Edgartown Pizza

Edgartown pizza has the BEST pizza on the island. Their pizza tastes amazing and it tastes the same every time I get it, which is exactly what I like - consistency. All of their menu items have great value and the Brazilian meals can last 2/3 days for one person. I highly recommend Edgartown Pizza, as they have the best value for food on the island, get your order ready fast, and have a HUGE menu - all delicious! If I were to recommend my favorites; all the pizzas are delicious, the steak Brazilian meal is my favorite item, and the mozzarella sticks are great as well. I’ve also gotten a burger here and it was big and less than $10! Can’t beat the price on the island!

Delicious pizza spot with a cool casual interior. We were looking for a simple, non-seafood meal during October and came across this pizza restaurant. The outside isn't fancy and a little unassuming, but inside it's warm and inviting. I got a small pepperoni pizza, and had a few slices left over. Two people with a small appetite could probably share it fine. The pepperoni was nice and crispy, and the cheese and sauce were tasty!

I don't have a picture because we were too busy eating this pizza that there was no picture to take. My sister lives on island and was a little apprehensive about ordering because the last pizza she ordered was not memorable Edgartown Pizza really stepped up the game, and I wish we would have gotten a much much bigger one because it was so good! Everything about it was fabulous and I can't wait to come back to visit so that we can order from this great place. PS, I think that my sister maybe ordering before next summer. 🙂

Edgartown Pizza has such an extensive menu - we tried their chicken alfredo pizza on cauliflower crust, chicken sandwich, chicken Caesar salad, teriyaki steak tips, meat lovers pizza. We enjoyed every dish and were pleased with the quantity and portions and the food for the price. Great customer service from their owner, Danny! Would definitely return. Reviewed by @MVacay.

WONDERFUL!!! Don't listen to the complaints, JUST GO! I was served by the owner himself, great service, price and quality food. The chicken & cheese was spectacular!! Also had some pepperoni pizza that was delicious!! If you don't think your pizza should have a little grease, you're not american!! Seriously people, this is a great restaurant and deserves your business!

Ordered a buffalo pizza, chef salad, buffalo chicken sub and a sandwich for 5 people and everything was delicious! The owner came around to check on us and he clearly take pride in his restaurant and its upgrades - the decor is significantly improved over last year. Friendly staff, great prices and most importantly delicious food!