The best Cheesecake in Marathon | Sluurpy updated in June

Island Fish Company

82/100 (11056 ratings)

Restaurants

Bar

American

Vegan Options

American

Gluten Free Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Vegan Options

Gluten Free Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Brunch

Breakfast

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Lobster

Fish

Lobster Roll

Tapas

Pancakes

Fish Taco

Tacos

Pasta

Salad

Fish Sandwich

Crab

Clams

Oyster

Fried shrimp

Calamari

Omelette

Tuna

Sandwiches

Corned Beef

Calamares

Burger

Key lime pie

Ceviche

Shrimp

Grouper Sandwich

Crab Cake

Cakes

Chowder

Pesto

Cheesecake

Sit down

American

Bar

Outdoor Seating

Takeout

Television

Waterfront

Seating

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Parking Available

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Accepts Credit Cards

Brunch

Breakfast

Dinner

Late Night

Lunch

Mid-range

"Great location, customer service ok, fresh food,no wifi, no glass bottled still water, plastic straw and cups some miles away from Turtle..."

Gmerk

"Everything the table ordered was top of the line. Service was outstanding. Their Conch Chowder was amazing. The atmosphere was incredible. Eating on..."

Alysan Burgbacher

"Great food! We had the crab cakes starter and the grouper and it was amazing! The atmosphere is really fun! The key lime coolada is to die for!! I..."

Ashley Ashton

"Fast, friendly service and delicious food!. Visited this restaurant on 3/12/15 and it was, by far, the best place I have eaten at in the Keys...."

Csfungirl03

"Shrimp poboy. Great-----24 Nov, 2014-----Mahi. Best ever-----24 Nov, 2014-----Oysters on the Half Shell...."

Jeffbud8

"Great place!!!. We enjoyed the food and the location on the water. Our kids really enjoyed watching the fish as they..."

Bridget

"Great Service and Huge Servings. We drove by this place and thought it was a great location and looked nice, read some reviews and decided to try it...."

Carrollwood Foodie

"Best Seafood Wish is at Island Fish!. I'll start by saying that this is the type of place you hope to find when on vacation! Island Fish..."

Gastroeclectico

"Love this place... I was in duck key for my honeymoon and went to this place about 4 times ... For breakfast and 3 dinners... Awesome... I still..."

John

"So good the first night we came back a second night. Highly recommend the conch fritters, lobster bisque, tuna tatika, and the fried key lime..."

Julie Haskard Lane

"Came here twice for dinner during my two week stay. Fresh seafood and friendly staff. Wonderful stone crab claws and oysters on the half..."

Shawn

"Loved it, can't beat the location! Wish the sunset wasn't covered by the clouds & a little noisy but otherwise no complaints. Service was great..."

Devin Ostermann

"Excellent service. Good food. Get there early. It fills up by 6:30 in..."

Diver91

"Good food, nice ambiance, and we had good wait staff who was very..."

Bkm

"Fantastic food, best place within walking distance of holiday inn. Fish tacos, ceaser salad nice and cold, pistachio yellowfin really nice. Extensive..."

Lou

"For the Keys, the price is too bad, but the food is definitely delicious!!! My family really enjoyed our dishes and the atmosphere of this marine..."

Liney

"My second trip here. Both were good. Good Fresh Fish and Stone Crab. Would go back when I'm in the area..."

Ed L

"Great food good atmosphere and good service you can't ask for..."

Dan Dundon

"The best restaurant in Marathon- best calamari I've ever had!! Fabulous service, right on the gulf coast! Tiki style, open floor plan right on the..."

Kmozyon

"Not the best service(waitress forgot my sister's order and returned saying she had a brain fart) but its a great atmosphere right on the water. I'd..."

Gal Fieri

"Outstanding food. Very popular. Conch Chowder was excellent. Fresh fish was very fresh. Try the oysters moscow!!!. Oysters with horseradish cream..."

Bob Chilcote

"Great fish sandwiches with delicious homemade coleslaw. Large portions. Service was friendly but slow, not the place to eat if you're in a hurry. I'd..."

BeachyKeen

"Gluten-free WIN. After searching for seafood restaurants with varied menus, we landed at Island Fish Co mainly because it is across the street from..."

Stegenrae

"The food was delicious! We started with the crab spinach dip, and had the shrimp diablo and shrimp Diane. Huge portions of the pasta bowls!!!..."

Mallory DuBois

"A fantastic spot to stop traveling thru the Keys. A scenic spot right on the water. Service was spot on and the menu has something for everyone with..."

TheQueenHasSpoken

"Great time! Good drinks! Good food! And great service! Skip the desert.. Too..."

CBee

"Hubby loved his oyster po'boy. I had the island chef salad. It was full of c crab, shrimp, and grilled chicken. Very nice atmosphere on th..."

Suzy Rupp

"Wide variety, from fish lovers to vegetarians this place has something for everyone. The hog fish was a favorite along with great sunset..."

Picky Eater

"Great gulf shore dining. This open air restaurant is located on the gulf side of Marathon and has outstanding views. The food was great but the..."

Rand_s

"Its a must stop when passing through marathon, food is excellent, atmosphere there is very warm and fun. I even drove my group from islmorada out of..."

Birdofprey

"Food was exceptional and you gotta have a key lime colada! I will be..."

Apolicerecruit

"Good food, great..."

JChetta

"Great view. This is tied with Sunset Grill for best Marathon view! Good..."

SPH

"Great Views, Great Ambiance. The Island is wonderful: the tiki bar is fun, and the outdoor seating here is breathtaking. Amazing views. Good service...."

Dr. Matt

"Great food and open atmosphere. Outdoor dining. Lots to choose from... prices from $9-$29. The key lime oysters were an awesome starter. Other good..."

Katie

"Good food and great atmosphere right on the..."

Rick Hunt

"We had a really great time -- good food (not fantastic) and a great open air atmosphere. You really can't pass this place..."

Foodsmith

"Good food and atmosphere but no live..."

Mar

"Great..."

Mar Woodworth

"I had a hankering for some fried shrimp and was happy to see them on the menu. BEST. FRIED. SHRIMP. EVER! I would swear they were fresh. They..."

FoodieOnTheSide.com

"The coolest part of this place was the atmosphere! Blue lights under the dock water, an island pet iguana with custom housing, which included fresh..."

C E

"First time trying Island Fish Company, and Kelly was an amazing server. She made our experience that much better and was very attentive,..."

Justin Ruiz

"The food here is exceptional! I think this was the VERY best meal I’ve had during my time here in The Keys! Our server was EXTREMELY personable,..."

Bailey Ostrom

"IMO, this is one of the best restaurants in the Keys, and the best in Marathon Key! First, the Grouper bisque! Nice, large chunks of grouper in the..."

David Williamsen

"This restaurant was great. It is located on the water, so the views are awesome. The food was good but our service wasn't that good. We kept having..."

Steve Gibbs

"On our recent trip to the Florida Keys we stopped in here to watch the FSU game and get something to eat. The food was amazing. Our server and the..."

Derek S

"Loved the appetizers , my creepy coco lychee drink and fried Cory lime pie. If you like creamy coconut drinks you definitely need to try their creepy..."

Esty Frometa

"Honestly the best place my family and I are on vacation… a great spot on Florida and even when things aren’t perfect they are very close to it...."

Anthony Calvanese

"This was a fun place to go. We went on the dock and fed the fish. You could be near the water if away. They have a gift shift. The seafood egg roll..."

Latisha “Hungry Hiker Hodgepodge” M

"Solid stop in Marathon. Friendly bartenders and good cocktails. Shrimp appetizer was great, oysters ok very mixed in size. Fried grouper was..."

Tammy Morgan

"We went twice on our visit but it’s definitely a different experience if you do not get a table by the water. It’s the best view I saw in..."

Heather T

"This was our second time eating here. We ate here almost 10 years ago. Very little has changed. The atmosphere is the same and the food is still..."

Nathan Corlew

"They are so popular they probably don’t need my review anyway. It has great vibe, great view and the food there is just superior. Had to wait for..."

Jake W

"Stopped by this place for some after dinner drinks. The island drinks are fantastic!! Staff was very friendly and the atmosphere was perfect as we..."

Dan Bell

"Great place to start the day. We had an amazing time enjoying our breakfast in one peacful morning. The place was nice, clean and quiet with a..."

Ginneson Willis

"Came for a quick dinner tonight. Got very prompt, friendly service by the bartenders. I tried the Cajun Fried Chicken Salad. It was more than..."

William Wright

"Flew in to Ft. Lauderdale end of July. Drove down to vacation in Key West. I knew we were stopping to eat here. The last time I was here was in 03' I..."

Chad Gambrell

"If I could give this place 10 stars I would. First time trying it out and let me just say, I was not disappointed. The server was amazing, food was..."

Chanse Augustine

"My favorite restaurant in Marathon. The atmosphere is superb and you can sit by the water and watch the fish swimming. Every food that I have had is..."

Reset

There are 14 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Cheesecake in Marathon

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Missy Tolbert

Madison Ortiz

Jenna Thomas

Justin D

Carissa Marriaga

Justa Foodie

Kara Speck

Bdarril

Cristin Harber

Daryl Johnson

Jim Burgraff

alicia lurye

Matt YouTube-FloridaAmbient

Derek 303 Schick

Raegan Linster

Devin Leary

Brittany Erica

Richard Williams

S C

Frank Vvk

Vanessa Hehl

Scott Bernhardt

GJ Poore

Becky Hurley

Wholegrain

Raegan Linster

Jason Nicholas

Noel Nissen

Kyle Johnson

Nick B

nathan goodfellow

Brandon Martinez

Zarina Steward

Megan Whitworth

Ani V

L W

Chris

Diane Zeigler

Susan Block

K P

Tena Jones

Heather Sherman

Allison Henderson

Andrew Lawson

Dr. Michelle McKenzie Poche

Dalila Stewart

Julie Eastman

Lina Arbelaez

Ben Clark

Britt Dearie

Jennifer Boyd

Varun Navale

Miranda Schultz

Suzanne Gay

Carlene Poster

Alexis Campbell

Yuliya HRISTOV - Outer Banks Realtor

Michael Davidson

Elena S

Elizabeth Tisone

Bradley

Bruce B

marie brett

Louann Jewell

Timothy C

David Smith

Tony Rodriguez

Sondra Willets