Just left here. We got there as soon as they opened for lunch. I love their tap beer selection and all local Montauk cans. Husband got a frozen drink that was good. Corn fritters are incredible! We got a pulled pork and pulled chicken sandwich delicious! I wish we had more time to return at night the outdoor area and bar Looks like a lot of fun. Saw Smore pits and Smore kits for sale super cute. Wait staff was super attentive and who I believe to be an owner came over to us himself a couple times. Nice hidden gem would return!
First time there. Will definitely be back. Had the lobster bake and my wife had the crab leg bake. At first thought it was a tad pricey even though we were in Montauk, but when the dishes came out the dollar amount wasn't even a conversation any longer. Food and portions were outstanding. Nice service from a lovely girl from Ireland. Met Rick and his dad as well. Very lovely meal. 5 stars . We will be back😀
Good mix of seafood and barbecue. They have both indoor and outdoor seating. Live music on weekends. Outdoor bar and firepits. The BBQ ribs are delicious. Serve was okay, difficult to get the waitresses attention.
Greate BBR Ribs and pulled pork. Great local fish bites. Maurice the bartender was great
El Piojo Chuecopiojoso98
+5
The food was spectacular, fresh , kids really enjoyed , definitely we looking to go back ......
Leigh Overland Architect
+4
Lunch was a wonderful experience, especially during the week as it wasn't to crowded, had nice music in the background and beautiful views. The clam bake had a great variety with a nice portion and was reasonably priced. The mussels were small so I've had better. The Greek salad was perfect. The wait staff were delightful.
Great casual vibe and stunning sunset. We loved our evening at Rick's!
They did a fantastic job for Maggies mission on Friday May 31. Great food and excellent service. Thank you to all the employees!!!
Ok food. Nice view. A little expensive but a good summer place.
Very fresh food. Had a great tuna sandwich The tuna was cooked perfectly, asked for medium rare and got it, and portion was surprisingly big. We also ordered the crab cake sandwich, fried fish sandwich, and pulled pork sandwich which were all very good. Very pleased with everything.
We were looking for a relaxed and cozy place by the marina and found just that. We were lucky to sit at a table by the window overlooking the marina and it was beautiful. The fried calamari and shrimp cocktail were tasty, the oysters left something to be desired. All in all, great experience!
What an unsung spot. Great fresh seafood and delightful waitstaff. I'm not sure why some people have had mixed experiences, but we will totally be returning. We had Montauk Pearl Oysters which are harvested from the Oyster farm at the end of the dock. We had the lobster and crab bake and a soft shell crab sand which too. All delicious and cooked properly. People around us were all enjoying their food and seemed very happy with their experience. The open air lazy day feeling along the harbor begs you stay all day long.
Now ... This isn't the four seasons and they aren't trying to be either. This is an ideal Long Island experience and a MUST when visiting the east end. If you want great quality seafood without pretentiousness... The Crabby Cowboy is the way to go. Ride on Crabby Cowboy ride on!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Montauk
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes