The best Key lime pie in Marathon | Sluurpy updated in May

"We were out of town for my daughter's birthday, and we needed to get her a birthday treat. This place was recommended, and I can see why. We bought..."

Nathan Corlew

Jake W

"Stopped by this place for some after dinner drinks. The island drinks are fantastic!! Staff was very friendly and the atmosphere was perfect as we..."

Dan Bell

"Great place to start the day. We had an amazing time enjoying our breakfast in one peacful morning. The place was nice, clean and quiet with a..."

Ginneson Willis

"Came for a quick dinner tonight. Got very prompt, friendly service by the bartenders. I tried the Cajun Fried Chicken Salad. It was more than..."

William Wright

"Flew in to Ft. Lauderdale end of July. Drove down to vacation in Key West. I knew we were stopping to eat here. The last time I was here was in 03' I..."

Chad Gambrell

"If I could give this place 10 stars I would. First time trying it out and let me just say, I was not disappointed. The server was amazing, food was..."

Chanse Augustine

"My favorite restaurant in Marathon. The atmosphere is superb and you can sit by the water and watch the fish swimming. Every food that I have had is..."

Star

Porky's Bayside Restaurant And Marina

81/100 (6672 ratings)

Free off-street parking

Non-smoking restaurants

Seating

Dog Friendly

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

"Finding places in marathon to have a good breakfast can be a little tricky. Porky's is right off US1 east of 7mile Bridge. Our breakfasts were..."

Dan Schultz

"Ate here for breakfast one day, and lunch another day. By far one of the best places to eat around the marathon area. Everything I got was excellent,..."

Travis Ebel

"Porky’s Bayside is as expected with some unexpected surprises. Expected: tiki hut charm ✅, friendly staff ✅, great happy hour ✅. Unexpected:..."

Brian Hager

"This place was yummy, I had Babyback ribs, corn coleslaw and mashed potates! This place has a giant menu, everything for everybody! And of course I..."

Sharon “SharBear” Lyons

"Awesome spot for lunch! Went to Porky's with my girlfriend and had an amazing experience. Our waiter “Kerr” was fantastic. Very attentive,..."

Ricardo Baptista

"Andrew our server was so lovely and pleasant! Had some great menu recommendations. Our food came out super fast and tasted great! Get the deep fried..."

Tu L

"Great dock side dining. Fun atmosphere and great food. Our group came for breakfast and had BBQ pork breakfast sandwich, Egg burrito, biscuit sausage..."

Rachel Beatrice

"Go there hungry! Lots of food and very well cooked. Didn't have a appetiser. Our server was almost to keen, sat down menus straight away. Drinks..."

Darran Neagle

"On a “bucket list” road trip with the family we pulled in here for lunch as they were right off the main highway. The curb appeal was what we..."

Cleaner Carpets by George Co.

"Great option if you want a break from seafood in the Keys. Porky’s did not disappoint! BBQ was good, the fish is delicious and not overpriced, for..."

Janine Carr

"We were planning on going to a different location but drove by this place and it looked very cute, so we stopped here instead. They didn't have it on..."

Christina Graves

"My husband and I decided to stop at this restaurant for brunch. Unfortunately, breakfast and at 11:00 a.m. and we were unable to have lunch. I was a..."

Shay W.

"Awesome and tasty food. The drinks were also well crafted and delicious. The restaurant is indoor/outdoor "tiki" style and can be humid during the..."

Shane Sellers

"Amazing little pearl!!! Very friendly service and great food!!! So good that we forgot to take a picture of the food! Prices are reasonable and the..."

Alba “AlbaSole”

"Delicious breakfast and rest of the day spot. Definitely has an island vibe but is very clean and the staff is a team and works well together! Skip..."

Stu Schwadron

"We stayed at Captain Pips. Came to Porky's and had a bucket of local beers and the BBQ Pork Fried Roll. Great service. AND the roll was amazing. ..."

cassidy fitzpatrick

"Andrew was an excellent server and had great recommendations for us. The food was killer; we got the spider roll, full snapper, and island chicken..."

Andria Zuccala

"Great food, excellent happy hour and the best mojito. Service by Stewart was fantastic. Thank..."

Ray Tessmann

Butterfly Cafe

81/100 (2323 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Absolutely incredible meal and experience from start to finish. The dining room was wonderfully appointed and just the right size. We shared the..."

Erin W (Erin)

"Very cozy and the food was delicious! The lemon pie was golden medal. This restaurant is inside Tranquility Bay Resort, with options to dine inside..."

Carolina Tardelli

"We had a great family meal here while staying at Tranquility Bay. The food was good, and our server Michelle was fantastic. The highlight of the meal..."

Woodie Zhao

"Really nice place to have dinner. I definitely recommend reservations. Our food was delicious, and the creme brulee was one of my favorites . Our..."

G. Image

"I found out about this place from my mother in law who lives down here. She ranted and raved about how good it was and she is one hundred percent..."

Frank Di Leo

"We went their for our anniversary dinner and it was amazing! We both had the filet and it was done perfectly. The dessert was great. The service was..."

Joy Rademacher

"We checked-in and went to the Butterfly Cafe for our first dinner. Randi took awesome care of us and made some great recommendations. We ordered the..."

S

"Came for the steak. Stayed for the fish. Kind, welcoming staff. Beautiful patio. Good food. Overall a relaxing evening at the Butterfly Café. Hope..."

Meghan Marks

"Celebrated hubby's birthday. We had a lovely time. Service and atmosphere were..."

Julia

"Absolutely no complaints about this place. The food was good, I sampled the crab soup special, the shrimp cocktail (a lil small but good), the lamb..."

Nick Sackandy

"The food was surprisingly amazing - we certainly did not expect this elevated dining experience. The warm goat cheese appetizer had a complexity of..."

Fanci Bosco-Duvall

"Roxanne was such an amazing and attentive server. She really helped complete the vibe at the butterfly cafe with all of her amazing recommendations...."

Jessica Sharpe

"Me and my group of other 4 people parked on the hotels parking and entered the restaurant. We went on a Sunday at around 7:50pm it was a big space..."

Devasya Nepal

"One of the best meals and environments I’ve ever had in the Keys. It was such a unique and beautiful experience all..."

Brandon Cornellier

"The food was good, the dessert was delicious, the service was great, would not recommend sitting outside, mosquitoes are terrible. A little pricey,..."

Natalie N

"Nara at The Butterfly Cafe was a great server! And the food was outstanding! Beautiful views - a must see in..."

Janice Essick

Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar

81/100 (7516 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"One of the BEST places we have eaten at, since we have been in the Keys! Little , hidden gem, with AMAZING food (sushi was favorite) , lots of..."

Katie Mantelli-Atlanta Realtor

"I had the immense pleasure of dining at Castaways in Marathon, and let me just say, it's a hidden gem you won't want to miss! From the outside, you..."

Jamie Engel, Florida Keys Real Estate

"Had a party of 7, so made reservations on open table- made seating super easy! Menu was extensive and had something for everyone. Kids menu also..."

Rachel Johnson

"First off Selina our server was great. If you go and you should, ask for her. They had a large selection of Sushi and seafood offerings. The Mahi..."

Tom Traynor

"Overall 5 stars and highly recommend a visit. Staff were very helpful and welcoming. Tracy (my server) was spot on with her seafood recommendation..."

David Wiseman

"Great food . Shrimp tacos was great in taste , well made and fresh. Mahi fish with castaway special was super great with wasabi sauce. Smoked..."

Sujit Patnaik

"Marathon has a true treasure in this restaurant. The food is excellent, the service is excellent, and the folks are friendly. We have eaten at places..."

Jean Foster

"Super fun place. Quirky decorations that draw from the local fishing culture. Brian was super helpful with recommendations and had lots of cool..."

Mason M

"Our server Christine was very friendly and fabulous at her job . Best server we have ever had . Had the lion fish sushi roll and coconut shrimp-..."

Christine Fryberger

"I recently had the pleasure of dining at Castaways Restaurant in Marathon, FL, and it was an excellent experience. Despite its unassuming exterior,..."

Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor (South Florida Realtor)

7 Mile Grill

79/100 (3351 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Both my husband and I were more than satisfied with our meals. I got the Eggs Benedict, and my husband got the Corned Beef Hash, the REAL deal, no..."

Christa Hall

"When vacationing in Marathon we’re always looking for a good breakfast place….who would’ve thought 7 Mile Grill! So so good, service was great,..."

Jay Canals

"An old-fashioned quick order diner. Staff was prompt, and the breakfast was tasty and greasy. The diner has indoor/outdoor seating. The bathroom..."

Shane Sellers

"Food is pretty standard for a breakfast joint. And the service was good. First cup of coffee came out lukewarm which was disappointing and the..."

Not Dr Strange

"What a great place to eat! The food was great! The rice was very flavorful, and they had a great vibe going on! Great service! My only complaint is..."

Alisha Pollard

"We stopped on a whim and oh so glad we did!! This place was phenomenal and our waitress was amazing! Food was fresh and absolutely delicious...."

Denise Ellis

"STOP HERE! What a wonderful experience. The ambiance, the service, the food and the best mimosa we’ve had in a long time! My husband enjoyed the..."

Blair Pollister

"My husband and I had breakfast. The nova lox was a very big portion with a nice kinda-thin bagel. Very fresh. Grits were delicious and buttery. He..."

Natalie Fincik

"Perfect meal to end a full day of site seeing in the Keys. The entire staff was friendly, smiling, kept our beverages full, and checking to see if..."

Stacy Klone

"Excellent breakfast and customer service, thank you from the EXPENDABLES TATTOOS INKORPORATED..."

EXPENDABLES

"Just happened to stop in for a drink and appetizer, when we were happily greeted and never left. Food and drinks are great. Aptomphere is..."

susan henderson

"Lots of menu choices besides the fresh fish found on every menu in Marathon. Chicken, pasta, great salads too. I had French Onion soup & house side..."

Rosalie Mietzel

"We were headed south and stopped in for lunch - sat at the bar and had lovely service. Bartender was local and so kind - talkative and gave fantastic..."

Kelli Durkin

"I quaint little diner with prices more reasonable than most places on the islands. The breakfast fare is what you'd expect, the corned beef hash is..."

Jaracgos

"First time at this place yesterday - it was great! Shrimp were large and perfectly breaded, service was friendly and prompt. One of the few..."

Jeff Wood

"The first time here in marathon and we decided to come here for breakfast! The waitress was absolutely wonderful!! I got the eggs Benedict and the..."

desiree klotz

Cracked Conch Cafe

77/100 (3550 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"We ate here on our Honeymoon in the Keys 30 years ago. We returned 7 years ago. And again last night. The Cracked Conch Sandwich is exactly the same!..."

William Lile

"My wife and I split the conch franchise and the conch ceviche appetizer for dinner, along with onion rings which were exceptional onion rings. Wow,..."

Shane Thee

"Our waitress was very outgoing and friendly with a great sense of humor. Our party of 9 ordered mostly sweet tea and she knew instantly we are..."

Tonya Hunter

"Had such an amazing eggs Benedict I went to eat here 2 out of my 3 days in Marathon! My boyfriend loves there half pound sirloin burger! I love that..."

Moonlight Artistry

"Table for four, please! Great little old fashion diner. The place may not look like much, but the food was amazing, and the staff was extremely..."

Doreen Burke

"Food was delicious and so inexpensive. Beachy local vibe. Sat at bar and was served by who I believe to be owner. She was great and even sent me on..."

Christine Thompson

"Love this place, big menu especially for conch! And great for breakfast! YUMMY! And awesome..."

Sharon “SharBear” Lyons

"Stopped here with my girlfriend after a day on the beach. She ordered a plate of the conch marsala. When the food arrived, and she picked up that..."

Brian Matthew

"Awesome place to try conch. Very tasty and big..."

Rafal Szczepankiewicz

"The only restaurant in the Florida Keys to have been open every day since it first opened! Fabulous and delicious lunch! Our server was the best..."

A Muncie Experience

"I had an absolutely delightful breakfast experience at Cracked Conch Cafe! The morning ambiance was charming, and the breakfast options were truly..."

Luke Bonner

"Excellent breakfast and Bloody Mary! Great spot for a quick bite - I had the steak and eggs, asked for the breakfast potatoes to be well done and..."

Alys Roark

"They say good things come in small packages, well consider Cracked Conch Cafe a hidden gem. Located right off the main highway, the restaurant..."

Allen bullard

"First time I ever ate there, very good food, great service, nice laid back atmosphere. Prices are reasonable for the keys, 5 guys had breakfast for..."

Tim Adams

"Made a quick stop and had one of the most scrumptious french onion soup. Very friendly staff that checks on you and they had a very interesting..."

Merlina Ramirez

"Great place right on Rt1. Easy on and off. Plenty of parking. Breakfast all day. Had the conch cafe (just tenderized conch batter fried). It was..."

Alexandra Mathiasen

Lazy Days South

77/100 (4322 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Stopped at the Lazy Day Marathon last night based upon my best friends recommendation. We had our kids with us too. My friend ordered the lazy day..."

Robin Prentice Bowlby

"Loved this restaurant. Save it for the last night, because this is the one restaurant, amongst all the awesome others, that shines in the light (and..."

Douglas Smith

"Hog Fish Francese is to die for. The best point blank. An absolute must if you are staying in Marathon. Ask them to make you a margarita with..."

Luis E Barreto

"We are at Lazy Days South while on vacation in Marathon on our last night there. The food was great, but more importantly the management and staff..."

Misti Vandenhouten

"I fished on a charter and the Captain recommended this place for cooking our catch. All I can say is wow! Presentation was perfect and the food was,..."

Chris Hamann

"We brought our tuna and mahi we caught today for them to prepare. Our waiter suggested jalapeño panko crusted for the tuna.The five of us all agree,..."

Chael Sanchez Hanley

"Had my first meal here tonight at the suggestion of Rachel at White Sands Inn (that's another amazing story to tell !) ...and she was SO right. The..."

Gail Camp Tucker

"We loved Lazy Days! Food was excellent, the portions are very large. We could have shared a meal. If you sit outside the view is beautiful. Our..."

Karri Huber

"Stopped in for some happy hour food and drinks - very comfortable, clean, friendly staff, Good food from the $4 menu and drinks reasonable. Will go..."

Kellie Hanck

"I don’t understand some of the reviews. I’m not a local; I’m from the Midwest. I found this restaurant to be affordable and delightful! I’m..."

Nicole Mariani

"It was the only place we visited twice on vacation. The fish was delicious prepared in Islamorada and Lazy Days styles. My absolute favorite was the..."

Nicole Handler

"Went there for breakfast and was simply astounded by the service we received from Patrick our waiter that went well above any standard service..."

Ryan Haga

"Great spot for water views, great drinks, and great food! We went for the sunset, which was beautiful but slightly blocked by the condos close by. ..."

Kelly

"Great for lunch and dinner … waterside dining which we preferred. There is also indoor dining. We had Seafood bisque, Crab Dip, Billings Salad,..."

Sherry Carey

"Definitely stop by Lazy Days. You won't be disappointed. Our server, Ella, made us feel like we were locals. The food was delicious and they had..."

Louise Coulter

"Absolute. BEST place for cook your catch!! We do it 3 ways- Lazy Days Style, garlic and jalapeño. It is PERFECTION!! Service great, love the..."

Sabre Mendoza

"Food was good. Service was slow but he was the only waiter so he did the best he could. He was friendly but they were..."

Amy Culligan

"After fishing in the morning, our charter recommended Lazy Days to cook our catch. We brought a few pounds of a variety of filets to be grilled and..."

Nicholas Bartolotta

"I hosted my son’s wedding rehearsal dinner here for 75 people and we couldn’t have been more pleased! The food was delicious, their service was..."

Kathy Taylor

"First time at this restaurant and it was very delicious! 😋 The food was fresh and well-made, and the drinks as well. Overall, everything was..."

Patty Hernández

"The chef will prepare your fresh catch of the day in a variety if ways. My favorite was lazy days with key lime butter tomatoes and some cheese...."

Loretta Calvert

"Absolutely fantastic!! We took our catch of tuna, yellowtail snapper, mutton snapper and mackerel there. The chef prepared it a few different ways...."

Denny Sharrone

"Had the grouper Lorenzo. Fish was cooked well but it was floating in the key lime butter and bearnaise sauce which made it hard to eat. I’d order..."

Rick Jensen

Lighthouse Grill

76/100 (2496 ratings)

Accepts American Express

Seating

Table Service

Waterfront

Wheelchair Accessible

"Start to finish service, food and drinks were awesome. Our server was super attentive. We’re not new to the Lighthouse Grill as we frequent here..."

Jay Canals

"During our return journey from K West, we were on the lookout for something extraordinary, a place that combined a modern kitchen with a beautiful..."

Dillon Mykalo

"The atmosphere would have been better if the sun was not setting during our 🍽️ meal. Also odd there is a pool adjacent to the restaurant but, oh..."

Rodreich Stotsenburg

"We had a great meal here and the atmosphere is awesome. Only four stars on the meal because we felt that the portions were too..."

Ken Jones

"Everything was wonderful. The view, the food and drinks and topped off with great service. Nikki was our waitress and she was happy and helpful. Very..."

Chris Brown

"We made our reservation online. Got a great table with a good view. They had live music while were there which was nice. Great food options other..."

Burcay Gurcan

"Excellent place and very convenient walk as it is on property of Faro Blanco resort. Reservations recommended. The lighthouse and yacht dock view is..."

Abhishek Shete

"We were a party of eight and were able to get a nice table on a patio on a Sunday night. The vibe of the restaurant was really nice as there was a..."

Emily Wloch

"The drinks were good and the food was pleasant as well. However I mentioned to the waiter that my wife did not really do spicy food and instead of..."

Charles Moore

"What an amazing experience! Walking in, we were greeted by Jennifer (“Jen”), who would be our server. What a patient and more than listening..."

Helen M. Kent

"Everything was amazing, our server Kellen was great! The crab puffs, grouper sandwich, and key lime pie were all delicious. The restaurant was super..."

Tango Mango

"Our reservation for 4 was sat immediately, our waitress, Shannon, was very helpful and attentive, and the food was Sublime! We had ceviche, linguine,..."

Diego Debesa

"Had a great Thanksgiving dinner. nice atmosphere and prices. Our Server “K” was amazing. She was very friendly and helpful. Thank you “K”..."

Kevin Olson

"Had lunch with my sister ! First time to come here ! Service was great ! Food was delicious ! Recommended..."

LIz B

"We have been coming to this area for years and somehow we have missed it. The view is fantastic. Right on the marina with an unimpeded view of the..."

Frank Di Leo

"Absolutely fantastic. Great place with an amazing view, awesome service crew, and spectacular food. A little more expensive than other places, but..."

Adam Engle

"We were staying next door at the Marriot and walked over based on the recommendation of the hotel staff. Glad we did, because this turned out to be..."

James LaMountain

"Very cool spot that we hadn’t been to before but saw they had live music. We were pleasantly surprised. Great spot next to the pool in the..."

Mike I

"Stopped by for lunch. Staff was friendly and accommodating. The lunch was a tad limited. I had the shrimp ceviche which was okay. The tajin throw it..."

Reset

There are 21 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Key lime pie in Marathon

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Missy Tolbert

Madison Ortiz

Jenna Thomas

Justin D

Carissa Marriaga

Justa Foodie

Kara Speck

Bdarril

Cristin Harber

Daryl Johnson

Jim Burgraff

alicia lurye

Matt YouTube-FloridaAmbient

Derek 303 Schick

Raegan Linster

Devin Leary

Sharon “SharBear” Lyons

Nathan Corlew

Shane Sellers

Big Lou

eugene clur

Rachel Johnson

Ross Lazarek

Mile Marker Brian

Jonathan Ptachcinski

B D

Brittany Erica

Richard Williams

S C

Frank Vvk

Vanessa Hehl

Scott Bernhardt

GJ Poore

Becky Hurley

Wholegrain

Raegan Linster

Jason Nicholas

Noel Nissen

Jill Samantha

Evie Weaver

Tomas Jedinak

Nickie Danowski

Cookie Bell McConaghie

Carrie Owens

Dave Tackes

Eric McEachern

Joshua Mann

Darice Lane Horachek

Lacy Fregm

Aaron Osters

Joe Mott

Judi Rovner Colgan

Rebecca Edmisten

Nina Grigio

Eva Cagwin

David A

Justa Foodie

Timothy Lentz

Dayna Guinn

Ashley S.

Ir DYB

Desirae Marie Hersey

Tia Thompson

Spring Rice

Glenda Gomez

Rob McClung

JohnLinda Haltiwanger

philippe gabulon