Wow! We had one of the best meals here that I've had in Sarasota. The steamed clams were delicious, the fish is super fresh and cooked to perfection, the tropical salsa was on point, the veggies were crisp (green beans were cooked perfectly), and the key lime pie is to die for. They have a super selection of beers, including local brews. And not everything is fried! Or maybe nothing is, which is awesome. Our waitress was informative and delightful. It was marvelous! Thank you.
Ate here twice on my vacation. The grouper tacos with tropical salsa are amazing. I didn't even eat fish until this trip. I would eat here anytime I came to visit. The Keylime pie was also amazing. We had a wonderful waitress Vanessa. This place is awesome. The Fish Stew was also really good!
First time here I had a buttered lobster roll with cole slaw.They also have quite the selection in their seafood market.One stop shopping,grab a bite to eat then order fresh fish to go.How can you go wrong, definitely recommend checking it out.
This restaurant is a hidden gem of Sarasota. The food was phenomenal and the service was on point. The stone crab chowder was to die for and the tropical salsa on the tacos and snapper wrap was delicious. The seafood was extremely fresh and cooked perfectly. This restaurant is a must go to if you love good seafood.
Come for the fish & portion size. You will be surprised at great prices. Clean & cozy place. Look at the size of these fish tacos!!
Highly Recommend: this place is solid good. You can pick any fish to be cooked from the display or get the stone crab. Blackened tripletail was really good. The service was great as well. The sides - potatoes were really good, however Spanish rice can be skipped, I did not enjoy it.
The place is not really big so for dinner, we came pretty early at 4, but by 430 it was filling up pretty quick. If coming at 5 or after maybe plan to make a reservation, or you may be seated by the bar.
Would definitely stop here again.
Amazing freshest fish around skillfully prepared. Can't beat the blackened fish sandwich and stone crab claws finished with the best key lime pie I've had. Owners are great, servers are great. This is a hole in the wall strip mall spot t H at delivers taste comparable or better than anything in the area. Thanks Bob and Veronica ya'll made our trip special.
This restaurant was delightful! Best crab leg steam pot, huge portions and amazing flavor. Even the corn was incredible - not soggy and so sweet. My husband had the grilled scallops and loved them. Clam chowder - awesome but the best was the key lime pie. Homemade every day and the creamiest texture! We can’t wait to go back!!!
We had the best meal ever at Fresh Catch! We had 6 in our party and each person was impressed with their entree. Service was exceptional and can’t say enough about how good the food was. Pictures don’t lie!
We stopped in to pick up Swordfish for a recipe and even though it was during dinner service, the staff was wonderful and very helpful. The fish by the way was some of the best swordfish we've ever had! Should be everyone's go to fish market in Sarasota.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Sarasota
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes