Wholesome and authentic Italian food at fair prices, plus sandwiches which locals call "wedges." Friendly waitstaff. No beer on draft but they have about four bottled. Clean bathroom and dining room receives lots of natural light. Tasteful decorations. In October 2022 the Westchester Libertarian Party gathered at this location.
Rolando Rosales Barrenechea
+5
The only two times I ordered from this restaurant the food was so delicious. NO REGRETS. the staff are very friendly and polite. The price is all right. They have three separate dining rooms, big enough to celebrate any special moments.
This place is an old school hidden gem, 5 minutes from downtown WP. Good food and great pizza - New York style with a crispy, slightly thicker crust. Easily one of the best slices you will find in Westchester.
John the owner treats everyone like family. I am from N.J. and have been going to Sir Johns for over 25 years with my N.Y. friend. The food portions are ample and always served with fresh Italian bread and water. The pricing is very reasonable.
Delicious food, comfortable restaurant, the owner was there and ensured we were well taken care of, our server was also great! Thanks for the great late dinner.
Finally, we found an old school Italian joint in the White Plains area that Sinatra and Dean Martin would love. The food is outstanding, the service is very friendly, plenty of parking... and no inflation here, prices are very reasonable. Dinner for two with a bottle of wine for about $85 plus tip. Loved it!
Best chicken parm we've ever had, homemade fettuccine and angel hair pasta. Eggplant parm is also outstanding... Will definitely be back.
Best Italian meal I've had in 10 years... I had a special with sautéed shrimp over homemade linguine in oil, garlic and diced tomatoes.
The chef is an artist, the staff was great and Barbara the waitress was terrific. Another night I had chicken parm. and it was pounded so I could cut it with a fork. Plus in house made fettuccine and angel hair. Food is truly amazing. I love the Montepulcano wine as well
We had a great experience when stopping here for lunch and ordered take out. The gentleman who served us even brought the food out to us in our car, which was so nice of him. Plus it was delicious!
After taking the kids to the nearby light show for the holidays we stopped here as group for dinner. The restaurant was warm, cozy and clean. The staff was beyond friendly and the service was honestly superb. The food was very good. The pizza was delicious as was the shrimp fra diavlo. The alfredo was not approved by us nor was the antipasto
The food here is great, and the staff is amazing.
On a late night, the owner allowed my wife and I to dine in, even after the Chef had left for the night, and cooked for us himself.
Will most definitely visit again!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in White Plains
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes