Olde Bay Cafe

Amazing. Simply amazing! Had a friend in town and took her here for some food and drinks at sunset. The beers on tab were fresh and rich.started with the tuna ahi as an appetizer then I had the southwest salmon sandwich and she had the scallop wrap. The chips had a perfect crunch and the fish was perfectly cooked. Will defiantly be coming back here. Not only was the food delicious and fairly priced. The views are unmatched. Perfect for a sunset dinner. This place is memorable.

We live in Lake Wales, Florida and we came to the beach with my son and father from Michigan. Dad said he wanted "seafood" so we came here for the first time. Not a great decision. First off, our server 'Sydney' was not adequate at all. She was seriously not going to get a tip from the get go, but, my husband is more generous than I am. Then, my 31 yr old son, who has won awards in Detroit for his cooking skills got some BAD, brown salmon. After 2 bites, he was ill in the bathroom. We then informed our server who said "let's get this taken care of for you", which meant absolutely nothing. My husband informed a different worker on our way out. Hopefully, someone takes precaution. The food and selection was sub par, and everything tasted the same, although we all ordered something different. FYI: no deep fried food no French fries, hush puppies or onion rings😅 I'm low carb, so it didn't bother me, but, the rest of our party would have loved other options besides as I on pasta salad and veggies.

I want to start with the fact that it has an amazing view. Absolutely worth eating here if you’re just looking for a good view. However If you’re looking for some good flavorful fish this is sadly not the place to go. I had the Mahi wrap and only could taste the tomatoes. The tacos were also very dry with no sauce on them. After adding tarter sauce it was a little better. The peel and eat shrimp were cooked very nice and had good flavor probably the best thing I ordered there. The beer was very good however it was in plastic disposable cups which just gives a cheaper feel. There were very very many birds that would fly down at you and steal food however an employee did state that they were ordering something in to help with that. It was also pretty cold and windy and there is not much seating inside. If you’re alone you have a better chance of sitting inside. So make sure to check the weather!! There is covers above you outside. Spent about 70$ and am disappointed.

Had lunch here. Very good food with a beautiful view. The hostess worked very hard to get us a comfortable place to sit, bad back, which she accomplished. My only complaint was dogs and I love them but a person came in with a very large dog right behind me and getting out was a little difficult. But I would definitely eat here again.