side salad delicious, and..."

Olga Kouznetsova

"After Party and Green Goddess will wake you up... Pancakes&bacon /Yogurt&Berries/Short ribs&eggs will kickstart your day's journey...even if its NOT..."

lorraine torrella

"Decent brunch, great..."

Dave S

"Beautiful space, food and service were not amazing but might have been off season. Staff were very friendly and great..."

Neil Capel

"The food, view and service were all great. One star was deducted for extremely high..."

Logan Greenlee

"Great food and service. Loved the smoked salmon. Amazing..."

Scott Treacy

"The views are amazing the food was amazing and the service was..."

Stacy G

"I would recommend making a reservation. This place is always..."

abhay chennagiri

"Tasty breakfast with a variety of..."

C G

"Views were..."

La

"2hat a..."

John Corcoran

"Güzel bir restoran ama servis biraz zayıf. Ortam güzel. Denniz kenarı öanzaralı tüm masalar niye iki kişilik..."

Huseyin Berkem

O'murphys Pub

"Solid dining experience. The ambience is really nice and the staff are friendly, albeit the service is a bit slow. I ordered my burger medium but it..."

Mike Wu

"Great food, pricey but worth it, good portions. Fresh seafood. Shrimp scampi was soooooo..."

SannoNYC

"We've been going to O'Murphys forever. In their new location they have a much bigger and nicer bar area, a bigger dining room. Lots of parking,..."

S Gries

"My friends and I affectionately call it Mother O'Murphy's! The food is great, wonderful burgers and shepherd's pie, and fantastic french onion soup...."

Ronald Redmond

"We visited O'Murphy's on their second day in their new location. It was hard to tell that it was a new place, the staff all seems to have moved and..."

Barney Simon

"You have to try the duck. Excellent. My wife had the shrimp scampi and loved it. My friend had the blackened swordfish also loved it. The calamari..."

Mike Weber

"Had the BEST EVER SHRIMP SCAMPI OVER LINGUINE yesterday. There was absolutely nothing wrong with it. The salad was super fresh and the staff adorable..."

Barbara Nelson

"Best Irish restaurant in Montauk!! Love everything I have ever gotten here. The wings and potato skins are the bomb. The shepherds pie is amazing...."

Michelle Kane

"This place was amazing ! A little pricey but the food is overall delicious so it makes up for it and the staff was so sweet and well manured. It was..."

Danky Daze

"We always go to O'Murphy's when we are in Montauk. The food is always good, the service and people are excellent, and the new location is really..."

George Fanno

"Had a delightful meal of fried fish sandwich and delicious homemade fries on a blustery New year's day, & Probably the best Irish coffee I've ever..."

Cory Davenport

"had dinner at omurphys last night it was great! food was excellent, very family friendly, I highly recommend the shrimp scampi, service was..."

mikaela fiscina

Mtk Lobster House

Free off-street parking

"I had the cold lobster roll, It was very delicious and very overstuffed. I had to eat half of it with a fork before it became sandwich size. Thank..."

Mody Caliendo

"Fresh and delicious seafood love this place coming back for..."

Pachi Manzano Ambrosi

"Excellent food, customer service and environment, when you visit Montauk go to..."

Tatiana V Serrano

"Fresh and delicious food nice atmosphere excellent..."

Ray Guiselle Manzano

"Such a beautiful place. The inside has a great vibe. The lobster roll was sooo delicious and buttery. 🤤🤤 The staff is also very friendly. They..."

Elizabeth Mac

"I was looking for a good lobster roll. The lobster roll here was so fresh tasting, just delicious! Fries were amazing too, crispy. This is more of a..."

Amber Kutner

"Great food, but wow the crowd in this town just keeps surprising me. I excitedly took a picture of our food when it arrived, but that was big..."

Nicole Chan

"Love Love Love this place. The food is excellent. Dined In and have had food to go, it is always a hit. Pasta is hand rolled on site and you can..."

J Anthony

"Simple and clean place..with the beachy vibe is next to wyld blue on the 1st floor right in the street!!!!outdoor seating available.👍 Indoor..."

It Starts at Home - Sonali Kapoor

"The food took a while to come. I wasn't able to see anything else on the island waiting for it. The stuffed lobster 🦞 was pretty good. The server..."

V Kendrick

"Lobster rolls were great and the oysters very..."

Jason Brown

"Great service! The food was very good and we wish The Family lots of Luck on this new Journey ¡Que Orgullo! To hear a local Latino family investing..."

Wen Lo

"My husband and I had dinner here on a recent weekend in Montauk. If you are going here, you are obviously looking for seafood and/or Lobster..."

S Gries

"The food here is great but the portion sizes are kinda small. We ordered the MTK lobster boil. Delicious but it looks disappointing compared to the..."

Luke Hess

"We were seated quickly at MTK Lobster House, and our waiters were wearing masks and socially distanced while serving us. Atmosphere is modern and..."

Maria Andrianos

"Restaurant close to main area to grab food, do touristy things in Montauk and go shopping. Indoor and outdoor dining at this restaurant. Service was..."

Eugenia Kim

The Dock

"Great bar and amazing lobster grilled cheese! The service was a little shakey, but I think it was just late, and I give a lot of server grace. This..."

Brittany McElhiney

"Good place near sunset beach. Looks like a local pub but a lot of people who are just visiting come to this place. Food and service is excellent...."

Vishal Chaudhary

"really liked the vibe of this place. food was very good. personable wait..."

Justin

"Arrived at an odd hour only to find this place packed. Well I was glad because it’s a good sign for a starter. A good number of staff around to..."

Lingmei Lin

"Pub-styled atmosphere with elevated, fresh-caught, high quality, freshly made food, at about half the price of many other Montauk eateries. Take a..."

Liz Harris

"Went to The Dock in Montauk always good food. The special was blackened scallops with risotto. Im not really a seafood person but the scallops were..."

Jennifer Costanzo

"Great dockside pub featuring all your favorites along with a long list of daily specials. Friendly service, great local ales and beers on tap along..."

John Guma

"Great food, good price, great service. Nice atmosphere, no tvs and they frown on cell phone use. Good..."

Patrick O'Brien

"Thankfully, some things don't change. This is still the best spot in town for a casual bite to eat and no frills local vibe. I highly recommend the..."

Jared Zlotnick

"excellent seafood choices. loved every bite. great..."

Kevin Chen

Westlake Fish House

"Good food and soooo much fun. Super live music. Larry the owner is such an awesome guy. Freshest fish dishes. So tasty. Great vibes from the staff..."

Frank Marzocca

"The West Lake is wonderful! I highly recommend it! The seating in the dining room, near the outdoor bar and tables overlooking the marina create..."

Dawn Reidlinger

"Ok full disclosure. My band plays at WLFH all the time - but that means, we eat dinner there all the time. Not only are the owners totally generous..."

Lynn Blumenfeld

"Best food in montauk...bartenders and wait staff are top shelf..oh and the view is outstanding..really cool place to hang and drink,kool..."

Mark A Revello

"The service is impeccable and staff are ridiculously good looking. Food is outstanding, freshest fish in the land! You're missing out if you don't..."

Siobháin Harrington

"The food is amazing and the staff are so efficient! If you haven't been down there your missing..."

Megan Hyland

"Love This place! Margaritas are fantastic, sushi is amazing and filled with great fun..."

Cheryl Lynn

"Excellent service, the food was amazing, drink recommendations were awesome! I'm from Texas and definitely will..."

Megan Vandewater

"Excellent service and very fresh sushi....My husband had a big juicy steak that we shared. The drinks were well made. It's in a great spot at the..."

Christina Mallia Yzaguirre

"Westlake it's a beautiful place to relax and have a great time with your friends. You'll love..."

Maribel Federico

"Best food on the east end - sushi is amazing, love the fish BLT sliders. Great atmosphere!! Great..."

Tammy Lyons

"Been in Mtk now for exactly 4 seasons by far the best season ever thank you all who came out and supported Westlake fish house. There will be more..."

Ira Gooden

"Excellent the service the food the freshness of the fish everything was just..."

Joanne Lorenzoni-Caceres

"Excellent food. I went with the specialties of the house and chef Larry Kolar never disappoints. Will be returning. May be this..."

Linnea Welker

"chef Kolar is one of my mentors. If you are in Montauk you must try this..."

Steven Zobel

"Best place to eat and drink in Montauk, great people, great vibes and you will always feel welcome..."

Michael Kiely

"Great great time at the Gannon Wedding..."

Jerry Belmont

"If you really want to feel like you’re eating in Montauk… This is a great place to do it. The best food is really the sushi… Which is fresh..."

Eileen R

"The sushi was delicious, the fish and chips were great, the tacos a 4 out of 5, and the linguine was good, the crispy chicken sandwich was very..."

Robert Nock

"This place is a vibe! Great food! Great service. Great atmosphere. Can't wait to go..."

Tom Brady

"Great food and live music. Live music was a bit too loud, forcing us shout across tables. My linguini clams is one of best I've ever had. It's not..."

Nic Nei

"Hands down the best! Even better if Darius is your bartender… On point Sushi and the baked Mac & cheese will make you want to slap your..."

Darius Ali

"Excellent sushi and fresh catch, lively bar indoor/outdoor, live music overlooking..."

Scott Falzone

"Nice marina side eatery. crab nachos, fish tacos, and beer. Indoor and outdoor seating..."

Barney Simon

"This is a No-Frills Eatery with good fish, good brunch items, and fair prices. Wait staff is friendly and accommodating although management should..."

joanne houseman

"Westlake is even better than its interesting menu might let on. Every dish was a delight. I don't know what they put in the broth their mussels are..."

Jahn Xavier Bonfiglio

"Each year gets better. Our first visit this season was excellent. Started with their award winning clam chowder and fabulous Westlake Salad with..."

Jay Goldstein

"Best sushi in Montauk. Family friendly with live..."

Phil Frost

"Some of the absolute best sushi I've ever had. Prices are a bit on the steep side, but hey, it's Montauk! Our bartender Liana was..."

TMC (NYSDOT)

"We leave our boat in montauk And we have a fur child, the owner James was so amazing to our baby girl (It was her 12 bday) English bulldog! The food..."

Fedora Lounge Salon

"The food is absolutely incredible, the restaurant/marina gets beautiful sunset views, the bar has such a fun vibe, and the staff is the sweetest and..."

fareesa abbasi

"the food was amazing and really good quality! My grandma said the salmon was the best salmon she had had in her entire life! (here is a tip: the kids..."

Sylv McGovern

"Honestly the best quality sushi I've had on the east of the city, bar none. Casual atmosphere and right on the marina for a lovely view and fresh..."

Ryan Sapienza

Muse At The End

81/100 (1405 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts American Express

"Great food and ambiance at this restaurant. A little bit on the pricier side. But is well worth it as the appetizer and entrees we ordered were..."

Vince Asuncion

"Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya! Had two great Espresso Martinis. Best I ever had. Bartender was amazing. You must go have a drink there and they have..."

Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino

"I came here tonight for dinner and drinks. The food and service here is utterly phenomenal. My Corn Popper appetizer and Cast Iron Montauk Seabass..."

Lisa S

"Outstanding restaurant. Exceptional food quality and attentive service. Kristina was professional, spontaneous and courteous. Fantastic music..."

Claudia Coetzer

"Great atmosphere. Half bar, half restaurant that wouldn't even look like it was attached to a bar. Live music, GREAT service, great food, had an..."

Gina Zhang

"Super good drinks and food, loved the grilled octopus and it was my first time having a lobster roll and mussles, was very impressed. The apple..."

Jessica Catelak

"Very good service, friendly and attentive. The atmosphere is beautiful and relaxing. The food is tasty but nothing special. I expected more of the..."

Alisa Briceno Ramirez

"Had an amazing and wonderful time. On Fridays, there is live music from a wonderful musician. Incredible food! Must have the scallops that melt in..."

Jessie Santiago

"Very nice restaurant. Bright and clean inside. All staff i encountered were friendly. Free bread was delicious. Had a calamari appetizer which was..."

Dan S

"The food and service here were impeccable! We had the octopus and mussels for an app and the sea bass and NY strip steak for dinner! Wonderful..."

michelle “Mich” vaillant

"Easy to make a reservation - sat outside with table of 4, private , yet classy and comfortable and we brought our creme retriever! Every disch was..."

Kevin Wood

"Great place to come hang at the bar or sit down at a table to eat. The atmosphere was inviting Inside & outside seating for dining The gracious owner..."

Theresa Gibbs

"Nice restaurant and my fish was delicious, but they need to learn to accommodate a vegan client. My wife's meal was tasteless!! Any top chef should b..."

Joseph Berkowitz

"We had a great experience at the muse. Every appetizer better then the one before. Entrees too. Nice portion sizes too. We will definitely be..."

d shap

"Our new favorite place when visiting Montauk! Victor ran the bar and some tables, stress free without missing a beat! Thank you Victor for making our..."

fourth laxer

"Went there for the first time, great experience. The grilled octopus, the chicken, and skirt steak were..."

Maria Cottone

St. Peter's Catch Restaurant

"Amazing lobster Rolls! Unspoiled by dressings or spices, just meat on a fresh New England style bun. I am a bit spoiled since there are lobster..."

DJ Hohn

"Love their fish toco. Have to go eat there every time out in mtk. Owner is a really nice gent friendly and happy and staff lovely ladies. So you must..."

Catherine Murtha

"Very good lobster roll. Friendly staff. Pricey but it’s Montauk and u do get what u pay for. 4/5 due to smaller portion than I expected. And..."

Drew Turano

"It used to be the best kept secret... a fish market that made the best fish taco in the universe. now they're a restaurant catering to the montauk..."

Sam Michaels

"Tucked away from the beach next to the Montauk Brewing Company, is St. Peter's Catch. This well curated fish market and fry bar has well seasoned..."

Barney Simon

"It's probably the best experience you can get in the area. The restaurant/ fish market is local which means you can buy a fish that went straight out..."

Tomek Woźniak

"#delish #fresh great fish tacos, best lobster roll we had all week! And conveniently next to montauk brewing..."

Brittany Ross Berlin

"The lobster meal may look expensive but is worth every penny!!! The extra portion of clams coming with it was a delightful..."

Rodrigo Ribeiro

"I don't like seafood but we come to Montauk for a week every year and I eat their fish tacos at least 3 times while I am..."

dan deegan

"Excellent quality fish and great customer service. A little pricey, but not unexpected in..."

N H

"Fish tacos were so delicious and so fresh. Best fish tacos ive ever..."

Robens Rodney

"Best fish taco's around. Everything cooked fresh, Amazing..."

chris jack

"$10 for a great fish and chips lunch, can't beat it. Cash only, you've been..."

Kaleb Kemper

"Smoked marlin dip is amazing. He will give you a sample if you ask. Trust me you wont be..."

Chris Kies

"LOVE THIS PLACE!!! The food is amazing and fresh. They are also so nice here..."

Molly Nye

"Great fresh seafood. Fish and shrimp tacos were..."

Jeff Sheridan

"The best seafood on Long Island. The calamari is world class. Bring..."

Urban Carmel

South Edison

81/100 (1114 ratings)

Accepts American Express

Street Parking

Gift Cards Available

Parking Available

Free off-street parking

Wheelchair Accessible

"Out of all the restaurants in Montauk, South Edison is truly the best culinary gem. The Chef is an absolute genius, each dish is more complex and..."

Lauren Jahoda

"The yellowfin tuna main course was delicious and highly recommended. We also tried the sashimi fluke, which was good and had a little bit of spice to..."

Jaclyn O'Day

"Best food I had in Montauk. Atmosphere could use some improvement. It's loud. But the waiter was super nice and the food was just fantastic. The duck..."

Wim Bonjean

"We had dinner here during our stay in Montauk. The restaurant is bigger than it looks, the staff are all friendly and attentive. Parking lot and..."

S Gries

"Our server Olivia was friendly, authentic, and extremely attentive. The Buffalo chicken bites and fried olive appetizers exceeded expectations...."

Austin Feinberg

"Insane food!!! First time in Montauk and we’ve been to five of the best restaurants here……hands down the best food around. Super friendly,..."

Adam Pattisall

"South Edison is a great casual bar/restaurant. The ambiance is very good and the service is perfect. Food is so good and the Oysters were so fresh..."

Sepehr Asadizadeh

"Beyond one of my favorite restaurants in Montauk. From the drinks to the food everything is on point. My favorite main dish is their Tuna and my..."

Gina Vega

"A solid four stars plus. Nothing exceptional, but an overall good experience. The staff is wonderful. Food and drink better than..."

Mack Vismusic

"Awesome! The drinks were great. Especially the espresso martini. Definitely get the duck fat fries. I wanted to eat all of them in one sitting but..."

Michael Peterson

Sammys

Wheelchair Accessible

"Lovely place. Lobster sandwich supreme, eating outside on the bay is lovely. The waiter from Ireland was lovely and kind. The best place I ate in..."

federico bastiani

"We are headed to the seafood festival and were reminded of our wonderful experience last May during the annual music festival. The drinks and beer..."

Mack Vismusic

"This review is for Sammy’s to Go (the food truck). Amazing place to get reasonably priced delicious takeout breakfast or lunch. And… you can sit..."

Amanda Grace Petrocelli McLean

"Delicious Oktoberfest dinner at Sammy’s tonight. The food never disappoints but the Sauerbraten and Wienerschnitzel were both exceptional. Great..."

Sheryl Kleven

"Absolute - Hands-Down Best Restaurant in Town. THE FOOD IS OUTSTANDING. If you truly want the "Montauk" experience, than Sammy's is a "Must." Sammy..."

Paul Forsberg

"Delicious gluten free and dairy free lobster salad rolls with coleslaw. So tasty and the lobster was..."

Elaina Oshea - G

"First time there. Food was delicious and Ginger is a great and helpful service staff!!! We'll be..."

PATRICIA McHugh

"Great food and great service. We've eaten at Sammy's several times and have never been..."

Barry Goldklang

"My husband and I reached out to Sammy's to host our 25 person wedding and could not be happier with our experience. Sammy's was so easy to coordinate..."

Mairead Wegenaar

"Had the fried Clam Sandwich. A pleasant lunch or dinner stop if driving to Montauk..."

Sarah Hudson

Montauk Bake Shoppe Limited

Wheelchair Accessible

Takeout

Breakfast

Cheap Eats

"So many tasty options here! We had breakfast wrap & sandwich and even went back another day to try another option. Even with a mixup on someone..."

Laura Johnson

"Adorable European style bakery in the center of Montauk. What stood out to me most - the efficiency of the staff. They are paying attention and..."

T H

"It's such a wonderful local bakery.. Taste 👍 Coffee..."

Mark Choi

"Pastries were cheap and delicious! A friend of mine grew up on these and told me to pay a visit during my stay. Needless to say it did not..."

Josephine Foong

"This is a Montauk institution, I've been coming here for almost 50 years. Inventive cookies, fantastic jelly rolls, and really nice customer service...."

Petra Holden

"Number one bake shoppe out East! Amazing assortment of donuts, muffins, crumb cakes, fresh rolls. They are famous for their delicious jelly..."

Nina Forcello

"This gem of a bake shop has some of the BEST cookies and pastries I’ve ever had. Their rainbow cookies are particularly fantastic - really thick..."

Jake Steinerman

"Awesome old fashion bakery, had coffee here every morning of our vacation. No nonsense delicious coffee. Also had the crumb cake and jelly filled..."

K may

"Beautiful and delicious custom vanilla fresh strawberry 8 inch birthday cake with whipped cream icing. Called 24 hours ahead and the pastry chef was..."

Vivian Janeo

"Had one of the most unique delicious breakfast sandwhiches here! Got the #8 on a roll. #8 2 Eggs, Mushrooms, Ricotta, Spinach, Swiss Cheese -..."

Amanda Hahn

"The food is excellent, but you must stay open minded to receiving and enjoying a meal other than what you what you ordered. This morning, I missed..."

M R

"Cool little bakery. The coffee cake is really good. There’s no seating inside..."

Jason Braun

"Linda helped us with a Bridal panic when we picked up a 2 layer not 2 level tiered cake some sort of miscommunication between myself, my mother and..."

Anne Carmel Davis

"Lovely food and drinks if you’re Irish you will appreciate they sell Barry’s..."

Victoria Graham

"Great pastries! Try the chocolate chip muffin. You wont regret..."

Cameron Vidrine

"When I first got to Montauk everyone was hyping on the bake shop. I'm here to tell you it's worth the hype. They have an array of pastries and they..."

Raphael Gorjian

"Great location & good vibe! Most importantly, food was delicious!! Oysters were perfection, salad was fresh & generous. Can't say enough about the..."

Cassie Cowman

"Outstanding food and a good experience. A bit more upscale than surrounding restaurants, but well worth..."

Bekim Becaj

"Taking over the former Dave's Grill space, we were happy to hear that the owners of one of our favorite restaurants (Bay Kitchen) had taken over. We..."

Tracy Becker

"Great food and cocktails in a beautiful setting..."

Stephen A. S.

"Service was good and the sea food was fresh and prepared excellent. Did not drink can not say how the drinks..."

Anthony Biondo

"Over the Top on a good way... Google said it was closed it was OPEN! The staff the food the ambiance is over the..."

Lawrence Chip Porter II

"Good..."

Robinson Wolff

Thomas Marcotullio

Matt F

Herb's Market

"Friendly staff. Great quality beef that we cooked on the grill and enjoyed their homemade potato and corn..."

Justa Foodie

"A bit pricey but excellent product quality. Sandwiches are excellent as is the fried..."

Robert Bacchi

"Fried chicken was amazing, legit some of the best I’ve ever had. It was quite packed/seemed a bit disorganized when we were there, so here’s a..."

Jakob Lazzaro

"The people are always nice The service is prompt The quality of the food is always..."

Barney Simon

"Best fried chicken in town hands down! Great service, friendly staff(say hi to Carl) and some of the best food in town. Great for grabbing something..."

Morgan Siegel

"I often wake up in the middle of the night, in a cold sweat, thinking about their chicken. I have driven two hours, just to sate my appetite for this..."

David Matthew Friedman

"The BEST egg sandwich ! My brother and sister owned a deli 20 years, and you nailed it..."

Suzanne Schmitt

"Full service Deli & Butcher in the middle of Montauk. Best fried chicken to take to the beach or home. Catering to go’s too. Rear entrance so you..."

The Corcoran Group

"Best fried..."

Timothy Cullinan

"Excellent deli sandwiches, cooked and raw chicken and ribs. As all the staff t-shirts read "you can't beat Herb's..."

Cody Xuereb

"Best chiken I ever ate in my..."

Stanislav Kovalenko

"Best fried chicken in MTK. Always have to stop to get some for the ride..."

Amanda Hahn

"Very good service , best fried chicken, very..."

Rich gallop

"Always a great go too!! Fresh and..."

pina sarlo

"Loved my sandwich..."

Tony Perry

"Nice little deli, including good..."

Gregor J. Rothfuss

Fro-yo & Gelato

"Froyo and Gelato is my family's favorite place! We go here everyday, every summer! The kids love it and I love it because there are so many options..."

Ghazala Choudhary

"This is a fun place for a frozen treat. There are always several frozen yogurts to choose from and a wide variety of toppings. Kids love the place. ..."

Barney Simon

"Tons of toppings. If you don't want the yogart you can just buy the toppings. Swedish fish, malted balls, reese's peanut butter cups, you name it...."

mary jo pojawis

"Elegant and chic, this joint has a lot of variety in a small space! Belgian waffles, crepes, candy, doggie treats, quinoa bowls, t-shirts and more -..."

Jeffrey Baez

"Buddaberry is a GREAT place to eat frozen yogurt and had a great and nice design. And is healthy too. But the people are sometimes not..."

Braeden Krzenski

"Best dessert in town. My family comes here every night when we’re in Montauk! Ask them for the Fro-Yo..."

Andy Bolton

"Delicious, delicious froyo and well worth the visit even in the summer crowds. Open fairly late,..."

Matt Ballard (450nm)

"So good! The amount of toppings they have is ridiculous. Will be returning for..."

Michelle Tate

"Favorite place in Montauk! Love going and getting some some froyo..."

Diana Arias

"Really good gelato and prices weren't..."

John

"Love it ,wish they more flavors and..."

NASA1

"Tasty but pricey. understandable for a seasonal..."

Michael Austin

668 The Gig Shack

80/100 (1524 ratings)

Free off-street parking

Highchairs Available

Free Wifi

Accepts Credit Cards

Non-smoking restaurants

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts Visa

Accepts American Express

"Pretty cool little place in the heart of town. Sat at the bar and watched the tennis match. Had a lobster slider, which was buttery and delicious...."

KGB (KGB)

"I am not a big fan of sea food and tacos, but it was a good experience. I loved the decoration and the restaurant's warm atmosphere. We ordered a..."

Sean ainechi

"The most reason why I'm here is this place is dog friendly restaurant. I took my spoiled puppy with me on a small vacation trip so everywhere I go...."

Melissa Naja

"Everyone in our party of 4 was delighted with our meals here. I got the baby back ribs: the meat was succulent and the corn bread was warm and soft...."

Tyron Pretorius

"We had a great dinner here on the patio. All of the food we tried was a riff on a classic. From the Mediterranean we had Spanakopita it was a light..."

Anna Bennett

"Best rum drink (super strong). Every time I come here they serve drinks in the coolest cups. We shared the chicken sandwich- it was 🔥🔥🔥...."

Amanda Hahn

"Food was very good. I started with the empanadas. They were amazing. After I had the grilled chicken and lobster croissant. Very good also. Service..."

Gabriel Davila

"Omg! Loved this restaurant. Plenty of space outdoors and indoors. Great place to quickly grab food and go about your day. Restaurant is in the..."

Eugenia Kim

"Already can't wait to come back to this place! It had a great atmosphere with delicious food. I ordered the ribs with cornbread & coleslaw and it was..."

Katie McKenna

"Stopped here with a girlfriend for lunch and we could not have chosen a better spot! You are welcomed by beautiful beach decor and a friendly staff...."

Sam Cosme

"Perfect location, wonderful atmosphere, OUTSTANDING service and cuisine. I strongly recommend the New England Clam Chowder, the best I ever had..."

Bob Weigel

"There is no words to describe this place! U just have to go and see it, enjoy amazing view, beautiful ppl, delicious food and much much more......"

Sanja Miloshevska

"Excellent food, great drinks and staff, and a tremendous view all..."

Geoffrey Wood

"Gosman's is beautiful scenic dining either outside under crisp umbrellas on the dock or interior aesthetically pleasing dining room. The food is the..."

Brenda Bamberski

"Amazing! Montauk Topside will never let you down. Granted, to make money you wont be getting a piece of corn and fries, but who goes to Montauk for..."

Marlene Morgs

"The food and drinks, the views, the staff, all top notch, we hope to see lots of you this season, For..."

Dana Craft

"Amazing oysters with a Wolfner Rosé and a watermelon, feta, gilled shrimp salad-along with a beautiful view of the harbor, whats not to..."

Nicci Zizelis

"I really enjoyed dinner here Wednesday night. Beautiful view. And I'm sorry but no kids allowed😘😍❤️ Be still my..."

Sabrena Creary

"A must for anyone visiting Montauk , great food , service and beautiful views..."

Mark D'Amico

"The view, the service, prosecco with lemonade yummy, and striped bass grilled to perfection. NO CHILDREN allowed. Topside is top notch..."

Frances McGarry

"A must when visiting Montauk.Great seafood and scenery where you get to observe some of the best fishing industry the world has to offer.Gosman's has..."

Charles Kenny

"Great view, staff very attentive, food excellent. Will be going back this..."

Elly Duehne Harrold

"We loved the atmosphere. Julie is the creme of the crop of montauk. She was so extremely helpful and very sweet and personable. She knew everything..."

Lilly Tyler

"Perfect location to eat out on the upper deck with a view of the..."

Julie Bienvenue

"Here, once again, I just have to say Julie and Aaron are amazing. I came back with someone new, and they enjoyed it here. We will definitely be..."

Chantelle H

"Great food, views, and service. Different kitchen and overall vibe than..."

Reset

There are 55 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Montauk

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Paul P

Eileen Choron

David Laster

Nike McAllister

Heidi Siciliano

Abby _

Nicole Toussaint

Kareem Elbasty

Anthony Nigrel

Stephen Lee

Alexandra Nikolchev

Christine Parlamis

Dylan Harvey

Maureen Cruz

Igor Krasnoperov

Melissa Naja

Michael Kessler

Steven Lewandowski

Chris

Stephen Bibbiani

B Christopher

Kim Hammerschmitt

John DeMelio

Robert Horowitz

Mashiro S

Henry Bradley III

Denis Mantsurov

Anushka Banerjee

Robert Martin

Steve Rogers

H. Jules

KGB (KGB)

Toria Banco

LaLatina EVERYWHERE

Stephanie Alegado

Laura Steeneck

Charles SSS

Lisa S

randall h

Craig Casey

Havi Harv

Livia Eastman

D Euro

Dan Rivera

Caitlin Richard

Becca Andersen

Zeynep Gunbay

saumikde

Alejandro Fernandez

christine

Miranda Thomason

Barney Simon

Mary McPartland

Megan Cox

Annsofie Fasth

Cambria Gould

Mark Nealon

Moira O’Connell

Max Tener

Chris M

Natalie Lynch

Michael Russo

Riley Walrath

Alexa Potish

Kimiko The Female

Melissa Fergusson

Teresa Pittman-Wall

Nick Bierman