Don’t know why there are so many negative reviews. Been coming since original owners opened. I was born and raised in Brooklyn 83 years ago so I know a NY bagel. Currently live on Long Island near the Hamptons.
Hard to find a real NY bagel in NY these days as the old Jewish bakers no longer exist. I thought the bagel I had today was pretty good for a Florida bagel. The outside was a little too crisp and the inside needs to be more chewy.
I think I spoke to one of the owners this morning.she told me they were working on improving their bagel by visiting bagel shops in NY.
Give them a chance or you will be stuck eating bagels from the chain store north of Bee Ridge. If you like those chain store bagels,you don’t know a NY bagel.
These are really good bagels. Especially for Florida, or anywhere outside of New York, which is the standard bearer of bagels. Certainly the best in Sarasota. When the original owners left I was sad that the quality would change, but they are still the best in Sarasota, so thank you to the new owners.
I’m the owner of Kenshō ice bath studio in the plaza next door and shockingly had never been in here! What an incredible bagel breakfast sandwich!!! Will certainly be recommending!
Best bagel I have ever had. Great selection of flavors and excellent service. If you’re looking for a yummy breakfast for a great price, I highly recommend this place.
Very busy place and quick to get your food! My husband got the nova lox with a garlic and onion bagel he added cream cheese, purple onion, tomato, and capers. He loved it so much that the next morning he had to go back for another one. I had the BLT on Wheat everything bagel. It was really good.
DELICIOUS! 😮 I am From NYC/Long Island, this place has a great bagel! Yummmmmmyyyy!!! And they have whitefish salad! And some really different kinds of sandwiches on bagels. Very good!
The bagels are incredible and the service was fantastic. Greeted with a warm smile. The coffee from Sarasota coffee Co was perfect for these bagels. You guys made my day🤩
New owners AND still the best true bagels in Sarasota. I have no idea what people are complaining about. They still boil and bake. They are crisp on the outside and chewy soft on the inside, the way they should be and yes I moved here from Manhattan, I know what a good NYC bagel is...! It's Sunday morning in the place was packed!
Great old school bagel shop. Driven by 1000 times. Always wanted to stop. Finally did. Great staff and food!!
Great old school bagel shop. Driven by 1000 times. Always wanted to stop. Finally did. Great staff and food!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Sarasota
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes