The service was great n the good was incredible. We ordered 3 pizza all hand tossed. There was no left over crust. We had one regular n two special pizzas. The mad or big greek was wonderful. The other was the pear gorgonzola with balsamic. I had no idea what that would be like. The sweetness of pear and acid of the balsamic were great.
I would order both again. We were in indy for 3 things 1. Our 19th anniversary. We are a gay couple n were congratulated. 2) for a convention and 3) my 53rd birthday. We had joked if they had a candle. When i was young in a large family a birthday dinner was your selection. Mine was always pizza. We would make three large and 10 small thst we froze.
When we got our bill they gave us a free pizza. If i get back to indy this will be my go to place
Atmosphere was relaxed n some sports were playing but not over powering. Place was clean n had old vibe to it
Oh.my.GOSH. This may be the first I don't want to write a 5 star review, because I'm afraid of everyone finding this hidden gem ;)
From the drink selection (think every local brewery on tap) and a full bar, amazingggg pizza, TVs everywhere, parking just across the street, and video games... what more could you want?
We had the bruschetta (I'm going to dream of that for weeks) & the small deep dish pizza with pepperoni and bacon. It was plenty of food for 2 hungry adults and the quality/taste was out of this world.
OH and if you're a ranch nut like me, ORDER it. ;)
I can't wait to come back!!
So we're in town for my stepdaughter's marching band champion called the bands of America. So, when me and my love have the time. We try to be the most touristy we can be, and this pizza place just happens to be real close to our hotel, and we just happen to love pizza 🍕. I mean, simply delicious, I ordered the pear and gorgonzola pizza. I love to order food where I'm not gonna get anywhere else, and that really hit the spot. Wash it down with beer and mixed drinks. Whatever the reason, and where back in town. We have to come back and enjoy more pizza!! Highly Recommended!!
Entry on alley, think the speak easy entrance :) Quick service, kid tested and approved, fresh toppings, buttery garlic crust, good crunch to crusts. Hand tossed or deep dish! We had pepperoni basil, bbq, cheese pizza.
My family was trucking through the city looking for something local and tasty. We stumbled across this hidden gem but wondered if it was a kid’s friendly place. It was! The atmosphere was chill and the staff welcoming. The food was even better! We felt the prices were more than fair, the menu had an excellent variety, and the food was just as tasty as it looked. You’d be crazy not to seek this place out. My toddlers slammed the pretzels and appreciated the extra cheesy pizza 😎
Salvador Larrauri Gonzalez
+5
Saturday dinner downtown Indianapolis, great location, parking in front of the street for 10 USD day on weekends. Good beer selection, the Mexican pizza is really good if you like spicy. Pretzel’s as appetizers. 60 USD for party of 3 with 3 alcoholic drinks.
Good place, I had the spicy chicken soup which was excellent. My friends had the pizza which looked good but they said if could be a little cheesier.
Went in around 9pm on a Friday and got a few specialty pizzas. Flavor, quality of ingredients and variety of styles were all so so good. It was a fairly low key bar feel with dark wood and lots of TVs but the pizza tasted like the highest end place you’d be. Very very good.
Had the gluten free cauliflower crust supreme and it was amazing! Definitely a great option for those who want something away from bread.
Absolute favorite pizza spot in downtown. Best pizza in the city, good selection of local beers and overall a great spot to hangout
Best pizza I have ever eaten. Crust is not too thick and very tasty. We ordered mushroom, green pepper, and red onion.
Salad is amazing as well.
Friendly, attentive, but not intrusive server.
Very clean and inviting.
Cannot wait to come back to Indy so I can eat here again!
12/26/22 before Monday night Colts game was our first time at pearl street pizza we wanted to see what the hype was about! The restaurant is very cool almost like a really nice dive bar if that makes sense! The pizza and appetizers were amazing definitely worth checking out! What was even better was our server Kate she was amazing you can tell she takes pride in her job and the product pearl street puts out! Our first time but definitely not the last gonna become one of our go to spots for Colts games! Thanks Pearl street and Kate!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Indianapolis
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes