Besides a slice or whole pie and other desserts, you can step in and find all sorts of key lime mechandise. Not only dessert but marinades, sauces, and rubs. They also have a section of clothing key west style of course.
Refreshing Key lime pie the crust was crispy. Very good I also had the toasted coconut ice cream. Very good not to sweet just right. Lots of things to buy.
We were staying at Andrews Inn and Garden Cottages which is right behind the Southernmost Key Lime Shop and stumbled upon this shop on our way back from exploring Key West. The staff were most helpful and very friendly. It was very late, but I still was able to get a cup of hot tea (with milk). We liked the store so much that decided to come back next day to get few slices of the famous Key Lime Pie and it didn't disappoint! We even got few more slices to bring back to West Pam Beach with us. I would highly recommend this place and I hope I can come back one day for more Key Lime Pie and tea.
Southern Most Key Lime Shop
We stumbled upon this place while exploring Keywest. Can't go to Keywest and not sample the pie.
This was a delectable slice of pie. The crust was baked to perfection. The filling was light and the taste was tangy, but not overpowering.
Nice little shop had souvenirs,clothes snakes and ice cream.
The key lime pie was great !!!
Staff was very friendly.
Key lime pie in key west is the best 👌
No lie, my entire party agreed this was the best piece of Key Lime Pie we tried in Key West! It was such a happy moment. I don’t think I even had time to take a picture of it because we ate it so fast. Delish- just the right amount of sour/tangy lime and not overboard, and a good crust and whipped cream, it was marvelous. The shop itself is very cute as well, they actually sell a lot of Kermits Key Lime shop products from down the road which I found interesting. I enjoyed how they had a lot of Ernest Hemingway pictures up on the walls- the hero of Key West! They also have ice cream and coffee for those other cravings you may have. Highly recommend the KLP!
This is where I ate key lime pie. The real key limes are small but full of sweet juice. The locates all said to try here 1st so we did. Keep up the good work. I tried my first my pie on a stick, so neat.
Yum. I absolutely love key lime pie!
I’ve been recommended to try this place by a colleague from work in Phoenix. WOW!!! You can sample here almost everything, they do have them - so nice! I liked so much the ambiance of this store and the girls at the counter were so welcoming and cute. They have a huge diversity of key lime delicatessens- Key lime cookies, candies, cakes, coolers, chocolates, ice creams and more. The Kermit’s pie and pie on the stick is a must to try - so delicious, LOVE it! Will go again for sure when be back to Paradise. Would definitely recommend this place to everyone who’s visiting Florida keys.
Cheers!
This wasn’t on our plan but noticed it while walking on the street. I wanted to try key lime pie in key west and accidentally stumbled on this place which had best key lime pie. I have never had key lime pie before so I cannot compare but it was delicious. Small cozy place which has few chairs outside. We sat outside eating our pie and drinking tea. Our son had ice cream. We saw few chickens running around which reminded me of my childhood back in India where chickens were just part of life in villages.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Key West
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes