The best Dinner in Key West | Sluurpy updated in May

Fogarty's

87/100 (7454 ratings)

Restaurants

American

Gluten Free Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Vegan Options

American

Seafood

Gluten Free Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Vegan Options

Brunch

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Sandwiches

Po' Boys

Cheeseburger

Cakes

Burger

Bruschette

Crab Cake

Hamburgers

Pesto

Chowder

Cheesecake

Fish

Tapas

Fish Taco

Shrimp

Tacos

Filet Mignon

Pork

Ribs

Lobster

Fish Sandwich

Pasta

Salad

Tortillas

Key lime pie

Crab

Lettuce Wraps

Tuna

Sit down

American

Seafood

Serves Alcohol

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Accepts Credit Cards

Outdoor Seating

Takeout

Television

Accepts Mastercard

Accepts Visa

Accepts American Express

Live Music

Seating

Table Service

Accepts Discover

Wheelchair Accessible

Late Night

Brunch

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"this is an awesome place dadsadadasd ada dadad ada dadad adada dasf afafa fsaf aqfqefwef afsfwef werwtwee twegfsdgfds etwtw wefsdfs fwe wtwt..."

Cesar Phantom

"Efendim ne zamandir tatil munasebetiyle yazamiyorum buyrun floridanin minigi key west te ne yenir lezzetli mi lezzetli deniz urunleri..."

Melodi

"Really, really good food. We had the cracked pepper Ahi Tuna as a starter - quality fish, seared to a perfect rare and with a chili soy, was..."

BlockDaddy21

"Great service! Even during the holiday rush my group of 10 got in with no wait. The food was absolutely delicious. Our group's favorites were the..."

Emilee B

"Yay! Key West Pride 2015! Dinner at Fogarty's was quite a pleasant experience. The service was good even though there was a large crowd.As..."

Alletun

"The crab and corn chowder was some of the best I ever had. That said, Luckie, pick up the pace. Maybe your having a bad day, but try a little..."

Matt Gorham

"Located in the midst of duval street, this establishment was serving up some tasty treats with really friendly service. They have cooling misters..."

E

"Amazing! Catch of the day was red snapper. Got it blackened, with the house sauce drizzled over, rice and veggies. Everything could not have been..."

Carter

"Good was great! We had the catch of the day (mahi) and we had the ribeye. Both were cooked perfect. The customer service was spot..."

Walt

"Good food... Great service, i went with 2 other friends.. we ordered the shrimp po' boy, the pork ribs and the fogarty burger.. all 3 things were..."

Birdiebyrd

"Excellent shrimp club sandwich. My friend loved the chopped salad. Fun place to people watch in Key..."

Rah Cha Chow

"We both had Chicken Romano and it was delicious, very garlicy. It was a big plate as well, so value was pretty good for..."

Jimmy Yoder

"Get the peppered tuna. It will change your life. Seriously.... Do it.Had a group of 8 have dinner here before we met for a ghost tour...."

Lacy Pennington

"Second time here. Fist time about three years ago. The Cobb salad is pretty good and the crusted chicken pasta is great! Will go back the next time I..."

Tulia

"Wasn't sure about this place when we first walked in. The food was really great. The chicken over pasta was amazing and you got your moneys worth of..."

Melonie

"Great atmosphere decebt prices, good location, drinks are..."

ImReallyPicky

"Good food, fun atmosphere.. This place is a great spot to people watch on Duval. Nice patio, friendly service, huge portions of good food. We had the..."

Acb244

"Great place to people watch on Duval. Great drinks at Flying Monkey. Great grilled fish sandwich and shrimp club. Always come here when coming to Key..."

Lorenzo Padron

"Had the crab cakes and they were fantastic. Friendly staff and speedy service. Great piña colada..."

Stephanie Cates Hodges

"Best Resturant In the Keys. This is by far a must eat at place in the Keys. I was there 3 days ans ate 2x's a day there. I did try another resturant..."

Mary Lane

"HUGE Portions. Be prepared to eat BIG....one of the bet values for the money in Key west. Service was super quick on a very busy night. The Salads..."

Hubby_88

"We had the lettuce wraps and the pecan crusted Mahi Mahi, both were very delicious. The atmosphere was great and the service was..."

Maggie

"Great find in Key West. If you don't know where your going and have just a short time in Key West, go here! Had the pecan encrusted Mahi and wow! You..."

Jerry

"Food was excellent. Mahi tacos were big enough to share with 2 or 3 people. Definitly get a frozen drink from the flying monkey. All of them are..."

Maggie Watts

"Outstanding this place is a must the bruschetta is to die for...it's not just about seafood the burgers are Devine and the prices are reasonable and..."

Rose Quintero

"Highly recommend eating here while vacationing in key west. Would recommend the shrimp poboy and conch fritters. Impressive bloody marys. A must eat..."

SLGY

"Huge juicy burgers.. Cooked to order and fabulous toppings. Enough..."

Emily Pernal

"Food was outstanding and large portions. We had fish tacos and the sloppy grouper. Friendly fast service. Great spot to people..."

Sheryl

"Good! Had ahi appt, grouper sandwich (huge-it was shared and great) and mahi tacos. Lots of bang for the buck. Nice atmosphere outside. Service was..."

FA Jenn

"Great food. Reasonable prices. Our server, Samantha was excellent. And the best part? The coldest beer I've had all..."

KellyR

"TOP NOTCH!. Fogarty's, without a doubt is the best restaraunt in Key West! Wonderful decor along with a kind wait staff; one could not be anymore..."

Ronnie

"Liked it very much. The Ahi tuna appetizer was delectable, as was the Key West sampler. Service was excellent both times we were there...."

Hatguy

"Great view of Duvall but not the standard Duvall fair. We had the peppered Ahi tuna appetizer-excellent. Also the shrimp BLT & the shrimp po boy were..."

Stephanie McClain Boyd

"Great food, reasonable prices, great wait..."

TJ Benoit

"Beautiful outdoor setting for dinner on Duval Street. Good, reliable..."

Jason B

"Fresh seafood, great service, and good frozen drinks...what more could you ask..."

Ryno

"Food was good and service was good! Got the "key west feeling" when you sit..."

Tabithaluvr

"We didn't actually eat at the restaraunt but rather drank numerous frozen cocktails at their outside bar called the Flying Monkey. You must try the..."

Joe C.

"Fun spot to sit and eat while hitting up the bars on Duval St. Recommended by our taxi driver we sat outside had good drinks and food at the right..."

Mike C

"A Tour Stop. 3 Stars - We dined at the patio of Fogarty's while on a "Taste of Key West" excursion tour that we booked through our Cruise..."

WAherron

"We came for an anniversary and was not disappointed! The ribs were AMAZING! My husband had the fish tacos and was so impressed with them. The banana..."

Kay Meyer

"Great place to grab a very strong slushy drink! Classic stop on Duval Street. Stop by and grab a Rum Runner, Banana Chocolate, or one of their..."

Eric

"Delicious! Portions were generous and food was fresh. Service was great. Would recommend stopping here for lunch or dinner while in KeyWest. The key..."

Cloe Mohsen

"Classic American style restaurant with seating areas and high stool tables. Very friendly and knowledgeable staff. Luke helped us with the menu and..."

Alessandra Distefano

"I've had many meals here. Our sever Natalie was perfect. Mahi tacos, shrimp po boy, and conch fritters. Everything..."

Jeff Shore

"Generous delicious portions of food and tasty pina coladas. My only dislike was they use high fructose corn syrup ketchup. I meant to order bacon on..."

LLO Legal Assistant

"Fogarty’s is an absolute must in KW. The atmosphere of the restaurant is so fun and enjoyable. The menu is not overly complicated like a lot of..."

Sabrina Locke

"My conch fritter appetizer was amazing! Best on the island, and the remoulade sauce A+ I don't remember our servers name, a redheaded guy. He was..."

Steve B.

"Well I can’t remember all the names of the foods precisely we got but Fogarty’s is easily the best place we have ate at in Key West so far and a..."

Daddy Hordel

"Fogarty's is pretty good and has a great location right on Duval street. The food was great but the drinks were not. The service was slow and almost..."

Peter Commerford

"I’d say the food was just ok for what it cost. We stopped in for lunch. Atmosphere is excellent, but again your in Kew West can’t go wrong..."

M C

"Tim our waiter was great, we received fast service, friendly and great attitude. Food was really good, couldn't have asked for anything better. Great..."

Gina Rehoseni

"We stopped for Margaritas - my husband had a Banana Split. Very laid back. Friendly..."

Kristin Grose

"My mom and I had the fish tacos and margaritas. The fish tacos were perfectly cooked and the sauce had a great kick to it. They were not cheap on the..."

Janet A.

"Absolutely great service! Food arrived quickly and was delicious and very ample serving..."

Dave Warner

"Amazing food and even much more amazing staff! Super friendly and very welcoming. For american customers it could be maybe absolutely normal thing,..."

Karolína Machatová

"In the heart of Duval Street. I try to eat here every time I’m in KW. Love the atmosphere and their menu. Fast and fresh food. We have a Fish..."

Maribel Cordoba

"We didn't have food but we did have some great drinks! We sat at the bar for drinks and the bartenders were really nice. They actually seemed to love..."

Diane Zeigler

"I had the blackened fish tacos and they were very nice. As something as simple as beans and rice, I couldn't stop eating them; they were very..."

Peter Franc

Caroline's Cafe

87/100 (12967 ratings)

Restaurants

Seafood

American

Gluten Free Options

Cafe

Bar

Vegan Options

Vegetarian Friendly

American

Bar

Seafood

Gluten Free Options

Vegan Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Brunch

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Sandwiches

Po' Boys

Fish & chips

Crab

Cheeseburger

Bruschette

Tuna

Burger

Pesto

Hamburgers

Fish

Cheesecake

Fish & Chips

Fish Sandwich

Shrimp

Tortillas

Chicken Sandwich

Lobster

Jambalaya

Key lime pie

Pasta

Cuban Sandwich

Salad

Lettuce Wraps

Wings

Club Sandwich

Sit down

Bar

American

Café

Seafood

Serves Alcohol

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Free Wifi

Accepts Credit Cards

Delivery

Outdoor Seating

Takeout

Accepts Mastercard

Accepts Visa

Accepts American Express

Seating

Live Music

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Late Night

Brunch

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"Caroline’s was wonderful. We visited twice while in Key West. Wonderful food, atmosphere, and company..."

Meredith Ann Carter

"On Duval Street, a great place to eat and watch people go by. Had skirt steak and the Cuban. Large portions of good food and great ice tea. Wait..."

Chuck

"Everything the table ordered was amazing! The burgers are HUGE. Caroline’s Famous Fish Sandwich was amazing. The Spicy Cajun Jambalaya was..."

Alysan Burgbacher

"Great outdoor atmosphere. We had salads, quesadillas and the Cuban sandwich. Food and drinks were great. Great local establishment when you are..."

Gottagetaway97

"Was there for dinner on Saturday night. I had a great fish sandwich. Very fresh, hot and crispy, not dried out. We also got an order of wings to..."

Paula Quillen

"Great food - had mahi sandwich, broccolini pasta and cajun pasta, great location - great outdoor seating next to street watching world go by, amazing..."

Alexis S.

"Best conch fritters! Delicious shrimp po boy. Overflowing quesadillos and good cuban mix.Kids menu, kids loved chicken tenders and fries. Great..."

Amy Mahaffey Cantrell

"Amazing service nicest staff I've ever had wait on me. From the servers to the two managers that made sure I knew that they knew I had a slight shell..."

John Dubreuil

"Mekan guzel yemekler lezzetli ancak servis yavas personel cok ilgili ve yardimci duvel st ustunde hareketli bolgede yiyecek birseyler cok rahat..."

Melodi

"Outdoor seating while you watch the world go by on Duval St. The food is good and fresh. The key lime pies is one of the best in Key West. I..."

Sue Ann

"Great food and excellent service, even on a VERY busy Saturday. Probably the best value in Key West. Try the grilled Mahi-Mahi sandwich or..."

Robert

"Un must of Key WestDe las mejores comidas de mi viaje a Miami. Buenas sugerencias en bebestibles y en comidas por quien nos atendió, muy..."

Rodry R

"The bruschetta here is fantastic!! Husband really enjoyed the peel and eat shrimp. Nice place to site outside and have lunch. Service wasn't good..."

HungryGirl

"Came in for lunch. Ordered a portobello sandwich and a Quessedia.. Loved both of them. And ya I thouroughly enjoyed the tasty Havana Margerita too!..."

Mini Gupta

"Excellent place. Highly recommend. The food is great, generous portions and very friendly waiters. We were served by a very kind lady; Natalie. Make..."

Lolah

"We ordered takeout the first night we arrived in Key West - the delivery was quick and the food was still fresh and warm. I got a pasta which I was..."

Andrew

"Great experience at Caroline's! I had the Mahi Mahi sandwich which was delicious. The service was very fast even though they were extremely busy..."

Emilee B

"Great location, and perfect for lunch. The food was nothing special, but good. The burger was great, the conch fritters were ok and the shrimp and..."

MD_Terpfoodie

"Very good prices and food always good. Had skirt steak with black beans, rice, and plantains. Awesome - service was a little slow this day but..."

Zims

"Had an amazing lunch! I had the shrimp lettuce wraps - so fresh and tasty! Service was excellent. Good vibes eating great food while enjoying people..."

Sparks

"Great friendly service and good people watching location on Duval. Food was..."

Towanda The Food Eater

"Fun and reasonably priced. We remembered Caroline's for the burgers and outside seating on an earlier trip. This time we ordered Conch Fritters for..."

Bill Joyce

"Good "dolphin" bites with light batter and tasty mahi mahi. Key lime margaritas fresh and tart (I liked but not my wife). Mojitos not so..."

Trevor

"Great place to eat on Duval. Really good food and very reasonably priced, especially for Duval street. Service was great. Cuban sandwich comes with..."

Matt

"Best salad I have ever had! I enjoyed "the bittersweet" while my husband had the "Macon and bacon " - both were amazing. You cannot..."

Megan Stano

"Friendly service, hearty and tasty fresh food, nice..."

Sharon Glazer

"Love it here. Great food, service, and outdoor people watching. Affordable and..."

American_sweet

"This was one of my favorite places in Key West. The service was better than most and the food was more..."

Romney Miller

"Wonderful lunch. We had a group of six here for lunch for the first time the other day. We were seated promptly and had excellent service. The Cuban..."

Rick

"Food was very good and the service was great! Out of all the places we've been here in Key West the past 3 days, the service here was the most..."

Amber

"Sitting at Carolina's right now... Couldn't wait to right review. IT'S FANTASTIC! Don't pass this place..."

Stacey

"Wonderful experience. Excellent food and terrific..."

LegendBham

"11/12/13. After a year since our last visit, we couldn't wait to try their key lime pie again. It was our wedding day and we couldn't have asked for..."

Calql8tor

"Big portions and..."

Gus Barres

"Great food at great prices for lunch. Ate here twice so..."

John

"Very relaxed environment. I like it because its good food, good drinks, and you can sit there and people watch on Duval. It's all outside seating..."

Lauren Elizabeth Grooms

"Very good food! We try to stay away from restaurants on duval but this is an exception. Hubby had the Cajun chicken sandwich and I had shrimp lettuce..."

Lori C

"The dolphin sandwich was one of the best I have ever had-- fresh, cooked perfectly, and well seasoned. Our server was friendly and helpful, and we..."

Joshua Roberson

"Great burgers and salads! Rum punch very good as well! Nothing fancy but a fun..."

Skyhawkflyer

"Place is good, staff is nice and food is tasty. Would recommend..."

Nick

"Fast service. Very tasty lunch. Shared bruschetta, Cuban mix (Cuban sandwich), Philly cheesesteak and fries. Suprisingly, they did all of these food..."

Jamie Elizabeth

"I have been going there since day one. Granted I live in Texas but I've always found a reason to go to The Keys, 3 or 4 times a year. I go to dive..."

Robin Burd

"Wonderful. We got a cheeseburger & shrimp poboy. The burger was extremely large, cooked perfectly, and tasted delicious! The poboy was overfilled..."

Jordan-Brock

"4 Tmes In 7 Days. That's how good this place is. Twelve bar seats at a small square bar, cafe style tables overlooking the street and numerous picnic..."

Rick

"Great Service. Had lunch at Caroline's. Wife had lettuce wraps and I had the burger. Burger was huge and cooked exactly as ordered (medium). Lettuce..."

Kempshark

"Amazing!! 10 minute wAit in off season (end of September) almost went to hard rock across the street...so glad we didn't! The mahi mahi fingers ap..."

Lindsay

"Great fish sandwich, Shrimp PoBoy, and giant Burgers. Prepare to take home leftovers, cause the servings are enormous! We ate there twice in two..."

Owb3

"Had a Great meal at Caroline's after a frustrating walk to another restaurant that was closed and actually walking out of Kelly's after reading..."

Ben Tewes

"Great Food and Atmosphere. For anyone to think this is normal bar food; they must not have ordered much. We went there at least 3 times this..."

Mermaid

"I ordered the caesar salad with blackened chicken. It was amazing! Great flavor great kick! My friend had the salad with deep fried chicken, cinnamon..."

Amy

"Food was good. I had the conch chowder, it was more spice than flavor but helped to nurse my Duval street hangover. our waitress was very attentive...."

TallyFoodie

"Not what you think.... A restaurant on Duval, so it must be a tourist trap, right?Wrong. I was pleasantly surprised, about the great fresh food,..."

Will P

"I have to say it is a good restaurant here with nice food and nice service, what's more, their prices are..."

Yue Zhuo

"Food Good...Service Average. Saturday evening, dinner, we chose Caroline's. DG had Grouper sandwich, and I had the Shrimp Po' Boy. The food was..."

JG

"The bruschetta was wonderful - I would get it again. The Macon Bacon salad was quite tasty as well: fresh greens, corn, crisp bacon, and candied..."

LSmith

"Yum!. We had a really excellent lunch at Caroline's Cafe. We shared appetizers of jumbo peel-and-eat shrimp (which were truley jumbo!) and dolphin..."

Chix96

"Good food and great location. We had one of their salads which was tasty, conch chowder which was peppery biut good, and the shrimp po'boy sandwich..."

Karen

"Great salads! Good spot for lunch and people..."

Boilerup

"Awesome burgers! And the first place we found that had sweet tea. Thumbs..."

Palmharborgirl

"Nothing fancy!. This place was just O.K. I wish this had a neutral posting. We ate and the food was filling; but nothing to write home..."

Rich

"Ehh.. Just ok... Conch fitters were unremarkable, lettuce wraps chicken overcooked, fresh fish was good. Great service and people watching..."

J

"Blackend Chicken Pasta & Mango Margarittas.... Will Always Hold A Place DEAR to My Heart Forever...LUVE YOU..."

Bayou72

"Great dinner! Skirt steak was awesome - Delian black beans. Lettuce cups were huge & very tasty. Brian was our waiter - he's super friendly. I..."

Cheryl

"This was our first dining experience in Key West, and we liked it well enough to go back for lunch a few days later. Considering all the food options..."

Chris W

"Good Food. Good Show. Not so Good Service.. We drifted down to Caroline's after the circus at Mallory Square. Our party ordered 4 drinks which..."

Table For Two

"The blackened dolphin sandwich was awesome and went well with a key west lager; and the reggae music coming from the store next door added to the..."

Jgr

"Duval Street Diner 's Delight. Thought we wouldn't find a place to eat on this lower portion of Duval Street, but a rainstorm swept us into..."

Jason S.

"Great people watching. We had the burgers, bring an appetite they're huge. Service was..."

Hatguy

"Huge portions, great appetizers, attentive waitresses. Sub par jambalaya, good blackedened fish sandwiches, po boy is..."

Scottscott

"Place was awesome. Great food and a great view of the street and crowds, great weekendnight place to..."

Miguel Gonzalez

"Great reatauraunt! The best jerk chicken I have ever had.. And I am from NYC! Great service! Go and order the Kingston..."

Menicknick

"The salads are fantastic, but the service isn't consistently good..,good but not..."

Alli Deneweth

"The food was good but the service was poor. Took 30 mins to even get drinks order. Go only if u have lots of time to..."

Matt Counts

"If you want to watch the key west crowds and get great jerk chicken and plaintains for a super deal check it..."

Patti

"Caroline’s is a neat restaurant with a street food kind of vibe with its decore and setup. We ordered conch fritter, Caroline's fish burger and..."

Jackson Hong (xenoverse)

"Very good food and service! I highly recommend for everyone to try them out. I had the fish sandwich (delicious and crispy) and my wife had the..."

Sean Young

"If you visit Key West you have to grab a bite to eat at Caroline’s!!!! Staff is extremely friendly. Food is to die for! Full of flavor and plenty..."

Ed Nadwodny

"Cute spot on Duvall Street, FL. Prices around $15 to low $30's for food. Food was good. I wasn't blown away but good. Nice outdoor place to eat...."

keyz_amazing

"Nice cafe style place to eat. Very busy but had no trouble getting a table. Service was spotty but we were not in a hurry to go anywhere..."

Bruce B

"Food was delicious and they have some of the best fries that I've had in Key West. Fish was very crispy. Service was great and food was made..."

Patrick Ryan

"The wife and I cut the fish sandwich in half, filled us both up , delicious, can't go wrong the fish sandwich. Staff,food and the atmosphere were..."

Kent Fink

"Delicious food and a fun Key West vibe! Caroline’s is very good at accommodating food allergies and has clear kitchen protocols to keep guests..."

Julie Peluso

"I recently had a delightful dining experience at Caroline's Cafe in Key West, Florida. The first thing that caught my attention was the beautiful..."

PopopThePatriot Ford

"Outdoor spot covered by huge umbrellas and cooled with water fans. It’s a small spot with a great atmosphere and great service. We all had the fish..."

Reset

There are 294 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Dinner in Key West

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Kristin Becker

Margarita Sorah

Kaitlynn Barrus

Henry Laun

Anshika Kapoor

D S

Madison Ayers

Lc B

Glen Morris

Maureen Magner

Kate Karja

KOURTNEY DENNISTON

Moaid Alfadeli

Jeremy Larsen (Escape Shroom Perspective)

Amol Kedar

Greg Knox

Vicky

Karen Kindberg

Jen Montgomery

Anthony W

Jac Whit

J S

Shane Kluge

Sandy Whitmore

Robert Barrett

Lucky Lulu

Lee Watson

Greg Sun

Jennifer Jackson

F'burg Foodie

Maria Ioannides

Patricia Gartley

Robert

Darya Eremina-Sovik

Jeffrey Ferrara

Joe

Noemi

Henry Kokenzie

Jade Gleitsman

Cristina P

Monika Day

Taner Mishler

Pauline Gras

Jess Bourdon

Vivian McGill

Jared Carson

mrbill7853

Kay Cee

James VanFleet

Diane Edwards

Ryan Beverly

mzwright Bella

Russell Wray

Diane Crandall

jeanne lomax

M Kellis

Mark Gilson

Anna Moses

E Blair

Jim DeGennaro

Scott Biggs

Amanda Rochette

Lisa Iacopino

Miles Brengle

C D

Danna M Brown

Bryan Parks

David Workman