The pizza was awesome and the owners were just as great!!!
Very good authentic pizza. We also had wings and cheese sticks for appetizers they both were very good.
Best pizza in the Keys! We've been ordering from Upper Crust for years during our visits to the Keys. Once again, I forgot to take a picture of the pizza because everyone devours it after a day a Bahia Honda beach. We stay on Big Torch Key and drive the 30 minutes to get this pizza.
Because of long-time-waiting-to-be-seated in other restaurants, we decided to have a pizza at this place on a Monday evening in February 2023.
The food, pizza and drinks were tasteful and the service was friendly and not pushy. Finally a place that wasn’t packed! Price/quality wise ok.
This pizza was the best pizza I have had in a long time!! Highly recommend this little pizzeria.
My kids , husband, and my self where very pleased.
Got a carry out pizza. Just visiting and staying at Isla Bella resort down the road. Got the large pepperoni and cheese and a small cheese pizza for the little guy. Pizza was phenomenal!! Glad I choose this place. Will try the Italian next time.
Please give the Upper Crust a try. I don’t think you’ll be disappointed. Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Toppings from crust to crust. I ordered the Tuscan my husband got sausage and pepperoni with white sauce. We tried another pizza place and was so disappointed. $20 for a “10 pizza with 2” of crust. Topping were very sparse. We will definitely be back to the Upper Crust!
Great service, super friendly and and overall great place with great pizza!
Not many places get a 5 star review from me but this place does! Aton, maybe the manager? Not really sure...but I know EVERY time I've been there and she is there I've gotten amazing pizza! I've actually never been there when she wasn't there so she might actually be the owner...not sure. All I know is this is the BEST pizza I've ever gotten (deluxe) and it is the BEST every time I've given them my business! Which has been 6 times now. 100% out of 6 times is enough to write a review I will definitely be back!
We stayed at a hotel right down the road from Upper Crust, and one night we just really felt like getting pizza, but not sitting down anywhere. So we called here and ordered takeout, and they were super awesome! Their website is super easy to look at a menu, which other pizza places I did not find the same, and when I called the lady I spoke to was so nice, and great. And when we got the pizza half an hour later, it was really good!! The perfect dinner in! And we also had to nab a slice of key lime pie, and I thought it was pretty good. I wasn’t a huge fan of the sprinkles on top, I didn’t really prefer that extra crunch but the raspberry or strawberry drizzle was wonderful, a great touch. So yeah, if you want some classic good Keys pizza give these guys a try!
We had the Greek salad and Tuscan pizza. It was so great! Nice quiet place and great service. I will come back next time we are here!
These reviews are opinions.. everyone has then. Try it for yourself and you decide :)
Fantastic pizza! Highly recommend this place. The wings were delicious, if you like a little heat, and the Tuscan pizza was uniquely delicious!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Marathon
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes