Fabulous ice cream, worth the long line. Got the ferry sundae which was superb. Only complaint is getting the unpleasant “stare” when they turn the screen for the tip on the credit card, not appropriate for a local ice cream place. They should just have a tip jar. Here’s your 20% (really?) but I won’t be back.
Helene Starzee
+5
It’s the BEST Ice Cream and topping in town! Friendly staff! Great hours too! ❤️
John Collins
+5
An old fashioned ice cream store. We never go to Shelter Island w/o stopping in for a treat.
Mark Hanrahan
+5
Best soft serve I’ve had in the US.
Dan Cooper
+5
$18.75 for a two scoop Sunday and one scoop plain has gotten a little out of control. Still the taste was there even though it was melted when I received the boat.
Colleen
+5
Great Ice Cream and a wonderful variety of flavors and toppings! Kids loved the milk shakes. The girl working was fantastic!
Mr. Hill
+5
Yummy, delicious Ice cream.
Phyllis Montgomery
+5
Been going here since it first opened when I was a kid. Love this place. Always reminds me a wonderful beach days abd happy times. Staff pleasant. Clean inside and out.
Finn Guillemin
+4
Super great ice cream amd I love the arcade. My fav flavor is the coffee. Would also recommend the mini golf course to though.
Erika Roque
+5
Although it can be overwhelming to choose a flavor from the many options that they offer, definitely some great ice cream. Must visit
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Shelter Island Heights
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes