I have been an owner at the Montauk Manor for over 20 years and I have to say that tonight was by far the best dinner I have ever experienced!
The staff was amazing, the atmosphere was that of a time long ago when you were treated with respect and kindness...and the food...well let me just say, it was absolutely beyond anything I could have ever imagined!
Bravo to the Monte family for creating a place where we can all feel like part of their family!
From the moment we stepped in the door, we were enveloped in the warm, authentic, traditionally Italian atmosphere. We could honestly feel the heart and soul that was poured into this space. I am the annoying person in the group who has many dietary restrictions and often when I hear ‘Italian Food’ it means an entire menu that I can’t eat most of ! That was definitely not the case here. Not only were the fish/ vegetarian options absolutely delicious, but everyone was beyond accommodating , which was no surprise giving the unwavering level of hospitality. We can not wait to go back again and again. Thank you Monte Family!
stephanie pietromonaco
+5
So fun to step back in time and enter The Manor, a historic building in Montauk, and dine in an intimate dining room just off the main lobby. Thoughtfully and well prepared food, great service, and a staff and owner that truly cares made our experience great. Food is old school Italian with all the faves. We all enjoyed the Carbonara, the Stretch, the Wedge, the Shrimps, the Fluke and a great bottle of Nero d'Avola.
This place is amazing. We had the Meatballs and the spaghetti with Monte’s sauce. I must say that I can not stop talking about how good these meatballs were. We will return again!
This place is off the hook delicious. Best place to eat in Montauk hands down. I highly highly recommend.
Best chicken parm I've ever had. Very casual setting in a beautiful location. Prices are reasonable. We will be back again for sure.
I’m a local and wanted to stop by and try the restaurant since it just opened and they have reasonable prices. I was pleasantly surprised on how good the food was. Highly recommend.
The food, service, ambiance, and energy were all top notch. I'm going back as soon as I get back to MTK! Great job Monte's!
We dined in and it was exceptional. Food is amazing and vibe is real. Congrats and thank you
Yes!! Warm, cozy, authentic Italian vibe through and through. Feels old school. Great vibe + will be back 🍝
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Montauk
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes