Best pie crust ever!!!! And the fillings were excellent as well.
Wow! I just stopped by and had a chicken enchilada. The perfectly flaky crust made it more meat pie than enchilada but no need to mince words over a minced pie. If you are a person that likes being overwhelmed with freshness and flavor stop what you are doing and go get one now. The sauce it came with is also outstanding. Thank you pie lady!
Apple butter pie is so yummy! Adorable little shop with friendly staff. This is the perfect stop for a snack or a take and bake gift when traveling along 81.
The Key Lime pie was phenomenal. Silky with a crisp crust, and great lime flavor. I also had a slice of the Coconut Chess pie which was a sugar delight. Definitely stop by for dessert or get there early for savory pies, which were pretty much sold out when I arrived( 12:30pm). This is a must stop of in the area.
Run, don't walk to get to Firkin Pie before they sell out of the best pies on the planet! Savory or sweet, every pie is a slice of heaven. Jane says the secret to their amazing crust is butter, but it must be some kind of magically enchanted butter, because i could eat just the crust and be happy. Anywhere else my crusts remain on the plate - they're too dry, too browned, too soggy etc. Her crust is magically delicious. Seriously, if you haven't been, get going! If calories weren't a thing I would have some every. single. day. Sausage rolls? Beef pie? Thanksgiving pie? Chocolate pie? Yes, yes, yes, yes! My dream job is being a Firkin Pie taste tester.
The pies, both savory and sweet, are excellent. The crust is buttery and flaky. The fillings are tasty as well. Don't miss this place for lunch. The hand pies are perfect.
Amazing crust. Right balance of sweet and tart. Excellent pies. We enjoyed our sweet and the quiche. This small shop has limited inventory so go early.
Absolutely delicious. Had Peanut Butter pie for dessert and a meat pie for lunch, specifically a buffalo chicken meat pie. Wonderful. My wife and I are putting this on our must stop when passing through the area.
Absolutely amazing! They were super friendly and the pies are outstanding! The smores pie was incredible and the apple was a winner with my wife even though she doesn't enjoy apple pie that much! Hope to visit them again the next time in VA
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Staunton
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes