Name: Reynold's Pasty Shop
Address: 3525 W Burleigh St, Milwaukee, United States, I-53210-1930
Telephone: +1 414-444-4490
Rating: 86

Ratings of Reynold's Pasty Shop

Trip

Last update on 02/01/2024

4,0

2 Reviews

Google

Last update on 31/12/2023

4,5

308 Reviews

Facebook

Last update on 28/09/2020

4,3

17 Reviews

Reviews

geri breitzman

They are the best been eating them since the 70's. We moved to TN and when we come home we bring some home with us. I wish you shipped them or were in TN

James Guse

Excellent. Know this the Hot-N-Fresh is very hot and real fresh. The pastry outer reminded me of pot pies of years long ago. We had beef gravy and sour cream. Sour cream was best but close 2nd was gravy. Some people park right on the street outside, we have a fat rear end so we squeezed into parking lot across the street. I hope we have time to stop in again before we leave.

Dave Assmann

Love this place. Best place around for pasties. Great childhood memories stopping here and getting one hot and ready to go.

Matthew Leeman

Delicious food every time! I always felt like they taste better from the shop compared to the frozen ones at the store. Staff are always very friendly and helpful. A Milwaukee classic for sure right here

Leo Jones

Great place. Recommend all to this small shop,that has been one of Milwaukee's finest, for years. You can find this pastry in super markets, world wide. This place has been in business for years.

Chetla Jackson

These are so good. Sadly, I can't find them in the stores anymore. You have to go the shop. The hours make it difficult to stop by after work...they were sold out to 2 and I needed 4 lol. But they're that good. The staff is always nice though I never really talk to anyone in the kitchen. I really wish they deliver via door dash or something lol.

Mary K

They really really really need to have a shipping service as they are not available anywhere out of Wisconsin and they are the best~~ truly the only pasties worth eating

Patricia Jordan

The pasties, as always, are perfect! The cashier is crazy as hell! Y'all be careful in there. She cursed out an old couple so bad it was disturbing and disgusting!

Timothy Fisher

Just like I asked call style bakery were you going in and they got beautiful cupcakes and a Lotta good sweet just like I asked call style bakery were you going in and they got beautiful cupcakes and a Lotta good sweets

Kayla Perlove

Really great tasting Pasty! Friendly and fast service. I'll be back again - oh and the gravy...YUM!

READ ALL REVIEWS

Description

Meal types

Lunch Dinner

Timetable

Now Open

Monday:

Closed

Tuesday:

09:30 AM - 06:30 PM

Wednesday:

09:30 AM - 06:30 PM

Thursday:

09:30 AM - 06:30 PM

Friday:

09:30 AM - 06:30 PM

Saturday:

09:30 AM - 06:30 PM

Sunday:

Closed

Read the reviews on

Trip

Google

Facebook

Info

Stay updated about Reynold's Pasty Shop's offers

Sluurpy's certification

Make a reservation

Order online

Find the best restaurant in Milwaukee

Unclamed activity

Compare the best restaurants near Reynold's Pasty Shop

				TA
Reynold's Pasty Shop	86	4.5	4.3	4
Mangos Cafe	71	4.2	3
Anodyne Coffee Roasting Co.	70
T's Everglades	70	4.2
KJ FOOD MART (Greenfield Ave)	70
Berry Me Frozen Yogurt & Cafe	85	4.5	4
Shah Jee's	90	4.5
Usinger's Famous Sausage	95	4.7	4.7	4.5