Best Restaurants in Edgartown

Discover 68 restaurants with browsable menus, verified reviews and prices. Complete guide updated August 2026.

⭐

80/100

Avg Rating

🍴

24

Cuisine Types

20 of 68 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

Alchemy Bistro & Bar

Alchemy Bistro & Bar

American European

💬 2205 reviews

📍 71 Main St

Mad Martha's

Mad Martha's

💬 537 reviews

📍 7 N Water St

Atlantic Fish & Chop House

Atlantic Fish & Chop House

American Seafood

💬 1663 reviews

Edgartown Pizza

💬 641 reviews

📍 224 Edgartown Rd

Wolf's Den Pizzeria

💬 108 reviews

📍 249 Vineyard Haven Rd.

Edgartown Diner

Edgartown Diner

💬 551 reviews

📍 65 Main St

Myx Market Martha's Vineyard

Myx Market Martha's Vineyard

Cafe Pizza Healthy

💬 10 reviews

📍 23 Kelley St

The Seafood Shanty

The Seafood Shanty

American Seafood Sushi

💬 4347 reviews

📍 31 Dock St

Town Bar Mv

American Bar Seafood

💬 344 reviews

📍 227 Upper Main St

Macphail's Corner Cafe

Macphail's Corner Cafe

💬 176 reviews

📍 18 Dock St

Lucky Hank's Restaurant & Cafe

Lucky Hank's Restaurant & Cafe

💬 650 reviews

📍 218 Upper Main St

Vineyard Scoops

Vineyard Scoops

💬 232 reviews

📍 58 Main St

Edgartown Pizza

Edgartown Pizza

💬 2726 reviews

📍 224 Edgartown Rd

Sharky's Cantina

Sharky's Cantina

Mexican Southwestern Bar

💬 1092 reviews

📍 266 Upper Main St

The Newes From America

The Newes From America

American Bar Pub

💬 1204 reviews

📍 23 Kelly St

L'etoile Restaurant

L'etoile Restaurant

French Contemporary

💬 1402 reviews

📍 22 N Water St

Slice Of Edgartown

Slice Of Edgartown

💬 36 reviews

📍 22 Dock St

R & B's Eatery

R & B's Eatery

💬 58 reviews

📍 258 Upper Main St

China House

China House

💬 300 reviews

📍 234 Upper Main St

Quarterdeck Restaurant

Quarterdeck Restaurant

American Seafood Fast Food

💬 140 reviews

📍 29 Dock St

🍴

Explore by Cuisine Type

American 36 Seafood 13 Cafe 11 Bar 6 Contemporary 4 Italian 4 Pub 4 Diner 3 International 3 Pizza 3 Deli 2 Fast Food 2 French 2 Healthy 2 Mediterranean 2 Mexican 2 Asian 1 Chinese 1 European 1 Gastropub 1 Moroccan 1 Soups 1 Southwestern 1 Sushi 1

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📋

29 Browsable Menus

📅

Aug 2026 Last Updated